missionseeker Posted March 20, 2008 Posted March 20, 2008 (edited) well... I basically just said that I thought I would throw into my midterm an argument (not big, just a little thing on the end) that in book five, chapter 10 of Nicomachean Ethics, one could argue that the "decent man" is the merciful man I'm at a Catholic school, so I can do things like that within a certain extent. In Book Five, Chapter ten of Nicomachean Ethics, Aristotle begins to elaborate on the notion of decency, what is decent, and who is the decent man. This notion of decency poses many questions. Are decent and just the same? If they are not, is one of more worth than the other? If they are, why can something be just and not decent and why is that which is called decent not also called just? Aristotle says that justice and decency seem to be “neither the same, nor different”. But decency and justice are also not interchangeable. Whatever is more decent is also more desirable. This would seem to mean that decency is without justice, for that which is praised for being decent is praised despite not being just. The decent, though, is not outside of the just. Aristotle claims that decency is a type of just. This is a particular type of justice and because it is preferable it is of more worth. But even this presents a problem: even though decency is just, is not just according to the law. This is because every law is a universal and every situation is a particular. It is impossible to have a universal for every circumstance. There are situations for which the universal fails to be good, just, or decent. This is why Aristotle says that decency is a “setting straight of a law, insofar as it leaves something out as a result of being universal”. Because of the universal, what is just in the particular situation is not what is prescribed by the universal. The decent is what the universal would have prescribed had the situation been known. This leads to the question: “who is the decent man?”. The decent man is he who sees the universal and knows when it is appropriate to deviate from that prescription. Often, he willingly takes less than what be just, even though the law is in his favour. It seems that Aristotle almost has two definitions of the word “decent”. In the first part, the part that explains decency and its relation to justice, it seems as if decency is simply the knowledge of what is just when the universal is not just in the particular. However, when he is talking about the decent man, it seems as if one could replace “decent” with merciful. A man who takes less than he is entitled to, even when the law favours him, is necessarily giving another party more than he deserves. An obvious example would be in the forgiving of a debt, but one could also say that a man speeding to take another man who is sick to the hospital is merciful because he is risking having the law against him (even though the law may excuse it) and risking taking the penalty. --------------------------------- that's what I wound up writing. Our assignment was just to outline and explicate one of a number of chapters and I chose that one. He gave me an A. I've never gotten an A from him. And A-, yes, but never an A. It's a small class (8 people) and a small school and he has his own way of grading and idea of what he's looking for. I think he really just wants to know that you understand something that you read. Edited March 20, 2008 by missionseeker
Guest Kayla Posted March 24, 2008 Posted March 24, 2008 I'm a freshman, but 99.9% sure I'm going to be a philosophy major. First semester I took Logic and right now I'm in Epistemology (I know, big jump! oh well!), and I'm loving it. We've studied some Plato, Aristotle, Aquinas, Augustine, Sextus Empericus, Kant, and looking to head to Locke. I've got a big paper due here in a few weeks, where I basically get to choose my own prompt. I'm considering using Aristotle/Aquinas to answer Sextus and his problem of the criterion. And for a question... how do you respond to the problem error in Aristotle/Aquinas' process of Induction/Abstraction? Is it something to do with the agent intellect? Or does it all just have to do with 'experience' and having enough 'images' to work with? Basically, how can you know that you know, how can you be sure that you're not deceived?
missionseeker Posted May 1, 2008 Posted May 1, 2008 so... i'm writing a paper on Love... for ethics. Actually.. it's more about the idea of "person" and love and ends.lol
missionseeker Posted May 8, 2008 Posted May 8, 2008 In Nicomachean Ethics, Aristotle says that the job of the human soul is the habituation of the intellect to virtue. He calls this habituation “being-at-work”. Being-at-work is the actualization of the intellects potential capabilities. In Love and Responsibility, Karol Wojtyla says that love is the culmination of human activity, that love is “the greatest possible fullness of being”. He says that love is the cause and end of all human actions. In Gospel of Matthew, a Pharisee attempting to trick Jesus asked Him “Teacher, which is the great commandment in the law?" And he said to him, "You shall love the Lord your God with all your heart, and with all your soul, and with all your mind. This is the great and first commandment. And a second is like it, You shall love your neighbor as yourself. On these two commandments depend all the law and the prophets." At first, this seems simple enough; in the words of The Beatles, “all you need is love”. Yet, if one takes just another second, the words of Christ raise so many questions that it makes one’s head spin. What is love? How does one love? Why must one love his neighbor and what does that mean? How does one love God? Isn’t self love egotistical? How does one overcome egotistical love of self? In order to understand what love is, one must first understand the person as the person is the only creature that can love and can receive love (in active manner). The objects that we experience are separated into two categories: persons and things. Persons are separated from things by the power of their intellect. Only persons can perceive things from within themselves and from outside of themselves. They can perceive themselves and other persons as the complete and completely separate entities that they are. He can recognize the fact that man alone in creation has this ability and that in creation every animate object (such as plants and animals) cannot be called a person. The animals are separated from and cannot be called persons because their intellects are purely sensory. They can perceive other objects and they can even perceive feelings to an extent (fear, hunger, pain) but they cannot reason; they cannot overcome the urges and feelings that they do have because they operate on an instinctual