Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

What makes techno music so satanic?  

45 members have voted

You do not have permission to vote in this poll, or see the poll results. Please sign in or register to vote in this poll.

Recommended Posts

Posted

[quote name='T-Bone _' post='1385125' date='Sep 13 2007, 08:36 PM'](And is anyone else just a wee bit suspicious of tetso987?)[/quote]
Since that was tetso987's first post and they are both Ukrainian Catholic....just a wee bit. :mellow:

rollingcatholic
Posted

I really wish I'd known about this before I started listening to techno music...

Posted (edited)

deleted by poster for reasons of repentance and complete unhelpfulness!

Edited by beatty07
Posted

[quote name='tetso987' post='1385099' date='Sep 13 2007, 08:58 PM']I understand where Monoxides is comming from, resently one of my friends liked to listen to Techno music, he is now addicted to meth and other typs of recreational drugs.

It is good you are warning people of its nature and intent. For that I thank you.
If only you would of told us earlier, you would of helped many ignorant people.[/quote]
So by your logic, does U2 cause people to lose strands of hair?

Posted

[quote name='RC _' post='1385790' date='Sep 15 2007, 12:57 AM']I really wish I'd known about this before I started listening to techno music...[/quote]

:lol_pound:

Posted

Music tecno is not satanic, only is is a music excrement.
I prefer classic music and heavy metal.

Posted

Heh, friends appear out of no-where. Maybe it is divine intention?

I am sensing a degeneration toward the ad-hominem, why do you resort to such weakness in your arguments? Resorting ridicule where it is not needed nor desired makes you seem almost bigoted. Honestly, it tells worlds about your character - are you lashing out because you feel a personal affront? Try connecting the sin in your life to your music habits. I am curious as to what you discover. Be objective. Keep your trousers on.

-monoxide

Posted

[quote name='Monoxide' post='1388744' date='Sep 19 2007, 02:43 PM']Heh, friends appear out of no-where. Maybe it is divine intention?

I am sensing a degeneration toward the ad-hominem, why do you resort to such weakness in your arguments? Resorting ridicule where it is not needed nor desired makes you seem almost bigoted. Honestly, it tells worlds about your character - are you lashing out because you feel a personal affront? Try connecting the sin in your life to your music habits. I am curious as to what you discover. Be objective. Keep your trousers on.

-monoxide[/quote]

This guy is talking about ad hominem and seeming bigoted?

:mellow:

I'm beyond laughing now.

Posted

Monoxide remembers me to my evangelical friend, this said me that I go to hell to listen to heavy metal.

Posted (edited)

Why is it that people refuse to see that a form of art used within an evil culture does not necessarily make the art evil? Look at the naked sculptures of the Roman artists and those of Michaelangelo. Very similar, right? Does that mean the Catholic Church is as hedonistic and idolatrous as the Romans because it holds the greatest collection of Michaelangelo sculptures? Of course not. But just because the rave culture has adopted Techno as its choice music, we have to assume that the evils of the Rave culture also relate to Techno music? Is Jazz music now evil, too, given that the homosexual counter-culture has chosen that style as its main preference? If we're gonna use catchy Latin phrases to describe bogus arguments, how about this one: non sequitur. That logic simply does not follow!

Edited by abercius24
Archaeology cat
Posted

[quote name='abercius24' post='1388960' date='Sep 20 2007, 08:34 AM']Why is it that people refuse to see that a form of art used within an evil culture does not necessarily make the art evil? Look at the naked sculptures of the Roman artists and those of Michaelangelo. Very similar, right? Does that mean the Catholic Church is as hedonistic and idolatrous as the Romans because it holds the greatest collection of Michaelangelo sculptures? Of course not. But just because the rave culture has adopted Techno as its choice music, we have to assume that the evils of the Rave culture also relate to Techno music? Is Jazz music now evil, too, given that the homosexual counter-culture has chosen that style as its main preference? If we're gonna use catchy Latin phrases to describe bogus arguments, how about this one: non sequitur. That logic simply does not follow![/quote]

Wow, you pretty much summed up what my husband & I had been talking about. Good thing I don't have to give up listening to jazz - I like Herbie Hancock too much. :)

Posted

[quote name='Monoxide' post='1388744' date='Sep 19 2007, 05:43 PM']Heh, friends appear out of no-where. Maybe it is divine intention?

I am sensing a degeneration toward the ad-hominem, why do you resort to such weakness in your arguments? Resorting ridicule where it is not needed nor desired makes you seem almost bigoted. Honestly, it tells worlds about your character - are you lashing out because you feel a personal affront? Try connecting the sin in your life to your music habits. I am curious as to what you discover. Be objective. Keep your trousers on.

