Tony Posted January 16, 2007 Posted January 16, 2007 did I tell you all about the time Flowery *whispers* and then she *whispers again*.. but you can't her I told you this! :-P
littleflower+JMJ Posted January 16, 2007 Posted January 16, 2007 [quote name='Tony' post='1166408' date='Jan 15 2007, 08:56 PM'] did I tell you all about the time Flowery *whispers* and then she *whispers again*.. but you can't her I told you this! :-P [/quote]
MissScripture Posted January 16, 2007 Posted January 16, 2007 [quote name='Tony' post='1166408' date='Jan 15 2007, 08:56 PM'] did I tell you all about the time Flowery *whispers* and then she *whispers again*.. but you can't her I told you this! :-P [/quote] Now I wanna know what she did! :
Socrates Posted January 16, 2007 Posted January 16, 2007 According to the Baltimore Catechism, among the things forbidded by the Eight Commandment is "the telling of secrets we are bound to keep."
homeschoolmom Posted January 16, 2007 Posted January 16, 2007 One thing I hate is the telling of secrets under the guise of requesting prayer for someone else... "Abby needs prayer for the nervous breakdown that she's having... yes, she was in the hospital for weeks... so, um, yeah... keep her in your prayers."
CrossCuT Posted January 16, 2007 Posted January 16, 2007 [size=1]Should Catholics keep secrets? Secrets about what??? [/size]
Paddington Posted January 16, 2007 Posted January 16, 2007 [quote name='homeschoolmom' post='1166447' date='Jan 16 2007, 12:54 AM'] One thing I hate is the telling of secrets under the guise of requesting prayer for someone else... "Abby needs prayer for the nervous breakdown that she's having... yes, she was in the hospital for weeks... so, um, yeah... keep her in your prayers." [/quote] SOOO Funny! : Yet, not. I think we should let bad things happen rather than break our trustiness. It would have to be something really really really bad to break the vow of secrecy. I was in Protestant churches for a while. They didn't have the whole "special intention" thing going on, in my experience. I tried it recently at my friend's Bible Study and I'm not sure they understood it. I wanted them to pray for Paddington's Special Intention and the guy did a general prayer for me.
CeeBee Posted January 16, 2007 Posted January 16, 2007 I think in rare cases where there is a sufficiently serious reason to break a confidence (e.g. someone intends to commit suicide, a minor tells you of ongoing abuse) you should always tell the person involved that you feel a moral obligation to tell such and such a person and if possible ask them to tell that person themselves, or give you permission to do so. Obviously this isn't always possible. Certainly you should not break a confidence unless someone's welfare is seriously at stake and I agree that even then you should tell the minimum number of people possible to resolve the situation. However it is worth bearing in mind that sometimes someone will disclose something personal because they want it dealt with and haven't the courage to do so themselves, so if you think a third party deserves to know and they won't tell them it is always worth asking for their permission to tell the third party yourself (though again, if they say no and you don't have a very serious reason you would have to respect their wishes). Just my opinion.
CrossCuT Posted January 16, 2007 Posted January 16, 2007 [size=1]So is this about keeping secrets or telling lies? And why does it apply only to "Catholics"? This thread seems really silly to me [/size]
EcceNovaFacioOmni Posted January 19, 2007 Author Posted January 19, 2007 (edited) This thread applies to everyone really, but I am looking for the teaching of the Church. I understand confidentiality, but what about spending all your cash on a Nintendo Wii or something and hiding it from your parents (no I did not do this...)? Something about this type of secrecy makes me feel odd. I was recently told something by a sibling (married and moved out) that I am not to tell my mother about (not really a big deal and she'll find out eventually) but it still irks me a bit. Edited January 19, 2007 by thedude
cmotherofpirl Posted January 19, 2007 Posted January 19, 2007 [quote name='thedude' post='1170102' date='Jan 19 2007, 12:18 PM'] This thread applies to everyone really, but I am looking for the teaching of the Church. I understand confidentiality, but what about spending all your cash on a Nintendo Wii or something and hiding it from your parents (no I did not do this...)? Something about this type of secrecy makes me feel odd. I was recently told something by a sibling (married and moved out) that I am not to tell my mother about (not really a big deal and she'll find out eventually) but it still irks me a bit. [/quote] If your parents give you money and expect you to spend the money on school books, and you buy the Nintendo, that is not keeping a secret, that is deception. If your sibling doesn't want your mother to know something then sibling shouldn't tell it to you. You should not be asked to keep a secret someone else is unwilling to keep. And if your mother finds out you you knew and didn't tell her is is gonna be upset, and if you tell your sibling will be upset. It is rude to put people in such positions.
EcceNovaFacioOmni Posted January 19, 2007 Author Posted January 19, 2007 This adult sibling has acquired a new pet. They have lots of pets so she is afraid my mom will think it's a bad idea or something. Doesn't seem like a big enough secret for me to go tell my mom about, especially when my sibling is an adult. I think I'll stay out of it. She intends to show my mom next time she visits anyway.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now