adt6247 Posted July 10, 2007 Posted July 10, 2007 [quote name='LouisvilleFan' post='1320957' date='Jul 9 2007, 06:34 PM']I'm curious: If done reverently, is there any problem with using modern music and instruments at Mass, or a mix, like cello and electric guitar? Seems to me that the problem isn't so much with the type of liturgy or music, but simply the bad taste of those who select it.[/quote] It's not just old vs. new or based on purely on taste. It's the style of music that brings one to worship. I adore Verdi's Requiem, which is [i]technically[/i] a requiem mass setting, but it is thoroughly inappropriate for the liturgy. Electric and classical guitar, the way they are [b]normally[/b] used, are also inappropriate. Percussion is almost always inappropriate. The highest form of prayer is contemplation, and the liturgy of the church should guide one towards this goal. As such, using instrumentation and techniques that produce sharp attacks, abrupt movements, and dissonance should be used sparingly, if at all. Vatican II's [i]Sacrosanctum Concilium[/i] specified that the pride of place went to the pipe organ for liturgical music: [quote]120. In the Latin Church the pipe organ is to be held in high esteem, for it is the traditional musical instrument which adds a wonderful splendor to the Church's ceremonies and powerfully lifts up man's mind to God and to higher things.[/quote] The primary instrument for the liturgy should be the human voice, and any instrument should promote, underline, accentuate, and accompany that voice. Instruments that do this well are the organ, bowed stringed instruments, woodwinds, some brass. It's a much harder case for percussion, plucked stringed instruments, hammered instruments, etc. as they tend to have a much sharper attack, and it's much more difficult for them to highlight and harmonize with the vocals in an organic, reverent way. Finally, liturgical music should have an otherworldly quality to it. It should be sacred, as in, 'set apart' for worship. Our liturgical music should not sound like popular music. When one enters the nave of a church, and gazes upon the sanctuary, where the tabernacle sits on, behind, or near the altar of God, one should know that he is in a holy place. In the mass, heaven and earth meet, the priest, in the person of Christ, enters into the Holy of Holies, and and takes part of the sacrifice that happened 2000 years ago that opened the gates of heaven so that man might enter into God's eternal kingdom. The music should reflect this reality, regardless of which form of the mass is being celebrated. I'm not saying many modern instruments are de facto useless for liturgical worship. I'm merely stating that they are poor at attaining the goals of sacred music the way they are typically used. Who knows -- maybe [url="http://www.johnpetrucci.com/"]John Petrucci[/url] will some day write a mass setting for electric guitar that is worshipful, reverent, conducive to contemplation, otherworldly, and fully set apart for worship. I think it's unlikely, but do not doubt that God could make it so. [i]Introibo ad altare Dei; ad deum qui laetificat juventutem meam.[/i]
EJames Posted July 10, 2007 Posted July 10, 2007 (edited) [quote name='Apotheoun' post='1322009' date='Jul 9 2007, 10:38 PM']The Churches of the Byzantine tradition (including the Melkites, who were "byzantinized" several centuries ago) have always rejected the use of musical instruments during the divine liturgy. Nevertheless, the effects of Latinization (on both Eastern Catholics and Eastern Orthodox) have brought instruments into use in many Byzantine Churches, and it has only been over the course of the last forty years that these "Western" intrustions have been slowly excised from Eastern Catholic Churches. The iconostasis itself was only restored in most Eastern Catholic Churches within the past twenty to thirty years. Moreover, the fact that a Greek Orthodox parish in the USA does something incorrectly is hardly shocking either, but the Greek Church's tradition rejects instruments of any kind, with the human voice alone singing praises to God. I know for a fact that my Orthodox friends would have a fit if they saw musical instruments being used during the divine liturgy. Finally, I thank God that the process of de-Latinization continues in the Eastern Catholic Churches, and I look forward to the day when all the Eastern Churches will have fully reclaimed their spiritual, liturgical, and doctrinal traditions. From the OCA website: