friendofJPII Posted October 11, 2007 Posted October 11, 2007 [quote name='hyperdulia again' post='1400914' date='Oct 11 2007, 06:07 PM']Well does it?[/quote] I hope you weren't going to say heretic. That is so mean spirited and uncharitable. You could say, "Our beloved separated brethren in Chirst."
Thy Geekdom Come Posted October 11, 2007 Posted October 11, 2007 [quote name='friendofJPII' post='1400916' date='Oct 11 2007, 07:12 PM']I hope you weren't going to say heretic. That is so mean spirited and uncharitable. You could say, "Our beloved separated brethren in Chirst."[/quote] He's from Phatmass' less PC days. We don't have nearly as many Protestants as we used to, HD. They must have gotten bored or something. Of course, we had one, but she was so constantly getting suspended I think she was very nearly banned this last time. I would love to have an honest discussion with a non-Catholic again. I'm afraid they've forgotten us.
Laudate_Dominum Posted October 11, 2007 Posted October 11, 2007 [quote name='friendofJPII' post='1400916' date='Oct 11 2007, 06:12 PM']I hope you weren't going to say heretic. That is so mean spirited and uncharitable. You could say, "Our beloved separated brethren in Chirst."[/quote] I prefer "heterodox Christians."
hyperdulia again Posted October 11, 2007 Author Posted October 11, 2007 I (He Raph, not she ) prefer the word used for most of the last five centuries: heretic. I do however recognize how problematic it is in forging Christian unity.
hyperdulia again Posted October 11, 2007 Author Posted October 11, 2007 Sum1 go and find some Protestants.
brendan1104 Posted October 11, 2007 Posted October 11, 2007 Heretics? Schismatics? Yep. We also have pagans and apostates.
Thy Geekdom Come Posted October 11, 2007 Posted October 11, 2007 [quote name='hyperdulia again' post='1400923' date='Oct 11 2007, 07:18 PM']I (He Raph, not she ) prefer the word used for most of the last five centuries: heretic. I do however recognize how problematic it is in forging Christian unity.[/quote] I don't know what you're talking about...I clearly wrote "he." Your avatar always confused me.
friendofJPII Posted October 11, 2007 Posted October 11, 2007 IMO, a heretic is someone who is Catholic and openly dissents. Sr. Joan C. is a heretic. Joe, my Protestant friend, is not.
Thy Geekdom Come Posted October 11, 2007 Posted October 11, 2007 [quote name='friendofJPII' post='1400929' date='Oct 11 2007, 07:31 PM']IMO, a heretic is someone who is Catholic and openly dissents. Sr. Joan C. is a heretic. Joe, my Protestant friend, is not.[/quote] A heretic is anyone who denies any or all aspects of the Christian faith after Baptism. It presumes that they know the true faith. Many non-Catholics in this day and age, therefore, are [i]probably[/i] not formal heretics, but only material heretics (meaning that they are unintentionally heretical, but not "heretics" in the popular sense of the word).
beata_virgo_maria Posted October 11, 2007 Posted October 11, 2007 (edited) This just seems a bit mean spirited. Not asking if there are any people who are Protestant, but uncharitable way in which a few posts seem to be going. Edited October 11, 2007 by beata_virgo_maria
jeffpugh Posted October 12, 2007 Posted October 12, 2007 I'll try and get my Pentecostal friend back on (Heshmafluff). He only did one topic, which was on Mary, and he found how "stubborn" Catholics were. I guess I wasn't doing my job by putting up enough of a fight...but I think he's avoiding Catholicism a bit... doen't want to know too much... you know...
XIX Posted October 12, 2007 Posted October 12, 2007 I think we still have dairygirl4u2c. And technically speaking, I think you have to claim to be Catholic and then teach heresies to be considered a heretic yourself.
jeffpugh Posted October 12, 2007 Posted October 12, 2007 Yeah, we still got Dairygirl on board. She and I were chatting it up on the debate board a couple of days ago. We have a few other protestants who just call themselves "Christians". It's interesting how many have not even heard of the term before. One of my proddy friends who is a "Bretheren" (whatever that is. Goes to a Bible chapel), never heard the term until I brought him to my diocesan youth festival a couple years back. I think he had a good time somewhat, but he wasn't too comfortable about the situation... anywho tangent... I'll try to bring more on.
brendan1104 Posted October 12, 2007 Posted October 12, 2007 Nope. [quote name='XIX' post='1400974' date='Oct 11 2007, 07:31 PM']And technically speaking, I think you have to claim to be Catholic and then teach heresies to be considered a heretic yourself.[/quote]
Seven77 Posted October 12, 2007 Posted October 12, 2007 modern day protestants can't rightly be called heretics. only the "reformers" could...
missionseeker Posted October 12, 2007 Posted October 12, 2007 Like Raph said, most modern Protestants would probably fall under the ctegory of Material heretic. Not formal.
XIX Posted October 12, 2007 Posted October 12, 2007 I should post a question on this in Transmundane or Q&A.
brendan1104 Posted October 12, 2007 Posted October 12, 2007 If I embrace the modernist heresy, then I am a modernist heretic. The arian heresy, then I am an arian heretic. Etc. etc. etc. [quote name='Seven77' post='1400980' date='Oct 11 2007, 07:49 PM']modern day protestants can't rightly be called heretics. only the "reformers" could...[/quote]
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now