Apotheoun Posted September 14, 2007 Posted September 14, 2007 As an Eastern Catholic I do not believe that Trent is an ecumenical council.
adt6247 Posted September 14, 2007 Posted September 14, 2007 [quote name='kenrockthefirst' post='1385371' date='Sep 14 2007, 10:55 AM']I don't get it. If the Council was protected from preaching doctrinal error, then it what sense can it be deemed to have been "hijacked?"[/quote] It was hijacked in that very liberal people, such as Annibale Bugnini, were able to get high positions in the council, and though were not able to actively put their agenda into the documents of the council, were able to minimize the affirmation of some traditional Catholic teaching, while at the same time ensuring that many of the council documents were vaguely worded, so they could be used after the council to cause confusion, and when cited out of context, teach error. That's just like saying because of the Holy Spirit protects the pope from proclaiming heresy, the pope can't make any bad decisions. There are plenty of popes throughout history that have done horrible things, but preached no heresy. I suggest you look up the histories of Steven VII, John XII, and Alexander VI, to name a few.
N/A Gone Posted September 14, 2007 Posted September 14, 2007 [quote name='Apotheoun' post='1385350' date='Sep 14 2007, 08:59 AM']From an Eastern Catholic perspective the Council of Trent is only a particular synod of the Latin Church held in response to a purely Western historical crisis that is normally called "The Protestant Reformation."[/quote] [quote name='Era Might' post='1385351' date='Sep 14 2007, 09:08 AM']Trent was an Ecumenical Council, and its dogmatic Canons are universally binding.[/quote] Thats what I thought. How is the eastern churches considered catholic when they can "blow off" the council? Was there Eastern representation there? Did the council make efforts or intention to include the eastern catholics? I dont like the idea of the council working as just a latin-rite only thing. [quote name='Apotheoun' post='1385372' date='Sep 14 2007, 09:56 AM']The theory of justification promoted by Trent does not conform to the teaching of the Eastern Fathers; and so, I cannot assent to it. Trent says that man is justified by a justice that is not God's very own justice, i.e., that he is justified by a "created" justice, but the Eastern Fathers teach that man is justified by the uncreated energy of God's own justice, i.e., by the very justice whereby God Himself is just. Moreover, Trent teaches that there is no virtue or divinity in icons, but the Eastern Churches hold that the uncreated divine energy is present within icons, and so -- as a consequence -- icons are theophanic manifestations of God and of the saint depicted in them. Sadly, Western Scholastic theology -- as exemplified by the Tridentine decrees -- on these two issues is impoverished from an Eastern Christian perspective. Clearly, the Tridentine teaching in responding to the Protestant heresy has lost touch with the Patristic understanding of grace, and the incarnational theology of icons.[/quote] This is what I was worried about. Im still a neophyte. I have only been Catholic for 2-3 years. Im still learning and growing. The problem is I converted due to patristics and that testimony reconciles itself more with what Todd says. If you were to make a post or survey asking about the 2 issues. With justice and icons I would have sided with Todd and given a reason for it (created justice makes no sense to me, and I have an old icon in my office) Im so confused. How is this any different than 2 denominations?
goldenchild17 Posted September 14, 2007 Posted September 14, 2007 (edited) [quote name='kenrockthefirst' post='1385355' date='Sep 14 2007, 08:20 AM']So are you saying that the Holy Spirit dropped the ball? I realize that this is a loaded question, but I'm always puzzled by Catholics who on the one hand insist, and rightly so, that within the context of Apostolic Succession the Church has full authority to determine all matters of faith, and yet on the other hand declare that the "Council was hijacked" because they disagree with what the successors to the Apostles agreed. Am I off base here?[/quote] If you want any more info you can email me. I don't intend to cross any boundaries dUST doesn't want crossed. In short, no I don't believe the Holy Spirit dropped the ball in the slightest. I believe that if the council is indeed to be considered valid, then is when the Spirit would have dropped the ball. I believe it was a bad idea before it ever began and I believe it was called to intentionally introduce bad things. Edited September 14, 2007 by goldenchild17
Laudate_Dominum Posted September 19, 2007 Posted September 19, 2007 [quote name='goldenchild17' post='1385498' date='Sep 14 2007, 01:16 PM']If you want any more info you can email me. I don't intend to cross any boundaries dUST doesn't want crossed. In short, no I don't believe the Holy Spirit dropped the ball in the slightest. I believe that if the council is indeed to be considered valid, then is when the Spirit would have dropped the ball. I believe it was a bad idea before it ever began and I believe it was called to intentionally introduce bad things.[/quote] Major props. I can't imagine how difficult it would be to be a convinced sedevacantist on a Catholic board and basically have to "keep it to yourself." I'm sorry that it has to be this way on these boards (I imagine there are other sites that are more welcoming to this kind of debate?), but I totally respect you for being able to restrain yourself so much and for respecting dUSt's wishes. You're a better man than I. Email me any time if you want to rap about anything in particular.
