Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

Here was something I ended up writing on today:

Today there has much celebration around the world, due to today's official release of Pope Benedict XVI's Motu Proprio, Summorum Pontificum. This letter is extremely important to many Catholics because it allows universal usage of the Tridentine Mass, or the "Latin Mass", which was the only Mass celebrated until Vatican II. It, and the Missal of Bl. Pope John XXIII, were replaced by the Missal of Paul XI and the Norvus Ordo Mass in 1970. For many of us, this is the Mass we grew up with.

Now the Tridentine Mass has been allowed for many years, but only with the explicit permission of the Bishop. Now, if the faithful want to have the Tridentine Mass, and there is a worthy priest available, then it may take place. I'm basically summing it up here, the full letter goes more into the specifics.

To those who suddenly fear they'll walk into church and the priest will suddenly start speaking Latin, don't worry. The Norvus Ordo Mass is still the ordinary Mass. However, this does make me wonder about a few things.

Now, many will say the only reason that the Tridentine Mass was brought back was to satisfy people stuck in their old habits. And for some, that's true. For many others though, there seems to be a different reason. For many, the Tridentine Mass gives them something.

What we have seemed to have lost is the sacred. Now I'm in full support of the Tridentine Mass and the Norvus Ordo Mass, but only if celebrated in reverence. How many "Masses" I've seen and heard of that are borderline heresy! The Mass is trying to made into something "entertaining"! I don't come to be entertained, I come to worship my Lord and Savior, and to partake in the Eucharist!

That has seemed to be my trouble with Mass lately. There seems to be no reverence in many churches. It's like people don't even care what's happening up there. It's something more important than they realize.

So my point is, no matter if you celebrate the Tridentine or the Norvus Ordo Mass, just remember to celebrate with reverence for the sacred. There's something earth-shattering going on during the Mass, and I don't want to miss it.

Posted

[quote name='Funky_R' post='1316934' date='Jul 7 2007, 06:10 PM']Now, many will say the only reason that the Tridentine Mass was brought back was to satisfy people stuck in their old habits. And for some, that's true. For many others though, there seems to be a different reason. For many, the Tridentine Mass gives them something.[/quote]

Some of us traditionalists would take offense at that. I wasn't even born when the 1970 missal was promulgated. I attended my first Tridentine mass 3 years ago. Most of the people in traditional parishes and communities, in my experience are under 40 years old. We were raised in the modern church, sang bad music, were improperly catechized, lived most of our life doing things the way they're done at most parishes. We were attracted to the old mass for various reasons, whether the rampant liturgical abuses that happen in some diocese, or a love for classical music and western high culture, or the reverence and silence inherent in the old mass.

Also, in the actual text of [url="http://www.vatican.va/holy_father/benedict_xvi/motu_proprio/documents/hf_ben-xvi_motu-proprio_20070707_summorum-pontificum_lt.html"]Summorum Ponitficum[/url], the Holy Father tries to curtail the implication that the reasoning for allowing the extraordinary form of the mass is not to shut up a bunch of old whiners until they die off. He, in fact, states that the 1962 missal was never abrogated.

Posted

Also, if you wish to read more about the Holy Father's thinking behind the moto proprio in question, he wrote the following letter to be distributed with Summorum Ponitficum:

[url="http://www.vatican.va/holy_father/benedict_xvi/letters/2007/documents/hf_ben-xvi_let_20070707_lettera-vescovi_en.html"]Letter to the Bishops that accompanies the Apostolic Letter Motu Proprio data Summorum Pontificum (July 7, 2007)[/url]

Noel's angel
Posted

[quote name='adt6247' post='1320557' date='Jul 9 2007, 08:03 PM']Some of us traditionalists would take offense at that. I wasn't even born when the 1970 missal was promulgated. I attended my first Tridentine mass 3 years ago. Most of the people in traditional parishes and communities, in my experience are under 40 years old. We were raised in the modern church, sang bad music, were improperly catechized, lived most of our life doing things the way they're done at most parishes. We were attracted to the old mass for various reasons, whether the rampant liturgical abuses that happen in some diocese, or a love for classical music and western high culture, or the reverence and silence inherent in the old mass.

