Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

SinginForHim
Posted

I just got back from Steubenville, Ohio, from one of the AWESOME youth conferences up there. I went to Confession while there, and noticed that burning CDs was noted as a sin in the examination of conscience, so of course I had to confess it. I was disappointed as I shared this experience with others, in that I wasn't able to have a fuller conversation with the priest concerning to what extent this is a sin. People began to ask -- What about ripping borrowed CDs onto your computer? What if you're not selling the CD? What about simply putting the CD onto your computer to transfer it onto your mp3 player/iPod/etc.?

I told these people that I didn't want to answer them until I had talked with a trusted "someone" about the matter. Is there anyone who knows the "extent" of this sin?

Thanks! God bless!!
~Nicole~

Posted (edited)

"Burning CDs" is an ambiguous term. To clarify:

Basically, purchasing [copyrighted] music gives you the right to do pretty much anything you want for your own personal use. This could include making copies, mixes, putting onto music players, etc. However, to give the music to someone else would constitute them stealing the music, because of the copyright protection. In the case of someone borrowing a CD, that does not seem to be a problem, but as soon as the borrower rips the CD onto the computer, it goes from borrowing to keeping i.e. stealing, even if the original media is returned to the rightful owner. Just because you are not making money from the friend getting your music for free does not make it ok for them to take it.

Personally, I do not like the RIAA and record companies in general, and I avoid giving them my money if I can help it. Most of my few CDs have come from ebay.

I do value integrity, and even though it is hard, I have decided that lawfully obtaining my music is the right thing for me to do.


You may want to research "fair use."

Edited by Petrus
Posted

Burning copies of another's CDs or copying them to your computer for indefinite use is, in effect, stealing and is morally wrong.

I will say that it probably depends somewhat on intent as well though. For instance, say you borrowed a friend's CD but he wanted it back quickly because it was brand new. You're trying to decide if you want to buy it as well. You rip the CD to your computer or burn a copy for yourself so you can give it a few listens and decide. After a short period of time (say a week or so) you decide you like it and go buy it. You're in the clear. If you decide you don't like it enough to buy it, you would have to delete the songs from your computer or toss the CD to be doing the right thing morally.

Technically what I described is against the letter of the law, but certainly not the spirit of the law. It's really no different than borrowing the physical CD for the same period of time and giving it back without duplicating it at all.

Posted

It seems that even if a person deliberately broke copyright laws, it would not be [i]grave [/i]matter since there is no material object involved (just data) and the money involved is a "trifling" amount (and indeed, since there is no material object involved and it is merely the principle of the process that is violated, the money involved isn't even [i]actual [/i]but rather only [i]potential[/i]) to the offended parties.

Does anyone disagree with that?

Posted

[quote name='Ziggamafu' post='1304135' date='Jun 28 2007, 10:14 AM']It seems that even if a person deliberately broke copyright laws, it would not be [i]grave [/i]matter since there is no material object involved (just data) and the money involved is a "trifling" amount (and indeed, since there is no material object involved and it is merely the principle of the process that is violated, the money involved isn't even [i]actual [/i]but rather only [i]potential[/i]) to the offended parties.

Does anyone disagree with that?[/quote]

no i do not, unless one is doing it to deliberately 'rub it in God's face.'

Posted

[quote name='Ziggamafu' post='1304135' date='Jun 28 2007, 10:14 AM']It seems that even if a person deliberately broke copyright laws, it would not be [i]grave [/i]matter since there is no material object involved (just data) and the money involved is a "trifling" amount (and indeed, since there is no material object involved and it is merely the principle of the process that is violated, the money involved isn't even [i]actual [/i]but rather only [i]potential[/i]) to the offended parties.

Does anyone disagree with that?[/quote]

Must a sin be mortal for it to be galling to me?

Can I go through with my life scourging Christ with intentional venial sins? Can I spit and beat my Lord who is present within my soul and assimilated within my body? Can I do so repeatedly and without remorse, excusing myself because I didn't crucify Him?

After reflecting on the matter last year, I deleted and destroyed my pirated music, computer applications, etc.

