Veritas Posted January 17, 2007 Posted January 17, 2007 [quote name='track2004' post='1167167' date='Jan 16 2007, 04:09 PM'] What about other rights besides marriage and adoption? In most areas gay people can be fired just because they are gay. One can be dishonorably discharged from the Armed Forces for being gay. One can be attacked or killed for being gay and it may not be considered a hate crime. One can be denied housing because they are gay. ETC. What about those things? [/quote] + Again, discrimination on the basis of behaviour is a right. If I don't want to employ someone or live with someone who is living the homosexual lifestyle, I have the right to do that -because behaviour is a choice. No one has the right to kill another, except in self-defense. [quote name='track2004' post='1167156' date='Jan 16 2007, 04:00 PM'] What's it matter if anything is a behavior. We let you give wine to kids; we let your priests marry people; we let you do all sorts of things even though you're Catholic. Being Catholic is a behavior. We let minorities have special rights because of their behaviors, gay people don't want special rights, they just want the regular ones extended to them. Being gay isn't a behavior, falling in love and all that is. I'll give you that, but really why is everyone all up in arms about the gay rights and the "gay agenda"? I guess the point that is always made in these arguments about sexual promiscuity is really the thing that upsets me the most. You are all up in arms, ready to get the torches out for 'sodomy' between gay people, but The Bible says all sorts of sex is wrong and that never gets discussed. I mean millions and millions of guys are having "alone time" that is a sexual sin. I'd argue more people are doing that than having gay sex. Straight couples have all sorts of sex that the OT considers 'sodomy'. So basically why don't you take a good long look at yourselves and your own community and fix all the problems in it before forcing your beliefs on the general populus. How are the rest of us supposed to abide by something some dead guy said 1000s of years ago about sex when you can't even make your own people abide?? [/quote] + No body is saying all Catholics practice perfectly. No one is saying all Catholics do what they should. BUT, when another group attempts to claims special privileges and redefine something sinful as nonsinful, that's when Catholics have an OBLIGATION to speak the truth about the morality of sexuality. Jesus never said not to speak the truth!!
matthew1618 Posted January 17, 2007 Posted January 17, 2007 [quote name='geistesswiesenschaften' post='1166824' date='Jan 16 2007, 02:12 PM'] What Is A Gay Right? [/quote] Nothing, except it's limp at the wrist.
Resurrexi Posted January 17, 2007 Posted January 17, 2007 [quote name='matthew1618' post='1167381' date='Jan 16 2007, 06:49 PM'] Nothing, except it's limp at the wrist. [/quote]
Guest Den Ouji Posted January 17, 2007 Posted January 17, 2007 [quote name='Jesus_lol' post='1166838' date='Jan 17 2007, 03:22 AM'] i wonder if anyone here actually considers gay people to be human as well. there is so much discrimination against them for something that in most cases they were born with or was a result of their upbringing. to my eyes a post like this outright condemning a group of people to hell for being born a certain way, is akin to saying the same about women or african americans. rascism isnt the ony form of discrimination. and about them wanting more rights it is because legally they are less than human and do not have many of the rights that we take for granted, not just the right to marry. gay people are people as well, and i should not have to tell you that. please dont just shut the door on a large part of humanity simply because they are different from you. [/quote] Hey alien guy, I'm a gay too, but I know it's more important for my soul to be wedded to GOD's holy virtue than to go against the law of the Lord to become "something" unnatural! I know it's hard being a homosexual and it's really painful not being able to "officially" be together with someone you like. It's difficult for me too, not being able to love the person I love or do the things that other normal couples do. It's even more difficult for me coz I had lost a fatherly figure in my life since I was 8, now it's over 10 years that I lived without a man in my life, would you like to trade places? No one to talk about my problems and all that?? Honestly, it's not what you get in this world that will give you ultimate pleasure, it's UP there...
