N/A Gone Posted September 12, 2007 Posted September 12, 2007 Im confused..L_D? Why dont you log as yourself? I assume that is the wife's log-in, so does that mean literally you are hiding behind her skirt?
Luthien Posted September 12, 2007 Posted September 12, 2007 [quote name='Revprodeji' post='1384389' date='Sep 12 2007, 06:41 PM']Im confused..L_D? Why dont you log as yourself? I assume that is the wife's log-in, so does that mean literally you are hiding behind her skirt?[/quote] This is L_D. because I'm using my wife's laptop and I don't want to log her out. I realize that it is kind of silly, I guess I'm a silly dude.
N/A Gone Posted September 12, 2007 Posted September 12, 2007 So, is that like posting in drag? Cause I think there are some threads right now that consider that a mortal sin. I will pray for your weakness for women's clothing.
N/A Gone Posted September 12, 2007 Posted September 12, 2007 you have a name for your cross dressing persona?
N/A Gone Posted September 13, 2007 Posted September 13, 2007 What you laughin at baldy? yea..your emoticon is bald. That sounds like a man type of thing. I know I bought your hubby's book but doesnt mean you need to steal his hair to get my attention!!!!! (*this is what happens when I am trying to focus on a paper)
goldenchild17 Posted September 13, 2007 Posted September 13, 2007 [quote name='Luthien' post='1384381' date='Sep 12 2007, 03:27 PM']Your opinion means something to me at least. If you can express your take without getting in trouble please do. This is L_D btw.[/quote] That's a tall order . I'll think about it for a little bit and see. And I respect your posts probably more than anyone else on here. So that's a nice compliment .
Apotheoun Posted September 13, 2007 Posted September 13, 2007 [quote name='Revprodeji' post='1384146' date='Sep 12 2007, 09:06 AM']It makes sense, but does Vat 2 consider itself only for the latin rite or is this just an example of the western church not taking into account the eastern christian churches? Being a council I would assume it was universal.[/quote] Latin Catholics have often seen their doctrinal, spiritual, and liturgical traditions as somehow normative for the whole Church, and Eastern Catholics have -- in the past -- been forced to accept that position, but those days are over. Eastern Catholics are presently going through a process of de-Latinization, which requires -- by its very nature -- the restoration of our own traditions. That said, what Latin Catholics think about Vatican II, or what the Latin bishops think about Vatican II, is irrelevant to me as an Eastern Catholic, because Vatican II does not represent the theological tradition of my [i]sui juris[/i] Church, and so it plays no part in my spiritual or theological life. As I said before, I accept only the seven councils of the first millennium as truly ecumenical.
N/A Gone Posted September 13, 2007 Posted September 13, 2007 Im going to sound like a novice. But does that mean that you reject trent also? How can you be catholic, and obey the authority of the pope and do that? it almost sounds greek orthodox. It appeals to me.
cmotherofpirl Posted September 13, 2007 Posted September 13, 2007 [quote name='Revprodeji' post='1384784' date='Sep 13 2007, 10:13 AM']Im going to sound like a novice. But does that mean that you reject trent also? How can you be catholic, and obey the authority of the pope and do that? it almost sounds greek orthodox. It appeals to me.[/quote] Eastern CAtholics have their own spirituality, Saints, theologians and tradition. They are part of the Catholic Church, but come from a totally different theological direction. I find it fascinating.
adt6247 Posted September 13, 2007 Posted September 13, 2007 [quote name='Revprodeji' post='1384429' date='Sep 12 2007, 07:22 PM']So, is that like posting in drag? Cause I think there are some threads right now that consider that a mortal sin.[/quote] That's the funniest thing I've read in a while. I simply have to use the term "posting in drag". Or maybe for some of my friends that are WAY to addicted to WoW, gaming in drag...
adt6247 Posted September 13, 2007 Posted September 13, 2007 [quote name='Laudate_Dominum' post='1384376' date='Sep 12 2007, 05:24 PM']For many 20th century liturgists Psalm 42 is not seen as part of the Mass because it was a late development. Anything that cannot be found in the Leonine, Gelasian or Gregorian Sacramentaries is treated as dubious. In my opinion this mentality suggests a false concept of tradition because it seems to equate tradition with antiquity rather than as a handing on and preserving of that which we have received (this demands a certain reverence, humility and faith that is quite rare to our age). In extreme cases one can find a kind of antiquarianism that is more or less an expression of the Protestant thesis. On the other hand if the simplification of the Mass (not its impoverishment) is considered to be a valid aspect of the restoration/enrichment of the Liturgy called for by the Council (which apparently it must be, within certain parameters), then the consideration of antiquity can be a valid consideration but only in conjunction with other principles. If antiquity is given an inordinate place we are talking about antiquarianism or archaeologism, which is antiliturgical heresy.[/quote] This is my interpretation as well. As I mentioned, the Asperges, the wedding rite, the baptismal rite, etc. were kinda grafted onto the mass in the ordinary form, whereas they existed outside of the old. If stating that psalm 42 was not part of the mass due to the fact that it was a late development is valid, why would that not apply to the Eucharistic Prayer #3, the second reading, the responsorial psalm, etc. in the ordinary form? Of what I've read, the mass starts when the priest genuflects and opens with "[i]In nomine Patri[/i]" at the prayers at the foot of the altar, and ends with the final blessing. I'll check Fortescue when I get home tonight. BTW: I highly recommend a copy of [b][url="http://www.buy.com/prod/the-ceremonies-of-the-roman-rite-described-14th-revised-edition/q/loc/106/31106756.html"]The Ceremonies of the Roman Rite Described [/url][/b]by Fortescue, O'Connell, and Reid, if you don't already have it. It's fantastic, and amazingly detail-oriented.
