Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Vatican Ii? I Am A Little Confused?


Recommended Posts

exquisitebones
Posted

Hey Guys! Its been a while since I have been around the PM. but anyway, my RCIA classes just started and I am all amped, and I have been doing a bunch of reading..

and in that reading, I am having a hard time Understanding "vatican2"
I have been reading, and it seems to me that the bare bones is the church changed to please the major public?
that seems incredibly strange to me??
I guess what I am not understanding is how they can just go change all the "written rules" or what havee you to suit their needs?

I am NOT trying to start a debate, just looking for some better insight I guess?

Posted

I would recommend you read the documents, and move this question to the Q&A section.

Posted

There is no need to move this to the QA, its just a matter of asking specific questions to get an answer that will help.

[quote]I have been reading, and it seems to me that the bare bones is the church changed to please the major public?[/quote]

Im a convert also, I read the V2 docs before my conversion, I never got the opinion that they changed the bare bones of the church. This is likely something that someone told you, considering you have not read the docs. Right?

[quote]I guess what I am not understanding is how they can just go change all the "written rules" or what havee you to suit their needs?[/quote]

If you want to explain a specific example, or even topic that would help with the issue. Like everyone else here, I recommend you read the doc. Here is a list that would help for topics. If you need help finding them let me know


[quote]Documents 4 Constitutions:
Dei Verbum (Dogmatic Constitution on Divine Revelation)
Lumen Gentium (Dogmatic Constitution on the Church)
Gaudium et Spes (Pastoral Constitution on the Church in the Modern World)
Sacrosanctum Concilium (Constitution on the Sacred Liturgy)
9 decrees:

Ad Gentes (Mission Activity)
Apostolicam Actuositatem (Lay People)
Christus Dominus (Bishops in the Church)
Inter Mirifica (Social Communication)
Optatam Totius (Priestly Training)
Orientalium Ecclesiarum (Eastern Churches)
Perfectæ Caritatis (Renewal of Religious Life)
Presbyterorum Ordinis (Life of Priests)
Unitatis Redintegratio (Ecumenism)
3 declarations:

Dignitatis Humanæ (Religious Freedom)
Gravissimum Educationis (Christian Education)
Nostra Ætate (Relations with Non-Christians)[/quote]

From there we can talk about specifics. The catholic faith, being a living tradition builds on the testimony of her history. It is fundamentally impossible to "change the bones" of the church.

Laudate_Dominum
Posted

There are certainly complex discussions that could be had on particular matters, but as a general reply I must note that the idea of Vatican II that you put forth is reminiscent of the illegitimate hi-jack mentality that is often spread by wannabe revolutionaries in the Church. The Popes have made it clear that understanding or interpreting the Council as a break or rupture with tradition and past teaching is a complete falsification of the Council itself.

The Council is neither an end nor a new beginning; it is rather a moment of development and insight that must necessarily be received in continuity and harmony with the totality of authoritative Catholic teachings and orthodox theology. Those who promote the attitude that Vatican II has somehow rendered the Church's past "irrelevant" are, quite frankly, wolves in sheep’s clothing – Ok, at the very least they are misinformed and their understanding of Catholicism is contradictory and seriously flawed. This is not my opinion; my perspective on this matter derives from the teachings of Pope John XXIII, Pope Paul VI, Pope John Paul II, Pope Benedict XVI, the Council itself and Catholic common sense.

Unfortunately this essentially anti-Catholic interpretation of the Council is pretty widespread and has contributed to a number of crises that the Church has been facing. On the one hand this falsification has fueled a false "progressive" spirit that has done much damage to the Church, and on the other hand it has contributed to ruptures in the Church that are often called "traditionalist" in nature. The writings of many heterodox theologians and pastors disseminate this idea as do the polemics of radical traditionalists (although their intentions are quite different, both do so in many respects to validate and perpetuate their cause).

Once again I acknowledge that there are complex discussions that could be had of particulars relating to conciliar and post-conciliar teachings and policies, but as a general rule the “hermeneutic of continuity” is the only valid starting point.

Posted

The importance of Vatican II tends to be over-emphasized in the Western Church to the detriment of immemorial Tradition.

That said, among Eastern Catholics Vatican II is for all practical purposes ignored.

Posted

Ignored todd?

How so? btw, OT I had some questions about theosis. But your pm box is full.

Good write up L_D

Posted

What changed?

Mass from Latin to English? Not really a VII change but regardless, the language of the Mass is not doctrine.

No Salvation Outside the Church? If you look at the 1917 Catholic Encyclopedia and Carl Adam's the Spirit of Catholicism, the teaching that was expressed at Vatican II was nothing new?

What else do you think "changed"?

Laudate_Dominum
Posted

[quote name='thessalonian' post='1383358' date='Sep 11 2007, 08:22 AM']What changed?

Mass from Latin to English? Not really a VII change but regardless, the language of the Mass is not doctrine.

No Salvation Outside the Church? If you look at the 1917 Catholic Encyclopedia and Carl Adam's the Spirit of Catholicism, the teaching that was expressed at Vatican II was nothing new?

