abercius24 Posted July 23, 2007 Posted July 23, 2007 Okay, you may not be stealing a CD or data, but what you are stealing by pirating music is an opportunity someone else has a moral and legal right to, that opportunity being the right to make money. In the case of Metallica, sure they probably were able to afford the evils of Napster. But what about the local band who is just starting out? You make it generally acceptable to pirate music in our society, and you make it okay to do it to the local band who NEEDS the royalties from their album sales to build their business. In this case, you have substantially contributed to the loss of opportunity and wages from another person. By the way, the FBI is in fact prosecuting people for pirating music today. If they happen to notice you trading songs on the internet (which they DO monitor regularly), and they see a number of unlicensed music files on your computer (which they can check since Microsoft has given them the password hash values for all Microsoft machines), they may prosecute you. There are a number of kids who are serving time in Juvenille Hall for music piracy who never thought the FBI would care.
abercius24 Posted July 23, 2007 Posted July 23, 2007 [quote name='adt6247' post='1331143' date='Jul 16 2007, 05:32 PM']How is it "property"? By any classical definition of property, a property is a physical object, whether land or gold or a ham sandwich. Information isn't property. For instance, the physical medium (such as, a compact disc) is property. If I purchase that CD, I own the physical medium. The data contained on the CD isn't property. It is data.[/quote] The classical definition is ignoranct and no longer suffices. Think about the case of Identity Theft. Give the wrong person your name, social security number, address and date-of-birth, and they can destroy your credit. They basically steal your opportunity to benefit from your credit reputation. You lose because they take something you have a right to. That is the definition of theft today. Justice itself is an intangible concept, but nonetheless real.
adt6247 Posted July 23, 2007 Posted July 23, 2007 [quote name='journeyman' post='1337584' date='Jul 22 2007, 04:37 PM']This is similar to the "out of print" question . . . although I thought the longest protected period was around 70 years . . . if adt says 150, he's probably checked, and I haven't[/quote] It depends on who the owner of the copyright is. If the copyright owner is a corporation, it's a flat 150 years. If the copyright owner is the author, or named authors, it is life of the author + 75 years. When copyright legislation was initially introduced in this country, it was 14 years, flat, plus the author could apply for an extension at the end of the 14 years for another 14, but this could only be done once. BTW: before the Digital Millenium Copyright Act of 1998, it was 75 by a corporation, or life of author + 50 years. Every time Mickey Mouse would become public domain, Disney buys a senator or three and gets the term lengthened. It's happenned like 4 times already.
adt6247 Posted July 23, 2007 Posted July 23, 2007 [quote name='abercius24' post='1337880' date='Jul 22 2007, 10:14 PM']Okay, you may not be stealing a CD or data, but what you are stealing by pirating music is an opportunity someone else has a moral and legal right to, that opportunity being the right to make money.[/quote] We do not have a moral right to make money any way we want. What if I want to make money posting of Phatmass, and I claim that anyone doing it for free is taking potential money away from me? You can merely set price on your goods and services. Your potential customers, if any, decide whether that is a fair price, or if your good or service has ANY value at all. [quote name='abercius24' post='1337880' date='Jul 22 2007, 10:14 PM']By the way, the FBI is in fact prosecuting people for pirating music today. If they happen to notice you trading songs on the internet (which they DO monitor regularly), and they see a number of unlicensed music files on your computer (which they can check since Microsoft has given them the password hash values for all Microsoft machines), they may prosecute you. There are a number of kids who are serving time in Juvenille Hall for music piracy who never thought the FBI would care.[/quote] Actually, the RIAA is suing individuals in civil court, the FBI is not prosecuting people in federal court. There's a HUGE difference. The RIAA has sued senior citizens that have never used a computer, 5-year-olds who can't read, librarians and lab techs that simply don't secure their networks enough, etc. They're setting up protection rackets for colleges. They're behaving like the mob, not a multinational corporation. Also, if you actually read the entire thread, I have stated, from the beginning that duplicating copyrighted works for purpose of distribution is illegal, and it is a sin to break the law. I am not defending people who do so. I'm saying that the law SHOULD change. From your statements, you make it clear that you know little about the law, or the history of such patent or copyright law. Can you even differentiate between a patent and copyright? Do you know what the founding fathers said about such laws in the Fedralist Papers? Do you know the reason such laws were put into effect (but with limits of 7 years for patents, and 14 years for copyrights)?
adt6247 Posted July 23, 2007 Posted July 23, 2007 [quote name='abercius24' post='1337896' date='Jul 22 2007, 10:20 PM']The classical definition is ignoranct and no longer suffices. Think about the case of Identity Theft. Give the wrong person your name, social security number, address and date-of-birth, and they can destroy your credit. They basically steal your opportunity to benefit from your credit reputation. You lose because they take something you have a right to. That is the definition of theft today. Justice itself is an intangible concept, but nonetheless real.[/quote] But the word 'justice' refers to a concept. The word 'property' refers to something very, very tangible and physical. Just talk to a distributist, and have them argue with you what property is. (I am NOT a proponent of distributism -- it is an egalitarian philosophy that is too socialist for my palate). No, the classical definition does suffice. When you broaden a definition to include more things, it becomes a weaker, less specific word, and thus leads to linguistic relativism. Identity theft is NOT theft -- it is fraud. Fraud is already illegal. There is no need to make changes to property law. You don't own opportunity -- it cannot be stolen from you. Your credit rating isn't property -- it is information. It's information that you don't have any control over. I reject modernism, in all its forms, including this bizzare tendency towards making language mean less, so you can reinterpret everything in your favor. The bastardization of language is why the radicals from the 60's are considered moderates now: they hijacked language. We have become a race of incredibly lazy thinkers.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now