Also, in the actual text of [url="http://www.vatican.va/holy_father/benedict_xvi/motu_proprio/documents/hf_ben-xvi_motu-proprio_20070707_summorum-pontificum_lt.html"]Summorum Ponitficum[/url], the Holy Father tries to curtail the implication that the reasoning for allowing the extraordinary form of the mass is not to shut up a bunch of old whiners until they die off. He, in fact, states that the 1962 missal was never abrogated.[/quote]

"The grass is always greener on the other side" comes to mind...

LouisvilleFan
Posted (edited)

The funny thing is that many Protestants still admire Catholics for our reverence at Mass.

I'm curious: If done reverently, is there any problem with using modern music and instruments at Mass, or a mix, like cello and electric guitar? Seems to me that the problem isn't so much with the type of liturgy or music, but simply the bad taste of those who select it.

Edited by LouisvilleFan
Noel's angel
Posted

Don't quote me, but I believe electric guitar is outlawed. My personal (and humble) opinion is that the music is much more important than the instrument. If you can make beautiful music, suitable for prayer with a 'secular' instrument, then what's the problem? By that I'm not saying 'as long as it sounds pretty it's ok'. I believe if the music allows hearts to be drawn closer to God, then that's what counts. Sometimes I find myself getting very distracted by our traditional choir, especially at Easter because they have so many harmonies that my ear is drawn to that, rather than my heart being lead to God. Obviously a triangle or bongo drums etc. aren't conducive to prayer, so one wouldn't argue that any instrument may be used. The hymns should also be of sound theological value of course.

That's just my opinion, and I know some people will quote various documents to you. I could have done that too but I like to think for myself rather than cutting and pasting.

Laudate_Dominum
Posted

Simplicity can be seen as an age old virtue for liturgical music. St. Augustine forbade music entirely in his diocese for a time because he thought it distracted from the meaning of the words in the psalms being sung (yes, all music meaning singing as instruments weren't used and were not the issue). He later allowed simple forms a chant and mentions Bishop Athanasius (Saint Athanasios) as having been influential in changing his mind. The Eastern Churches have, to my knowledge, never allowed instruments and it was reluctantly that the Roman Church originally approved the organ as a liturgical instrument. There are numerous letters and interventions of Popes both ancient and modern that could be brought into this discussion but the only real point I want to make is not a juridical one but one of spirit.

Given the history involved and the spirit behind the letter on these matters I think that the most appropriate attitude toward such questions is a conservative one.

:idontknow:

Noel's angel
Posted (edited)
:thumbsup:
The man makes a good point.

Whether it was allowed reluctantly or not, we have the organ and other instruments, so we have to deal with the situation as it is, not necessarily how it might have been had a decision gone a different way.
It's a difficult one because music is very subjective. It has varying effects on people, so it's a difficult thing to judge. I'm just glad I'm not the one that has to make these sorts of decisions lol. Edited by Noel's angel
Laudate_Dominum
Posted

[quote name='Noel's angel' post='1321125' date='Jul 9 2007, 05:59 PM']Whether it was allowed reluctantly or not, we have the organ and other instruments, so we have to deal with the situation as it is, not necessarily how it might have been had a decision gone a different way.
It's a difficult one because music is very subjective. It has varying effects on people, so it's a difficult thing to judge. I'm just glad I'm not the one that has to make these sorts of decisions lol.[/quote]
lol, ditto! :lol:

Posted

[quote name='Laudate_Dominum' post='1321072' date='Jul 9 2007, 04:13 PM']Simplicity can be seen as an age old virtue for liturgical music. St. Augustine forbade music entirely in his diocese for a time because he thought it distracted from the meaning of the words in the psalms being sung (yes, all music meaning singing as instruments weren't used and were not the issue). He later allowed simple forms a chant and mentions Bishop Athanasius (Saint Athanasios) as having been influential in changing his mind. The Eastern Churches have, to my knowledge, never allowed instruments and it was reluctantly that the Roman Church originally approved the organ as a liturgical instrument. There are numerous letters and interventions of Popes both ancient and modern that could be brought into this discussion but the only real point I want to make is not a juridical one but one of spirit.

Given the history involved and the spirit behind the letter on these matters I think that the most appropriate attitude toward such questions is a conservative one.

:idontknow:[/quote]
Musical instruments are not allowed in the Eastern Churches. All chant (singing) is done without musical instruments.