What else do you think "changed"?[/quote]
Good points, but since I'm obsessed with the liturgy I must point out that the Council's constitution on the liturgy approves an increase in the use of the vernacular, with good reasons, but does not actually replace Latin since even at the promulgation of the renewed Roman rite it is assumed that Latin will be a normal part of the Mass, particularly in the parts of the ordinary that are typically sung by the congregation (Agnus Dei, Credo, Sanctus, et cetera). The expressed intention of the Council was the preserve Latin as the language of the Church but to adapt the liturgy in such a way that the use of the vernacular might cultivate a fuller actual participation of the faithful (that is the engagement of heart and mind, etc.) for example in the liturgy of the word, the restored prayers of the faithful, and such.

The constitution does not really get down to the specifics since it is guidelines for a reform that was envisioned for the future, but the importance of Latin is clear enough. The radical vernacularization of the liturgy owes more to the prevailing liturgical establishment of the 1970's than to expressed magisterial desire.

This is not to say that a Mass entirely in the vernacular is anathema, but the current situation of Latin being all but extinguished in mainstream liturgical practice is certainly far from the spirit and letter of the Council's constitution. In essence there is still work to be done in renewing and enriching the liturgical life of the Church.

Posted

[quote name='Laudate_Dominum' post='1383362' date='Sep 11 2007, 10:32 AM']This is not to say that a Mass entirely in the vernacular is anathema, but the current situation of Latin being all but extinguished in mainstream liturgical practice is certainly far from the spirit and letter of the Council's constitution. In essence there is still work to be done in renewing and enriching the liturgical life of the Church.[/quote]
I agree. [i]Sacrosanctum Concilium[/i], if read in the light of tradition, is a pretty conservative document. It attempts to renew the liturgy that we already had, calling for chant to be more widely used, and for the mass as a whole to be better celebrated. The changes it authorizes -- optional vernacular readings, prayers of the faithful, more scripture, etc. -- are not contrary to the spirit of the old liturgy; in fact, they are additive. Were the 1965 missal promulgated instead of the 1970, very few would have made noise. Well, I might have... I REALLY love the prayers at the foot of the altar, and that was removed in the 1965...

Laudate_Dominum
Posted

[quote name='adt6247' post='1383443' date='Sep 11 2007, 10:12 AM']I agree. [i]Sacrosanctum Concilium[/i], if read in the light of tradition, is a pretty conservative document. It attempts to renew the liturgy that we already had, calling for chant to be more widely used, and for the mass as a whole to be better celebrated. The changes it authorizes -- optional vernacular readings, prayers of the faithful, more scripture, etc. -- are not contrary to the spirit of the old liturgy; in fact, they are additive. Were the 1965 missal promulgated instead of the 1970, very few would have made noise. Well, I might have... I REALLY love the prayers at the foot of the altar, and that was removed in the 1965...[/quote]
Amen. But I do have a question: I've only taken a cursory glance at the 1965 work, but were the prayers at the foot of the altar actually done away with or were they simply made into private prayers to be said in the sacristy or perhaps a silent Judica Me during the procession? I know a lot of dudes in the liturgical movement thought this should be done because they saw it as improper that those prayers, which are technically not a part of the liturgy, were bundled with the Mass so tightly as to appear as parts of the Mass. The whole issue is debatable -- and was certainly debated -- but my impression is that this was the dominant view not the view that would seek a complete abolition.

Thanks.

Posted (edited)

[quote name='Laudate_Dominum' post='1383497' date='Sep 11 2007, 01:06 PM']Amen. But I do have a question: I've only taken a cursory glance at the 1965 work, but were the prayers at the foot of the altar actually done away with or were they simply made into private prayers to be said in the sacristy or perhaps a silent Judica Me during the procession? I know a lot of dudes in the liturgical movement thought this should be done because they saw it as improper that those prayers, which are technically not a part of the liturgy, were bundled with the Mass so tightly as to appear as parts of the Mass. The whole issue is debatable -- and was certainly debated -- but my impression is that this was the dominant view not the view that would seek a complete abolition.

Thanks.[/quote]
No, it is suppressed. And I mistyped; it's not the entirety of the prayers at the foot of the altar that were removed, it's just psalm 42 (43). The antiphon, "[i]Introibo ad altare dei, ad deum qui laetificat juventutem meum[/i]" was kept, as was the [i]confiteor[/i], and [i]adjutorum nostrum[/i]. It would be odd for them to have removed the prayers up to the first [i]oremus[/i], as that would have completely removed the [i]confiteor[/i] from the mass (the 1962 missal removed the "second [i]confiteor[/i]"), and considering it's in the ordinary form still, that wouldn't be the case. Then again, the [i]asperges[/i] did not used to be part of the mass, but a blessing for the people prior to the priest even vesting in his chasuble, and now it's actually part of the [i]novus ordo[/i].

The prayers at the foot of the altar are most decidedly part of the mass; the Asperges and the Last Gospel are not, but Psalm 42 certainly is. The reason I was told is that it was replaced by the responsorial psalm. I think this is unfortunate; it's a prayer that the priest (and secondarily, his ministers) says as he ascends the altar of God, as the antiphon alludes to.