Please understand that I loathe the Music Industry, and take great exception to the abusive use of our foolishly written copyright laws. Even so, I will do Satan no such favor at the altar of convenience.

  • 3 weeks later...
Posted

[quote name='Ziggamafu' post='1304135' date='Jun 28 2007, 08:14 AM']It seems that even if a person deliberately broke copyright laws, it would not be [i]grave [/i]matter since there is no material object involved (just data) and the money involved is a "trifling" amount (and indeed, since there is no material object involved and it is merely the principle of the process that is violated, the money involved isn't even [i]actual [/i]but rather only [i]potential[/i]) to the offended parties.

Does anyone disagree with that?[/quote]

But the money involved is not a "trifling" amount in a lot of cases. Some people have thousands of dollars worth of stolen music. I also don't understand your point about the money being "potential".

Posted

[quote name='Ziggamafu' post='1304135' date='Jun 28 2007, 09:14 AM']It seems that even if a person deliberately broke copyright laws, it would not be [i]grave [/i]matter since there is no material object involved (just data) and the money involved is a
"trifling" amount (and indeed, since there is no material object involved and it is merely the principle of the process that is violated, the money involved isn't even [i]actual [/i]but rather only [i]potential[/i]) to the offended parties.

Does anyone disagree with that?[/quote]

well, yes

short reason:

"stealing" = per se "grave" matter - first prerequisite
full knowledge and consent - deliberate choice - second prerequisite


long reason:

if a computer hacker changes the electrons on the bank's computer to show your account has 0 dollars and his has 100 . . . or the DMV records to show your car was sold to his brother . . . is that "merely data"
if you find a floppy disk with my term paper on it . . . and it is really good . . . and it is my only copy because my computer hard drive crashed, losing all my data . . . and you turn it in and get an A . . . is that "merely data"

When Moses broke the original copy of the ten commandments over Aaron's head . . . or was it the calf . . . did he make a copy or did he go back up the mountain to get a new copy from the author?

ideas, concepts, melodies, lyrics are "protected" "property" under American law and the law of many other nations
electronic versions of those ideas, concepts etc etc are the same as the paper, plastic, vinyl or whatever format


Mortal sin: a mortally bad human act which is grievously offensive to God; that sin which destroys charity, robs the soul of sanctifying grace, and makes it deserving of eternal punishment.
Concise Catholic Dictionary (Angelus Press 1943)
compared to Venial Sin: an offense against God in a light matter or without full consent of the will which does not destroy grace or friendship with God or the right to eternal happiness, but is a partial or small aversion from God; venial sin may be so slight that it is called a venial fault rather than a sin.


The terms mortal, deadly, grave and serious applied to sin are synonyms, each with a slightly different implication. Mortal and deadly focus on the effects in the sinner, namely deprivation of the state of friendship with God; grave and serious refer to the importance of the matter in which a person offends God. But the Church never distinguishes among these terms as though they represented different kinds of sins. There is only one recognized correlative to mortal sin, and that is venial sin . . .
Hardon, Modern Catholic Dictionary (Doubleday 1980)

54. Q. What is mortal sin?
A. Mortal sin is a grievous offense against the law of God.
"Grievous" that is, very great or serious. "Against the law." If we are in doubt whether anything is sinful or not, we must ask ourselves: is it forbidden by God or His Church? and if we do not know of any law forbidding it, it cannot be a sin, at least for us.
Suppose, for example, a boy should doubt whether it is sinful or not to fly a kite. Well, is there any law of God or of His Church saying it is sinful to fly a kite? If not, then it cannot be a sin. But it might be sinful for another reason, namely, his parents or superiors might forbid it, and there is a law of God saying you must not disobey your parents or superiors. Therefore a thing not sinful in itself, that is, not directly forbidden by God or His Church, may become sinful for some other reason well known to us.
We must not, however, doubt concerning the sinfulness or lawfulness of everything we do; for that would be foolish and lead us to be scrupulous. If we doubt at all we should have some good reason for doubting, that is, for believing that the thing we are about to do is or is not forbidden. When, therefore, we have such a doubt we must seek information from those who can enlighten us on the subject, so that we may act without the danger of sinning. It is our intention that makes the act we perform sinful or not. Let me explain. Suppose during Lent a person should mistake Friday for Thursday and should eat meat-that person would not commit a real sin, because it is not a sin to eat meat on an ordinary Thursday. He would commit what we call a material sin; that is, his action would be a sin if he really knew what he was doing. On the other hand, if the person, thinking it was Friday when it was really Thursday, ate meat, knowing it to be forbidden, that person would commit a mortal sin, because he intended to do so. Therefore, if what we do is not known to be a sin while we do it, it is no sin for us and cannot become a sin afterwards. But as soon as we know or learn that what we did was wrong, it would be a sin if we did the same thing again.
Lesson 6: On Sin and its Kinds (Baltimore Catechism)