Posted

[quote name='Noel's angel' post='1321125' date='Jul 9 2007, 06:59 PM']:thumbsup:
The man makes a good point.

Whether it was allowed reluctantly or not, we have the organ and other instruments, so we have to deal with the situation as it is, not necessarily how it might have been had a decision gone a different way.
It's a difficult one because music is very subjective. It has varying effects on people, so it's a difficult thing to judge. I'm just glad I'm not the one that has to make these sorts of decisions lol.[/quote]

As a musician, I must take issue with the idea that music is completely subjective. The real problem is that people are ignorant of music and are very confused on the issue as a result.

You see, music is a science and an art. For the longest time, popular music was only performed by scholastic professionals, people who studied under great masters and learned the techniques of other great masters. Bach, Beethoven, Mozart, etc.; these are examples of such professionals. The Church used to exclusively hire these professionals and others who have studied beneath them. A certain level of education was required to perform music for the Church, and the Church paid these professional a reasonable wage (relatively reasonable). Contemporary to these masters were other musicians of lesser degree -- local minstrels. These musicians performed their own uneducated derivations of music -- colloquial music -- for local pubs and festivals. Because these colloquial songs were written without any in-depth study of music, they usually exhibited a more immature expression. Today, we have elevated the minstrel and subjugated the master. The majority of music you hear today (and buy at the music store) is colloquial music -- music written and performed by uneducated musicians. Colloquial music is limited in what emotions it can communicate -- usually more shallow and immature emotions, such as happiness, haughtiness, anger, lust, infatuation, etc. The "masters" of today are employed exclusively by the rich and by Hollywood; John Williams, for example. Because music is mainly represented by uneducated artists, people have generally lost an understanding of how deep music can be.

The bottom line is that music is emotion communicated through sound. Each instrument has a certain range of characters -- personalities -- it can convey. To the Western ear, drums are generally violent instruments. They communicate confrontation. Even when they are played softly, they still communicate a more gentle level of confrontation (such as regret or depression -- self-directed confrontation). Each style of music further communicates certain emotions -- such as reverence, solice, aggression, abandonement, etc. A true musical artist can understand and anticipate what emotions his/her music will invoke in the listener. Sure, some people will have different opinions on what emotions they feel, but a good musician will already have taken those differences into account and insured that the majority of people will feel emotions appropriate to the venue. If you would like a good example of this, find a movie clip on YouTube.com that is missing the orchestral music behind it. You will find that the emotions you feel during the scene are rather weak. Watch the same scene with the background orchestral music, and you find your emotions hightened. Hollywood has understood this reality for decades and subsequently has hired masters to compose their movie scores. (You can find a similar experience with some unscored deleted/alternate scenes they include as extras in DVDs).

As well, culture is a big factor in a listener's interpretation of music. Drums invoke a completely different emotion in an African than they do to a native Californian. Some Western liberals will tell you that they have a multicultural attitude and can appreciate an African drum the same as an African would. They fool themselves, though. They may "attempt" to respond to the drum the same way, but it is an immature and unnatural response. Cultures are so much more different than that -- which is why they are so rich and beautiful of themselves. A native German citizen may learn to speak and read English, but the lyrics of the Stars Spangled Banner would never mean as much to them as it does to a lifelong citizen of the United States. Culture may not take long to appreciate, but it takes years, decades and sometimes a lifetime to experience. Because of this reality, drums will always be violent instruments to our Western ears, and therefore, completely inappropriate for the mass.

And this is what the Church understands -- the emotions that are conveyed by musical styles and musical instruments must be inline to the emotions that are appropriate for mass. The organ and polyphony generally create emotions of grandieur and mysticism. Chant generally creates emotions of ethereal being and unearthly essence. Guitars are generally fun and playful. This is why the Latin (Western) Church has preferred organ, polyphony, and chant and has frowned upon guitar at mass.

Laudate_Dominum
Posted

[quote name='Apotheoun' post='1321292' date='Jul 9 2007, 06:53 PM']Musical instruments are not allowed in the Eastern Churches. All chant (singing) is done without musical instruments.[/quote]
Thank you for the confirmation. I just wasn't sure if there may be some strange exception in the history of the Eastern Churches that I don't know about. :smokey:

Laudate_Dominum
Posted

[quote name='abercius24' post='1321518' date='Jul 9 2007, 08:32 PM']As a musician, I must take issue with the idea that music is completely subjective. The real problem is that people are ignorant of music and are very confused on the issue as a result.

