mroger Posted January 16, 2007 Posted January 16, 2007 [url="http://www.cwnews.com/news/viewstory.cfm?recnum=48634"]http://www.cwnews.com/news/viewstory.cfm?recnum=48634[/url] This is the link to a story about the gay activists, and it's all about how they have rights too. yes, they have the right to seek God and do God's will in accordance with the Apostle Paul, who, in effect, said [and I'm paraphrasing] "Don't be a homo". Paul's message was consistent with the Old Testament too. There is not such a thing as gay rights, not as I define it anyway. Right to what? What inalienable right do they not have, that all human beings do not also have? Getting married is not a human right, it is a Human Rite, a sacrament. The way I see it, all this protestant theology about being spiritual obscures something that I see is more important. In fact, it purposely does so. What is most important to me and what Evangelists will "play down" is Holiness. I think they would have you believe, along with the Unitarians, is that Spirituality should replace Holiness. In Public Relations, we call this "ownership". It is when a group of interested persons take ownership of a position. In effort to do so, they must also create a particular kind of vocabulary that favors that position. It is something that our Church actually needs to do. We've lost words like sanctity in the vocabulary of everyday conversation regarding religious topics and I'd like to bring about the return of a distinctly Catholic vocabulary in a way that it is not being attacked daily, but in a way that we renew the faith for all who've gone astray from the Sacraments. It must be so strong that anyone who would dare attack the values which support this vocabulary would seem foolish to all, not just to Catholics. We need to globalize the vocabulary of Catholicism in a way that special interest groups, like the gay rights activists would lose political steam and crazies who set themselves on fire will be recognized for what they are - delusional. The first key to building any defense is communication - always. This communication always begins with a kind of vocabulary. This vocabulary protects the interested persons in debate and discussion. I read the book by Father Waiss, Letters Between a Catholic and an Evangelical. Its content seems obvious enough, but the arguments of Father Waiss, while accurate, fail to be convincing. And believe me - I'm very Catholic, do not fear that I am going to the other side. But Waiss is inadequate in building a favorable vocabulary and actually allows the Protestant to take ownership of some parts of arguments that are distinctly Catholic. My efforts here is to bring words like Sacrament, Sanctity and Holiness into the interest of Theological spotlight, having the Catholic church take ownership of them, and setting the standard for faith and behavior for Protestants. Such that substitute or linear words like "symbols or signs, spirituality" do not have the effect that would make others believe that Catholics do not possess these qualities. I don't want to be misundertstood. I'm not saying that Catholic are not spiritual, I think we have always owned spirituality. But for the last 50 years, Protestant evangelicals are outgunning us, using distinctly Ignatian practices and claiming them as their own. It would seem to the Protestant that Catholics lack spirituality, which they place above Holiness. I want Holiness, which is Judiac/Catholic, or "Old School" to reclaim its priority above Spiritual. In Holiness, the perverted ideals of gays who set themselves on fire for political activism are self-defeating, but it does not seem to be the case in spirituality.
Jesus_lol Posted January 16, 2007 Posted January 16, 2007 i wonder if anyone here actually considers gay people to be human as well. there is so much discrimination against them for something that in most cases they were born with or was a result of their upbringing. to my eyes a post like this outright condemning a group of people to hell for being born a certain way, is akin to saying the same about women or african americans. rascism isnt the ony form of discrimination. and about them wanting more rights it is because legally they are less than human and do not have many of the rights that we take for granted, not just the right to marry. gay people are people as well, and i should not have to tell you that. please dont just shut the door on a large part of humanity simply because they are different from you.
