Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Where Should Catholic Music Go From Here?


Catholic Music Questions  

53 members have voted

You do not have permission to vote in this poll, or see the poll results. Please sign in or register to vote in this poll.

Recommended Posts

Posted

[quote name='the Apologist' post='1306550' date='Jun 30 2007, 01:22 PM']But also, the Catholics themselves don't support their own artists that much... i mean just look here on Phatmass how few even visit the artists phorums or ask questions or show support. Yet you go to the "What are listening to now" link and everyone is posting 99% secular groups... and this is the home of Catholic hip hop.[/quote]
I admit that I could do more to support as a fan. But on the other side, I think the artists themselves contribute to that lack of interest. I know they're all busy with their real lives, and I'm not saying this as a negative criticism, I mean it constructively. When was the last time Phatmass really had any updates about anything? The radio has had the same stuff on it for years, Aftermass never materialized (I don't even know if it's still going to be released). The artists don't really post much on their own boards to keep us involved. I think we can all step up our game, the fans supporting but also the artists keeping their own name and music alive. Part of the reason why other Christian rappers are successful is because they put their grind in. If you want people to listen, you have to promote your music continuously and get people involved. I noticed dUSt took away the music section and it just says Hip Hop now. I think it would be a good idea to commit to really putting the emphasis on the Hip Hop and keeping interest alive, maybe by having one phorum for all the artists, maybe a separate section on PM where we get news, updates, samples on new music, stuff like that. I'm sure we could find volunteers to help do that, because it seems to me like we're stagnant as far as the Hip Hop scene at Phatmass. We could be doing so much more, we could have interviews with artists, etc. We can't expect the music to market itself just because it's Catholic music. We have to put in the work to build that fan base, we have to reach out to them as listeners and not just as Catholics.

Posted

Wow, that topic brought out some strong feelings. That's good. I think we're getting into the nitty gritty, even if it is a familar dead horse. ;-)

Some of us in California did some experimental stuff with some venues that may be of interest and an inspiration to you guys and gals. First, we eventually got around to making the event more religious than the music. It became a standard at most shows to have confession and adoration DURING performances. We kept both sacraments a stone throw away from the main room; just enough to get people interested as they walked by, and just far enough away that the music did not interefere too much. We also got into having adoration and benediction with more reverential music (including some authentic Chant) at the very end, which always gave everyone a solid feeling of conclusion to the evening. Looking back on all that, in the light of your explanation of the fundamentalists' zeal, some of our most successful venues were ones that had the sacraments available. I remember being outside of one show (trying to stop the ringing in my ears), and this one college girl came out from confession. She was so overwhealmed with emotion since she had not been to confession in about 4 years and she felt so free to have had the opportunity to go. It was almost like how our fundamentalists brothers in Christ share about the emotions they feel after an "altar call", but in this case, the "altar call" (if you will) was put in the right context. I ended up hearing of a number of other stories very similar, which made the evening really stick with me. In fact, I'm not even sure the show was that good, but I remember feeling the Holy Spirit all over everyone that night. Truly a supernatural experience for second-rate musicians.

We also had one show called "Generation Live" where we pre-sold tickets 2-4 weeks in advance to the Youth Ministers at all the local Churches. We ended selling out 340 tickets at $10 each, which included admission to the first part of the show (since we couldn't charge people to go to the sacraments during the 2nd part), plus a modest meal and drink. Because we pre-sold the tickets, we were able to get a good sound guy under contract, we balanced our budget before we made our big purchases, we paid all of the bands for their time and transportion costs, -- and we had a guaranteed number of people who would be there, which gave us some credibility when we asked some Catholic book stores and t-shirt vendors to come and setup booths. It took a lot of work to find the Youth Ministers who would go in with us, but we eventually did and everyone loved it. The strategy was so successful, it got me thinking about how a marketing person is just as important to a smooth show as a producer, a stage manager and a sound guy.