56. Q. How many things are necessary to make a sin mortal?
A. To make a sin mortal three things are necessary: a grievous matter, sufficient reflection, and full consent of the will.
"Grievous matter." To steal is a sin. Now, if you steal only a pin the act of stealing in that case could not be a mortal sin, because the "matter," namely, the stealing of an ordinary pin, is not grievous. But suppose it was a diamond pin of great value, then it would surely be "grievous matter." "Sufficient reflection," that is, you must know what you are doing at the time you do it. For example, suppose while you stole the diamond pin you thought you were stealing a pin with a small piece of glass, of little value, you would not have sufficient reflection and would not commit a mortal sin till you found out that what you had stolen was a valuable diamond; if you continued to keep it after learning your mistake, you would surely commit a mortal sin. "Full consent:' Suppose you were shooting at a target and accidentally killed a man: you would not have the sin of murder, because you did not will or wish to kill a man.
Therefore three things are necessary that your act may be a mortal sin: The act you do must be bad, and sufficiently important; You must reflect that you are doing it, and know that it is wrong; You must do it freely, deliberately, and willfully.
Lesson 6: On Sin and its Kinds (Baltimore Catechism)


Moving to the modern catechism


III. The Different Kinds of Sins

1852 There are a great many kinds of sins. Scripture provides several lists of them. the Letter to the Galatians contrasts the works of the flesh with the fruit of the Spirit: "Now the works of the flesh are plain: fornication, impurity, licentiousness, idolatry, sorcery, enmity, strife, jealousy, anger, selfishness, dissension, factions, envy, drunkenness, carousing, and the like. I warn you, as I warned you before, that those who do such things shall not inherit the Kingdom of God."

1853 Sins can be distinguished according to their objects, as can every human act; or according to the virtues they oppose, by excess or defect; or according to the commandments they violate. They can also be classed according to whether they concern God, neighbor, or oneself; they can be divided into spiritual and carnal sins, or again as sins in thought, word, deed, or omission. the root of sin is in the heart of man, in his free will, according to the teaching of the Lord: "For out of the heart come evil thoughts, murder, adultery, fornication, theft, false witness, slander. These are what defile a man." But in the heart also resides charity, the source of the good and pure works, which sin wounds.

IV. The Gravity of Sin: Mortal and Venial Sin

1854 Sins are rightly evaluated according to their gravity. the distinction between mortal and venial sin, already evident in Scripture, became part of the tradition of the Church. It is corroborated by human experience.

1855 Mortal sin destroys charity in the heart of man by a grave violation of God's law; it turns man away from God, who is his ultimate end and his beatitude, by preferring an inferior good to him. Venial sin allows charity to subsist, even though it offends and wounds it.

1856 Mortal sin, by attacking the vital principle within us - that is, charity - necessitates a new initiative of God's mercy and a conversion of heart which is normally accomplished within the setting of the sacrament of reconciliation:
When the will sets itself upon something that is of its nature incompatible with the charity that orients man toward his ultimate end, then the sin is mortal by its very object . . . whether it contradicts the love of God, such as blasphemy or perjury, or the love of neighbor, such as homicide or adultery.... But when the sinner's will is set upon something that of its nature involves a disorder, but is not opposed to the love of God and neighbor, such as thoughtless chatter or immoderate laughter and the like, such sins are venial.

1857 For a sin to be mortal, three conditions must together be met: "Mortal sin is sin whose object is grave matter and which is also committed with full knowledge and deliberate consent."