Weblink: [url="http://www.oca.org/QA.asp?ID=88&SID=3"]Musical Instruments[/url][/quote] Amen and O.K> to all you wrote,."I look forward to the day when all the Eastern Churches will have fully reclaimed their spiritual, liturgical, and doctrinal traditions." Amen, amen, amen.. i ws just sharing my experiences as opposed to official statements, to show it can exist, rightly or wrongly, as incorrect thing exist in the Latin Church as well... . it was just all the more surprising to me because the Patriarch of Constantinople was there, with the organs blazing...thats all....so it must be rather mainstream amongst Greeks i thought... i used to attended at St Elias Ukrainian Catholic in Brampton,Ontario(the most orthodox of catholics :0 ) for 2 years, where such a thing would have been impossible, unheard of... Pax P.S. the Monks at ST Macarius are as far away from anything Latin as you can get...but very hospitable amazing monks...whos Spiritual Father was Mathew The Poor, of Blessed memory.. Edited July 10, 2007 by EJames
LouisvilleFan Posted July 10, 2007 Posted July 10, 2007 [quote name='adt6247' post='1322302' date='Jul 10 2007, 11:12 AM']I'm not saying many modern instruments are de facto useless for liturgical worship. I'm merely stating that they are poor at attaining the goals of sacred music the way they are typically used. Who knows -- maybe [url="http://www.johnpetrucci.com/"]John Petrucci[/url] will some day write a mass setting for electric guitar that is worshipful, reverent, conducive to contemplation, otherworldly, and fully set apart for worship. I think it's unlikely, but do not doubt that God could make it so. [i]Introibo ad altare Dei; ad deum qui laetificat juventutem meam.[/i][/quote] I'm not a musician, but I know the Baptist church I used to attend has some songwriters who have done a really good job writing new hymns and adapting some well-known older hymns for modern instrumentation. A lot of it may just be amplification, but they produce the kind of "big" sound that suits the worship context. I've always thought it would sound pretty awesome in an old church building, and even though it could be entertainment in its own right (as all good music should be entertaining to those who can appreciate it), I really believe the kind of sound that calls our minds upward to heaven can be produced just as well with modern instruments as with the pipe organ... or a blend of both, for that matter.
Noel's angel Posted July 10, 2007 Posted July 10, 2007 The thing is, the music for Mass shouldn't really excite the senses too much. You shouldn't be half-way through the Consecration and still humming the entrance hymn to yourself. My point about music being subjective is that the majority of people who attend Mass are those 'ignorant Westerners' someone mentioned earlier. Singing is a wonderful way to pray, but if people don't like a melody, many of them won't sing. Fact. Yes, they may be uneducated when it comes to music, but that is what we have to deal with. Maybe it's the subjectiveness of people we should be discussing rather than the subjectivity of music.
adt6247 Posted July 10, 2007 Posted July 10, 2007 [quote name='Noel's angel' post='1322602' date='Jul 10 2007, 01:31 PM']The thing is, the music for Mass shouldn't really excite the senses too much. You shouldn't be half-way through the Consecration and still humming the entrance hymn to yourself. My point about music being subjective is that the majority of people who attend Mass are those 'ignorant Westerners' someone mentioned earlier. Singing is a wonderful way to pray, but if people don't like a melody, many of them won't sing. Fact. Yes, they may be uneducated when it comes to music, but that is what we have to deal with. Maybe it's the subjectiveness of people we should be discussing rather than the subjectivity of music.[/quote] I've yet to meet a single individual who has a well formed Catholic faith and does NOT enjoy hearing, if not reciting, the standard chants in the [i]Liber Usualis[/i]. Who, unless their hearts are hardened, wouldn't be moved by a solemn high mass set to Victoria's [i]Missa O Quam Gloriosum[/i] or Palestrina's [i]Missa Brevis[/i] or [i]Missa Pro Defunctis[/i]? I can see some differing in tastes in the later Renaissance and more modern pieces, but something as simple, beautiful, and ancient as Gregorian Chant or early renaissance polyphony? Or some of the eastern forms of chant? If a Catholic cannot enjoy such music, he should search his soul as to find out why.