Now I'm not saying the sun always shines on Catholic music events in California. It took a lot of shows for us to figure these things out, but I offer this to all of you to consider. In fact, I would like to hear of some other successful strategies anyone else may have discovered. Please do share.

the Apologist
Posted

[quote name='Era Might' post='1306557' date='Jun 30 2007, 01:40 PM']I admit that I could do more to support as a fan. But on the other side, I think the artists themselves contribute to that lack of interest. I know they're all busy with their real lives, and I'm not saying this as a negative criticism, I mean it constructively. When was the last time Phatmass really had any updates about anything? The radio has had the same stuff on it for years, Aftermass never materialized (I don't even know if it's still going to be released). The artists don't really post much on their own boards to keep us involved. I think we can all step up our game, the fans supporting but also the artists keeping their own name and music alive. Part of the reason why other Christian rappers are successful is because they put their grind in. If you want people to listen, you have to promote your music continuously and get people involved. I noticed dUSt took away the music section and it just says Hip Hop now. I think it would be a good idea to commit to really putting the emphasis on the Hip Hop and keeping interest alive, maybe by having one phorum for all the artists, maybe a separate section on PM where we get news, updates, samples on new music, stuff like that. I would be willing to help do that if dUSt was interested, because it seems to me like we're stagnant as far as the Hip Hop scene at Phatmass. We could be doing so much more, we could have interviews with artists, etc. We can't expect the music to market itself just because it's Catholic music. We have to put in the work to build that fan base, we have to reach out to them as listeners and not just as Catholics.[/quote]


I agree with what you say but honestly man i have seen over and over how artists try to promote their music and it seems like it falls on deaf ears... for example an artist posts a link to check out his songs and the response is not that great. Some would say that the artist is to blame for not making good music and maybe something can be said for that... but the in comparison with Protestants, the fan support is very very weak. And trust me, i have done a many things to promote stuff even to the point of giving stuff away for free... More has to be done, but if the fans where more dedicated in supporting Catholic artists, then i think we would be further in the game than we are now. If everyone was a fan like Era Might, then we wouldn't have so much of a problem... Also, i don't think it is so much that artist are busy with their lives as the lack of avenues to promote their materials and support make it difficult for them to get their material out... but of course, all of that depends on each individual case. Also to reach out to build the fan base there are many "Church leaders" who tell you don't want hip hop or rock, or are against it because they think it is not good music and is "misleading youth", i mean i was told many times that rap is "evil." Not many see it in a good light.

Posted

I think a lot of that could change if we would get ourselves organized. I know the artists post links here and there, but that's the problem. Just posting a link to music may get you a few listens, but it doesn't keep people around and involved. When I go to an artists website and I see that they rarely update it, I lose my interest as a fan because I feel like why should I care if they don't seem to care enough to keep us updated? We have a bunch of different phorums for each artist, plus a muzik phorum, everything is scattered everywhere, there is no link to the radio, no real information in the music section of the website.

As far as people not liking rap music, I don't think that's a major issue. I like rap music and you like rap music and a lot of the people who come here like rap music. We don't need to appeal to people who don't like what we're doing, we only have to appeal to people who share our interests. If that gets recognized by the larger Catholic community then that's great, but first we have to build up our own thing and worry about the rest later.

We have to work together more as well, because there's not a lot of us. Why not make a new collaboration mix with all the Phatmass artists every few months and sell it as a download, and put the money toward individual albums? We can come up with 6 solid tracks every few months to keep the music going and keep interest.

I don't know, but I think we should think about doing something to make the Hip Hop more organized and prominent here. Not just the music but to keep the artists visible and the fans involved. How many of the artists post here on a regular basis? I know they're busy and I'm not blaming them for that, but if we were better organized with maybe someone running a Hip Hop section of the site, they could contact the artists and get updates and post samples of new music and all that kind of stuff.

Posted (edited)

I feel there is a lack of interest in Catholic hip-hop, hip-hop in general. Though we are doing this for the greater glory of God and for his Church. When I was promoting massmatics in Austin, people just didn't seem interested. More annoyed than anything. I didnt get much support, i gave my cd to priests down here and posted flyer's, i even gave away free cd's to some youth. Many of the youth are too tangled up in lil john and kanye west and couldnt care less about hip-hop preaching the truth about God and religion..shoot, many catholics down here dont even know if there catholic! lol

We are not for having hip-hop in the liturgy. I know I'm not. I'm a traditionalist.(not schismatic so calm down) In love with orthodoxy. What can we do to get people more interested? How can we reach the youth?