You see, music is a science and an art. For the longest time, popular music was only performed by scholastic professionals, people who studied under great masters and learned the techniques of other great masters. Bach, Beethoven, Mozart, etc.; these are examples of such professionals. The Church used to exclusively hire these professionals and others who have studied beneath them. A certain level of education was required to perform music for the Church, and the Church paid these professional a reasonable wage (relatively reasonable). Contemporary to these masters were other musicians of lesser degree -- local minstrels. These musicians performed their own uneducated derivations of music -- colloquial music -- for local pubs and festivals. Because these colloquial songs were written without any in-depth study of music, they usually exhibited a more immature expression. Today, we have elevated the minstrel and subjugated the master. The majority of music you hear today (and buy at the music store) is colloquial music -- music written and performed by uneducated musicians. Colloquial music is limited in what emotions it can communicate -- usually more shallow and immature emotions, such as happiness, haughtiness, anger, lust, infatuation, etc. The "masters" of today are employed exclusively by the rich and by Hollywood; John Williams, for example. Because music is mainly represented by uneducated artists, people have generally lost an understanding of how deep music can be.

The bottom line is that music is emotion communicated through sound. Each instrument has a certain range of characters -- personalities -- it can convey. To the Western ear, drums are generally violent instruments. They communicate confrontation. Even when they are played softly, they still communicate a more gentle level of confrontation (such as regret or depression -- self-directed confrontation). Each style of music further communicates certain emotions -- such as reverence, solice, aggression, abandonement, etc. A true musical artist can understand and anticipate what emotions his/her music will invoke in the listener. Sure, some people will have different opinions on what emotions they feel, but a good musician will already have taken those differences into account and insured that the majority of people will feel emotions appropriate to the venue. If you would like a good example of this, find a movie clip on YouTube.com that is missing the orchestral music behind it. You will find that the emotions you feel during the scene are rather weak. Watch the same scene with the background orchestral music, and you find your emotions hightened. Hollywood has understood this reality for decades and subsequently has hired masters to compose their movie scores. (You can find a similar experience with some unscored deleted/alternate scenes they include as extras in DVDs).

As well, culture is a big factor in a listener's interpretation of music. Drums invoke a completely different emotion in an African than they do to a native Californian. Some Western liberals will tell you that they have a multicultural attitude and can appreciate an African drum the same as an African would. They fool themselves, though. They may "attempt" to respond to the drum the same way, but it is an immature and unnatural response. Cultures are so much more different than that -- which is why they are so rich and beautiful of themselves. A native German citizen may learn to speak and read English, but the lyrics of the Stars Spangled Banner would never mean as much to them as it does to a lifelong citizen of the United States. Culture may not take long to appreciate, but it takes years, decades and sometimes a lifetime to experience. Because of this reality, drums will always be violent instruments to our Western ears, and therefore, completely inappropriate for the mass.

And this is what the Church understands -- the emotions that are conveyed by musical styles and musical instruments must be inline to the emotions that are appropriate for mass. The organ and polyphony generally create emotions of grandieur and mysticism. Chant generally creates emotions of ethereal being and unearthly essence. Guitars are generally fun and playful. This is why the Latin (Western) Church has preferred organ, polyphony, and chant and has frowned upon guitar at mass.[/quote]
Awesome. Thanks! I wouldn't mind a thread devoted to this single topic.