Laudate_Dominum Posted July 10, 2007 Posted July 10, 2007 [quote name='adt6247' post='1322725' date='Jul 10 2007, 12:26 PM']I've yet to meet a single individual who has a well formed Catholic faith and does NOT enjoy hearing, if not reciting, the standard chants in the [i]Liber Usualis[/i]. Who, unless their hearts are hardened, wouldn't be moved by a solemn high mass set to Victoria's [i]Missa O Quam Gloriosum[/i] or Palestrina's [i]Missa Brevis[/i] or [i]Missa Pro Defunctis[/i]? I can see some differing in tastes in the later Renaissance and more modern pieces, but something as simple, beautiful, and ancient as Gregorian Chant or early renaissance polyphony? Or some of the eastern forms of chant? If a Catholic cannot enjoy such music, he should search his soul as to find out why.[/quote] I dig that post.
adt6247 Posted July 10, 2007 Posted July 10, 2007 [quote name='Noel's angel' post='1322602' date='Jul 10 2007, 01:31 PM']The thing is, the music for Mass shouldn't really excite the senses too much. You shouldn't be half-way through the Consecration and still humming the entrance hymn to yourself.[/quote] The music isn't merely for parts of the mass. The mass itself should be sung. The hymns should be chosen so that they are harmonious with the mass setting. In the old mass, the entrance hymn is pretty immediately followed by the Asperges (or Vidi Aquam during Easter), after which the Priest and his assistants recite the prayers at the foot of the altar and Confiteor quietly, while the choir chants the introit. This continues through the entire mass, except the canon, which is silent. The music, in and of itself, should not excite the senses alone. All the rich expressions of the mass (the music, the inscense, the bells, the choreography, the readings, the statues, the stained glass windows, etc.) should together elevate the senses towards contemplation at the mystery of the sacrifice, and orient the soul to ask for God's mercy, and take part in the joy only He brings.
Laudate_Dominum Posted July 10, 2007 Posted July 10, 2007 [quote name='adt6247' post='1322741' date='Jul 10 2007, 12:34 PM']The music isn't merely for parts of the mass. The mass itself should be sung. The hymns should be chosen so that they are harmonious with the mass setting. In the old mass, the entrance hymn is pretty immediately followed by the Asperges (or Vidi Aquam during Easter), after which the Priest and his assistants recite the prayers at the foot of the altar and Confiteor quietly, while the choir chants the introit. This continues through the entire mass, except the canon, which is silent. The music, in and of itself, should not excite the senses alone. All the rich expressions of the mass (the music, the inscense, the bells, the choreography, the readings, the statues, the stained glass windows, etc.) should together elevate the senses towards contemplation at the mystery of the sacrifice, and orient the soul to ask for God's mercy, and take part in the joy only He brings.[/quote] You're speaking to me.. Please, write a book in this thread.. I beg you..
Noel's angel Posted July 10, 2007 Posted July 10, 2007 [quote name='adt6247' post='1322725' date='Jul 10 2007, 07:26 PM']I've yet to meet a single individual who has a well formed Catholic faith and does NOT enjoy hearing, if not reciting, the standard chants in the [i]Liber Usualis[/i]. Who, unless their hearts are hardened, wouldn't be moved by a solemn high mass set to Victoria's [i]Missa O Quam Gloriosum[/i] or Palestrina's [i]Missa Brevis[/i] or [i]Missa Pro Defunctis[/i]? I can see some differing in tastes in the later Renaissance and more modern pieces, but something as simple, beautiful, and ancient as Gregorian Chant or early renaissance polyphony? Or some of the eastern forms of chant? If a Catholic cannot enjoy such music, he should search his soul as to find out why.[/quote] I didn't deny that. The thing is, you're talking about things that one doesn't find in the average Catholic parish (at least not here anyway) and I'm talking about what issues are generally facing us today in many parishes. Please, continue.
