Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Kid Nation


Recommended Posts

Posted

EAT THE CHICKEN! I'm so glad they killed the chicken...

Posted

I would think if they didn't do it in this episode, they would eventually. It's good to see so many of the children understand what is necessary to survive.

I bet that one girl is going to let some of the chickens go...

Posted

One quirk I noticed is the fact that some heavy editing is taking place (obviously). But, one shot Greg has pimples on his chin, the next shot, clear face, next shot, pimples are back. This happened throughout the show, haha.

Posted

[quote name='dUSt' post='1394730' date='Sep 28 2007, 10:35 AM']One quirk I noticed is the fact that some heavy editing is taking place (obviously). But, one shot Greg has pimples on his chin, the next shot, clear face, next shot, pimples are back. This happened throughout the show, haha.[/quote]
So you were never 15 years old? :mellow:

Posted

[quote name='homeschoolmom' post='1388983' date='Sep 20 2007, 08:00 AM']And that Sophia.... She would be an awesome babysitter. :mellow:[/quote]
Oh absolutely.

[quote name='homeschoolmom' post='1394446' date='Sep 27 2007, 09:33 PM']I hope they are portraying Taylor acurately. I mean, she's coming off pretty badly.... I hope that they aren't over-emphasizing her prima dona attitude. If they could vote people off, she'd have been my first choice.[/quote]
Yes... I worry about that too. Yes she's young. But I just don't want her to be so self-righteous.

Isn't this show under a lot of scrutiny about the ethical nature of the show and the children being unsupervised? I admit, the premise is interesting. And I'll definitely watch a few more episodes, but every now and then I keep thinking "Are they really allowed to do this?" :idontknow:

Posted

[quote name='homeschoolmom' post='1388983' date='Sep 20 2007, 08:00 AM']And that Sophia.... She would be an awesome babysitter. :mellow:[/quote]
Oh absolutely.

[quote name='homeschoolmom' post='1394446' date='Sep 27 2007, 09:33 PM']I hope they are portraying Taylor acurately. I mean, she's coming off pretty badly.... I hope that they aren't over-emphasizing her prima dona attitude. If they could vote people off, she'd have been my first choice.[/quote]
Yes... I worry about that too. Yes she's young. But I just don't want her to be so self-righteous.

Isn't this show under a lot of scrutiny about the ethical nature of the show and the children being unsupervised? I admit, the premise is interesting. And I'll definitely watch a few more episodes, but every now and then I keep thinking "Are they really allowed to do this?" :idontknow:

Posted

[quote name='shortnun' post='1394840' date='Sep 28 2007, 01:39 PM']Isn't this show under a lot of scrutiny about the ethical nature of the show and the children being unsupervised?[/quote]
I'm assuming the people holding the cameras are all adults.

Posted

[quote name='dUSt' post='1389050' date='Sep 20 2007, 10:02 AM']No she was watching MTV. Some dating show where a bunch of guys were on a bus. I only have basic cable so all the shows on those channels should be kid friendly right?[/quote]
Dust, the mtv show you are refering to is called next. its lame in adult eyes, enjoybable for teens. What can I say its MTV.

Posted

I can't believe that that many kids watched them kill the chickens. I know I would not be able to watch them chop the head off!

What channel and what time does is this show? I just watched it online but I want to catch the next episode.

  • 2 weeks later...
Posted

Taylor was hilarious in that last episode, just yellin for everyone to "Deal With It!" I hope Green doesn't go back to Laborers this week.

Posted

Taylor makes me seriously irritated. She says she's going to change, but I'm going to be surprised if she follows through.

Same with Greg--if he does get the star, I feel like he'll gloat about it. And swearing in front of eight-year-olds is not cool.

This week, there's supposed to be a big debate over the town religion. I'm looking forward to it.

I'm Mr. Snikkers
Posted

I watch it last week. I thought it was pretty cool.

But I did not like Greg...at all...

I'm watching it this week.

homeschoolmom
Posted

[quote name='MissyP89' post='1399334' date='Oct 8 2007, 11:11 AM']Taylor makes me seriously irritated. She says she's going to change, but I'm going to be surprised if she follows through.