1858 Grave matter is specified by the Ten Commandments, corresponding to the answer of Jesus to the rich young man: "Do not kill, Do not commit adultery, Do not steal, Do not bear false witness, Do not defraud, Honor your father and your mother." The gravity of sins is more or less great: murder is graver than theft. One must also take into account who is wronged: violence against parents is in itself graver than violence against a stranger.

1859 Mortal sin requires full knowledge and complete consent. It presupposes knowledge of the sinful character of the act, of its opposition to God's law. It also implies a consent sufficiently deliberate to be a personal choice. Feigned ignorance and hardness of heart do not diminish, but rather increase, the voluntary character of a sin.

1860 Unintentional ignorance can diminish or even remove the imputability of a grave offense. But no one is deemed to be ignorant of the principles of the moral law, which are written in the conscience of every man. the promptings of feelings and passions can also diminish the voluntary and free character of the offense, as can external pressures or pathological disorders. Sin committed through malice, by deliberate choice of evil, is the gravest.

1861 Mortal sin is a radical possibility of human freedom, as is love itself. It results in the loss of charity and the privation of sanctifying grace, that is, of the state of grace. If it is not redeemed by repentance and God's forgiveness, it causes exclusion from Christ's kingdom and the eternal death of hell, for our freedom has the power to make choices for ever, with no turning back. However, although we can judge that an act is in itself a grave offense, we must entrust judgment of persons to the justice and mercy of God.
Catechism of the Catholic Church, 1852-1861

Posted

[quote name='T-Bone _' post='1329265' date='Jul 15 2007, 12:43 PM']I also don't understand your point about the money being "potential".[/quote]

I think "potential" refers to the idea that Joe the Music Thief would not necessarily have bought the music if he were not stealing it. Also, when Joe steals an orange from the market, the market has one less orange. Metallica didn't lose a song from a pile when it got stolen.

I'm not saying it is okay to pirate music. I don't think it is.

Posted

[quote name='Paddington' post='1330043' date='Jul 16 2007, 02:18 AM']I think "potential" refers to the idea that Joe the Music Thief would not necessarily have bought the music if he were not stealing it. Also, when Joe steals an orange from the market, the market has one less orange. Metallica didn't lose a song from a pile when it got stolen.

I'm not saying it is okay to pirate music. I don't think it is.[/quote]

Metallica didn't lose songs, as in they previously had X songs to sell and now have X-1, but they did lose money, because they did not receive the royalties they were owed from the sale of a record. Therefore, by depriving someone of part of their livelihood, you are committing a sin against charity, and depriving someone of their rightful earnings.

Deuteronomy 24:15 - "Pay him his wages each day before sunset, because he is poor and is counting on it. Otherwise he may cry to the LORD against you, and you will be guilty of sin."

OK, I doubt the members of Metallica are that poor and going to go broke over a couple of stolen songs, but the principle holds firm. And it all adds up - they probably only lose pennies over one song, but it doesn't take many stolen albums for the total loss to run into hundreds of pounds.

Posted (edited)

[quote name='Paddington' post='1330043' date='Jul 15 2007, 06:18 PM']I think "potential" refers to the idea that Joe the Music Thief would not necessarily have bought the music if he were not stealing it. Also, when Joe steals an orange from the market, the market has one less orange. Metallica didn't lose a song from a pile when it got stolen.

I'm not saying it is okay to pirate music. I don't think it is.[/quote]

What if that orange was going to be thrown out at the end of the day? (Supermarkets and such toss hundreds of pounds of food into the Dumpster every day.) It is still wrong to steal it. Theft is theft.

edit: Forgot to capitalize "Dumpster," which is a registered trademark.

Edited by T-Bone _
Posted

[quote name='T-Bone _' post='1330666' date='Jul 16 2007, 12:14 PM']What if that orange was going to be thrown out at the end of the day? (Supermarkets and such toss hundreds of pounds of food into the dumpster every day.) It is still wrong to steal it. Theft is theft.[/quote]

I wonder if that would relieve a person of the duty to compensate? :detective:

Posted

[quote name='Paddington' post='1330700' date='Jul 16 2007, 08:26 AM']I wonder if that would relieve a person of the duty to compensate? :detective:[/quote]

I think morally (don't know about legally) that if one waits until it is in the Dumpster, they're in the clear...