Edited by Akalyte
abercius24
Posted (edited)

[quote name='Akalyte' post='1307387' date='Jun 30 2007, 11:18 PM']I feel there is a lack of interest in Catholic hip-hop, hip-hop in general. Though we are doing this for the greater glory of God and for his Church. When I was promoting massmatics in Austin, people just didn't seem interested. More annoyed than anything. I didnt get much support, i gave my cd to priests down here and posted flyer's, i even gave away free cd's to some youth. Many of the youth are too tangled up in lil john and kanye west and couldnt care less about hip-hop preaching the truth about God and religion..shoot, many catholics down here dont even know if there catholic! lol

We are not for having hip-hop in the liturgy. I know I'm not. I'm a traditionalist.(not schismatic so calm down) In love with orthodoxy. What can we do to get people more interested? How can we reach the youth?[/quote]

You see, the problem is that public exposure (like Catholic music performances) is a one way street. The public doesn't talk back. They don't have a voice unified enough to speak for them -- again another need for some good Catholic music marketeers. I can tell you, though, that your music is rather popular within the circles I've worked in Southern California. I've heard a lot about your music, even though I've never met you, as funny as that is.

The other problem is organization. After having a bit of a Catholic music summit among some promoters, we agreed we needed to have a few Catholic bookstore carry and promote a Catholic music section. We did find 2 stores that agreed to carry the music, but the patrons of those stores were not the same people who buy Catholic music, and the project failed. We didn't align our market with that of the stores'. I think the one thing we did right, though, was that we experimented. We learned how not to promote Catholic music. :-) Experimentation seems to be the one thing we need more of find ways to better organize ourselves. It's clear to me now that the internet is the best way to market Catholic music. You see, we have preconceived notions about how things should work, but we are working in an entirely different medium than that of secular music. We need to put more energy into working out our mistakes to define how things work in our medium. We need "to boldly go where no geniuses have gone before" (geniuses for Christ, that is). But we need to find courage and patience to fail as many times as it takes before we get it right. And, we need to be willing to communicate our mistakes with each other. It seems we are all making the same mistakes and everybody is afraid to warn each other because they don't want to look like a fool. I say its time for us to recognize how foolish we are to be doing this work in the first place (all for love of Our Lord) and its time to be geniuses together!

Edited by abercius24
Posted

[quote name='abercius24' post='1307663' date='Jul 1 2007, 07:25 AM']You see, the problem is that public exposure (like Catholic music performances) is a one way street. The public doesn't talk back. They don't have a voice unified enough to speak for them -- again another need for some good Catholic music marketeers. I can tell you, though, that your music is rather popular within the circles I've worked in Southern California. I've heard a lot about your music, even though I've never met you, as funny as that is.

The other problem is organization. After having a bit of a Catholic music summit among some promoters, we agreed we needed to have a few Catholic bookstore carry and promote a Catholic music section. We did find 2 stores that agreed to carry the music, but the patrons of those stores were not the same people who buy Catholic music, and the project failed. We didn't align our market with that of the stores'. I think the one thing we did right, though, was that we experimented. We learned how not to promote Catholic music. :-) Experimentation seems to be the one thing we need more of find ways to better organize ourselves. It's clear to me now that the internet is the best way to market Catholic music. You see, we have preconceived notions about how things should work, but we are working in an entirely different medium than that of secular music. We need to put more energy into working out our mistakes to define how things work in our medium. We need "to boldly go where no geniuses have gone before" (geniuses for Christ, that is). But we need to find courage and patience to fail as many times as it takes before we get it right. And, we need to be willing to communicate our mistakes with each other. It seems we are all making the same mistakes and everybody is afraid to warn each other because they don't want to look like a fool. I say its time for us to recognize how foolish we are to be doing this work in the first place (all for love of Our Lord) and its time to be geniuses together![/quote]

wow, that made so much sense!