Same with Greg--if he does get the star, I feel like he'll gloat about it. And swearing in front of eight-year-olds is not cool.

This week, there's supposed to be a big debate over the town religion. I'm looking forward to it.[/quote]
Something I'm concerned about with this show is something that is true of all reality tv shows and that is editing. Has Taylor said some really stupid, bratty things? Yes. Do we know if that's all she ever says? Well, it could very well be... but we don't know for sure because of editing... same with Greg. I'm somewhat concerned with how these children will feel watching themselves be vilified when that may not have been exactly the way they behaved in Bananza City. I'm a little concerned with how a child will handle being the subject of blogs etc. It's embarrassing enough to have your bad behavior chastized by your parents in front of a neighbor or something. It's something else again to have the whole country HATE you.... She's only, what? nine?
Btw, I think this week's episode will be really interesting. The subject of religion comes up sooo rarely on reality shows and yet it's really a big part of many people's lives. Should be interesting to see how the kids handle it.

Posted

I hope one of the kids is like an altar server with a really really good CCD teacher.

Posted

[quote name='homeschoolmom' post='1399371' date='Oct 8 2007, 11:29 AM']Something I'm concerned about with this show is something that is true of all reality tv shows and that is editing. Has Taylor said some really stupid, bratty things? Yes. Do we know if that's all she ever says? Well, it could very well be... but we don't know for sure because of editing... same with Greg. I'm somewhat concerned with how these children will feel watching themselves be vilified when that may not have been exactly the way they behaved in Bananza City. I'm a little concerned with how a child will handle being the subject of blogs etc. It's embarrassing enough to have your bad behavior chastized by your parents in front of a neighbor or something. It's something else again to have the whole country HATE you.... She's only, what? nine?
Btw, I think this week's episode will be really interesting. The subject of religion comes up sooo rarely on reality shows and yet it's really a big part of many people's lives. Should be interesting to see how the kids handle it.[/quote]

I could understand how your afraid the editing may be skewed, which is perfectly possible, but I think Taylor is probably accurate because of how the town reacted at the town meeting. It seemed like everybody had a problem with her

homeschoolmom
Posted

No doubt. She's certainly said many, many things that would merrit a punishment in my house ("beauty queens don't do dishes," "Let them starve" etc). I just wonder what realizing that the nation hates you does to her. I HOPE that she's learned from the council meeting and has shaped up...

Posted

She was brought to tears by everyone in the little town meeting saying she had a problem, imagine if she realizes the whole country agreed with them. wow... although, maybe her experience through the whole 40 days changed her, and so now she would understand why they had a problem with her and think of herself as a different person now. still gotta be embarrassing to have that known everywhere.

she'll probably get over it because of all the fame she has anyway, I'm sure she just eats that part up, being a little beauty queen and all ;)

I'm Mr. Snikkers
Posted

If I were on Kid Nation, I'd probably be the best cook.

Posted

[quote name='homeschoolmom' post='1399371' date='Oct 8 2007, 12:29 PM']Something I'm concerned about with this show is something that is true of all reality tv shows and that is editing. Has Taylor said some really stupid, bratty things? Yes. Do we know if that's all she ever says? Well, it could very well be... but we don't know for sure because of editing... same with Greg. I'm somewhat concerned with how these children will feel watching themselves be vilified when that may not have been exactly the way they behaved in Bananza City. I'm a little concerned with how a child will handle being the subject of blogs etc. It's embarrassing enough to have your bad behavior chastized by your parents in front of a neighbor or something. It's something else again to have the whole country HATE you.... She's only, what? nine?
Btw, I think this week's episode will be really interesting. The subject of religion comes up sooo rarely on reality shows and yet it's really a big part of many people's lives. Should be interesting to see how the kids handle it.[/quote]
I couldn't agree with you more, hsmom. I won't be able to watch this week. But I'll be eager to see how you all react.

Posted

I caught this show for the first time last night. It was great! so seldom that we get a possitive view of religion from the media.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...