Veritas Posted January 16, 2007 Posted January 16, 2007 [quote name='geistesswiesenschaften' post='1166824' date='Jan 16 2007, 01:12 PM'] [url="http://www.cwnews.com/news/viewstory.cfm?recnum=48634"]http://www.cwnews.com/news/viewstory.cfm?recnum=48634[/url] This is the link to a story about the gay activists, and it's all about how they have rights too. yes, they have the right to seek God and do God's will in accordance with the Apostle Paul, who, in effect, said [and I'm paraphrasing] "Don't be a homo". Paul's message was consistent with the Old Testament too. There is not such a thing as gay rights, not as I define it anyway. Right to what? What inalienable right do they not have, that all human beings do not also have? Getting married is not a human right, it is a Human Rite, a sacrament. The way I see it, all this protestant theology about being spiritual obscures something that I see is more important. In fact, it purposely does so. What is most important to me and what Evangelists will "play down" is Holiness. I think they would have you believe, along with the Unitarians, is that Spirituality should replace Holiness. In Public Relations, we call this "ownership". It is when a group of interested persons take ownership of a position. In effort to do so, they must also create a particular kind of vocabulary that favors that position. It is something that our Church actually needs to do. We've lost words like sanctity in the vocabulary of everyday conversation regarding religious topics and I'd like to bring about the return of a distinctly Catholic vocabulary in a way that it is not being attacked daily, but in a way that we renew the faith for all who've gone astray from the Sacraments. It must be so strong that anyone who would dare attack the values which support this vocabulary would seem foolish to all, not just to Catholics. We need to globalize the vocabulary of Catholicism in a way that special interest groups, like the gay rights activists would lose political steam and crazies who set themselves on fire will be recognized for what they are - delusional. The first key to building any defense is communication - always. This communication always begins with a kind of vocabulary. This vocabulary protects the interested persons in debate and discussion. I read the book by Father Waiss, Letters Between a Catholic and an Evangelical. Its content seems obvious enough, but the arguments of Father Waiss, while accurate, fail to be convincing. And believe me - I'm very Catholic, do not fear that I am going to the other side. But Waiss is inadequate in building a favorable vocabulary and actually allows the Protestant to take ownership of some parts of arguments that are distinctly Catholic. My efforts here is to bring words like Sacrament, Sanctity and Holiness into the interest of Theological spotlight, having the Catholic church take ownership of them, and setting the standard for faith and behavior for Protestants. Such that substitute or linear words like "symbols or signs, spirituality" do not have the effect that would make others believe that Catholics do not possess these qualities. I don't want to be misundertstood. I'm not saying that Catholic are not spiritual, I think we have always owned spirituality. But for the last 50 years, Protestant evangelicals are outgunning us, using distinctly Ignatian practices and claiming them as their own. It would seem to the Protestant that Catholics lack spirituality, which they place above Holiness. I want Holiness, which is Judiac/Catholic, or "Old School" to reclaim its priority above Spiritual. In Holiness, the perverted ideals of gays who set themselves on fire for political activism are self-defeating, but it does not seem to be the case in spirituality. [/quote] + Amen! Finally!
Bonbon Posted January 16, 2007 Posted January 16, 2007 God blow up Sodam(sp) and Gamora(sp) (that city with all the gay people) because of all the sins and sinners AKA homo's
Laudate_Dominum Posted January 16, 2007 Posted January 16, 2007 [quote name='Cardinals Flower' post='1166852' date='Jan 16 2007, 02:34 PM'] God blow up Sodam(sp) and Gamora(sp) (that city with all the gay people) because of all the sins and sinners AKA homo's [/quote] huh?
Veritas Posted January 16, 2007 Posted January 16, 2007 [quote name='Jesus_lol' post='1166838' date='Jan 16 2007, 01:22 PM'] i wonder if anyone here actually considers gay people to be human as well. there is so much discrimination against them for something that in most cases they were born with or was a result of their upbringing. to my eyes a post like this outright condemning a group of people to hell for being born a certain way, is akin to saying the same about women or african americans. rascism isnt the ony form of discrimination. and about them wanting more rights it is because legally they are less than human and do not have many of the rights that we take for granted, not just the right to marry. gay people are people as well, and i should not have to tell you that. please dont just shut the door on a large part of humanity simply because they are different from you. [/quote] + Everyone has the right to discriminate on the basis of behaviour. Homosexuality is a behaviour. Being African American or of a certain ethnic descent is NOT. This is a fundamental, logical difference. Attempting to equate the two belays a basic misunderstanding of logic. Finally, no ONE is condemning anyone to Hell in the Catholic Church. However, they ARE being faithful to the teachings of Christ by pointing out an extreme danger to one's soul! And, in the face of much relativistic objection -THAT is true love! Individuals with same-sex attractions deserve kindness and help overcoming their disorder just as someone attracted to children, an individual with anxiety, or a kleptomaniac.
Laudate_Dominum Posted January 16, 2007 Posted January 16, 2007 I believe that same sex eroticism is intrinsically disordered, but this doesn't mean that people with those inclinations are evil. There are plenty of immoral tendencies that fall under the category of heterosexuality. The desire to check out porn, temptations toward auto-erotic behaviour, marital infidelity, fornication, etc. I just don't understand why sins of same sex eroticism, and persons with those inclinations deserve some sort of special status as if being heterosexual automatically means that you are without concupiscence and sin.
prose Posted January 16, 2007 Posted January 16, 2007 To me, I see it this way... What rights do gay people NOT have? If someone can name me 5 rights that a gay person does not have that a heterosexual person does have, then we can talk. Essentially, they have all the human rights of any other human.