-monoxide[/quote]

Multiple Accounts
Multiple accounts are prohibited. Creation of an account to bypass a suspension may result in a deletion of all accounts.

Posted (edited)

[quote name='cmotherofpirl' post='1389142' date='Sep 20 2007, 01:54 PM']Multiple Accounts
Multiple accounts are prohibited. Creation of an account to bypass a suspension may result in a deletion of all accounts.[/quote]

Wow, that's a new technique in an attempt to win an argument: set up a new account to agree with yourself. That's really pathetic. Thank you for catching him/her on this.

Edited by abercius24
Posted

Unfortunatly you are incorrect in your analysis - I do not run multiple accounts. If that is the only counter that you have to what I declare, then you fail. qed.

IcePrincessKRS
Posted

[quote name='Monoxide' post='1389685' date='Sep 21 2007, 02:23 AM']Unfortunatly you are incorrect in your analysis - I do not run multiple accounts. If that is the only counter that you have to what I declare, then you fail. qed.[/quote]

You have been given plenty of arguments which you ignore entirely.

Cmom's post is perfectly legitimate. There's this nifty little fingerprint called an IP address. 1+1=2.

Posted

[quote name='Monoxide' post='1389685' date='Sep 21 2007, 12:23 AM']Unfortunatly you are incorrect in your analysis - I do not run multiple accounts. If that is the only counter that you have to what I declare, then you fail. qed.[/quote]

The thing is all you do is declare. You don't back anything up with either facts or logic.

Posted

[quote name='Monoxide' post='1388744' date='Sep 19 2007, 02:43 PM']Try connecting the sin in your life to your music habits. I am curious as to what you discover. Be objective. Keep your trousers on.

-monoxide[/quote]


Let's see......I listen to a lot of rock music (Linkin Park, Modest Mouse, Bowling for Soup, and that such). And what am I doing today...going to my youthgroup's GiveUP (Give Unlimited Praise!! its a day where we just sing christian songs). Ok I can still see how lyrics in songs can pursuade people. A bunch of Linkin Park songs have a lot of songs that talk about hate and stuff. Yes i listen to LP because i can relate to the lyrics. But i use it to help me. by the time im done listening to those songs....i am relieved. i feel a lot better. its like listening to Christian music......but in another way...im sorry i dont think this makes sense...its just my response for a 7 page long debate..

Archaeology cat
Posted

[quote name='theaznguy' post='1389813' date='Sep 21 2007, 04:28 PM']Let's see......I listen to a lot of rock music (Linkin Park, Modest Mouse, Bowling for Soup, and that such). And what am I doing today...going to my youthgroup's GiveUP (Give Unlimited Praise!! its a day where we just sing christian songs). Ok I can still see how lyrics in songs can pursuade people. A bunch of Linkin Park songs have a lot of songs that talk about hate and stuff. Yes i listen to LP because i can relate to the lyrics. But i use it to help me. by the time im done listening to those songs....i am relieved. i feel a lot better. its like listening to Christian music......but in another way...im sorry i dont think this makes sense...its just my response for a 7 page long debate..[/quote]

For what it's worth, your post makes sense to me. Some of the songs I listen to are when I'm feeling frustrated or down or whatever and need a release.

Posted

[quote name='Monoxide' post='1389685' date='Sep 21 2007, 03:23 AM']Unfortunatly you are incorrect in your analysis - I do not run multiple accounts. If that is the only counter that you have to what I declare, then you fail. qed.[/quote]
You have stated your personal opinion. You haven't come up with a single fact to back it up. Nada. None. So your personal opinion carries no more weight than anyone elses.
It is simply your feeling on the topic.

Do I listen to techno? Yes.
But I also listen to classical [ brahms and bach come immediately to mind], jazz, blues, new age, country, rock, oldies from the 50s to 70s, big band era stuff, chant, emo-punk, CATHOLIC hip hop, celtic -traditional and modern, drums and bagpipes, and snippets of opera.
Occasionally I throw in reggae, latin or african for variety. THe only thing I avoid is heavy metal, its too grating for my ears.

Most people, except the very young, listen to a variety of music.

Posted

[quote name='Monoxide' post='1389685' date='Sep 21 2007, 03:23 AM']Unfortunatly you are incorrect in your analysis - I do not run multiple accounts. If that is the only counter that you have to what I declare, then you fail. qed.[/quote]
You're using the fallacist's fallacy. You claim that because one irrelevant claim is fallacious, you win the argument. That is false.

You have yet to provide any authoritative or logical set of proofs to back your position. You have instead claimed repeatedly that everyone is wrong, you're right, and everyone against you needs to reform their sinful behavior and thoughts, and resorted to ad hominem. Your sole argument is based on personal experience, yet you reject everyone else's personal experience. How is this equitable?

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...