N/A Gone Posted September 20, 2007 Posted September 20, 2007 care to answer my question above L_D? If you got the time that is.
goldenchild17 Posted September 20, 2007 Posted September 20, 2007 (edited) [quote name='Laudate_Dominum' post='1388675' date='Sep 19 2007, 01:12 PM']Major props. I can't imagine how difficult it would be to be a convinced sedevacantist on a Catholic board and basically have to "keep it to yourself."[/quote] It's no biggie. It's hard in that I care about a lot of people on here (wierd I know considering I haven't met hardly anybody here in person), and I would like to at least have intellectual discussions about some things of this topic, not so much to change people but to at least let people know where I'm coming from and to know my, and the most honest of the Sedevacantist arguments. It's hard because I read through all the sites given in the Catholic Defense Directory in response to this topic and its sad for me because I notice how lacking the arguments are. Not that I'm dissing an opposing belief to mine. It's not that at all, because having fought with this for over a year I have come across much better arguments against the sedevacantist position than what is found in the directory. Ultimately, it wasn't enough to keep me in check, obviously. But they are a way better and far more intellectually fair and accurate assessment of our position and its weak points, which any honest sede will admit there are a couple soft spots in the position. But that's really all. I just want to help a lot of you guys become better informed, and in turn if I am certainly wrong in my position, I would want to know and I can't think of too many places where I could find a better chance of that happening than here. [quote]I'm sorry that it has to be this way on these boards (I imagine there are other sites that are more welcoming to this kind of debate?), but I totally respect you for being able to restrain yourself so much and for respecting dUSt's wishes. You're a better man than I. Email me any time if you want to rap about anything in particular. [/quote] There aren't a whole lot. And the few that probably would I have never been too interested in. Most of those sites that would allow it aren't nearly at the intellectual level as some of you guys here are, so it just wouldn't be worth it as much of it would blow right over their heads. It's cool with me though, I don't really care to just spout off about sedevacantism. I can do that on my site for anyone to read whenever they want. I'm not out to try and cover every message board on the internet with my arguments. Budgieness isn't quite my style . I just wanted it here because I feel like I know a lot of you guys and that's what makes it important for me here. But I totally understand dUST's reasoning too. It's a hard topic and could confuse a lot of people. I'm not sure why a private forum couldn't be set up here with anyone who wants to defend sedevacantism (or SSPX or another traditionalist position or topic) having access to it, and then only people such as those who have proven themselves on the phorum to have the knowledge to deal with the topic. Anyone else wouldn't need to see it and/or be scandalized by it. Kinda like the Q&A board, in that only those capable of addressing the issues can post, but private and not limited to one post and one (give or take) reply per thread. But that's just me. And this ain't my forum. And I've been here too long to leave over something like that. But if you, or anyone else here, ever have any questions or want to get into it, just let me know. I've got email and a cheap message board that nobody uses where we can talk about anything ya'll want , peace. Edited September 20, 2007 by goldenchild17
N/A Gone Posted September 20, 2007 Posted September 20, 2007 I would be interested in hearing the arguments, also some of the objections that naturally come to mind (not that they will turn you, im sure you have heard them. Im just curious of the response)
goldenchild17 Posted September 20, 2007 Posted September 20, 2007 And you aren't the only one. A fair number of people have expressed interest in at least throwing it out there as discussion material. Personally I think at the very least it could provide a little better practice in theological discussions than the alleged demons at Fatima, or the demons in the ufo's or any of these sort of diacussions that are popular on the debate table. Maybe we could find an off-site location where everybody who wanted to could see these discussions? I only have a cheap free forum in connection with my website. There is probably a better place but any one that wants to can check that out.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now