Era Might Posted December 13, 2006 Posted December 13, 2006 Well, I think we can agree on the essential point: that the Church firmly teaches that Our Lady remained a Virgin before, during, and after Our Lord's birth. What is meant by "before" and "after" are clear: that she did not know any man. What is meant by "during", I would say, is not so clear. Maybe it is best left that way, so that we leave a mystery a mystery. If the Church chooses to clarify herself, or if she has done so already, then let that judgement be obeyed.
Thy Geekdom Come Posted December 13, 2006 Posted December 13, 2006 I edited my earlier post. Please see it.
Era Might Posted December 13, 2006 Posted December 13, 2006 [quote name='Raphael' post='1140786' date='Dec 12 2006, 07:37 PM']Edited to add: my beloved fiancee adds that "during" doesn't make any sense in a context of virginity referring only to a lack of intercourse, since it doesn't make sense to specify virginity before and after birth and then to have, "oh, and during sex, too." Of course, if you're talking about the intercourse definition, you'd have to be a virgin during if you were a virgin after and before. However, it seems to me that the virgin-birth is referring more directly to the mode of the birth...Christ was born in a way that kept His mother a virgin...kept her womb closed. It's a what, but it's also a how. He wasn't just born of a virgin, but He was born virginally.[/quote] I agree that "during" refers to the mode of birth (that is, Our Lady gave birth in a "virginal" manner). Pope John Paul II reiterated this in one of his speeches. However, that still doesn't solve the question of what "virginal" means as far as Catholic doctrine is concerned. Does the Church take as her own a particular definition of the ancients? Does it mean that Our Lord could not pass through or open the womb? Why does Pope John Paul II cite Pope St. Hormisdas speaking of Our Lord "opening" the womb, but doing so in a virginal way? Are the two concepts necessarily opposed? These are questions only the Church can answer, and I have not been able to find a formal treatment of these questions. I'm not saying she hasn't provided one, but I'm not aware of it myself. Personally, I'm weary about saying anything definitive on the matter, except that Mary remained a Virgin during Our Lord's birth; beyond that, I will respect whatever the Church teaches, as best I understand it.
Thy Geekdom Come Posted December 13, 2006 Posted December 13, 2006 [quote name='Era Might' post='1140818' date='Dec 12 2006, 09:26 PM'] except that Mary remained a Virgin during Our Lord's birth [/quote] Do you see what I'm saying, though? Of course Mary remained a Virgin during Our Lord's birth. To say otherwise doesn't make any sense...with Mary or with any other woman. That's what leads one to believe that the Church's declaration wasn't talking about virginity the way we think of it. They wouldn't need to specify that if they were just talking about intercourse.
Era Might Posted December 13, 2006 Posted December 13, 2006 Yes, we agree, by the phrase "during birth", the Church isn't saying that Our Lady knew not man (which is obvious that she didn't), but that Our Lady gave birth in a "virginal" manner (John Paul says she was a virgin during birth "in everything which concerns the integrity of the flesh"). The remaining question is how the Church understands this "virginity" during birth. Does the Church teach specifically that Our Lord did not open the womb? John Paul cites Pope St. Hormisdas positively where he speaks of Our Lord opening the womb in a virginal manner. Is this phrase only incidental? I don't believe we can say for sure what the Church does or does not mean when she says that Our Lady remained a virgin during birth. Does the Church define "virginity" as "not opening the womb"? She may, but I don't think we can speak definitely unless the Church does; at the same time, we shouldn't speak in crude ways of Our Lady's giving birth, or discount that Our Lord could pass in a miraculous way. It was a mystery; we know that Our Lady gave birth in a "virginal" way; beyond that, I don't know if the Church intends to define what this means, or leave it a mystery. We should respect and obey whatever the Church decides, or has decided.
Chiquitunga Posted December 13, 2006 Author Posted December 13, 2006 I thought I'd post again all the sources I was able to find about this from different Church documents, and also a quote from [b]the_rev[/b] which was posted in the thread in Open Mic - "Mary in the Nativity Story" - to put all the sources together in a precise way without forgetting any of them, even the obvious ones. If anyone else has more quotes from sources like these, they can post them too. It'd be great if we could have a concise list of sources one after another. Then we could read only what the Church is saying, one after another. On the Catholic Answers site, they don't have many sources on this - just some sayings of the Church Fathers on the virginity of Mary. We'll start with the new USCCforAdults - the goal in this catechism was to write things clearer for Americans, I think. [quote]United States Catholic Catechism for Adults, glossary: Perpetual Virginity: Mary was a virgin in conceiving Jesus, in giving birth to Him, and in remaining always a virgin ever after.[/quote][quote]Catechism of the Catholic Church 499 The deepening of faith in the virginal motherhood led the Church to confess Mary’s real and perpetual virginity even in the act of giving birth to the Son of God made man. [/quote][quote]Catechism of the Council of Trent, Part 1 - The Creed, Article III: He is born of His Mother without any diminution of her maternal virginity, just as He afterwards went forth from the sepulchre while it was closed and sealed, and entered the room in which His disciples were assembled, the doors being shut; or not to depart from every-day examples, just as the rays of the sun penetrate without breaking or injuring in the least the solid substance of glass, so after a like but more exalted manner did Jesus Christ come forth from His mother's womb without injury to her maternal virginity.[/quote] And finally, the quote from the_rev which has a few sources that refer to Our Lady experiencing pain in childbirth. [quote name='the_rev' post='1138887' date='Dec 9 2006, 04:43 PM'] The Church has taught the truth of Our Lady's perpetual virginity from ancient times. Saint Ambrose taught that the closed gate of the temple spoken of in Ezekial as the closed womb of Mary ... The Catechism of the Council of Trent teaches[quote]"to Eve it was said, 'In pain you shall bring forth children.' Mary was exempt from this law for preserving her virginal integrity inviolate she brought forth Jesus the Son of God, without experiencing as we have already said, any sense of pain."[/quote] ... In addition, in the Mass of the Blessed Virgin Mary the priest prays: [quote]"In Your divine wisdom, You planned the redemption of the human race, and decreed that the new Eve should stand by the cross of the new Adam: as she became His mother by the power of the Holy spirit, so by a new gift of Your love, she was to be a partner in His passion, [b]and she who had given Him birth without the pains of childbirth was to endure the greatest of pains in bringing forth to new life the family of your Church[/b] as we join the angels and the saints in their hymn of praise. (emphasis added by Margaret Clare)[/quote][/quote]
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now