Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

[quote name='KnightofChrist' post='1181726' date='Jan 31 2007, 07:51 PM']
Your brother is in need of help not condemnation.
[/quote]

Haha, contrary to what seems to be popular belief on this site, I'm a girl :P:





[quote name='Didymus' post='1181749' date='Jan 31 2007, 08:17 PM']
Hows it goin' onathing1? Been waitin to see you in this thread!

Anyways everyone, I still think there is some misconception about the meanings of some of Metallica's songs. Especially from MoP. I dont see the "blasphemy." Maybe cuz there is none.

here's my biggest argument and stance on the issue (cuz people will be complaining about metal until they take away the metal, and all we have left is soft indie pop emo love songs) I'm gonna keep listening to the secular stuff until you can give me something Christian that doesnt sound like garbage. Im sick of the lack of talent in todays world of pop and 'rock' music. If anyone here actually payed attention to these metal lyrics (and avoided trying to twist the meanings so that they can claim the writer means something far from real intentions) they would see that their bias is mostly based on the fact that the style in and of itself is different than the trash out there because its fast or dark or heavy.

I am getting so sick of the fact that this thread still exists. There really is nothing left to say, as is obvious from the fact that Truthseeker isnt even trying to refute us but only damning us to hell. (wait! let me guess, we're damning ourselves to hell!) This is so rediculous.

I listen to music as entertainment. I pray when I pray. If you can pray with your musical entertainment, then more power to you. My rule of thumb for 'Christian music' is that you need to take the music and make it christian, not take the Christian and add music (if that makes any sense.) You cant evangelize with talentless garbage. When the right stuff comes, you let me know. Until then, I'm gonna sit back and enjoy the ingenious, musical guitar solos of Darrel Abbot and Kirk Hammet.

Peace out :cool:
[/quote]



Hey Didymus...It woulda been going better if I hadn't seen this thread on here :idontknow: But anyway, howbout you?


I agree with everything you say up there. Especially with the whole people hating metal cuz it's metal. Like I said, you can find stuff like this in any genre. For some people just like to beat on Rock.

Posted

[quote name='KnightofChrist' post='1181708' date='Jan 31 2007, 07:38 PM']
If the music we listen to is contrary to the Law, or Word of God, then we are being contrary to the command to be perfect as our Father in heaven is perfect.

And yes Music Artists, or songs which are lustful or degrading to women are also contrary to Christ.

Still Metallica is nothing a Christian should be proud to listen to, what they say in their lyrics is contrary to Christ, rebellion to the things His teaches. Am I wrong, would Christ kick back and listen to the Black Album, or Master of the Puppets? Would He use some of their lyrics to teach, or would he condemn their lyrics?

Be honest.
[/quote]
I'm not sure Christ would listen to Metallica, but quite frankly, I have trouble picturing Him listening to [i]any[/i] modern pop/rock/rap.

I'm not sure why Metallica is being singled out here, (other than perhaps their widespread popularity).

I don't really have a problem with most of their lyrics. Their songs are about many different things, and their songs do not all glorify or promote what they describe. (Many actually are against various evils in the world - hypocrisy, horrors of war, abuse of power, drug abuse, etc.)

If Christians want to avoid Metallica, that is fine and good, but there are many much worse influences in the culture.

KnightofChrist
Posted

[quote name='onathing1' post='1181759' date='Jan 31 2007, 08:25 PM']
Haha, contrary to what seems to be popular belief on this site, I'm a girl :P:
[/quote]

Well double dang!

Posted

[quote name='Socrates' post='1181767' date='Jan 31 2007, 07:32 PM']
I'm not sure Christ would listen to Metallica, but quite frankly, I have trouble picturing Him listening to [i]any[/i] modern pop/rock/rap.

I'm not sure why Metallica is being singled out here, (other than perhaps their widespread popularity).

I don't really have a problem with most of their lyrics. Their songs are about many different things, and their songs do not all glorify or promote what they describe. (Many actually are against various evils in the world - hypocrisy, horrors of war, abuse of power, drug abuse, etc.)

If Christians want to avoid Metallica, that is fine and good, but there are many much worse influences in the culture.
[/quote]

Like our three special members here :D:

Posted

[quote name='Truthseeker777' post='1180548' date='Jan 31 2007, 06:40 AM']
Unfortunately this just shows how blinded you Catholic kids are,satan will sit next to you in mass and you would still think its your granny!!![/quote]Most Christian metal bands are protestant.

xTrishaxLynnx
Posted

[quote name='Fixxxer' post='1181908' date='Jan 31 2007, 10:06 PM']
Like our three special members here :D:
[/quote]

Haha :rolleyes:

Posted

I had an interesting thought yesterday evening. I was watching a movie w/ techno music (Fast and the Furious), and I noticed how its pulsing affected my heartbeat. I wondered, idly, that if you like a piece of music only for its psychoacoustic affect on you, etc. would that be a hallmark of insidious music? To put the thought opposite, should for music to be good, you have to like it for itself? (Why does language so often fail to convey my thoughts well?)

Posted

I find it interesting that most techno songs are recorded at a BPM (beats per minute) of about 120 - ironically, roughly the same pace as the human heart...Interesting...

