Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted (edited)

[quote name='adt6247' post='1331122' date='Jul 16 2007, 11:21 PM']It's possible to argue on the path of denying a worker his wages (I don't accept that argument, as it is based on a potential sale that has not happenned, thus isn't a sale), however, that does NOT meet the definition of theft. It's violation of a law. Contract violation at worst, which is lying, not stealing. Theft assumes that person A has object Θ, person B takes object Θ, and person A no longer has object Θ.[/quote]

It's a sale that would have happened if you'd bought the CD. By not buying the CD, and therefore not paying the royalty, you are stealing wages from someone. It is theft because you are denying object Θ to someone, in that object Θ is their wages for performing work Ω, and by not paying for object Ω you are stealing payment from their work from them.

Edited by rosamundi
Posted

[quote name='T-Bone _' post='1330999' date='Jul 16 2007, 04:00 PM']The use of someone's property without their permission is not theft?

That's good to know...[/quote]
How is it "property"? By any classical definition of property, a property is a physical object, whether land or gold or a ham sandwich. Information isn't property. For instance, the physical medium (such as, a compact disc) is property. If I purchase that CD, I own the physical medium. The data contained on the CD isn't property. It is data.

If I buy a ham sandwich at a deli, and I make a duplicate copy of that sandwich to give to a friend out of materials I had at home, does that mean that I stole a sandwich from the deli?

Is F=MA the property of Isaac Newton? Is e=mc² the property of Einstein? Is I=V/R the property of Ohm? Is 6.02 * 10²³ the property of Avagadro? Should they be allowed to restrict people from using their formulæ were they alive? How are ideas and words peoples' property? They are infinitely reproduceable. Knowledge belongs to nobody, except God.

Posted

[quote name='rosamundi' post='1331130' date='Jul 16 2007, 06:25 PM']It's a sale that would have happened if you'd bought the CD. By not buying the CD, and therefore not paying the royalty, you are stealing wages from someone. It is theft because you are denying object Θ to someone, in that object Θ is their wages for performing work Ω, and by not paying for object Ω you are stealing payment from their work from them.[/quote]
And why is the artist owed that sale? I am under no obligation to buy a CD, whether or not I copy it. A sale isn't a sale if both parties do not have the option of not proceeding with the transaction, otherwise it would be extortion.

Again, I'm not arguing that copying CD's isn't sinful, I'm just arguing that it isn't stealing. You are talking about a sale that never did, and never will happen.

Posted (edited)

[quote name='adt6247' post='1331147' date='Jul 16 2007, 11:36 PM']And why is the artist owed that sale?[/quote]

Because he did the work. By taking his work (the CD) and not paying for it, you are permanently denying him (stealing from him) the payment he is owed for the work he did. If you have no intention of paying him for his work, you shouldn't benefit from it, by being able to listen to the CD.

By copying the CD, and not buying it, you are not keeping your side of the obligation. The musician performs on and releases a CD in the expectation that you will buy it. By copying the CD and not buying it, you are not keeping your side of the bargain.

Edited by rosamundi
Posted

[quote name='rosamundi' post='1331173' date='Jul 16 2007, 06:54 PM']\
By copying the CD, and not buying it, you are not keeping your side of the obligation. The musician performs on and releases a CD in the expectation that you will buy it. By copying the CD and not buying it, you are not keeping your side of the bargain.[/quote]
My side of what bargain? I made no deal with him. There was no contract. If I purchase a CD, I should be able to do anything I want with that CD, including make duplicates. If I purchase an apple, I should be allowed to plant the seeds and grow that apple (of course, this isn't necessarily legal. If, for instance, it's a patented genetically modified apple, I'm not legally allowed to do this, which is beyond retarded.)

Data is merely information. The copyright laws we know today were written to address an entirely different problem of an entirely different time. When the laws were set up as part of British common law (which much American law is based on), the means of production and distribution were in the hands of the few, so large publishers that had access to a printing press could stamp out so many more copies of a written work for a fraction of the cost that anyone else could, and thus dictated really unfavorable terms to the authors, or just copied and sold the authors' works without any attribution or compensation, and charge monstrous amounts for their work, as the authors had no means of production or distribution. Today, the reverse is true: the means of production are nearly free, and in the hands of many.

And I practice what I preach too. I'm a software developer. Every piece of software that I write that is not for commission by my employer, I release under the GNU GPL, which gives the user to copy and distribute not only the software itself, but also the source code to it.

