Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

RezaMikhaeil
Posted

[quote name='rkwright' post='1211696' date='Mar 10 2007, 09:10 PM']NFP does not render procreation impossible.[/quote] Neither do oral contraceptives, alot of contraceptives fail [as Fr. Etenauer mentioned in saying that 60% of women at an abortion clinic are there because their contraceptive pill failed them] but like oral contraceptives and condoms its still attempting to control a situation that may or may not be ours to control.

[quote]It would be immoral for a married couple to restrict their conjugal relations to the woman's infertile periods alone with the intention of never having children, since that would be a form of "contraception."[/quote] Agreed, it would be the attempt to control the situation, have the benefits of intimacy without the responsibilities.

Reza

Posted

[quote name='RezaLemmyng' post='1212059' date='Mar 11 2007, 10:57 AM']Neither do oral contraceptives, alot of contraceptives fail [as Fr. Etenauer mentioned in saying that 60% of women at an abortion clinic are there because their contraceptive pill failed them] but like oral contraceptives and condoms its still attempting to control a situation that may or may not be ours to control.

Agreed, it would be the attempt to control the situation, have the benefits of intimacy without the responsibilities.

Reza[/quote]

Just because the mechanism failed it was still put in place in order to stop life. One who uses contraceptives is not open to the gift of life.

RezaMikhaeil
Posted

[quote name='rkwright' post='1212066' date='Mar 11 2007, 10:39 AM']Just because the mechanism failed it was still put in place in order to stop life. One who uses contraceptives is not open to the gift of life.[/quote]

Natural Birth Control is the same thing, and even taught in schools as such. Whats the point of "the rhythem method" [as it used to be known as]? It's to avoid a woman's most furtal points, in order to avoid the conception of life.

Reza

Posted

I agree taht Hannity did see to have his back up with this priest. But then this priest had publicly attacked him. I don't approve of Hannitys behavior during the interview. He attacked the priest personally and was very defensive. All in all I think it was a mistake to have had him on the program with Sean.

I will continue to listen to Sean Hannity on the occasions that I have the chance to hear him. I have not heard Hannity say the things that he is accused of saying.

Posted

well, I have been to busy reading a newspaper to even know that Hannity was a catholic or know that this such thing happened. i guess I am to busy watching TV. I only get to watch a couple hours of TV each week. The last time I was able to watch more thatn 2 hours of tv was last summer, when I was on break.

Posted (edited)

Good on Fr. Etenauer. Hannity passes himself off as some orthodox Catholic, but like all neoconservatives, he will compromise the faith for his sacred ideology. He's been doing it for years in his books.

I love how Hannity tries the classic neocon Catholic ploy, "How DARE you criticize me? I'm not YOUR side!" Well, sometimes heresy happens on the right too, and thankfully there are some who aren't afraid to call it when they see it.

I won't even comment on Hannity's feeble attempts at attacking the Church, other than he sounded like a token anti-Catholic/atheist. True colors?

Edited by Nathan
Posted

[quote name='Nathan' post='1212282' date='Mar 11 2007, 07:45 PM']Good on Fr. Etenauer. Hannity passes himself off as some orthodox Catholic, but like all neoconservatives, he will compromise the faith for his sacred ideology. He's been doing it for years in his books.[/quote]

Painting a lot of people with a very broad brush aren't you?

Posted (edited)

[quote name='Mercy me' post='1212287' date='Mar 11 2007, 07:00 PM']Painting a lot of people with a very broad brush aren't you?[/quote]

You're damned right I am. Richard John Neuhaus, George Weigel, Robert Novak, Peggy Noonan, (in recent years) Joseph Fessio... they're all the same. Their views warrant criticism. Just because they're more orthodox than liberal Catholics does not mean that they don't hold heretical views. All of them do; it's called Americanism and Zionism.

Edited by Nathan
Posted

[quote name='Nathan' post='1212288' date='Mar 11 2007, 09:02 PM']You're damned right I am. Richard John Neuhaus, George Weigel, Robert Novak, Peggy Noonan, (in recent years) Joseph Fessio... they're all the same. Their views warrant criticism. Just because they're more orthodox than liberal Catholics does not mean that they don't hold heretical views. All of them do; it's called Americanism and Zionism.[/quote]

It is a very, very broad brush... it's hard to be charitable when you feel strongly about something and a whole group disagrees with you! I know because I personally stink at it. I do not agree with everything I have ever read from Fr. Neuahus, Mr. Weigel etc (noooo way) but heresy is a word with a legal meaning, and it's probably not best to throw it around when the situation isn't clear. I really don't think Mr. Weigel fits the definition of heretic, for instance - he was the authorized biographer of John Paul II, wasn't he? :idontknow:

Posted

[quote name='Nathan' post='1212288' date='Mar 11 2007, 07:02 PM']You're damned right I am. Richard John Neuhaus, George Weigel, Robert Novak, Peggy Noonan, (in recent years) Joseph Fessio... they're all the same. Their views warrant criticism. Just because they're more orthodox than liberal Catholics does not mean that they don't hold heretical views. All of them do; it's called Americanism and Zionism.[/quote]
As far as I'm aware, none of the people you listed here support contraception nor attack the Church's teaching on contraception like Sean Hannity (though I don't know enough about Peggy Noonan to be sure). In fact, most of these people have publicly defended the Church's teaching on this topic.

Heresy is a serious charge; it should not be bantered about lightly to attack those you disagree with politically. You have provided not a single example of the alleged heresy of these people. I'm sorry, Nathan, but when you resort to calumny and slander, you are acting no better than Sean Hannity or anyone else.