Posted (edited)

Okay....I have bought LimeWire and it is a legal program for downloading music...but it is not from the artists themselves .....I take the songs I have downloaded through my payed serves and burn those Cds. Am I still sinning, even if the law is okay with LimeWire?

Edited by Cardinals Flower
Posted

[quote name='Cardinals Flower' post='1330707' date='Jul 16 2007, 08:31 AM']Okay....I have bought LimeWire and it is a legal program for downloading of music...but it is not from the artists themselves .....I take the songs I have downloaded through my payed serves and burn those Cds. Am I still sinning even if the law is okay with LimeWire?[/quote]

Are the CDs for your own personal use? If so, and it does not violate the terms of service and the license you got from LimeWire, then no, it is not a sin.

Posted

Yes its for my personal use...but i have two other brothers who burn also...so we may end up with three copies of the same album...silly yes but we kinda go around with our own music.

Same thing with bought cds, we buy one then burn copies for all of us(we all live at home but listen to our music in different areas)...we have more then one computer so i'll rip my cd on all of them so i don;t have to go from computer to computer look for a song. And i leave my cds in my car or whatever. I have one cd that is now ruined, but i had rip the cd onto the computer, now that is my only copy of that cd.

Posted

[quote name='Ragamuffin' post='1303319' date='Jun 27 2007, 03:22 PM']Burning copies of another's CDs or copying them to your computer for indefinite use is, in effect, stealing and is morally wrong.[/quote]
No, it is NOT stealing. It may, or may not, be morally wrong, but it is NOT stealing.

Theft is taking something from someone. If you have a burrito, and I take your burrito from you when you're not looking, I have stolen your burrito, because you no longer have possession of your burrito, which is rightfully yours.

If you got the federal government to grant you the sole right to create burritos, and I look at your burrito, and assemble my own burrito that is nearly identical to yours, you still have your burrito. Thus, it is not theft.

Copying a copyrighted work is not stealing, it is infringement. It's probably a sin because it is disobedient to the law that is placed in front of us, unless you can argue that the law is gravely unjust. We are called to obey civil authorities. However, were the law removed, it would no longer be a sin to do so.

Frankly, I support the complete removal of both patent and copyright protections; it amounts to a government-protected monopoly on a good, service, or idea, and actually stifles innovation and competition.

Posted

The use of someone's property without their permission is not theft?

That's good to know...

Posted

[quote name='adt6247' post='1330898' date='Jul 16 2007, 07:41 PM']No, it is NOT stealing. It may, or may not, be morally wrong, but it is NOT stealing.

Theft is taking something from someone. If you have a burrito, and I take your burrito from you when you're not looking, I have stolen your burrito, because you no longer have possession of your burrito, which is rightfully yours.[/quote]

Actually, it is stealing. Every artist is paid a royalty every time a CD of theirs is sold, every time a song they perform on is played on the radio, or their music video is played on the TV. If you copy your friend's CD, whilst the artist has received the royalty due to them from your friend, he has not received the royalty due from you - you have stolen that money from him. By copying a CD, and not buying it, you are denying a worker his wages, one of the five sins that cry to Heaven for vengeance.

Posted

[quote name='rosamundi' post='1331002' date='Jul 16 2007, 04:05 PM']Actually, it is stealing. Every artist is paid a royalty every time a CD of theirs is sold, every time a song they perform on is played on the radio, or their music video is played on the TV. If you copy your friend's CD, whilst the artist has received the royalty due to them from your friend, he has not received the royalty due from you - you have stolen that money from him. By copying a CD, and not buying it, you are denying a worker his wages, one of the five sins that cry to Heaven for vengeance.[/quote]
It's possible to argue on the path of denying a worker his wages (I don't accept that argument, as it is based on a potential sale that has not happenned, thus isn't a sale), however, that does NOT meet the definition of theft. It's violation of a law. Contract violation at worst, which is lying, not stealing. Theft assumes that person A has object Θ, person B takes object Θ, and person A no longer has object Θ.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...