Do you have a cell phone that runs Linux or SymbianOS? Does it have an AOL Instant Messenger client? If so, there's a chance that said software contains some code I wrote, or is the derivative work of some code I wrote around 2001 or so. Did I ever see a cent for it? Nope. Am I fine with someone else making money from my code? Yup. Who would it benefit if I restricted access to my code? No one. Because of the exposure I got from that code, I was able to get a good job, that recently lead to a better job.

Same with music -- most artists make nothing, or almost nothing, from album sales. The album sales only benefit the label. Artists make their money by performing concerts. If the RIAA didn't have a lockdown on radio distribution and such, the artists would be able to self publish online, give their recordings away for free, thus improving their visibility, and make more money touring.

Posted

adt6247
As you noted earlier, the action is against the law. "malum prohibitum" As such it falls within the definition of sin posted earlier.

While it is a valid strategy in criminal law to obtain an innocent verdict by proving the defendant did not commit the crime for which they were charged (and so long as it is not a lesser included offense, double jeopardy sets in and the defendant walks), the question here is one of morality.

There is a cartoon in my office - a man in a pin strip suit with a briefcase approaches a "T" interesection . . . to the left the road is labeled "legal;" to the right the road is "ethical." The cartoon's title "How to stump a corporate lawyer."

While you may have no "contract" with the author/artist, you do have one with your society. What is called the golden rule is not a bad rule for social interaction.

Releasing some of your work in open source - as freeware - does not mean all your work has that status. Music artists may choose to perform at free concerts or paid concerts. As I understand your posts, if one attends a paid concert without paying, they've done no wrong. The artist still has all their songs, no material thing of theirs has gone from their possession to the possession of the other.

I must disagree.

In my example, there could be theft from more than one person.

The first would have been from the venue operator. There was a space available, which for a price, could be occupied at a certain time to hear a certain artist. While the free market does not guarantee that space will be purchased (leased), no one has a right to be in that space without the permission of the venue operator. (if this were a real estate question, I'd be describing the offense of trespass)

The second could have been from the artist. The venue operator may have paid a percentage of the gate. The more popular the artist, the higher the expected gate. If I were on the bill, a closet would be too big. Real performers can sell out a sports stadium. Or maybe there would have be a "bonus" for paid attendance for which the performer would have qualified if that last ticket had been sold.

There is also a possible "theft of services" argument, but again, it requires entry into the venue.

Where I do agree with your argument is where the listener doesn't enter the venue. If the artists fill the stadium, and the listener is on the street outside the stadium, there was no theft, no breach of contract, no harm/foul/sin in listening. They won't have the best "view" or the best "acoustical" experience but there was no wrongdoing.

In the retail world, obtaining a CD (or the electrons arranged on it) would appear to be the equivalent of entering the venue for a performance.

Posted

[quote name='journeyman' post='1335216' date='Jul 19 2007, 10:46 PM']As you noted earlier, the action is against the law. "malum prohibitum" As such it falls within the definition of sin posted earlier.[/quote]
Here we are in perfect agreement.

[quote name='journeyman' post='1335216' date='Jul 19 2007, 10:46 PM']While you may have no "contract" with the author/artist, you do have one with your society. What is called the golden rule is not a bad rule for social interaction.[/quote]
I don't buy the idea of a "social contract". Contracts must be explicitly agreed to by both parties. I agree that the golden rule applies here. If the law allowed, I'd do unto others as I'd have them do unto me. Currently, I'm bound by the law to not do such things.

[quote name='journeyman' post='1335216' date='Jul 19 2007, 10:46 PM']Releasing some of your work in open source - as freeware - does not mean all your work has that status.[/quote]
Only because I do not have the legal option of doing so. If I did, I would. If the law, however, was sane, I wouldn't have to, as restriction of digital replication should not be part of the law.

[quote name='journeyman' post='1335216' date='Jul 19 2007, 10:46 PM']Music artists may choose to perform at free concerts or paid concerts. As I understand your posts, if one attends a paid concert without paying, they've done no wrong. The artist still has all their songs, no material thing of theirs has gone from their possession to the possession of the other.

I must disagree.[/quote]
As must I. Information, by any traditional definition, is not property. I believe that the law should force attribution to the author (or in the case of a recording, the performer(s)). Not to provide attribution is clearly fraud. However, one cannot own something that is not a physical object.

[quote name='journeyman' post='1335216' date='Jul 19 2007, 10:46 PM']The first would have been from the venue operator. There was a space available, which for a price, could be occupied at a certain time to hear a certain artist. While the free market does not guarantee that space will be purchased (leased), no one has a right to be in that space without the permission of the venue operator. (if this were a real estate question, I'd be describing the offense of trespass)[/quote]
And this, as you admit, is rooted in actual property rights. The venue operator owns, or represents the owner of, the venue. Thus, the operator has the right to restrict access to the venue.

