Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Noel's angel
Posted

It's good that you get mad, it shows you care :)

Posted (edited)

[quote name='adt6247' post='1322302' date='Jul 10 2007, 10:12 AM']It's not just old vs. new or based on purely on taste. It's the style of music that brings one to worship. I adore Verdi's Requiem, which is [i]technically[/i] a requiem mass setting, but it is thoroughly inappropriate for the liturgy. Electric and classical guitar, the way they are [b]normally[/b] used, are also inappropriate. Percussion is almost always inappropriate.

The highest form of prayer is contemplation, and the liturgy of the church should guide one towards this goal. As such, using instrumentation and techniques that produce sharp attacks, abrupt movements, and dissonance should be used sparingly, if at all. Vatican II's [i]Sacrosanctum Concilium[/i] specified that the pride of place went to the pipe organ for liturgical music:
The primary instrument for the liturgy should be the human voice, and any instrument should promote, underline, accentuate, and accompany that voice. Instruments that do this well are the organ, bowed stringed instruments, woodwinds, some brass. It's a much harder case for percussion, plucked stringed instruments, hammered instruments, etc. as they tend to have a much sharper attack, and it's much more difficult for them to highlight and harmonize with the vocals in an organic, reverent way.

Finally, liturgical music should have an otherworldly quality to it. It should be sacred, as in, 'set apart' for worship. Our liturgical music should not sound like popular music. When one enters the nave of a church, and gazes upon the sanctuary, where the tabernacle sits on, behind, or near the altar of God, one should know that he is in a holy place. In the mass, heaven and earth meet, the priest, in the person of Christ, enters into the Holy of Holies, and and takes part of the sacrifice that happened 2000 years ago that opened the gates of heaven so that man might enter into God's eternal kingdom. The music should reflect this reality, regardless of which form of the mass is being celebrated.

I'm not saying many modern instruments are de facto useless for liturgical worship. I'm merely stating that they are poor at attaining the goals of sacred music the way they are typically used. Who knows -- maybe [url="http://www.johnpetrucci.com/"]John Petrucci[/url] will some day write a mass setting for electric guitar that is worshipful, reverent, conducive to contemplation, otherworldly, and fully set apart for worship. I think it's unlikely, but do not doubt that God could make it so.

[i]Introibo ad altare Dei; ad deum qui laetificat juventutem meam.[/i][/quote]

Amen to everything here. That's exactly what I'm trying to communicate.


[quote name='Noel's angel' post='1323201' date='Jul 10 2007, 04:53 PM']No, that's not what I'm saying. But I am saying that it's the reality we are faced with. The traditional choir in our church are extremely tempermental. Once, our priest was unhappy with the offertory which was an unsuitable flute solo. They almost quit. Generally they are very good when it comes to selection of hymns, however the odd time they let vanity get in their way. I'm just trying to be realistic. I'm as against ridiciulous hymns such as 'Table of Plenty' (I've never heard 'Gather Us In') as you are. I'm just saying that this is what happens. It's not what I like but it happens.

I do not wish to argue with you. It just seems that everything I say, you take it as my personal opinion when I'm actually saying that it's reality.[/quote]

Your traditional choir wanted to quit for one reason -- they are volunteers and not hired professionals. If you pay them, then they would feel more obligated to provide their employer what has been requested of them. Nothing is free. A free choir is an arrogant choir. A professional would not quit so easily because: 1. The money is nice to get; 2. They've already worked jobs similar in difficulty and have already developed a sense of flexibility (something a musician must have) 3. Such an action would inherently be unprofessional -- "the show must go on" is still a primary value to professional musicians.

Edited by abercius24
Posted

[quote name='adt6247' post='1322302' date='Jul 10 2007, 10:12 AM']The primary instrument for the liturgy should be the human voice, and any instrument should promote, underline, accentuate, and accompany that voice. [i]Introibo ad altare Dei; ad deum qui laetificat juventutem meam.[/i][/quote]

I just want to reiterate that this is an excellent focal point when choosing instruments. In fact, I will be adopting this idea from now on.

[quote name='Noel's angel' post='1322602' date='Jul 10 2007, 12:31 PM']The thing is, the music for Mass shouldn't really excite the senses too much. You shouldn't be half-way through the Consecration and still humming the entrance hymn to yourself.