Posted

[quote name='Laudate_Dominum' post='1321883' date='Jul 9 2007, 09:53 PM']Thank you for the confirmation. I just wasn't sure if there may be some strange exception in the history of the Eastern Churches that I don't know about. :smokey:[/quote]
well some exceptions..
i only write this for precision in understanding and knowledge...since the Eastern Church is generally only human voice,in music for Worship of God, the person being the BEST instrument for praise!...but,
actually in a Melkite Parish i was at, during the 'recessional' if you will, out came the Lebanese bongos, all was very joyful, clapping..at a Syrian Catholic Church (Patr. of Antioch)i visited in the Middle east they had also little drums and some kinda bells. [u]during [/u]certain parts.......and at the very ancient tradition Eritrean Orthodox Church in Toronto, [u]in the middle [/u]of the Divine Liturgy,,,,which lasted 5 hours that day..a little group of men and women came up front and sang some hymns in urdu, with a huge! drum,a wind instrument and simple folkish dancing.... AND... in many Coptic Orthodox Monasteries, like the ancient and still full p0f vocations,btw,St Macarius Monastery in Egypt , the monks Chant and have little ..kinda mini-cymbals, keeping time i suppose... and shocking and weird to me, but i say this is a American 'Latinization', was when His Beatitude Bartholomew? visited from Constantinople the Greek Orthodox Cathedral in Florida, guess what a, big pipe organ playing along with opening hymns etc...and keeping the tones..its on line to watch actually..
so it seems that its principally the Eastern Churches of Slavic Usage/Tradition that are always completely instrument free, while some middle and far east use some percussion, and even little flutes in parts.....
this of course is very relevant to culture, and since the Divine Liturgy of St John Chrysostom is the true charismatic Liturgy :P
-

Posted (edited)

[quote name='Laudate_Dominum' post='1321883' date='Jul 9 2007, 09:53 PM']Thank you for the confirmation. I just wasn't sure if there may be some strange exception in the history of the Eastern Churches that I don't know about. :smokey:[/quote]
well some exceptions..
i only write this for precision in understanding and knowledge...since the Eastern Church is generally only accapella,in music for Worship of God, the person being the BEST instrument for praise!...but,just to show a lack of rigidity..
actually in a Melkite Parish i was at, during the 'recessional' if you will, out came the Lebanese bongos, all was very joyful, clapping..at a Syrian Catholic Church (Patr. of Antioch)i visited in the Middle east they had also little drums and some kinda bells. [u]during [/u]certain parts.......and at the very ancient tradition Eritrean Orthodox Church in Toronto, [u]in the middle [/u]of the Divine Liturgy,,,,which lasted 5 hours that day..a little group of men and women came up front and sang some hymns in urdu, with a huge! drum,a wind instrument and simple folkish dancing.... AND... in many Coptic Orthodox Monasteries, like the ancient and still full p0f vocations,btw,St Macarius Monastery in Egypt , the monks Chant and have little ..kinda mini-cymbals, keeping time i suppose... and shocking and weird to me, but i say this is a American 'Latinization', was when His Beatitude Bartholomew? visited from Constantinople the Greek Orthodox Cathedral in Florida, guess what a, big pipe organ playing along with opening hymns etc...and keeping the tones..its on line to watch actually..yet this may actually have been beciuase it was a big event, and they feel Americans realte Organs to big Church events. hence this from one Greek Orthodox Church ;
-
"MUSICAL INSTRUMENTS IN THE CHURCH

"In her love and understanding, our Holy Orthodox Church has allowed for the use of the organ for the processional and recessional at weddings, as this is part of the American wedding traditions. No other instruments - can be used for weddings or any other Orthodox Sacrament or Service." (From Diocese of Chicago Encyclical of August 1, 1990.)
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
so it seems that its principally the Eastern Churches of Slavic Usage/Tradition that are always completely instrument free, while some middle and far east use some percussion, and even little flutes in parts.....yet granted the overall,principall is just for keeping time in rare far eastern traditions..and Accapella is the universal understanding..since Instrument of music have different 'sign values' or significations in different cultures.what may be profane or normally seen as an entertainment instrument in one culture, may be seen as an instrument only for Worship, folklore in another.
this of course is very relevant to culture, and since the Divine Liturgy of St John Chrysostom is the true charismatic Liturgy :P
-
[quote]The Use of the Instrument In Church History
By Ron Longwell
The fact that the Jewish people and the pagan religious people both used instruments as part of their worship makes the early church’s non-use of the instrument very unusual. We would have expected that they would have adopted the instrument from their Jewish or pagan roots. But that’s not what we find. The fact is that musical instruments were part of the religious fabric of that time. They were inexpensive, they were readily available, they were portable, and yet the early church chose not to use them. The early church ran against the religious culture of their time in not using musical instruments as part of their worship. We have Christian writers from those centuries who make it very clear that Christians did not use instruments of music in their worship. As a matter of fact, it would probably come as a surprise to many people, that Christians did not generally use instruments of music in their worship until the 9th and 10th centuries; that is, until the 800s or the 900s. It was a rare exception instead of something that was regularly practiced. This is why we call non-instrumental music acappella. Acappella means “according to the chapel” or “like the music of the chapel,” or “like the music of the church.” And that’s because historically, the music of the church was without instruments.