[quote name='journeyman' post='1335216' date='Jul 19 2007, 10:46 PM']The second could have been from the artist. The venue operator may have paid a percentage of the gate. The more popular the artist, the higher the expected gate. If I were on the bill, a closet would be too big. Real performers can sell out a sports stadium. Or maybe there would have be a "bonus" for paid attendance for which the performer would have qualified if that last ticket had been sold.[/quote]
Again, the artist is either a paid contractor, or contracts the hall themselves. It's rooted in the property rights of the venue. The operator has the right to control access to the venue, and thus, allowing enterance to the venue is a paid service, and purchasing a ticket or whatever constitutes as a contractual transaction.

[quote name='journeyman' post='1335216' date='Jul 19 2007, 10:46 PM']Where I do agree with your argument is where the listener doesn't enter the venue. If the artists fill the stadium, and the listener is on the street outside the stadium, there was no theft, no breach of contract, no harm/foul/sin in listening. They won't have the best "view" or the best "acoustical" experience but there was no wrongdoing.[/quote]
Agreed; the venue operator has no right to police property unmanaged by him. Nobody owns the air, and sound propagated is not property.

[quote name='journeyman' post='1335216' date='Jul 19 2007, 10:46 PM']In the retail world, obtaining a CD (or the electrons arranged on it) would appear to be the equivalent of entering the venue for a performance.[/quote]
If you stole the physical CD, then yes, you're correct. The data on the CD is not property. The physical medium is. The data is no more property than a math equation is property.

I think part of your problem is you are still looking at the data as if it were phyisical -- I'm talking about the data as an abstract concept. On a CD, the data is stored in pits in one of the plastic layers on the disk. A laser registers each pit as a 1 or a 0. If it's ripped to a hard disk, the data is stored on disk as a series of magnetic charges. It's the same data, but stored differently in a different physical media. It is, however, the same.

Again, I'm not talking about how the law treats it; I acknowledge that the law treats data as property. I am also aware that I am bound by the law under penalty of sin. I also am stating that I do follow the law. However, I posit that the law is wrong.

Posted

Lets say an engineer sells designs for something.

The person he sold them to copies the designs, and then returns them.

By your logic, he does not have to pay the engineer.

The engineer won't get paid for his work, the person stole labor from the engineer. But you claim they didn't steal anything.

You are wrong wrong wrong...

Posted

[quote name='T-Bone _' post='1335646' date='Jul 20 2007, 11:54 AM']Lets say an engineer sells designs for something.

The person he sold them to copies the designs, and then returns them.

By your logic, he does not have to pay the engineer.

The engineer won't get paid for his work, the person stole labor from the engineer. But you claim they didn't steal anything.

You are wrong wrong wrong...[/quote]
The engineer shouldn't take a return. One isn't ethically obligated to take a product for return unless there is a defect in the product, and even then, it can be fixed.

When I write code to spec, and someone decides they don't want the code that I delivered for cash, I still get paid. There's been a couple of cases where customers of mine have commissioned me to build something that they never used. In one case, they said they wanted a refund. I said no. They contracted a service from me, I did the service for them, they paid me, and then they decided they didn't want the service I gave them. It's too late; the contract is concluded.

Were there a defect in the product I produced them, I would of course fixed it free of charge.

Also, with stuff like purchased software or off-the-shelf engineering plans, usually there is something on the box that says "if you break this seal, you have to abide by this contract." This is referred to a "shrink-wrap" license or EULA (End-User License Agreement). If it states terms on that, and you open it, you are bound by the contract that you de-facto signed.

Now, it gets really messy with software that have EULA's that you have to click through to install. First of all, what happens if you install a piece of software on a computer used by multiple people? Does that legally bind all other users of the computer to the contract? What if someone under 18 installs it, as they're legally not allowed to enter into a contract? Again, messy. I try to avoid using commercial software whenever possible for just this reason (among others).