Luthien Posted January 17, 2007 Posted January 17, 2007 [quote name='Den Ouji' post='1167468' date='Jan 17 2007, 12:39 AM'] Hey alien guy, I'm a gay too, but I know it's more important for my soul to be wedded to GOD's holy virtue than to go against the law of the Lord to become "something" unnatural! I know it's hard being a homosexual and it's really painful not being able to "officially" be together with someone you like. It's difficult for me too, not being able to love the person I love or do the things that other normal couples do. It's even more difficult for me coz I had lost a fatherly figure in my life since I was 8, now it's over 10 years that I lived without a man in my life, would you like to trade places? No one to talk about my problems and all that?? Honestly, it's not what you get in this world that will give you ultimate pleasure, it's UP there... [/quote]
Socrates Posted January 17, 2007 Posted January 17, 2007 (edited) [quote name='Jesus_lol' post='1166838' date='Jan 16 2007, 02:22 PM'] i wonder if anyone here actually considers gay people to be human as well. there is so much discrimination against them for something that in most cases they were born with or was a result of their upbringing. to my eyes a post like this outright condemning a group of people to hell for being born a certain way, is akin to saying the same about women or african americans. rascism isnt the ony form of discrimination. and about them wanting more rights it is because legally they are less than human and do not have many of the rights that we take for granted, not just the right to marry. gay people are people as well, and i should not have to tell you that. please dont just shut the door on a large part of humanity simply because they are different from you. [/quote] As others have pointed out, the issue here is whether certain [i]behaviors[/i] being given rights/privileges, not about being denied rights just for existing, like racial discrimination. This stuff about homosexuals not having the same rights legally as other people is nonsense. They are allowed to vote, work, own property, buy and sell property, run for office, and do everything else legally that "straight" people can. The fact is simply that two people of the same sex sodomizing each other is not marriage, is not a substitute for marriage, and does not deserve to be legally treated as such. As for donating blood, since when is donating blood a universal "right"? Plenty of people cannot donate blood for reasons having nothing to do with homosexuality. This is a health issue. While of course not every "gay" man has AIDS or other diseases, sodomy is a high-risk behavior healthwise, and this question is thus part of the health screening before giving blood. There is no need to play Russian roulette with the life of blood donation recipients in order to fulfill active homosexual's self-declared "right" to donate blood. Human life and safety and medical integrity should come before cheap sexual identity politics. Edited January 17, 2007 by Socrates
Socrates Posted January 17, 2007 Posted January 17, 2007 [quote name='track2004' post='1167167' date='Jan 16 2007, 05:09 PM'] What about other rights besides marriage and adoption? In most areas gay people can be fired just because they are gay. One can be dishonorably discharged from the Armed Forces for being gay. One can be attacked or killed for being gay and it may not be considered a hate crime. One can be denied housing because they are gay. ETC. What about those things? [/quote] A lot of workplaces forbid discrimination on "sexual orientation" - and that actaully makes it more difficult legally to fire "gay" people than straights - for any reason - because they can sue for being discriminated against for their sexuality, whether or not that was ever actually the issue. It's dangerous when government starts telling everybody what they can and cannot fire people for. Basic freedom of association and other rights are coming under increasing attack in this politically-correct society which becomes more and more dominated by lawyers. As for the military, that involves behavior which is detrimental to the effectiveness of a fighting unit. It is clear you have no experience with military life. And the whole Orwellian idea of "hate crime" legislation should chill [i]any[/i] freedom-loving American, whatever his politics or "orientation." They in essence punish people for having politically-incorrect [i]thoughts[/i]. We have already seen in certain countries people being arrested or sued for voicing traditional Christian morality. That is the only possible end of such laws. Otherwise they give homosexuals and others special protected status under the law. Should killing a young innocent girl, or an elderly grandmother, have less of a penalty than killing a "gay" man??? Murder and other crimes should be prosecuted equally under the law, regardless of the sexual orientation of the victim or perp. Anything else is giving homosexuals special legal favors. That is not equal protection under the law, but an Orwellian perversion of justice.