There is a quote from Eusebius in the early part of the 4th century (the early 300s) that merits attention at this point. Eusebius was a very well known church historian of that time who says this:


“when formerly the people of the circumcision [that is the Jews] were worshipping with symbols and types, it was not inappropriate to send up hymns to God with psaltries [which is a kind of instrument] and kithara [another kind of instrument]. . . . We render our hymn with a living psaltry and a living kithara, with spiritual songs. The unison voices of Christians would be more acceptable to God than any musical instrument.”[1]

In other words, Eusebius says that within the church, we no longer use those instruments, but praise God with our voices, which are living instruments. He goes on to say,

“Accordingly in all the churches of God, united in soul and attitude, with one mind and in agreement of faith and piety, we send up a unison melody in the words of the Psalms.”[2]

In the 9th and 10th centuries, use of instrumental music did become very popular in worship, but there was a major divide at this point between the Roman Catholic Church and the Eastern Orthodox Church. The Eastern Orthodox Churches, until this day, are the dominant group in the history of Christianity that do not use instruments of music in their worship.

There was a periodof time, then, from about the 10th century to the 15th century, where instruments of music dominated in one major group (Roman Catholocism), but then in another major group (the Eastern Orthodox Church), the acappella tradition was maintained.

The 15th century was the time of the Reformation. And in the time of the Reformation, there were many of the early reformers who spoke out against the use of instruments. Part of what they rejected about the Roman Catholicism out of which they came was the use of instruments. This is true of many of the reformed churches and the Anabaptist churches – those churches that would later become known to us best as Presbyterian churches and Baptist churches during this early period of time. For instance, John Calvin, who was outspoken on several occasions in his opposition to the use of instruments in worship, says this:

“Musical instruments in celebrating the praises of God would be no more suitable than the burning of incense, the lighting of lamps, and the restoration of other shadows of the law.”

Calvin, like Eusebius about a millennium before him, felt that instruments were appropriate in the age of the old worship in which the emphasis was more external, and not appropriate in the age of Christian worship.

These groups – Anabaptist groups and Reform groups – generally began to accept the instrument very widely in the 1700s and the 1800s. “The first organ accepted into a New England church was set up in King’s Chapel of Boston in 1714 (Church of England). The second was not installed until 1733 at Trinity Church in Newport, Rhode Island. As late as 1800, it is estimated that there were less than 20 organs in all of New England.”[3] Instrumental music in worship “came to be used in the nineteenth century only over much protest and at the end of heated debate.”[4] Of course, today, the acceptance of the use of instruments in most of the churches is very widespread. But in the perspective of 2,000 years of church history, acappella music has been the dominant position.

Today, of course, the primary protestant group that holds to acappella music is Churches of Christ. The other primary group, and the larger group, is the Eastern Orthodox churches."[/quote]

Edited by EJames
Posted

The Churches of the Byzantine tradition (including the Melkites, who were "byzantinized" several centuries ago) have always rejected the use of musical instruments during the divine liturgy.

Nevertheless, the effects of Latinization (on both Eastern Catholics and Eastern Orthodox) have brought instruments into use in many Byzantine Churches, and it has only been over the course of the last forty years that these "Western" intrustions have been slowly excised from Eastern Catholic Churches. The iconostasis itself was only restored in most Eastern Catholic Churches within the past twenty to thirty years. Moreover, the fact that a Greek Orthodox parish in the USA does something incorrectly is hardly shocking either, but the Greek Church's tradition rejects instruments of any kind, with the human voice alone singing praises to God. I know for a fact that my Orthodox friends would have a fit if they saw musical instruments being used during the divine liturgy.

Finally, I thank God that the process of de-Latinization continues in the Eastern Catholic Churches, and I look forward to the day when all the Eastern Churches will have fully reclaimed their spiritual, liturgical, and doctrinal traditions.