Posted

[quote name='adt6247' post='1335641' date='Jul 20 2007, 09:44 AM']I think part of your problem is you are still looking at the data as if it were physical -- I'm talking about the data as an abstract concept. On a CD, the data is stored in pits in one of the plastic layers on the disk. A laser registers each pit as a 1 or a 0. If it's ripped to a hard disk, the data is stored on disk as a series of magnetic charges. It's the same data, but stored differently in a different physical media. It is, however, the same.[/quote]

We get to the same place, but by different routes. I do think non-material things, including data, can be "property." They represent a talent, a thought, a concept, an arrangement, that are uniquely that of the author/performer. For that unique talent (etc) there may be a market place. If so, the originator of that thought, arrangement whatever should reap a benefit if others like/appreciate/value what they have done. They have to eat too.



and the engineer example is interesting . . . at least from a law school hypothetical point of view

customer engages engineer to draw plans for a building to be erected at location A
engineer draws plans
engineer is paid
customer builds building
customer is happy

customer is so happy, that when he needs a new building, he takes the plans off the shelf and builds the same building at location B

should engineer get paid again?

unfortunately, the soil at location B was not the same as at location A, the foundation at location B is inadequate, the building collapses, and the customer is very unhappy

should he be able to sue engineer for drawing bad plans


what are the intangibles of service contracts and why wouldn't a recording constitute a substitute for a personal service agreement?

would you have the same opinion if music still came on vinyl and wasn't so overtly "data"

Posted

[quote name='adt6247' post='1331147' date='Jul 16 2007, 04:36 PM']And why is the artist owed that sale? I am under no obligation to buy a CD, whether or not I copy it. A sale isn't a sale if both parties do not have the option of not proceeding with the transaction, otherwise it would be extortion.

Again, I'm not arguing that copying CD's isn't sinful, I'm just arguing that it isn't stealing. You are talking about a sale that never did, and never will happen.[/quote]


you are under no obligation to purchase the CD - the artist is not "owed" a sale
the artist is under no obligation to perform for your benefit - you are not owed a song

the consideration you pay for the CD is what induces the artist to sing for you . . . via the CD . . . there may be other considerations available, that's what makes the free marketplace (even if it isn't as free as it might be - but that's a whole other topic) invite the artist to dinner in exchange for a song; offer to drive them from the airport in exchange for a song . . .

Posted

[quote name='journeyman' post='1335942' date='Jul 20 2007, 10:06 PM']customer engages engineer to draw plans for a building to be erected at location A
engineer draws plans
engineer is paid
customer builds building
customer is happy

customer is so happy, that when he needs a new building, he takes the plans off the shelf and builds the same building at location B

should engineer get paid again?[/quote]
No. The engineer was paid for a task. Even if the plans constituted as "intellectual property", unless the engineer and customer signed a contract stating that the engineer is to be paid for additional buildings built with the plans, and that the customer is not to share the plans, there is no obligation from the customer to do so. The customer contracted the engineer for the service, the engineer provided the service, and thus the transaction was complete. Even if the data is property, the property is transferred.

[quote name='journeyman' post='1335942' date='Jul 20 2007, 10:06 PM']unfortunately, the soil at location B was not the same as at location A, the foundation at location B is inadequate, the building collapses, and the customer is very unhappy

should he be able to sue engineer for drawing bad plans
what are the intangibles of service contracts and why wouldn't a recording constitute a substitute for a personal service agreement?[/quote]
Nope. The engineer was never given specs for the different location. If the customer was smart, he would have gone back to the engineer with the survey results of the new location, and had the engineer approve or adjust the designs. The customer is under no obligation to do so, however, it would be prudent. The engineer had no way to know that the plans would be used again. The engineer designed the building to spec, and was unaware of other uses of the plan, so would not be liable.

[quote name='journeyman' post='1335942' date='Jul 20 2007, 10:06 PM']would you have the same opinion if music still came on vinyl and wasn't so overtly "data"[/quote]
Still data. Just because it's analog does not mean it's not data. Yes, recording it would require loss of quality, as there is no way to do lossless analog replication, but it is data nonetheless.

In fact, the record companies argue that digital replication is worse, because it allows for lossless copies, whereas analog replication, though still illegal, requires that each generation of copy is necessarily worse than the prior.

Posted

hmmmmm.so what exactly is the purpose of CD burners in the first place? If its illegal or a "sin" to make copies of other cd's?

Posted

[quote name='Akalyte' post='1336382' date='Jul 21 2007, 08:07 AM']hmmmmm.so what exactly is the purpose of CD burners in the first place? If its illegal or a "sin" to make copies of other cd's?[/quote]

1) It is not illegal, nor is it a sin, to make archival copies of audio CDs
2) CDs are also used to store non-audio data

Posted

[quote name='Akalyte' post='1336382' date='Jul 21 2007, 11:07 AM']hmmmmm.so what exactly is the purpose of CD burners in the first place? If its illegal or a "sin" to make copies of other cd's?[/quote]
When CD-ROM's first appeared on the market, the average hard drive was about 120MB, so as the original CD-ROM's could store 650MB, that was a huge boon to inexpensive storage, which allowed rich media applications, and eventually delivered us from having to install software from a stack of floppies. Burners entered the scene when hard drives were typically around 1GB, so you could back up all your stuff on 2 disks, which at the time, were about $5-10 a piece. Compared to other consumer backup technology, this was dirt cheap!