Posted

as long as we have really slow music as well as really fast music, wouldnt there theoretically always be a style of music associated with the same BPM as the human heart?

dairygirl4u2c
Posted (edited)

most of the metallica lyrics can eb taken as bad or portraying simply the darkness, not necessarily promoting it. like master of puppets could be said to portray the harsh reality of drug addiction, or it could be said to glorigy it. i think it's protraying har reality.

there is one song i don't think anyone would argue about it's meaning though. it has a good message in a way overall. but the way it makes the message and words....

if you want to know... look up "so what?" lyrics by metallica in google.

edit: again i reiterate that most of the lyrics prob arent that bad. there's only two that struck my eye offhand as maybe bad. one is am i evil. i think he's really saying he's evil, but i could be misinterpreting it. antoher is "the god that failed". you could say he's talking about frustration and loss of faith, is part of life. but it seems mroe to me he's saying he believes it....

"I see faith in your eyes
Never your hear the discouraging lies
I hear faith in your cries
Broken is the promise, betrayal
The healing hand held back by the deepened nail
Follow the god that failed"

Edited by dairygirl4u2c
Posted

[quote name='dairygirl4u2c' post='1184223' date='Feb 3 2007, 07:24 PM']
most of the metallica lyrics can eb taken as bad or portraying simply the darkness, not necessarily promoting it. like master of puppets could be said to portray the harsh reality of drug addiction, or it could be said to glorigy it. i think it's protraying har reality.

there is one song i don't think anyone would argue about it's meaning though. it has a good message in a way overall. but the way it makes the message and words....

if you want to know... look up "so what?" lyrics by metallica in google.

edit: again i reiterate that most of the lyrics prob arent that bad. there's only two that struck my eye offhand as maybe bad. one is am i evil. i think he's really saying he's evil, but i could be misinterpreting it. antoher is "the god that failed". you could say he's talking about frustration and loss of faith, is part of life. but it seems mroe to me he's saying he believes it....

"I see faith in your eyes
Never your hear the discouraging lies
I hear faith in your cries
Broken is the promise, betrayal
The healing hand held back by the deepened nail
Follow the god that failed"
[/quote]

I see you are one of the smarter people ;) . So what? isnt by metallica so scratch that, but you are right with the song, the god that failed. its about james hetfield losing his mother, she was a christian scientist and believed God would save her.

Posted

'am i evil' is a cover song though, isnt it?

  • 2 months later...
johnnydigit
Posted

i heard some of this material at a talk. when the priest played back most of the songs in reverse, i thought, "well it doesn't sound THAT convincing," perhaps it's coincidence. then he played Britney Spears "hit me baby one more time" and i clearly heard it say "sleep with me i'm not too young" and i was SHOCKED. WHAT THE HECK? how are they even able to do that? well it really opened my eyes.

i listen to and love Christian pop/rock music. Chris Tomlin, Third Day, Kutless, etc. their messages are purely christian, nothing negative, ever. always about praising God and Jesus Christ. some start sounding like rock music, in that they have guitars and drums. Kutless has a few older songs that have the "screamo" type of singing. like a word or two that is yelled loudly.

now, i firmly believe that this is ok, and that not all rock music is evil, just the ones mentioned or any music that contains any sort of evil or negative message. even if rolling stone has 99% good songs and even has a praise song, if they have one song with anything about satan or the devil in it, i won't touch it.

if anyone has any insight on Christian Rock, i'd like to hear it. i have heard all the bad things about CCM in protestant church services, but as long as we keep it out of Mass i think it's okay.
the only danger i can see is being lured into harder and harder rock that gets less and less christian.

Posted

My personal music tastes prefer the heavy metal-type Christian rock than the more popular 'Kutless' and 'Switchfoot' Christian rock. I have no problem with these bands, I just dont prefer their musical genre. The message of course I like. But the Christian stations around me only get as heavy as Switchfoot.
I guess you could say the softest Christian rock that I really like is Spoken. (tooth and nail records, at least originally)

I might be kinda somewhat hypocritical though, cuz some of my own stuff is lighter, but usually that's when I'm in a more personally prayerful mood than an 'in your face' evangelize mood.

johnnydigit
Posted

actually i like some of the metal stuff, but only the music. the singing sounds kinda devlish and creepy to me.

so i'm thinking again, don't throw the baby out with the bath water. it's a matter of tolerance(?). the internet is bad, but also can be used for good. some people don't have to use it at all, but some do. driving has bad racing, you can do bad stuff in cars, bad things happen, but do you stop driving? no.

but then that page says a reason to avoid ALL rock is because of near occasion of sin. but then i think with that mentality, everyone should be a hermit or cloistered religious. i dunno. i'll take it in stride for now.. or is that sloth?! hehe

Guest T-Bone
Posted

I love things like this. They're amusing. Album covers that don't exist, suicides that never happened, back masking that you need to know what it says before you hear it, and erroneous song interpretations. It's funny how far some will go to condemn that which they don't like.

Paladin D
Posted

Bon Jovi rocks dude!

Jesus_lol
Posted

[quote name='T-Bone' post='1261987' date='May 1 2007, 04:37 PM']I love things like this. They're amusing. Album covers that don't exist, suicides that never happened, back masking that you need to know what it says before you hear it, and erroneous song interpretations. It's funny how far some will go to condemn that which they don't like.[/quote]


its amazing really. heck, going by that approach, give me some time and ill prove that gospel choir songs are really satanic!
from "praise the lord jesus" to "i gave candy to lucifer" is probably just as likely as most of this stuff. or better yet a picture of mother teresa with MS Paint "horns"!

hoosieranna
Posted

[quote name='Jesus_lol' post='1262270' date='May 2 2007, 01:46 AM']its amazing really. heck, going by that approach, give me some time and ill prove that gospel choir songs are really satanic!
from "praise the lord jesus" to "i gave candy to lucifer" is probably just as likely as most of this stuff. or better yet a picture of mother teresa with MS Paint "horns"![/quote]

:lol_pound:

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...