From the OCA website:

[quote][b]Musical Instruments[/b]

QUESTION:

I am a member of the Greek Archdiocese and I am wondering why musical instrument such as organs are not found in OCA Churches, or in Churches I visited in Greece or on Mt Athos? It seems Psalm 150 condones praising the Lord with stringed instruments.


ANSWER:

Actually, the tradition of the Orthodox Church is to have no musical instruments in the church. This is not unique to the OCA, as you experienced during your trip to Greece and Mt. Athos. The appearance of organs in Orthodox churches is, to my knowledge, pretty much limited to Greek and a few Antiochian Orthodox parishes in the US. I have never heard of organs or other musical instruments used elsewhere. Hence, the use of organs in some churches in the US is an innovation of recent origin. If I am not mistaken, His Eminence Archbishop Spyridon of the Greek Orthodox Archdiocese of America has addressed his concerns over the introduction of organs into the church's worship.

It is true that Psalm 150 condones praising the Lord with stringed instruments. This, however, never carried into Christian worship. One could say that there are many things one finds condoned in the Old Testament -- the sacrificing of animals, for example -- which were not carried over into the New Testament Church, in which Christ becomes the sacrificial lamb and the human voice becomes the musical instrument par excellance.[/quote]

Weblink: [url="http://www.oca.org/QA.asp?ID=88&SID=3"]Musical Instruments[/url]

Noel's angel
Posted

[quote name='abercius24' post='1321518' date='Jul 10 2007, 03:32 AM']As a musician, I must take issue with the idea that music is completely subjective. The real problem is that people are ignorant of music and are very confused on the issue as a result.

You see, music is a science and an art. For the longest time, popular music was only performed by scholastic professionals, people who studied under great masters and learned the techniques of other great masters. Bach, Beethoven, Mozart, etc.; these are examples of such professionals. The Church used to exclusively hire these professionals and others who have studied beneath them. A certain level of education was required to perform music for the Church, and the Church paid these professional a reasonable wage (relatively reasonable). Contemporary to these masters were other musicians of lesser degree -- local minstrels. These musicians performed their own uneducated derivations of music -- colloquial music -- for local pubs and festivals. Because these colloquial songs were written without any in-depth study of music, they usually exhibited a more immature expression. Today, we have elevated the minstrel and subjugated the master. The majority of music you hear today (and buy at the music store) is colloquial music -- music written and performed by uneducated musicians. Colloquial music is limited in what emotions it can communicate -- usually more shallow and immature emotions, such as happiness, haughtiness, anger, lust, infatuation, etc. The "masters" of today are employed exclusively by the rich and by Hollywood; John Williams, for example. Because music is mainly represented by uneducated artists, people have generally lost an understanding of how deep music can be.

The bottom line is that music is emotion communicated through sound. Each instrument has a certain range of characters -- personalities -- it can convey. To the Western ear, drums are generally violent instruments. They communicate confrontation. Even when they are played softly, they still communicate a more gentle level of confrontation (such as regret or depression -- self-directed confrontation). Each style of music further communicates certain emotions -- such as reverence, solice, aggression, abandonement, etc. A true musical artist can understand and anticipate what emotions his/her music will invoke in the listener. Sure, some people will have different opinions on what emotions they feel, but a good musician will already have taken those differences into account and insured that the majority of people will feel emotions appropriate to the venue. If you would like a good example of this, find a movie clip on YouTube.com that is missing the orchestral music behind it. You will find that the emotions you feel during the scene are rather weak. Watch the same scene with the background orchestral music, and you find your emotions hightened. Hollywood has understood this reality for decades and subsequently has hired masters to compose their movie scores. (You can find a similar experience with some unscored deleted/alternate scenes they include as extras in DVDs).

As well, culture is a big factor in a listener's interpretation of music. Drums invoke a completely different emotion in an African than they do to a native Californian. Some Western liberals will tell you that they have a multicultural attitude and can appreciate an African drum the same as an African would. They fool themselves, though. They may "attempt" to respond to the drum the same way, but it is an immature and unnatural response. Cultures are so much more different than that -- which is why they are so rich and beautiful of themselves. A native German citizen may learn to speak and read English, but the lyrics of the Stars Spangled Banner would never mean as much to them as it does to a lifelong citizen of the United States. Culture may not take long to appreciate, but it takes years, decades and sometimes a lifetime to experience. Because of this reality, drums will always be violent instruments to our Western ears, and therefore, completely inappropriate for the mass.