misereremi
Posted

[quote name='abercius24' post='1307663' date='Jul 1 2007, 01:25 PM']I think the one thing we did right, though, was that we experimented. We learned how not to promote Catholic music. :-) Experimentation seems to be the one thing we need more of find ways to better organize ourselves. It's clear to me now that the internet is the best way to market Catholic music. You see, we have preconceived notions about how things should work, but we are working in an entirely different medium than that of secular music. We need to put more energy into working out our mistakes to define how things work in our medium. We need "to boldly go where no geniuses have gone before" (geniuses for Christ, that is). But we need to find courage and patience to fail as many times as it takes before we get it right. And, we need to be willing to communicate our mistakes with each other. It seems we are all making the same mistakes and everybody is afraid to warn each other because they don't want to look like a fool. I say its time for us to recognize how foolish we are to be doing this work in the first place (all for love of Our Lord) and its time to be geniuses together![/quote]
Definitely agree. I've been doing a lot of trial-and-error promotion. Myspace and other internet sites have been a good launchpad for our music.

I actually go to a lot of secular (underground) circles to market our stuff- like underground music record stores which showcase homegrown artists, and linked radio shows- int eh virtual and real world. We got a lot of support. We even got support for live shows. I guess this is because many of us are reverts and converts, and for us it comes easier to work with past secular connections.

Hopefully once we have proven ourselves and built up enough resources, the Catholic circles will be a bit more open to having bands like ours play. In the meantime, we have to look at creative fundraising ourselves. We have been trying to establish our Catholic label and get a collective of artists on board. We've had funding problems, and we're all based in different parts of Europe :rolleyes: but we're working on it.

I think one of the reasons that some of the other Christian "denominations" do a better job is that they put a lot of resources into it. They sweat people for money. They also invest a lot of time and resources into "community building." There is that wider work that needs to be done: we need to get our communities back into parish life, and be a bit more bold in how we do it.

misereremi
Posted

[quote name='abercius24' post='1306375' date='Jun 30 2007, 07:56 AM']There's another point you bring to my mind. At one point, we the Church were the greatest patrons of the arts. The massive museums held by the Vatican prove this. Today, our separated brethren, the Fundamentalist Christians have been much more successful in producing Contemporary Christian music. In fact, one of the bands I played with was only 1 of 2 Catholic bands that auditioned for the Spirit West Coast festival -- 2 out of 5000 bands. Any ideas why they have us beat on our own proven territory?[/quote]
I agree with what hope 4 the new said in his post. They put a lot of resources into putting on a show because[i] that [/i]is their worship, and outside of that, there's not the wealth of Sacramental life that we have.

I've also seen the growing disconnect in our Church between those who catechize and young people, so many young people got put-off. But things are totally changing. We're in a new era of renewal and we must persevere with our calling no matter how small the following. When I think of how Our Lord was resolute and patient with all those whom he recruited for His ministry, I really can't give up hope.
[quote name='hope4thenew' post='1306518' date='Jun 30 2007, 05:47 PM']with the teachings and love 4 the youth of John Paul II, a generation was CATECHISED and found a deep LOVE and APPRECIATION 4 their catholic faith...a huge re-conversion if u will...there4, through prayer and the God-given talents in music, the arts, dance or what-have-u, we r just now re-learning how 2 apply and incorparate r gifts with the love and knowledge of this great Church that Christ himself has established...

if we can combine the Sacraments, prayer, studying the sacred scriptures, prayer, liturigal catechisis, and prayer...and unite this with r love 4 music in all it's forms...the Lord will provide the people who want 2 hear it[/quote]
:yes:

abercius24
Posted

[quote name='misereremi' post='1307684' date='Jul 1 2007, 09:17 AM']Hopefully once we have proven ourselves and built up enough resources, the Catholic circles will be a bit more open to having bands like ours play. In the meantime, we have to look at creative fundraising ourselves. We have been trying to establish our Catholic label and get a collective of artists on board. We've had funding problems, and we're all based in different parts of Europe :rolleyes: but we're working on it.[/quote]

Catholic music in the UK? I wasn't aware there was a movement over there. That rocks! You've got to share some details. I thought it was something pretty exclusive to the U.S. By the way, what's your band's name, Misereremi?

misereremi
Posted

[quote name='abercius24' post='1307962' date='Jul 1 2007, 08:33 PM']Catholic music in the UK? I wasn't aware there was a movement over there. That rocks! You've got to share some details. I thought it was something pretty exclusive to the U.S. By the way, what's your band's name, Misereremi?[/quote]
I am a member of the New Jerusalem Projekt, it's more of a project or "collective" than a band with set members. All the members are into very different genres and have different side projects.... and live in different countries, too.