Before thumb drives and mostly-universal broadband, I used to give people things on CD, whether it was programs I wrote, documents I constructed, or whatever.

There are plenty of legal, moral, non-infringing uses for CD and DVD (or BluRay or HD-DVD) burner.

Chiquitunga
Posted

I haven't read all the posts, but I agree that buring CDs of copyrighted music to give to others, or obtaining it for yourself, is wrong.

However, what about CDs or DVDs of music or movies that are out of print? I don't feel it's wrong to obtain a ripped DVD, for example, of a film that is not available to purchase anywhere, after an extensive search to find it.

Posted

[quote name='Margaret Clare' post='1336723' date='Jul 21 2007, 07:39 PM']I haven't read all the posts, but I agree that buring CDs of copyrighted music to give to others, or obtaining it for yourself, is wrong.

However, what about CDs or DVDs of music or movies that are out of print? I don't feel it's wrong to obtain a ripped DVD, for example, of a film that is not available to purchase anywhere, after an extensive search to find it.[/quote]
It depends on why you think it's wrong. You should read all the posts.

I argue, a lot in this thread, that the ONLY reason it is wrong to do so is because it is illegal. It is a sin to break the law. If it were not illegal, it would be perfectly moral to copy CD's and DVD's. It doesn't matter whether they are out of print or not; if the Copyright is still valid (150 years after the recording is made), it's illegal, and thus a sin to copy.

Posted

[quote name='journeyman' post='1335946' date='Jul 20 2007, 08:14 PM']you are under no obligation to purchase the CD - the artist is not "owed" a sale
the artist is under no obligation to perform for your benefit - you are not owed a song[/quote]




adt, did I miss your response to this statement of the implied contract?






the question of "vanish"-ware . . . the owner has vanished . . . is a hot topic in gaming software, where "old" games cease to be supported, even though they are still fun to play . . . actually, the term for this is "abandonware" . . . strict copyright interpretation says these copies are also a violation of the statutes . . . but common parlance is "who is going to complain"

This is similar to the "out of print" question . . . although I thought the longest protected period was around 70 years . . . if adt says 150, he's probably checked, and I haven't

there is a group of businesses that go around buying old written off debts, and long after people think the creditor has forgotten about them, along comes this new guy and starts the headache all over - typically they are nastier than the original creditor, and have no problem levying on personal belongings/cars etc to collect. If you're prepared for that kind of surprise in the gaming environment, abandonware may be for you . . . in the current music and movie world, ripped cds . . .

there are a number of out of print books that I would love to have, but the asking price in the used/collectible/antique market is out of my range. E-bay sellers sometimes don't know what they're selling, and I have had some success filling in the gaps there. Whether or not anyone at E-bay has your out of print music/movie is a question that only E-bay can answer.

the publisher's of CDs and DVDs must be trying to limit our ability to acquire what will some day be "old" stuff . . . I understand that there are regional codes built into the discs when originally made, and a US player won't recognize (play) an Asian or European disc . . . now that business practice flies in the face of maintaining a legal aftermarket and encourages breaking the copy protection

. . . this has gotten a ways away from the question of "sin" . . . sorry

Chiquitunga
Posted

[quote name='adt6247' post='1337321' date='Jul 22 2007, 05:55 AM']It doesn't matter whether they are out of print or not; if the Copyright is still valid (150 years after the recording is made), it's illegal, and thus a sin to copy.[/quote]

Okay, I think it would be a different case though if it's a movie that's out of print (in USA format, with subtitles) and only airs on EWTN once a year or so - to obtain a ripped DVD copy of someone else's recorded copy.

Posted

[quote name='Margaret Clare' post='1337594' date='Jul 22 2007, 02:48 PM']Okay, I think it would be a different case though if it's a movie that's out of print (in USA format, with subtitles) and only airs on EWTN once a year or so - to obtain a ripped DVD copy of someone else's recorded copy.[/quote]

if you set your VCR to record it on the one day a year EWTN airs it . . . you might be ok

the whole personal use/fair use aspect of the copyright law is less comprehensible than the bulk of it . . . I do know that colleges are (or were) very leery of "copying" stuff for class handouts because of concerns over whether or not that is "fair us" . . . I personally think that if you include the newspaper/magazine info (adt mentioned this above - attribution), you've respected their authorship . . . but I am not a voracious "my copyright has been infringed" plaintiff's lawyer . . . nor have I gone out and researched the topic

expecting common sense from the law is sometimes expecting too much . . . unfortunately

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...