adt6247 Posted July 10, 2007 Posted July 10, 2007 [quote name='Noel's angel' post='1322761' date='Jul 10 2007, 02:43 PM']I didn't deny that. The thing is, you're talking about things that one doesn't find in the average Catholic parish (at least not here anyway) and I'm talking about what issues are generally facing us today in many parishes. Please, continue.[/quote] If these things aren't found in the average Catholic parish, should not the average Catholic parish change? I'm utterly realistic that it's incredibly difficult for the average church choir in every church in the land to pull off masses by Haydn and Durafle, but honestly, there's no reason that the propers can't be chanted at least at one mass every Sunday. If the [i]Liber[/i] is too complex, just using the psalm tones can be beautiful. Really, you only need one man to do it, and three to do it well. I'd say that chanting the propers in the psalm tones, as well as the commons in a simple setting, is within the reach of every Catholic parish. My parish choir is made up of 5 members that are decidedly amatures, my betrothed among them. They constantly feel that they do a poor job, but the parish loves the music. God doesn't require our perfection -- he just asks us to attempt perfection. (I should probably admit now that I have zero gift for music, but do find chanting easier than any other form of singing. I can follow others somewhat competently if I know the tune. I'd like to be able to read music, but even then, I have exceptionally poor relative pitch.) Quite frankly, it was reverence, chant, and a sense of Catholicity that drew me to the Tridentine liturgy.
Noel's angel Posted July 10, 2007 Posted July 10, 2007 I disagree with you on some points but I must say, you are a very intelligent and well-spoken individual. I admire you. In and ideal world, what you say would be wonderful, but people are tempermental and sometimes it's like treading on eggshells if you point out any negatives in a choir's music.
Laudate_Dominum Posted July 10, 2007 Posted July 10, 2007 [quote name='Noel's angel' post='1323155' date='Jul 10 2007, 03:26 PM']...but I must say, you are a very intelligent and well-spoken individual. I admire you...[/quote] I know right? Welcome to phatmass adt!! btw, thanks for keeping this fascinating discussion going. Awesome points! I'm inspired to study this subject further.
adt6247 Posted July 10, 2007 Posted July 10, 2007 [quote name='Noel's angel' post='1323155' date='Jul 10 2007, 05:26 PM']I disagree with you on some points but I must say, you are a very intelligent and well-spoken individual. I admire you. In and ideal world, what you say would be wonderful, but people are tempermental and sometimes it's like treading on eggshells if you point out any negatives in a choir's music.[/quote] So, you're saying that not hurting people's feelings is more important than promoting real Catholic worship? The reality of the sacrifice communicated by our rich liturgical tradition yields the power of conversion! Do you think the congregants get any spiritual benefit from singing "Gather Us In" after a homily where the priest tells everyone that God loves them just the way they are and there's no need for them to change? I think that the greatest tragedy in our church today is that priests and bishops are more concerned with filling pews and getting donations than they are with saving the souls of the people they are entrusted by God. The irony of the situation is if people were brought closer to Christ, they'd attend more frequently, and open their wallets. I lament that the word "pastoral" has come to mean "unchallenging".
Laudate_Dominum Posted July 10, 2007 Posted July 10, 2007 [quote name='adt6247' post='1323195' date='Jul 10 2007, 03:45 PM']So, you're saying that not hurting people's feelings is more important than promoting real Catholic worship? The reality of the sacrifice communicated by our rich liturgical tradition yields the power of conversion! Do you think the congregants get any spiritual benefit from singing "Gather Us In" after a homily where the priest tells everyone that God loves them just the way they are and there's no need for them to change? I think that the greatest tragedy in our church today is that priests and bishops are more concerned with filling pews and getting donations than they are with saving the souls of the people they are entrusted by God. The irony of the situation is if people were brought closer to Christ, they'd attend more frequently, and open their wallets. I lament that the word "pastoral" has come to mean "unchallenging".[/quote] He pulled the Schutte card, ouch!
adt6247 Posted July 10, 2007 Posted July 10, 2007 [quote name='Laudate_Dominum' post='1323194' date='Jul 10 2007, 05:45 PM']I know right? Welcome to phatmass adt!! [/quote] Thanks, friend. I have a feeling I'll be sticking around.