Oh yes, we have Catholic artists here in Europe, it's just not usually marketed as [i]Catholic [/i]music. There are some youth movements like Youth 2000 that have made some compilations. We've got a lot of Christian hip-hop in the UK. We've got our own styles like grime, 2step, and ragga and jungle etc. which might not be too popular in the US.

abercius24
Posted

[quote name='misereremi' post='1307684' date='Jul 1 2007, 09:17 AM']Definitely agree. I've been doing a lot of trial-and-error promotion. Myspace and other internet sites have been a good launchpad for our music.

I actually go to a lot of secular (underground) circles to market our stuff- like underground music record stores which showcase homegrown artists, and linked radio shows- int eh virtual and real world. We got a lot of support. We even got support for live shows. I guess this is because many of us are reverts and converts, and for us it comes easier to work with past secular connections.[/quote]

I have heard that myspace is the best way to get started. That website is "a hive of villany and scumware", though. My spyware fiddler goes crazy every time I am there. There is actually a decent network of Catholic musicians on myspace.com.

Anybody have some specific showcase sites they can recommend? Any tips on the best way to present on these sites and myspace.com?

Misereremi, how well are U.S. Catholic artists received in Europe?

Totus Tuus
Posted

Personally, I love all types of music but the most important in my mind right now is reviving/reprinting old hymnals with beautiful traditional hymns (in all languages, including Latin). Once we get some great liturgical music back into play, then I would love to see more CCM-type music by Catholic artists that could include Catholic theology. I love CCM but it always feels just a bit empty for lack of the fullness of Truth that we have. I think Catholics can definitely praise God with music that is not written or performed by Catholic artists, but for the most part we need Catholic-written music because we're the only ones who can write about things like the Eucharist!

zealousrap
Posted

I wonder if phatmass should become a member of the CAM for more exposure...

[url="http://www.cammusic.com/membership.html"]http://www.cammusic.com/membership.html[/url]

Posted

[quote name='Era Might' post='1306557' date='Jun 30 2007, 01:40 PM']Aftermass never materialized (I don't even know if it's still going to be released).[/quote]

not true... Aftermass Records is really pushing the envelope in Quality Catholic Music.

[url="http://aftermassrecords.com"]www.aftermassrecords.com[/url]


unless you were refering to Massmatics vol. 2 (in that case you are right)

gurlie4godsd
Posted

Catholic Ska would be lovely....anyone?

Posted

[quote name='gurlie4godsd' post='1310100' date='Jul 2 2007, 09:09 PM']Catholic Ska would be lovely....anyone?[/quote]

that's another thing I've been thinkin, with the reggae thread and all. I haven't really ever heard a good combination of kinda a 'metalska' and so it might sound pretty original. It think the metal sound would come from my own guitar sound as well as some good drumming. But it'd be nice to have other back up intruments, especially a keyboard and maybe some horns. it'd be nice to have an mc as well, to make the reggae sound more complete. Alot of ska rhythms are just fast reggae lines anyways. I'm just thinking out loud kinda, but I think it would sound good and original cuz it's not done very often, or at all... i don't really know.

Posted

I agree that there should be one board for all the PM artists. There are only so many topics you can post about one artist.

misereremi
Posted

[quote name='abercius24' post='1308911' date='Jul 2 2007, 05:23 AM']Misereremi, how well are U.S. Catholic artists received in Europe?[/quote]
Father Stan Fortuna was well-received. He performed at Bright Lights. I'm relatively new to Catholic events, but I think that if the artist were big enough (as in well-known), they would be welcome to play one of the big festivals.

misereremi
Posted (edited)

oops double post! Didymus, have you heard of a band called Sublime?

Edited by misereremi

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...