Laudate_Dominum Posted January 9, 2007 Posted January 9, 2007 I'm sure its different for people who are in school some place, but for me I often find that while studying something, typically the works of a philosopher, I wish that I had people interested and knowledgeable in the subject with which to converse. Currently I'm attempting to read the works of Heidegger in chronological sequence. If anyone here has any opinions or remarks to share regarding Heidegger's philosophy please spew here! This isn't just a Heidegger thread; if there is some other philosopher that someone is studying which they would like to discuss please have at it. The only thing I ask is that this thread remains a philosophy thread. Cheers!
Justified Saint Posted January 10, 2007 Posted January 10, 2007 I have [i]only[/i] read Heidegger's seminal work and masterpiece [i]Being and Time[/i], along with some short essays and excerpts. I will be reading [i]What is Called Thinking[/i] for the upcoming semester -- so I am looking forward to that. My reading and understanding of Heidegger is heavily influenced by one of my professors. Fundamental ontology is a clear break and inversion of the traditional philosophic categories of metaphysics and epistemology. Thus I think Heidegger both makes problematic traditional expressions of faith and religion as well as renews and calls forth their lasting source. Heidegger said (with some contempt) that people of faith do not even raise the question of Being, though if he were to write a theology (which he never did) the word "Being", we are told, would not appear.
Laudate_Dominum Posted January 16, 2007 Author Posted January 16, 2007 [quote name='Justified Saint' post='1160659' date='Jan 10 2007, 01:31 PM'] I have [i]only[/i] read Heidegger's seminal work and masterpiece [i]Being and Time[/i], along with some short essays and excerpts. I will be reading [i]What is Called Thinking[/i] for the upcoming semester -- so I am looking forward to that. My reading and understanding of Heidegger is heavily influenced by one of my professors. Fundamental ontology is a clear break and inversion of the traditional philosophic categories of metaphysics and epistemology. Thus I think Heidegger both makes problematic traditional expressions of faith and religion as well as renews and calls forth their lasting source. Heidegger said (with some contempt) that people of faith do not even raise the question of Being, though if he were to write a theology (which he never did) the word "Being", we are told, would not appear. [/quote] Cool. I appreciate Heidegger's erudition and philosophical imagination immensely. He is one of the most "fun" philosophers that I've read to date. My opinion on the value of Heidegger's philosophy is borderline worthless considering my standing as a philosopher, but I nonetheless have a take on the matter. In essence, I agree with your last paragraph if multiplied by 0.26 or so. hehe In other words when I read things by those who are in love with Heidegger or see him as one of the most important guys in philosophical history, I tend to appreciate their basic points, but generally feel that they are drastically over-stated. If I were a neo-scholastic I would perhaps be very much threatened by Heidegger, but as one who has always tended more toward the apophatic traditions and the mystical theology of the Catholic religion the implications and challenges of Heidegger's philosophy have a bit less sting. To be honest I find myself agreeing with Heidegger more than I disagree. Perhaps I have been infected with Heideggerian views via osmosis. But still, like most broad stroke criticisms, I think his fundamental critique of western metaphysics is too general and discounts a lot of the more obscure thinkers in the tradition who I've happened to admire. We'll see how my impression changes once I have a chance to pore over the late writings. That's cool that you're reading [i]What is Called Thinking[/i], be sure to tell me what you think of it. :-)
missionseeker Posted January 25, 2007 Posted January 25, 2007 We're reading Hobbes and Locke and Rouseau(sp) this semester. Is this a place where I can ask questions about what we've read?
Guest JeffCR07 Posted January 25, 2007 Posted January 25, 2007 absolutely, this thread is meant to be about philosophy, so if you have any philosophical questions, then this is the place to ask them!
Laudate_Dominum Posted January 26, 2007 Author Posted January 26, 2007 [quote name='JeffCR07' post='1176060' date='Jan 25 2007, 05:41 PM'] absolutely, this thread is meant to be about philosophy, so if you have any philosophical questions, then this is the place to ask them! [/quote]
Era Might Posted January 26, 2007 Posted January 26, 2007 What is math? Is math a human invention? Did mankind create math or discover math? Why is math universal? Can different cultures create different number systems, like we have different vocabularies?