goldenchild17 Posted September 13, 2007 Posted September 13, 2007 (edited) [quote name='goldenchild17' post='1384564' date='Sep 12 2007, 08:00 PM']That's a tall order . I'll think about it for a little bit and see. And I respect your posts probably more than anyone else on here. So that's a nice compliment .[/quote] I'm not sure I can really go into much detail without getting into trouble. All I can really say is that I agree with many conservative Catholics who believe the Council was hijacked. But I am disturbed by the fact of who it was likely hijacked by. I understand the comments about it having to be read "in light of tradition" but I believe this can only take place if the same doctrine had been preached by the Church previous to the Council and I can't see that for a number of things posited by the Council. I also agree that much of it is ambiguous and hard to understand. But I also believe that, especially for any council of the Church, this is a sign of unorthodoxy. I believe the Church has declared ambiguity as being un-Catholic and a sign of the heretics by Pope Pius VI. And in some cases where I can admit a somewhat difficult reading because of ambiguity, I believe such statements are clarified by people in a certain position of power which clarify and confirm an understanding of such statements which I find very hard to reconcile as orthodox. And I believe that although much of the statements of Vatican II can be considered ambiguous, I think that, in accordance with Pope Pius VI, that a true understanding of its intended meaning can become clear enough. Edited September 13, 2007 by goldenchild17
Apotheoun Posted September 14, 2007 Posted September 14, 2007 [quote name='Revprodeji' post='1384784' date='Sep 13 2007, 07:13 AM']Im going to sound like a novice. But does that mean that you reject trent also?[/quote] From an Eastern Catholic perspective the Council of Trent is only a particular synod of the Latin Church held in response to a purely Western historical crisis that is normally called "The Protestant Reformation."
Era Might Posted September 14, 2007 Posted September 14, 2007 Trent was an Ecumenical Council, and its dogmatic Canons are universally binding. [quote]We indict, announce, convoke, appoint, and decree a sacred, ecumenical and general council -- to be opened on the ensuing calends of November of the present year, MDXLII, from the Incarnation of the Lord -- in the city of Trent, a place commodious, free, and convenient for all nations; and to be there prosecuted, concluded, and completed, with God's help, to His glory and praise, and the welfare of the whole Christian people. --Bull of Indiction[/quote]
kenrockthefirst Posted September 14, 2007 Posted September 14, 2007 [quote name='goldenchild17' post='1385059' date='Sep 13 2007, 06:02 PM']I'm not sure I can really go into much detail without getting into trouble. All I can really say is that I agree with many conservative Catholics who believe the Council was hijacked.[/quote] So are you saying that the Holy Spirit dropped the ball? I realize that this is a loaded question, but I'm always puzzled by Catholics who on the one hand insist, and rightly so, that within the context of Apostolic Succession the Church has full authority to determine all matters of faith, and yet on the other hand declare that the "Council was hijacked" because they disagree with what the successors to the Apostles agreed. Am I off base here?
adt6247 Posted September 14, 2007 Posted September 14, 2007 [quote name='kenrockthefirst' post='1385355' date='Sep 14 2007, 10:20 AM']So are you saying that the Holy Spirit dropped the ball? I realize that this is a loaded question, but I'm always puzzled by Catholics who on the one hand insist, and rightly so, that within the context of Apostolic Succession the Church has full authority to determine all matters of faith, and yet on the other hand declare that the "Council was hijacked" because they disagree with what the successors to the Apostles agreed. Am I off base here?[/quote] The Holy Spirit doesn't guarantee that an Ecumenical council will not be hijacked, only that the council will not preach doctrinal error. I believe the council was partially hijacked by a bunch of liberals and groups hostile to the church. Unlike Goldenchild17, I do believe that while they did damage (making a handful of unwise pastoral provisions, inserting ambiguous language, etc.), the Holy Spirit protected the council from doctrinal error.
kenrockthefirst Posted September 14, 2007 Posted September 14, 2007 [quote name='adt6247' post='1385364' date='Sep 14 2007, 08:44 AM']The Holy Spirit doesn't guarantee that an Ecumenical council will not be hijacked, only that the council will not preach doctrinal error. I believe the council was partially hijacked by a bunch of liberals and groups hostile to the church. Unlike Goldenchild17, I do believe that while they did damage (making a handful of unwise pastoral provisions, inserting ambiguous language, etc.), the Holy Spirit protected the council from doctrinal error.[/quote] I don't get it. If the Council was protected from preaching doctrinal error, then it what sense can it be deemed to have been "hijacked?"
Apotheoun Posted September 14, 2007 Posted September 14, 2007 [quote name='Era Might' post='1385351' date='Sep 14 2007, 07:08 AM']Trent was an Ecumenical Council, and its dogmatic Canons are universally binding.[/quote] The theory of justification promoted by Trent does not conform to the teaching of the Eastern Fathers; and so, I cannot assent to it. Trent says that man is justified by a justice that is not God's very own justice, i.e., that he is justified by a "created" justice, but the Eastern Fathers teach that man is justified by the uncreated energy of God's own justice, i.e., by the very justice whereby God Himself is just. Moreover, Trent teaches that there is no virtue or divinity in icons, but the Eastern Churches hold that the uncreated divine energy is present within icons, and so -- as a consequence -- icons are theophanic manifestations of God and of the saint depicted in them. Sadly, Western Scholastic theology -- as exemplified by the Tridentine decrees -- on these two issues is impoverished from an Eastern Christian perspective. Clearly, the Tridentine teaching in responding to the Protestant heresy has lost touch with the Patristic understanding of grace, and the incarnational theology of icons.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now