basis. Humans, however, can overcome instinctual desires, urges, and thoughts by virtue of their reason. It could be said that difference between humans and animals is that persons can perceive themselves from within themselves. Persons can also think of themselves in relation to other persons and things. A reasonable man would not say that a tree or a raccoon had as much right to live as a human. There is still something that plants and even animals are missing that humans have; something that sets humans apart and above every other thing or species in the physical world: an intellect that can know itself and know beyond itself. This ability to know beyond itself in a comprehensive manner is what makes the person capable of love. Pierre-Marie Emonet says that “love is a psychic movement that moves in an opposite direction to the movement of knowledge”. Knowledge moves the object towards the person knowing; in order to know, one must bring the object to be know into one’s self. Knowledge is imprinted upon the intellect, it is taken in. Love, on the other hand, is the soul’s movement toward the object that it knows. This knowledge and love must begin within the person. In a sense, all love begins as egotistical because human intellect is developed by loving. The work of the intellect is to know. Because the intellect is personal, the first thing that the intellect knows is its own person. Even this, though is a primitive, instinctual type of knowing: a knowing of desires. This is clearly seen in the development of children. The newborn infant knows nothing about parent/child relationships. The only thing that a newborn infant “knows” is that he is hungry or in some other way uncomfortable. Though the infant would not be able to articulate it, this is “knowledge” is the first emanation of self love. And it is only through this “self love” that a child can begin to love others. He learns to love his parent, though at first not to love his parent or the sake of his parent, but for the sake of his own desires being fulfilled by that parent. This is the type of egotistical love that must be overcome. If the child never outgrows his “I-love-you-for-the-sake-of-my-needs-being-met” phase, he can never truly love anyone else. But as the child grows, he learns that his desires are not the only desires that exist. He learns that others’ desires must be taken into account if there is to be a peaceful coexistence. He eventually learns – at least in an ideal environment- that every other person has just as much worth as his person has. In order for him to come to this conclusion, though, it is imperative that he has a healthy love of self. If he loves himself too much, he inhibits love of God, the natural end of man. If he loves himself too much, he will love others too little; if he loves himself not enough, he will not love others enough, either. Or, he will come to love others more than he loves himself and place his worth in others. This cannot be done because then, a person thinks of himself as subhuman and not as a person. The command to “love your neighbor as yourself” obviously implies that love of self is required for other love. This love of self and love of neighbor and love of God can all be summed into “love of person”. The commandment to love God with “all you heart, and with all your soul and with all your mind shows that God is the most perfect being. The commandment to “love your neighbor as yourself” shows the intrinsic value of the person, every person. This is what John Paul II calls “the personalistic norm”. This norm is the acknowledgment of the value inherent within a person simply because he is a person, not a thing. When human actions are driven by this norm, use of other persons is eliminated. When this norm is not the motivating force behind actions, human interactions become utilitarian. Utilitarianism inhibits human interactions from expressing love because it treats persons as things, not as persons; as means to ends for one’s own sake, and not individual, free thinking and choosing persons, not as end by himself. Wojtyla writes that “anyone who treats a person as a means to an end does violence to the very essence of the other”. Violence obliterates love. The basis of actions in the personalistic norm is essential. If an action is not rooted in the personalistic norm, it is use; if an action is utilitarian, there can be no love. If there is no love, a man can never reach perfection; his soul can never ultimately “be-at-work”. Wojtyla’s teaching is directly opposed to Kant’s theories. Kant’s theories of Duty and Law have shaped the ethical thought process of the last three centuries. According to Kant, only one motive of action is of any moral worth: Duty. I'm only like halfway through lengthwise, but does anyone have any feedback?
Innocent Posted August 25, 2008 Posted August 25, 2008 (edited) [quote name='missionseeker' post='1480551' date='Mar 20 2008, 01:08 PM']It seems that Aristotle almost has two definitions of the word “decent”. In the first part, the part that explains decency and its relation to justice, it seems as if decency is simply the knowledge of what is just when the universal is not just in the particular. However, when he is talking about the decent man, it seems as if one could replace “decent” with merciful. A man who takes less than he is entitled to, even when the law favours him, is necessarily giving another party more than he deserves. An obvious example would be in the forgiving of a debt, but one could also say that a man speeding to take another man who is sick to the hospital is merciful because he is risking having the law against him (even though the law may excuse it) and risking taking the penalty.[/quote] With those examples, couldn't you also say that "decency" can be replaced with "magnanimity"? Or does mercy describe it better than magnanimity? Edited August 25, 2008 by Innocent
Ziggamafu Posted August 26, 2008 Posted August 26, 2008 (edited) re: Math Ironically, I was just reading Hume on the subject. Even Hume was willing to accept math as formal truth. I have wondered, from time to time, if math is actually an aspect of God's own ontology of Truth? After all, math certainly seems to be an eternal principle, and has no physical substance. I suppose the real philosophical question is: "Before" God created Space / Time and the matter that occupies it, did 2+2 still = 4? I would say yes. 2+2 still = 4 even if there are no objects by which the principle may be demonstrated. Edited August 26, 2008 by Ziggamafu
Selah Posted August 26, 2008 Posted August 26, 2008 [quote name='Raphael' post='1177157' date='Jan 26 2007, 10:11 PM'] ...and that will be my sole contribution to this thread. Thank you.[/quote]
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now