Guest JeffCR07 Posted January 26, 2007 Posted January 26, 2007 Well, first I would state that "mathematics" is the science concerning the relationship between numbers (and variables, though a variable is an abstraction from numbers). Given this, I would argue that numbers are arrived at as a result of man's natural and implicit analysis of essence and existence in observation. Basically, we see [i]this[/i] cup and [i]that[/i] cup, and in doing so we see two very simple facts. First, they are different things (we individuate the one from the other). Second, they are both [i]cups[/i] (they have the same essence. In this way, we find multiplicities of essences in nature, and from this fact we are able to abstract pure entities of multiplicity (the different numbers). For the record, I do not subscribe to the platonic hypostatization of numbers, but I do think that numbers [i]exist[/i], just in the same way that I would assert that ideas exist (but that subject could get really interesting...)
Laudate_Dominum Posted January 27, 2007 Author Posted January 27, 2007 To briefly add to Jeff's comments... [quote name='Era Might' post='1176831' date='Jan 26 2007, 02:32 PM']Can different cultures create different number systems, like we have different vocabularies? [/quote] Yes. Besides the base ten number system there are many others such as base twenty, base sixty, base nine, base twelve, etc. Historically there have been a variety of positional numeral systems which use a variety of radices. Even today there are quite a few numeral systems in use, for example binary (radix=2) and hexadecimal (radix=16). There are practical reasons why one system may be said to be preferable to another. The adoption of the base ten decimal system that we are most familiar with today fostered significant developments in mathematics because it had a greater capacity to describe the mathematical principles which are embodied in the world around us. As is commonly known, the base ten notation that we use today, which includes the number zero, were imports from India (replacing the old Roman numeral system). The binary system, while perhaps being too far removed from our natural way of thinking to be altogether practical for balancing a checkbook, has made possible the computer technology which drives phatmass because of its direct applicability to the primitive qualities of electronic circuitry. More to come...
Thy Geekdom Come Posted January 27, 2007 Posted January 27, 2007 [quote name='JeffCR07' post='1177082' date='Jan 26 2007, 07:15 PM'] platonic hypostatization of numbers [/quote] ...and that will be my sole contribution to this thread. Thank you.
Franimus Posted January 27, 2007 Posted January 27, 2007 Wow, philosophy, binary, and hexadecimal ALL IN THE SAME THREAD! *oogles* I say that math is a universal thing which was discovered by humans, just as matter and time were discovered.
Laudate_Dominum Posted January 28, 2007 Author Posted January 28, 2007 [quote name='Era Might' post='1176831' date='Jan 26 2007, 02:32 PM']What is math? [/quote] I don't know. Several common definitions come to mind but none of them strike me as entirely adequate. For the sake of perpetuating the discussion I will assert my own working definition, and I apologize in advance for its imprecision (I must greatly compress my view since this is a message board post). I would describe mathematics broadly as the process of systematically formalizing the intelligibility of dimensional existence. This description should not be understood as implying that mathematics is by nature empirical; my view is that mathematics pertains essentially to the range of possibility inherent to the noetic apparatus. At first glance this may appear to be a move toward philosophical idealism, but in fact my view would be better described as a kind of moderate realism. The assumption to my view is that mathematics is borne from the noetic capacity to formulate and project abstract possibilities into the field of intelligibility. Thus I would locate the basis of axiomatic deduction, mathematic conjecture and the [i]a priori [/i] modality of axiomatic formulation itself foundationally in the salient structure of human situatedness. One might object by suggesting that we have an innate understanding of quantity but the fact is I don't exactly disagree with this. What I'm saying is more that when we begin systematically formalizing such concepts in terms of signs (i.e., numbers) we are talking about a sort of linguistic project. Thus mathematics as mathematics is a kind of extension of language with its own particular properties and rules. [quote name='Era Might' post='1176831' date='Jan 26 2007, 02:32 PM'] Is math a human invention? Did mankind create math or discover math? Why is math universal? [/quote] In light of my above viewpoint it would seem that mathematics as such is a human invention but that the intelligibility of diastemic reality which it attempts to explicitly describe is something that is discovered or uncovered through the process of systematic formalization. Although I would also say that the processes of mathematics can at times obscure this intelligibility. This occurs when the locus of mathematical [i]ergon[/i] is misunderstood, for example when people absolutize aspects of mathematics in such a way that mathematical deductions become ontological assumptions. In sum I would answer that the subject matter of mathematics is universal but that the conceptual and symbolic edifice of mathematics is not universal and cannot be in any strict sense because of the contextualization in what I call 'the salient structure of human situatedness'. Crud.. There is a ton more that I'd like to throw out there but I have to go.