adt6247 Posted July 10, 2007 Posted July 10, 2007 [quote name='Noel's angel' post='1323155' date='Jul 10 2007, 05:26 PM']I disagree with you on some points but I must say, you are a very intelligent and well-spoken individual. I admire you. In and ideal world, what you say would be wonderful, but people are tempermental and sometimes it's like treading on eggshells if you point out any negatives in a choir's music.[/quote] I apologize if I come across as rude or dismissive. I'm a bit curt, direct, and sarcastic for my own good. I mean no disrespect; I honestly welcome your dialog. I honestly feel very humbled by some of the minds on this board. Laudate_Dominum just responded to me on another topic in a paragraph of Greek.
Noel's angel Posted July 10, 2007 Posted July 10, 2007 [quote name='adt6247' post='1323195' date='Jul 10 2007, 10:45 PM']So, you're saying that not hurting people's feelings is more important than promoting real Catholic worship? The reality of the sacrifice communicated by our rich liturgical tradition yields the power of conversion! Do you think the congregants get any spiritual benefit from singing "Gather Us In" after a homily where the priest tells everyone that God loves them just the way they are and there's no need for them to change? I think that the greatest tragedy in our church today is that priests and bishops are more concerned with filling pews and getting donations than they are with saving the souls of the people they are entrusted by God. The irony of the situation is if people were brought closer to Christ, they'd attend more frequently, and open their wallets. I lament that the word "pastoral" has come to mean "unchallenging".[/quote] No, that's not what I'm saying. But I am saying that it's the reality we are faced with. The traditional choir in our church are extremely tempermental. Once, our priest was unhappy with the offertory which was an unsuitable flute solo. They almost quit. Generally they are very good when it comes to selection of hymns, however the odd time they let vanity get in their way. I'm just trying to be realistic. I'm as against ridiciulous hymns such as 'Table of Plenty' (I've never heard 'Gather Us In') as you are. I'm just saying that this is what happens. It's not what I like but it happens. I do not wish to argue with you. It just seems that everything I say, you take it as my personal opinion when I'm actually saying that it's reality.
adt6247 Posted July 10, 2007 Posted July 10, 2007 [quote name='Noel's angel' post='1323201' date='Jul 10 2007, 05:53 PM']I do not wish to argue with you. It just seems that everything I say, you take it as my personal opinion when I'm actually saying that it's reality.[/quote] No, I state that we are to fight against this reality. Just because this is the state we are in now does not mean it cannot change. We are against the world. We should fight to bring about the Kingdom of Heaven on earth. We must hold Heaven as our ideal, even though we live in the world. Christ came not to bring peace, but the sword! We are to live in this world, but not of it. In fact, this world is against us. I'm sympathetic to the way you look at things, but I choose to be more hopeful. I quite honestly want to spread hope. Perhaps my writing style doesn't lend itself to this.
Noel's angel Posted July 10, 2007 Posted July 10, 2007 [quote name='adt6247' post='1323215' date='Jul 10 2007, 11:01 PM']No, I state that we are to fight against this reality. Just because this is the state we are in now does not mean it cannot change. We are against the world. We should fight to bring about the Kingdom of Heaven on earth. We must hold Heaven as our ideal, even though we live in the world. Christ came not to bring peace, but the sword! We are to live in this world, but not of it. In fact, this world is against us. I'm sympathetic to the way you look at things, but I choose to be more hopeful. I quite honestly want to spread hope. Perhaps my writing style doesn't lend itself to this.[/quote] You're right. Things should change and must change. Maybe I'm being pessimistic but I'm just reflecting the attitude of many people I have met.
adt6247 Posted July 11, 2007 Posted July 11, 2007 [quote name='Noel's angel' post='1323222' date='Jul 10 2007, 06:06 PM']You're right. Things should change and must change. Maybe I'm being pessimistic but I'm just reflecting the attitude of many people I have met.[/quote] The church's weakest point is that it is made up of people like us -- i.e., imperfect sinners. Sometimes, I forget that rather than getting confrontational and indignant about the problems in the church, maybe I should just shut up, fast, and pray.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now