My point about music being subjective is that the majority of people who attend Mass are those 'ignorant Westerners' someone mentioned earlier. Singing is a wonderful way to pray, but if people don't like a melody, many of them won't sing. Fact. Yes, they may be uneducated when it comes to music, but that is what we have to deal with. Maybe it's the subjectiveness of people we should be discussing rather than the subjectivity of music.[/quote]

I guess I'm being a bit too rhetorical for my own point when I say "ignorant". I believe the average Westerner has been culturally acclimated to the type of music that would be appropriate for mass. I mean "ignorant" in that they are not aware of this acclimation. Anyone who has watched our Western movies all their lives (Western not as in gunslinger, but the opposite of Eastern movies, like Hong Kong and Baliwood cinema) unknowingly understands the value of subtle, emotion-invoking music -- the prime essence of good movie scores. I believe they are ready for this music, but they need to put their preconceived ideas aside and be willing to feel music on a much deeper level.

Noel's angel
Posted

[quote name='abercius24' post='1324450' date='Jul 11 2007, 07:51 PM']Amen to everything here. That's exactly what I'm trying to communicate.
Your traditional choir wanted to quit for one reason -- they are volunteers and not hired professionals. If you pay them, then they would feel more obligated to provide their employer what has been requested of them. Nothing is free. A free choir is an arrogant choir. A professional would not quit so easily because: 1. The money is nice to get; 2. They've already worked jobs similar in difficulty and have already developed a sense of flexibility (something a musician must have) 3. Such an action would inherently be unprofessional -- "the show must go on" is still a primary value to professional musicians.[/quote]


Incorrect. Our organist is paid well and he shows up when he feels like it.

Laudate_Dominum
Posted

I just got a phaaat email from the organist at the parish I attended in Maine.. Wow.. I might post parts of it after consulting someone about it (I don't want to post from it if the author prefers I don't).

Laudate_Dominum
Posted

Something interesting I read yesterday was talking about how even if the Pope mandated an extraordinary form Mass at least once a month at all parishes (which he isn't going to do but for the sake of the point let's pretend), you wouldn't see that happening because there are tons of things that Rome has called for that never happen because the local Bishops and/or pastors ignore it.

I think it's funny that when the Church calls for something it is so often ignored but when the Church allows some questionable novelty (EM's, altar girls, communion on the hand, or whatever) you see it implemented on a level far beyond what was approved.

It reminded me of a few years ago when a buddy of mine approached the liturgist in charge of the Masses at Franciscan University (at that time) with a bunch of Church documents (mostly recent things from Pope John Paul II and the SCDWDS), many things that are common to the Masses their were clearly forbidden, discouraged or conditional. The response from this liturgist was, "the Bishop allows it".

Ok, so let's excuse or even encourage dissent and disobedience from our Bishops. But of course I doubt they actually invite the Bishop over to get approval for all the stuff they do. Give me a break. Maybe, just maybe they did get approval for some things in the past (let's say 1979--yes, I will pretend that the "last supper" masses celebrated on picnic tables with baskets of rolls were approved), but you would think that at the very least these documents of the Church (most of them from the 1990's or later) would encourage them to double check things with the Bishop and ask specifically about these directives. The reason this particular case is so scandalous to me is because this school forms young eager Catholics who do actually go out to their parishes and head up "liturgical ministries" and Catholic education programs. It is sad to me that most will likely come away from that school with the impression that "this" is Catholic orthodoxy; "this" is the fullest and most magisterially faithful way to be Catholic.

If we were still living in the 1970's and 80's I wouldn't be quite as upset, I mean they probably didn't know better back then, but there has just been too much direction and clarification given by the Church on these matters to excuse the 1970's style worship on that campus.

photosynthesis
Posted

I recently went to their Young Adult conference and it was amazing to see how much Catholic culture has permeated Steubenville culture. I still can't get over the fact that every residence hall has a chapel with Jesus in the Blessed Sacrament. But as far as music, architecture and religious art are concerned, the place is an aesthetic atrocity. Every day, the Franciscan priests would celebrate Mass in front of this weird modern art piece that looked like a globe with a cardboard dove flying out of it, and the altar cloths looked like they could double as bedsheets. Hopefully in a few years they'll have enough money to build a new church and hire a decent music director.

Laudate_Dominum
Posted

[quote name='photosynthesis' post='1324588' date='Jul 11 2007, 03:38 PM']I recently went to their Young Adult conference and it was amazing to see how much Catholic culture has permeated Steubenville culture. I still can't get over the fact that every residence hall has a chapel with Jesus in the Blessed Sacrament. But as far as music, architecture and religious art are concerned, the place is an aesthetic atrocity. Every day, the Franciscan priests would celebrate Mass in front of this weird modern art piece that looked like a globe with a cardboard dove flying out of it, and the altar cloths looked like they could double as bedsheets. Hopefully in a few years they'll have enough money to build a new church and hire a decent music director.[/quote]
Yeah, that's what's so strange about FUS to me; it is such a mix of amazing and good things with strange things that just seem out of place. You can walk down the hall of a dorm and see students coming out of an adoration chapel with total devotion and then hear horrid secular music coming from someone's room and see immodesty and nasty TV shows in the common room. I guess the Church on Earth has always had weeds and wheat.