EcceNovaFacioOmni Posted January 28, 2007 Posted January 28, 2007 [quote name='Laudate_Dominum' post='1178139' date='Jan 27 2007, 08:38 PM'] I don't know. Several common definitions come to mind but none of them strike me as entirely adequate. For the sake of perpetuating the discussion I will assert my own working definition, and I apologize in advance for its imprecision (I must greatly compress my view since this is a message board post). I would describe mathematics broadly as the process of systematically formalizing the intelligibility of dimensional existence. This description should not be understood as implying that mathematics is by nature empirical; my view is that mathematics pertains essentially to the range of possibility inherent to the noetic apparatus. At first glance this may appear to be a move toward philosophical idealism, but in fact my view would be better described as a kind of moderate realism. The assumption to my view is that mathematics is borne from the noetic capacity to formulate and project abstract possibilities into the field of intelligibility. Thus I would locate the basis of axiomatic deduction, mathematic conjecture and the [i]a priori [/i] modality of axiomatic formulation itself foundationally in the salient structure of human situatedness. One might object by suggesting that we have an innate understanding of quantity but the fact is I don't exactly disagree with this. What I'm saying is more that when we begin systematically formalizing such concepts in terms of signs (i.e., numbers) we are talking about a sort of linguistic project. Thus mathematics as mathematics is a kind of extension of language with its own particular properties and rules. In light of my above viewpoint it would seem that mathematics as such is a human invention but that the intelligibility of diastemic reality which it attempts to explicitly describe is something that is discovered or uncovered through the process of systematic formalization. Although I would also say that the processes of mathematics can at times obscure this intelligibility. This occurs when the locus of mathematical [i]ergon[/i] is misunderstood, for example when people absolutize aspects of mathematics in such a way that mathematical deductions become ontological assumptions. In sum I would answer that the subject matter of mathematics is universal but that the conceptual and symbolic edifice of mathematics is not universal and cannot be in any strict sense because of the contextualization in what I call 'the salient structure of human situatedness'. Crud.. There is a ton more that I'd like to throw out there but I have to go. [/quote]
Laudate_Dominum Posted January 29, 2007 Author Posted January 29, 2007 My description of mathematics in terms of process may seem strange at first glance ([i]"Mathematics is the process of systematically formalizing dimensional existence in its intelligibility"[/i]), but this is because I am not approaching the matter according to the activity of static schematization (at least I'm struggling not to). I am approaching mathematics somewhat as an anthropological phenomenon. You might say that my first question would be what is mathematics 'for us'? I believe that this entails conceiving of it diachronically. I realize that my previous post includes a number of terms that I should probably define or at least clarify a bit. The problem is that my philosophical take on mathematics is currently a work in progress and to be honest this line of speculation is forcing me to reconsider my understanding of knowledge and language so I may require a significant conceptual overhaul before I will truly have a cogent approach to the problem. Hopefully other people will pipe in soon to carry on this thread while I wallow in philosophical madness.
missionseeker Posted February 8, 2007 Posted February 8, 2007 1st question: Can someone elaborate on existentialism for me? I'm starting Sartre and sort of confused.
Theoketos Posted February 8, 2007 Posted February 8, 2007 [quote name='missionseeker' post='1187914' date='Feb 7 2007, 08:49 PM'] 1st question: Can someone elaborate on existentialism for me? I'm starting Sartre and sort of confused. [/quote] [url="http://www-berkeley.ansys.com/wayne/sartre-cookbook.html"]This is one of the best illustrations of Sarte I have read. [/url]
missionseeker Posted February 10, 2008 Posted February 10, 2008 (edited) I have to write a paper on the first section of Kant's Groundwork analyzing the relation of Good Will, Duty, and Law. Just a couple of points that I'd like to make sure that I'm clear about. For Kant, any system of morality must be a priori and not empirical, for if it is empirical then it is not universal? Even if one is inclined towards duty, the inclination towrds that duty should not be the motivation for acting in accordance with Duty, but Duty itself and if it is from the inclination, the act has no moral worth at best and is bad at worst? I will probabl have more as I write. Thanks Edited February 10, 2008 by missionseeker
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now