And this is what the Church understands -- the emotions that are conveyed by musical styles and musical instruments must be inline to the emotions that are appropriate for mass. The organ and polyphony generally create emotions of grandieur and mysticism. Chant generally creates emotions of ethereal being and unearthly essence. Guitars are generally fun and playful. This is why the Latin (Western) Church has preferred organ, polyphony, and chant and has frowned upon guitar at mass.[/quote]

I'm also a musician, and I didn't say music was completely subjective. If it was, I don't think it would have any place in the Liturgy. It is however QUITE subjective-just ask ten people what music they like and why they like it and you'll get very different answers. Good point about 'uneducated' musicians though. A lot of people who lead choirs don't have a clue what's appropriate and what's not.

Archaeology cat
Posted

[quote name='LouisvilleFan' post='1320957' date='Jul 9 2007, 10:34 PM']The funny thing is that many Protestants still admire Catholics for our reverence at Mass.[/quote]

Quite true. My brother (who is Methodist) remarks about how even just entering a Catholic church he can sense more reverence.


[quote name='LouisvilleFan' post='1320957' date='Jul 9 2007, 10:34 PM']I'm curious: If done reverently, is there any problem with using modern music and instruments at Mass, or a mix, like cello and electric guitar? Seems to me that the problem isn't so much with the type of liturgy or music, but simply the bad taste of those who select it.[/quote]

I'm not keen on electric guitar, but I do like classical guitar. I can be fairly flexible on music, as long as it's done well, and done reverently. I was visiting a parish with my in-laws one Sunday and the organ was in bad need of tuning. It made my ears hurt. Normally I like the organ (in part because I grew up with my dad playing it), but it has to be tuned and played properly!

Posted (edited)

[quote name='Noel's angel' post='1322190' date='Jul 10 2007, 07:25 AM']It is however QUITE subjective-just ask ten people what music they like and why they like it and you'll get very different answers.[/quote]

What someone would say they like would actually have little bearing on the matter. If you played a musical score outright for 10 people, you'd probably only get 2 or 3 who said they liked it. Put the music behind a dramatic scene in a movie, though, and you'll find 9 out of 10 responding just the way the composer and director wanted. It's about response, not appreciation. The average Westerner doesn't know music well enough to really understand how to listen to it. Most people listen for the tickle in the ear, which is a shallow response. A deep response to music is one of profound emotional movement, something the average Westerner would be too involved in to realize he/she was experiencing it, unless someone pointed it out to them. Musical scores to movies are an excellent parallel for the type of music that is appropriate for mass, too. Very rarely do people "listen" to the music of a movie score, but they certainly feel it. Music for the mass should be similarly subtle, but moving. It should leave the focus on the mass itself, but should magnify that focus.

Edited by abercius24
Archaeology cat
Posted

[quote name='abercius24' post='1322231' date='Jul 10 2007, 02:26 PM']What someone would say they like would actually have little bearing on the matter. If you played a musical score outright for 10 people, you'd probably only get 2 or 3 who said they liked it. Put the music behind a dramatic scene in a movie, though, and you'll find 9 out of 10 responding just the way the composer and director wanted. It's about response, not appreciation. The average Westerner doesn't know music well enough to really understand how to listen to it. Most people listen for the tickle in the ear, which is a shallow response. A deep response to music is one of profound emotional movement, something the average Westerner would be too involved in to realize he/she was experiencing it, unless someone pointed it out to them. Musical scores to movies are an excellent parallel for the type of music that is appropriate for mass, too. Very rarely do people "listen" to the music of a movie score, but they certainly feel it. Music for the mass should be similarly subtle, but moving. It should leave the focus on the mass itself, but should magnify that focus.[/quote]

Totally agree. I would never have been able to put into words quite as well as you did, so thank you. :) There have definitely been times where I haven't felt that the music reflected what was going on in the Mass, didn't create the right atmosphere, if you will. And then there have been other times that the music has exactly fit what was going on and I felt as though I could hear the angels and Saints joining in the Mass. I think the problems have been when the focus is on the music, instead of the Mass; when the music has complemented, and enhanced, the Mass is when the Mass has been such an extraordinary experience. Not sure I worded that well, but I hope my point got across.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...