They like to describe the spirit of the university as “dynamic orthodoxy”, but I’ve yet to really figure out what that means. Are periodic concessions to secular culture and do-it-yourself Masses a part of this? There are common heresies too. The one that was taught in class on a couple of occasions and that I was forced to debate with students more than anything was the heterodox view which says that the married state is equal to consecrated religious life. I still can’t believe how often I heard that. Once a Carmelite nun was giving a talk about being a Carmelite and some girl presumed to lecture her by saying, “but we’re all brides of Christ, you don’t have to be a nun to be a bride of Christ”. Besides the rudeness factor of this, it showed a total disregard for what this venerable nun was actually saying. But my favorite must be this:

[i]“Me: The Church teaches that consecrated life is an objectively higher calling.. etc., etc.”
“Person: Nuh-uh, John Paul II teaches that marriage and religious life are equal”
.. Some further discussion involving obstinate heresy…
“Me: According to Catholic Mystical Theology the monastic life is most well suited for the ascent of the mystical ladder.”
“Person: Well the Theology of the Body says that sex is the highest and most mystical experience.”[/i]

Such silly and somewhat disturbing conversations were a normal experience for me when at FUS. Oh, and of course the ever recurring slogan of modernity, "you can't judge". Dun dun dun...

LouisvilleFan
Posted (edited)

So is Franciscan really supposed to be one of the "best" Catholic universities in the country? (in terms of theological teaching and moral practices) That seems to be the impression I've received in the past, like if you're orthodox you go to Franciscan or Ave Maria... maybe Notre Dame. I'm over and done with college, so it's not something I've bothered to research on my own. All I know is Notre Dame is the only one of those with a sports program that anyone's ever heard of.

I think if you're gonna deal with those issues at a private school, why not just save yourself a ton of money and find a public university with a good Newman Center. :)

Edited by LouisvilleFan
Laudate_Dominum
Posted

[quote name='LouisvilleFan' post='1324662' date='Jul 11 2007, 04:51 PM']So is Franciscan really supposed to be one of the "best" Catholic universities in the country? (in terms of theological teaching and moral practices)

If you're gonna deal with all that at a private school, why not just save yourself a ton of money and find a public university with a good Newman Center. :)[/quote]
There is much more to Franciscan than that. It is without a doubt one of the best Catholic schools in this country, it's just not perfect. I'm sure all of the schools have their problems and at least at Franciscan those problems are not overt dissent, anti-Catholicism or immorality.
I would want my kids to go to Franciscan before any public university.

Posted (edited)

[quote name='Noel's angel' post='1324529' date='Jul 11 2007, 03:46 PM']Incorrect. Our organist is paid well and he shows up when he feels like it.[/quote]

Let me rephrase that. If you pay a professional choir, and not a few amatuer singers. As for your organist, I think its time to hire a new one. Organist are pretty versitile, and they come a dime a dozen.

Edited by abercius24
Noel's angel
Posted

Not here they don't. We had one who had to retire a while ago. The new one is a music teacher and the only one we can get. It's not easy finding organists in rural North Antrim.

Posted

[quote name='LouisvilleFan' post='1324662' date='Jul 11 2007, 06:51 PM']So is Franciscan really supposed to be one of the "best" Catholic universities in the country? (in terms of theological teaching and moral practices) That seems to be the impression I've received in the past, like if you're orthodox you go to Franciscan or Ave Maria... maybe Notre Dame. I'm over and done with college, so it's not something I've bothered to research on my own. All I know is Notre Dame is the only one of those with a sports program that anyone's ever heard of.[/quote]
Franciscan is better than most, Ave Maria is a mixed bag, mostly because of lack of stability. There's also Thomas Aquinas, but only if you're interested in a great books education, and staying in LA diocese. There's also Christendom College in Front Royal, VA.

Notre Dame is a joke -- they have Fr. Richard McBrien on the payroll, among other heretics.

Posted

[quote name='Noel's angel' post='1325608' date='Jul 12 2007, 09:17 AM']Not here they don't. We had one who had to retire a while ago. The new one is a music teacher and the only one we can get. It's not easy finding organists in rural North Antrim.[/quote]

I forget how many nations other than the U.S. post on this website. I apologize. I cannot speak for the population of organists in Ireland.

Noel's angel
Posted

lol. No worries. My town is pretty much the only Catholic town around here. And it's quite small so organsist are hard to come by.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...