Veritas Posted January 17, 2007 Posted January 17, 2007 [quote name='hot stuff' post='1168058' date='Jan 17 2007, 08:55 AM'] Veritas I'm being picky because language and catechesis is critical. What you are listing, including the idea that homosexuals can't marry, are not examples of discrimination. They are examples of individual merit. A muslim cannot become the pope (your example) because he would not be qualified to be pope. That's individual merit. Two homosexuals cannot get married, not because they are homosexual, it is because they cannot fulfill the vows asked to be married. They cannot be open to life. If a heterosexual couple wanted to marry but were absolute about never having children, they wouldn't be able to marry either. To discriminate means the decision is based completely on their group or category. If blondes weren't allowed to drive simply because they were blonde, that would be discrimination. Again, the Church is clear that discrimination is a sin. I'm not saying your point is off. I'm just clarifying. [/quote] + Okay, interesting. I'm all for using accurate language. I appreciate what you are saying about "individual merit". I wonder if there is another word expressing this idea, which would be more appropriate...
avemaria40 Posted January 17, 2007 Posted January 17, 2007 [quote name='Cathoholic Anonymous' post='1168206' date='Jan 17 2007, 02:01 PM'] This isn't true. In Britain and the rest of Europe, ANYONE who has had anal sex - no matter whether they are gay or straight - is not allowed to give blood. Ever. This is because it is apparently easier for condoms to break and diseases to be transmitted during anal sex, according to the leaflet that was given to me by the National Blood Service. It's nothing to do with being gay, as the ban also affects heterosexual couples who practise anal sex. As for having 'unprotected sex with 150 anonymous partners and still being allowed to donate blood' - what? Whenever I go to donate blood I have to fill out a massive questionnaire about my sexual life, and there are lots of questions about unprotected sex on there. If you tick even one of those boxes you are not allowed to donate. Where do you get your information from? [/quote] Same for the Red Cross Blood Donation. I had to answer so many questions about my sexual life and if anyone answered even one yes, they can't donate. And it is true that anal sex is more risky, as well as the fact that even with a condom, there is so much more bacteria involved. You can't worry about people's feelings when lives and people's health are at stake.
mroger Posted January 17, 2007 Author Posted January 17, 2007 [quote name='track2004' post='1167156' date='Jan 16 2007, 04:00 PM'] What's it matter if anything is a behavior. We let you give wine to kids; we let your priests marry people; we let you do all sorts of things even though you're Catholic. Being Catholic is a behavior. We let minorities have special rights because of their behaviors, gay people don't want special rights, they just want the regular ones extended to them. [color="#FF0000"]To begin, "you" do not let any priest marry. Marriage is an institution of God, not man. So you can just end that kind of thought right away.[/color] Being gay isn't a behavior, falling in love and all that is. I'll give you that, but really why is everyone all up in arms about the gay rights and the "gay agenda"? [color="#FF0000"]Because, given the opportunity - they would, as they did during the Clinton administration, attempt to influence every aspect of life and culture. They would promulgate their ideology flagrantly through the media. This is not some scant "gay scare" and I'm not a homophobic. This is what happened, it's history. Notwithstanding that the Republican led government was scandalous, while they were in office, we just didn't have this visually dominant minority trying to influence lives.[/color] I guess the point that is always made in these arguments about sexual promiscuity is really the thing that upsets me the most. You are all up in arms, ready to get the torches out for 'sodomy' between gay people, but The Bible says all sorts of sex is wrong and that never gets discussed. I mean millions and millions of guys are having "alone time" that is a sexual sin. I'd argue more people are doing that than having gay sex. Straight couples have all sorts of sex that the OT considers 'sodomy'. So basically why don't you take a good long look at yourselves and your own community and fix all the problems in it before forcing your beliefs on the general populus. [i][b]How are the rest of us supposed to abide by something some dead guy said 1000s of years ago about sex when you can't even make your own people abide?[/b][/i] [color="#FF0000"]Now, ya see, you're already trying to take God's Word out of this. And this is why you shouldn't be allowed to vote. You've gotta start respecting those dead guys you see, or your opinions will never carry weight, because those dead guys are the founders of our Church, which is the backbone of our entire code of life, what we believe in. You can't attack that without much repercussion.[/color] [/quote]
cmotherofpirl Posted January 17, 2007 Posted January 17, 2007 [quote name='avemaria40' post='1168295' date='Jan 17 2007, 04:12 PM'] You can't worry about people's feelings when lives and people's health are at stake. [/quote] Would that this was true.! If it was every case of AIDs would have been treated like other sexaul diseases and reported to the health department for followup and contacting of all previous partners.
MissScripture Posted January 17, 2007 Posted January 17, 2007 May I ask when it became a right for someone to be able to donate blood? It's not about the person giving, it's about who is getting the blood. And when did having children become a right? I'm pretty sure that children are a gift, not a right.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now