Jaime Posted January 17, 2007 Posted January 17, 2007 [quote name='Veritas' post='1166858' date='Jan 16 2007, 01:36 PM'] + Everyone has the right to discriminate on the basis of behaviour. Homosexuality is a behaviour. Being African American or of a certain ethnic descent is NOT. This is a fundamental, logical difference. Attempting to equate the two belays a basic misunderstanding of logic. Finally, no ONE is condemning anyone to Hell in the Catholic Church. However, they ARE being faithful to the teachings of Christ by pointing out an extreme danger to one's soul! And, in the face of much relativistic objection -THAT is true love! Individuals with same-sex attractions deserve kindness and help overcoming their disorder just as someone attracted to children, an individual with anxiety, or a kleptomaniac. [/quote] Veritas with all due respect, you might be using discriminate... indiscriminately. [quote]1935 The equality of men rests essentially on their dignity as persons and the rights that flow from it: Every form of social or cultural discrimination in fundamental personal rights on the grounds of sex, race, color, social conditions, language, or religion must be curbed and eradicated as incompatible with God's design. [/quote] We can offer correction in charity. We cannot discriminate.
Socrates Posted January 17, 2007 Posted January 17, 2007 [quote name='hot stuff' post='1167675' date='Jan 17 2007, 12:15 AM'] Veritas with all due respect, you might be using discriminate... indiscriminately. We can offer correction in charity. We cannot discriminate. [quote]1935 The equality of men rests essentially on their dignity as persons and the rights that flow from it: Every form of social or cultural discrimination in fundamental personal rights on the grounds of sex, race, color, social conditions, language, or religion must be curbed and eradicated as incompatible with God's design.[/quote] [/quote] Says nothing in there about homosexual behavior. (And btw "sex" refers to whether one is a man or a woman). And note also this is speaking of fundamental human [i]rights[/i] - that does not mean granting people special legal protection or privilege for certain deviant behaviors. People have far too many "rights" in modern liberal society - and too few responsibilities.
Jaime Posted January 17, 2007 Posted January 17, 2007 And using language properly is integral to catechesis we do not discriminate
Veritas Posted January 17, 2007 Posted January 17, 2007 (edited) [quote name='hot stuff' post='1167675' date='Jan 16 2007, 11:15 PM'] Veritas with all due respect, you might be using discriminate... indiscriminately. We can offer correction in charity. We cannot discriminate. [/quote] + Thanks for the generous post But, you'll notice that the CCC lists NO behaviours in their list Again, to discriminate on the basis of behaviors and choices another makes in our free associations with said person is a right. eg I may hire, associate, befriend, etc. whomever I choose on the basis of their moral believing and choices as that affects my ability to work and live. eg, the church will not hire someone from planned parenthood to head their prolife office. Courage will not hire someone from "dignity" to plan their programs! The Vatican will not be forced to hire a muslim as pope! Is that "discrimination"? No, it's just common sense. Edited January 17, 2007 by Veritas
Laudate_Dominum Posted January 17, 2007 Posted January 17, 2007 What is a gay right? What isn't a gay right? Rights in general just make me happy!
xTrishaxLynnx Posted January 17, 2007 Posted January 17, 2007 [quote name='Laudate_Dominum' post='1167964' date='Jan 17 2007, 01:40 AM'] What is a gay right? What isn't a gay right? Rights in general just make me happy! [/quote]
CeeBee Posted January 17, 2007 Posted January 17, 2007 In England we have strict legislation against discrimination on the basis of race or colour and sexual orientation is lumped together with these, so that if you refuse to hire someone because they are a practicing homosexual that is against the law. I actually agree with most of the legislation in principle, though in practice the pendulum has often swung too far. I think that homosexual men and women have the same rights as the rest of us when it comes to work, housing etc. except in cases where this is in direct contradiction with the job description e.g. priests. I would also distinguish between someone who is practicing homosexual behaviours and someone who is resisting such urges in the pursuit of holiness - we all suffer from temptation and I think that being gay without engaging in any inappropriate sexual behaviour is no more a sin than being an alcoholic who no longer drinks. Without condoning behaviour that is contradictory to the Bible, we must also remember that we have a duty to treat [i]all[/i] people with love and respect - and that only God (who is without sin and can see the inner workings of men's hearts) is able to judge anyone. It's about drawing a distinction between the person and the behaviour.