Posted

[url="http://www.foxnews.com/story/0,2933,258291,00.html"]Fr. Jonathan weighs in[/url]

Posted

[url="http://spirit-and-life.blogspot.com/2007/03/hannity-liberal.html"]Fr. Euteneuer responds to all the commotion[/url]

Posted

I feel like Fr. Jonathan kind of punted.

Posted

[quote name='Nathan' post='1212288' date='Mar 11 2007, 08:02 PM']You're damned right I am. Richard John Neuhaus, George Weigel, Robert Novak, Peggy Noonan, (in recent years) Joseph Fessio... they're all the same. Their views warrant criticism. Just because they're more orthodox than liberal Catholics does not mean that they don't hold heretical views. All of them do; it's called Americanism and Zionism.[/quote]

As an citizen of the United States I take offense to your comments. May I suggest that you take a look at what is happening in your own yard. You might want to be careful throwing all those stones.

Posted

Fr. J's response was weak and a bit disheartening. He makes the point that Fr. E should have been a bit more civil in his approach. Fine (maybe...) but Fr. J never once stood up for the Church teaching. He never once said 'Fr. E could have been nicer, but he is right.' Something tells me Fr. J was maybe 'prompted' to write that article a certain way to ensure Fox doesn't lose its Catholic conservative viewers? Maybe I'm jumping to conclusions but thats what it seemed like to me. Granted I don't know much about Fr. J...

I also read Fr. Eutenauers resposne. Incredible. This man is truly a light in this world. He reminds me of a John the Baptist; calling out the public officals for their wrongs.

Posted

I used to like Sean Hannity...

Now I think he's a...well, I don't think it would be wise for me to post the adjectives I feel at this time.

Perhaps this picture will be sufficient..

[img]http://members.shaw.ca/statistic/pictures/Donkey-4.jpg[/img]

Posted

[quote name='kujo' post='1212720' date='Mar 12 2007, 08:07 PM']I used to like Sean Hannity...

Now I think he's a...well, I don't think it would be wise for me to post the adjectives I feel at this time.

Perhaps this picture will be sufficient..

[img]http://members.shaw.ca/statistic/pictures/Donkey-4.jpg[/img][/quote]
[size=1]I think that is a perfect picture.

All he did was yell.
The priest didnt even get a chance to say anything without being cut off.
I dont like Mr. Hannity either.
[/size]

Posted

[quote name='CrossCuT' post='1212848' date='Mar 12 2007, 11:47 PM'][size=1]I think that is a perfect picture.

All he did was yell.
The priest didnt even get a chance to say anything without being cut off.
I dont like Mr. Hannity either.
[/size][/quote]

Unfortunately, this is the sort of journalism that we have in our country now--there's no real investigation, just the rabid reciting of the same talking points by talking heads.

Posted

This was Fr. Eutenauer's response to Fr. Morris's letter...

Dear Father Jonathan,

Your letter to Sean Hannity indicates that you did not know that I asked to speak to him in private about this matter in 2004 otherwise you may have tempered your remarks about my supposed lack of charity in dealing with a high profile Catholic who dissents from clearly-defined and reiterated Church teachings. [See “Fr. Euteneuer asks to meet with Hannity about birth control” on sidebar.] You also seemed to be unaware of the fact that Sean was the one who invited me on his program and who then promptly “[threw] civility to the wind,” refused to display “cultivated intelligence” on the issues and jeopardized another person’s “reputation and dignity.” May I also point out that you did not employ with me the same standard of “fraternal correction” that you expected me to employ with Mr. Hannity. I at least made the attempt to speak to him about this issue in private without success; you, in contrast, went immediately to the internet to take me to task. I do not intend to understand your motives; I can only evaluate what I see in your actions.

The question that comes to mind is an obvious one: if you are a Fox analyst on Catholic matters, wouldn’t you have been the one to have had those “private conversations” on birth control with Mr. Hannity? How about discussions on his abortion exceptions? When you told Sean “in person” that you “disagreed with him,” was it on the issue of birth control? If you had done that, I applaud you, but your powers of persuasion may need a little honing—Sean has only gotten more vocal on this issue over time. If you did not speak to him about his public dissent, then I ask you, “Why?” While we are on the subject, have you also analyzed and disagreed with Bill O’Reilly’s perfectly horrible disdain for the Holy Father and the Church that you represent?

The church sex abuse scandal was not just about homosexual and predatory priests. It was about clerical negligence and silence on issues that not only affect people’s souls but also ruin people’s lives. It is highly unusual that you or anyone else would want a priest to be silent on issues that affect the salvation of souls. We used to recognize “admonishing the sinner” as one of the Spiritual Works of Mercy, and I consider my admonishment of Mr. Hannity to have been done in that spirit. I might also add that in doing so I have fulfilled my duty as a priest which is a requirement for my salvation.

As a seminary rector, I would sincerely hope that you are not teaching by word or example the young men in your charge to be politically correct sissies who are afraid to roll up their sleeves and defend the Church in private and in public. We have tons of those types in the clergy already. I would advise you to drink deeply of the wisdom of the Number Two man at our Headquarters who has in no uncertain terms told all of us that high profile dissenters are a scourge and a danger to souls. [See item: “Bertone: Dissident Catholics More Worrying Than Atheists.” [url="http://www.lifesite.net/ldn/2007/jan/07011003.html"]http://www.lifesite.net/ldn/2007/jan/07011003.html[/url].]

I wish you fraternal blessings for your priestly work.

Sincerely,
Rev. Thomas J. Euteneuer
President
Human Life International


Found here [url="http://www.hli.org/article_open_letter_to_fr_morris.html"]http://www.hli.org/article_open_letter_to_fr_morris.html[/url]

Posted

Go Fr. Euteneuer!... but I think implying his fellow priest is a "politically correct sissy" was perhaps a bit harsh.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...