Jesus_lol Posted January 16, 2007 Posted January 16, 2007 well for one marraige. in most places that is denied to gays even those that may truely love each other. i think if we can marry a man and a woman who do not actually truely love each other then to gays who love each other should be allowed to marry. adopting children. only one of the "parents" gets legal rights to that child, and the other parent is not allowed any. also are only allowed to adopt if they are single, which is odd as normally you need to be in a stable relationship to adopt. are not allowed to donate blood. this is related to the myth that only gay people have AIDS. even though when AIDS first came out it was predominantly in gay men now that has changed and young-middle aged women is the fastest growing group with AIDS. basically if you had gay sex(even protected) at any point after the 70s you cant donate blood, yet if you are heterosexual but have had unprotected sex with 150 different anonymous partners you will still be allowed to donate blood. there is a few that are actual laws.
Veritas Posted January 16, 2007 Posted January 16, 2007 (edited) [quote name='Jesus_lol' post='1166877' date='Jan 16 2007, 01:59 PM'] well for one marraige. in most places that is denied to gays even those that may truely love each other. i think if we can marry a man and a woman who do not actually truely love each other then to gays who love each other should be allowed to marry. adopting children. only one of the "parents" gets legal rights to that child, and the other parent is not allowed any. also are only allowed to adopt if they are single, which is odd as normally you need to be in a stable relationship to adopt. are not allowed to donate blood. this is related to the myth that only gay people have AIDS. even though when AIDS first came out it was predominantly in gay men now that has changed and young-middle aged women is the fastest growing group with AIDS. basically if you had gay sex(even protected) at any point after the 70s you cant donate blood, yet if you are heterosexual but have had unprotected sex with 150 different anonymous partners you will still be allowed to donate blood. there is a few that are actual laws. [/quote] + I think people, who don't agree with the homosexual agenda are often seen as "mean" because we "won't let people do whatever they want." However, it must be seen that many people must, at many times ,not do what they want (even if it makes them immediately 'happy' in the short term). For example: drug addicts, sex addicts, child molesters, over-eaters, shopping-addicts, kleptomaniacs, etc... These things do not honor the created order. The question must be, "Who made us?" If we really believe that God made us, we must believe that he knows what is best for us! The next time you and I create the world and everything in it, we can decide how things work! But, for now, there are challenges to be overcome -including unhealthy desires like homosexuality! Furthermore, look at the example of something purported to be as innocuous as birth control in the 1970's. Then, look at the fruits -rampant pre-marital sex leading to rampant abortion, the abuse of women leading to super high divorce rates... people thought the Church was crazy for rejecting artificial birth-control, but infact she was wise and prophetic. We will see the same things from the cultural acceptance of homosexuality. The sad thing, is that so many will have to needlessly suffer because we are accepting the abuse of the body in the name of "acceptance" and "tolerance". Children especially. Homosexual "adoption" is one of the greatest travesties of our time and a serious form of child abuse. Edited January 16, 2007 by Veritas
mroger Posted January 16, 2007 Author Posted January 16, 2007 (edited) [mod]See phorum guidelines (personal attacks) - L_D[/mod] I'm just not going to go there. But as for marriage? What makes you think marriage and adoption are RIGHTS? They are not, they certainly are not. And let me tell you something - I was adopted. I really will not hear your opinion about who can adopt who. A person who cannot be morally straight must not adopt because of how vulnerable the children are. That DOES NOT exclude straight persons from the sin of bringing young, vulnerable children into a sinful home, the home of a person who "obstinately persists in sin". They no are lss sinful than a gay. And no one ever said otherwise. Edited January 16, 2007 by Laudate_Dominum
Veritas Posted January 16, 2007 Posted January 16, 2007 (edited) [quote name='Jesus_lol' post='1166877' date='Jan 16 2007, 01:59 PM'] well for one marraige. in most places that is denied to gays even those that may truely love each other. i think if we can marry a man and a woman who do not actually truely love each other then to gays who love each other should be allowed to marry. [/quote] + "love" isn't enough. Should a man be able to marry his dog because he loves it? His sister? His mother? 10 women? There must be matter as well as form and the matter is one biological woman and one biological man. We cannot deny the realities of our bodies and expect to be healthy and right. Edited January 16, 2007 by Veritas
Aloysius Posted January 16, 2007 Posted January 16, 2007 homosexuals have the exact same right to marriage as any other person in society. absolutely everyone has the right to marry a person of the opposite sex. No one is turned away from getting a marriage license from the state on the basis that they are gay. the state treats all males equally and all females equally. all males of age are afforded the right to marry any consenting female of age and all females of age are afforded the right to marry any consenting male of age.