One thing I really don't understand about the responsorial psalm in the ordinary form is why there is no [i]Gloria Patri[/i] doxology before saying the final antiphon. It puts it out of sync with the way the psalms are traditionally prayed in the liturgy. I think adding it would alone make people more predisposed towards liturgy of the hours. If the new breviary really is designed to be prayed by the laity as well, why would the Church wish make the psalms in Her mass so foreign in formula?

Edited by adt6247
Laudate_Dominum
Posted

[quote name='goldenchild17' post='1383754' date='Sep 11 2007, 05:57 PM']:wall: :shutup: :P[/quote]
:sadder: :weep:



:beer:

Posted (edited)

[quote name='Revprodeji' post='1383348' date='Sep 11 2007, 07:12 AM']Ignored todd?[/quote]
The council documents are couched in a terminology foreign to Eastern Christians, and even the one and only document addressed directly to the Eastern Catholic Churches sounds -- as Archbishop Elias Zoghby pointed out -- like a message sent from the Catholic Church to a group of Non-Catholic Churches. It is written in a rather condescending tone.

P.S. - The Melkite Catholic Church does not consider any of the councils held in the Latin Church during the last 1,000 years as "ecumenical"; instead, they are held to be particular synods of the Roman Church.

Edited by Apotheoun
Posted

[quote name='Apotheoun' post='1384078' date='Sep 12 2007, 09:41 AM']P.S. - The Melkite Catholic Church does not consider any of the councils held in the Latin Church during the last 1,000 years as "ecumenical"; instead, they are held to be particular synods of the Roman Church.[/quote]
That stance makes sense to me. I haven't read all of the V2 documents, but they seem to be primarily pastoral provisions and general statements particular to the Latin rite. I can't see [i]Sacrosanctum Concilium [/i] being applied to the eastern Divine Liturgies. Most of what it said doesn't apply, and the bits of it that would, just affirm that tradition should be upheld. I also couldn't see Trent's declarations on the universality of the missal of Paul V applying to the eastern churches.

Posted

It makes sense, but does Vat 2 consider itself only for the latin rite or is this just an example of the western church not taking into account the eastern christian churches? Being a council I would assume it was universal.

Posted

[quote name='adt6247' post='1384143' date='Sep 12 2007, 12:59 PM']That stance makes sense to me. I haven't read all of the V2 documents, but they seem to be primarily pastoral provisions and general statements particular to the Latin rite. I can't see [i]Sacrosanctum Concilium [/i] being applied to the eastern Divine Liturgies. Most of what it said doesn't apply, and the bits of it that would, just affirm that tradition should be upheld. I also couldn't see Trent's declarations on the universality of the missal of Paul V applying to the eastern churches.[/quote]
SC specifically states that it applies to the Roman rite alone and even gives props to the other liturgical traditions.

Posted

[quote name='Laudate_Dominum' post='1384044' date='Sep 12 2007, 06:00 AM']:sadder: :weep:
:beer:[/quote]

haha :smokey: . Anyways exquisite, even though my opinion doesn't mean anything here in regards to these questions I'll just say that I believe you are totally on to something with your questions. I think you are very close to understanding them very, very well. :mellow:

Posted (edited)

[quote name='adt6247' post='1383528' date='Sep 11 2007, 02:46 PM']The prayers at the foot of the altar are most decidedly part of the mass; the Asperges and the Last Gospel are not, but Psalm 42 certainly is. The reason I was told is that it was replaced by the responsorial psalm. I think this is unfortunate; it's a prayer that the priest (and secondarily, his ministers) says as he ascends the altar of God, as the antiphon alludes to.[/quote]
This is Laudate_Dominum.

For many 20th century liturgists Psalm 42 is not seen as part of the Mass because it was a late development. Anything that cannot be found in the Leonine, Gelasian or Gregorian Sacramentaries is treated as dubious. In my opinion this mentality suggests a false concept of tradition because it seems to equate tradition with antiquity rather than as a handing on and preserving of that which we have received (this demands a certain reverence, humility and faith that is quite rare to our age). In extreme cases one can find a kind of antiquarianism that is more or less an expression of the Protestant thesis.
On the other hand if the simplification of the Mass (not its impoverishment) is considered to be a valid aspect of the restoration/enrichment of the Liturgy called for by the Council (which apparently it must be, within certain parameters), then the consideration of antiquity can be a valid consideration but only in conjunction with other principles. If antiquity is given an inordinate place we are talking about antiquarianism or archaeologism, which is antiliturgical heresy.

Edited by Luthien
Posted (edited)

[quote name='goldenchild17' post='1384358' date='Sep 12 2007, 06:02 PM']haha :smokey: . Anyways exquisite, even though my opinion doesn't mean anything here in regards to these questions I'll just say that I believe you are totally on to something with your questions. I think you are very close to understanding them very, very well. :mellow:[/quote]
Your opinion means something to me at least. If you can express your take without getting in trouble please do.

This is L_D btw.

Edited by Luthien

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...