Jaime Posted January 17, 2007 Posted January 17, 2007 [quote name='Veritas' post='1167928' date='Jan 17 2007, 12:54 AM'] + Thanks for the generous post But, you'll notice that the CCC lists NO behaviours in their list Again, to discriminate on the basis of behaviors and choices another makes in our free associations with said person is a right. eg I may hire, associate, befriend, etc. whomever I choose on the basis of their moral believing and choices as that affects my ability to work and live. eg, the church will not hire someone from planned parenthood to head their prolife office. Courage will not hire someone from "dignity" to plan their programs! The Vatican will not be forced to hire a muslim as pope! Is that "discrimination"? No, it's just common sense. [/quote] Veritas I'm being picky because language and catechesis is critical. What you are listing, including the idea that homosexuals can't marry, are not examples of discrimination. They are examples of individual merit. A muslim cannot become the pope (your example) because he would not be qualified to be pope. That's individual merit. Two homosexuals cannot get married, not because they are homosexual, it is because they cannot fulfill the vows asked to be married. They cannot be open to life. If a heterosexual couple wanted to marry but were absolute about never having children, they wouldn't be able to marry either. To discriminate means the decision is based completely on their group or category. If blondes weren't allowed to drive simply because they were blonde, that would be discrimination. Again, the Church is clear that discrimination is a sin. I'm not saying your point is off. I'm just clarifying.
Akalyte Posted January 17, 2007 Posted January 17, 2007 [quote name='Den Ouji' post='1167468' date='Jan 16 2007, 09:39 PM'] Hey alien guy, I'm a gay too, but I know it's more important for my soul to be wedded to GOD's holy virtue than to go against the law of the Lord to become "something" unnatural! I know it's hard being a homosexual and it's really painful not being able to "officially" be together with someone you like. It's difficult for me too, not being able to love the person I love or do the things that other normal couples do. It's even more difficult for me coz I had lost a fatherly figure in my life since I was 8, now it's over 10 years that I lived without a man in my life, would you like to trade places? No one to talk about my problems and all that?? Honestly, it's not what you get in this world that will give you ultimate pleasure, it's UP there... [/quote] If only other "gays" can think like that. I admire that you lift up your heart to God rather than to the world. That's good.
SRMiller Posted January 17, 2007 Posted January 17, 2007 [quote name='Akalyte' post='1168060' date='Jan 17 2007, 03:00 PM'] If only other "gays" can think like that. I admire that you lift up your heart to God rather than to the world. That's good. [/quote] I ditto that. I wish everyone could realize this, that we should have our eyes on God and His desires for us.
cathoholic_anonymous Posted January 17, 2007 Posted January 17, 2007 [quote]are not allowed to donate blood. this is related to the myth that only gay people have AIDS. even though when AIDS first came out it was predominantly in gay men now that has changed and young-middle aged women is the fastest growing group with AIDS. basically if you had gay sex(even protected) at any point after the 70s you cant donate blood, yet if you are heterosexual but have had unprotected sex with 150 different anonymous partners you will still be allowed to donate blood.[/quote] This isn't true. In Britain and the rest of Europe, ANYONE who has had anal sex - no matter whether they are gay or straight - is not allowed to give blood. Ever. This is because it is apparently easier for condoms to break and diseases to be transmitted during anal sex, according to the leaflet that was given to me by the National Blood Service. It's nothing to do with being gay, as the ban also affects heterosexual couples who practise anal sex. As for having 'unprotected sex with 150 anonymous partners and still being allowed to donate blood' - what? Whenever I go to donate blood I have to fill out a massive questionnaire about my sexual life, and there are lots of questions about unprotected sex on there. If you tick even one of those boxes you are not allowed to donate. Where do you get your information from?
Theoketos Posted January 17, 2007 Posted January 17, 2007 Rights are grounded in nature. Act of homosexuality is against both our physical and spiritual natures. We know this without the aid of revelation. And so our human laws should prevent such actions.
heavenseeker Posted January 17, 2007 Posted January 17, 2007 i think they have something to do with over half of the liberals
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now