mroger Posted January 16, 2007 Author Posted January 16, 2007 besides that, if you have beef about a gay not being able to marry, then consult your nearest Bible as to why that is. Don't worry, you don't even have to look in the Old Testament. Just stick with the New and you'll be allright!
prose Posted January 16, 2007 Posted January 16, 2007 [quote name='Aloysius' post='1166977' date='Jan 16 2007, 01:35 PM'] homosexuals have the exact same right to marriage as any other person in society. absolutely everyone has the right to marry a person of the opposite sex. No one is turned away from getting a marriage license from the state on the basis that they are gay. the state treats all males equally and all females equally. all males of age are afforded the right to marry any consenting female of age and all females of age are afforded the right to marry any consenting male of age. [/quote] Yup. So this right has not been infringed upon. As for adoption, since when is raising a child a "right"?? And for donating blood. Is it a "right" to be able to donate blood? If so we are infringing on the rights of people under 16, of drug users, and others too. I know someone very close to me who was refused the "right" to donate blood because she had unprotected sex within the last year. I was refused the "right" to donate blood because I had a tatoo in the last twelve months. That certainly was based on the myth that tatooed people have AIDS or Hep. C.
track2004 Posted January 16, 2007 Posted January 16, 2007 What's it matter if anything is a behavior. We let you give wine to kids; we let your priests marry people; we let you do all sorts of things even though you're Catholic. Being Catholic is a behavior. We let minorities have special rights because of their behaviors, gay people don't want special rights, they just want the regular ones extended to them. Being gay isn't a behavior, falling in love and all that is. I'll give you that, but really why is everyone all up in arms about the gay rights and the "gay agenda"? I guess the point that is always made in these arguments about sexual promiscuity is really the thing that upsets me the most. You are all up in arms, ready to get the torches out for 'sodomy' between gay people, but The Bible says all sorts of sex is wrong and that never gets discussed. I mean millions and millions of guys are having "alone time" that is a sexual sin. I'd argue more people are doing that than having gay sex. Straight couples have all sorts of sex that the OT considers 'sodomy'. So basically why don't you take a good long look at yourselves and your own community and fix all the problems in it before forcing your beliefs on the general populus. How are the rest of us supposed to abide by something some dead guy said 1000s of years ago about sex when you can't even make your own people abide??
Mercy me Posted January 16, 2007 Posted January 16, 2007 Good post Aloysius! One other thing to remember is that in this country, the US, individuals have rights. Couples do not have rights.
track2004 Posted January 16, 2007 Posted January 16, 2007 What about other rights besides marriage and adoption? In most areas gay people can be fired just because they are gay. One can be dishonorably discharged from the Armed Forces for being gay. One can be attacked or killed for being gay and it may not be considered a hate crime. One can be denied housing because they are gay. ETC. What about those things?
Mercy me Posted January 16, 2007 Posted January 16, 2007 [quote name='track2004' post='1167167' date='Jan 16 2007, 05:09 PM'] One can be attacked or killed for being gay and it may not be considered a hate crime. [/quote] What? No one can kill a person for being gay. This is ridiculous. So what about it whether it is or isn't a hate crime. Hate crime legislation is inherently unconstitutional because it makes certain people more protected than others. This is of course the antithesis of all men being created equal. Eventually it will be overturned.
avemaria40 Posted January 16, 2007 Posted January 16, 2007 [quote name='track2004' post='1167167' date='Jan 16 2007, 05:09 PM'] What about other rights besides marriage and adoption? In most areas gay people can be fired just because they are gay. One can be dishonorably discharged from the Armed Forces for being gay. One can be attacked or killed for being gay and it may not be considered a hate crime. One can be denied housing because they are gay. ETC. What about those things? [/quote] According to my dad (he would know, he works for my grandpa's business), you have the right to fire anyone for any reason under the sun. That's perfectly legal, as it is a private business. And if someone is killed for something like their sexuality, the reason it isn't always considered a hate crime is because it's always considered murder. It's still against the law to kill. Also, you could be denied housing for any reason. My gay guy friend is going to Yale, wears Louis Vuitton and gets to meet celebrities. What persecution!
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now