missionseeker Posted October 12, 2007 Posted October 12, 2007 yes, but most mosern day heretics don't start out Catholic. That's the point. They wer taught that heresy was truth through no fault of their own. Therefore, they are in a sort of invincible ignorance. YES ONLY to a degree, but it's there nonetheless. That's the difference between material and formal. Formal heretics used to be Catholic.
friendofJPII Posted October 12, 2007 Posted October 12, 2007 (edited) [quote name='missionseeker' post='1401017' date='Oct 11 2007, 09:33 PM']yes, but most mosern day heretics don't start out Catholic. That's the point. They wer taught that heresy was truth through no fault of their own. Therefore, they are in a sort of invincible ignorance. YES ONLY to a degree, but it's there nonetheless. That's the difference between material and formal. Formal heretics used to be Catholic.[/quote] Even then they might not fully understand what they left. If those Catholics who left the Church fully understood our faith and what they were leaving, I doubt many would. Edited October 12, 2007 by friendofJPII
missionseeker Posted October 12, 2007 Posted October 12, 2007 true indeed. basically it boils down to culpabiltiy being dependent upon knowledge.
photosynthesis Posted October 12, 2007 Posted October 12, 2007 [quote name='missionseeker' post='1401017' date='Oct 11 2007, 11:33 PM']yes, but most mosern day heretics don't start out Catholic. That's the point. They wer taught that heresy was truth through no fault of their own. Therefore, they are in a sort of invincible ignorance. YES ONLY to a degree, but it's there nonetheless. That's the difference between material and formal. Formal heretics used to be Catholic.[/quote] I thought, to some degree, being baptized did make you a member of the Catholic Church. and modern day Protestants are still heretics, if they profess to believe something contrary to what the Church teaches. There are Protestants I know who have been taught the truth of the Catholic faith several times, and after many conversations with me (and a bunch of other Catholics) they still hold onto their false ideas. I'd consider them to be culpable for the sin of heresy. There are also people that were raised in Protestant homes, and through no fault of their own were taught false ideas. They're still heretics, but they aren't culpable for such sins until the authentic Catholic faith has been presented to them. Heretic isn't a derogatory term meant to insult people. Of course God loves heretics. They're our brothers and sisters in Christ, and we are called to treat them with charity. Are we supposed to tactlessly remind Protestants over and over again that they are heretics while we shove Catholic teaching down their throats? No. But the Church has formally defined Protestantism as a heresy, and until the 20th century, it was a sin to go to a Protestant church service. As much as Protestants are our brothers and sisters in Christ, we are not in communion with them. That hurts Our Lord even more than it hurts us.
missionseeker Posted October 12, 2007 Posted October 12, 2007 [quote name='photosynthesis' post='1401054' date='Oct 11 2007, 10:23 PM']I thought, to some degree, being baptized did make you a member of the Catholic Church. and modern day Protestants are still heretics, if they profess to believe something contrary to what the Church teaches. There are Protestants I know who have been taught the truth of the Catholic faith several times, and after many conversations with me (and a bunch of other Catholics) they still hold onto their false ideas. I'd consider them to be culpable for the sin of heresy. There are also people that were raised in Protestant homes, and through no fault of their own were taught false ideas. They're still heretics, but they aren't culpable for such sins until the authentic Catholic faith has been presented to them.[/quote] yes Being baptized makes you a member of the Church but unless you were baptized Catholic, the Church has no ecclesial authority over you and therefore you aren't a formal heretic. I think. I am tired and stressed and not explaining things very well, so I will stop.. lol
hoosieranna Posted October 12, 2007 Posted October 12, 2007 There are still some of us non-Catholics here. The degree of militancy varies wildly. I'm here because I'm curious and still learning. Some are here to proselytize.
Andreas E. Posted October 12, 2007 Posted October 12, 2007 I put "Christian" for religion as I am not a Catholic, but I do not belong to any particular protestant denomination either. I do not identify myself with any protestant church.
missionseeker Posted October 12, 2007 Posted October 12, 2007 [quote name='Nadezhda' post='1401072' date='Oct 11 2007, 10:52 PM']There are still some of us non-Catholics here. The degree of militancy varies wildly. I'm here because I'm curious and still learning. Some are here to proselytize.[/quote] or as one of my friends said "polyesterize"
hyperdulia again Posted October 12, 2007 Author Posted October 12, 2007 is protestantism a heresy? do protestants believe the protestant heresy? Heretic does not mean Hellish demon. It means misguided Christian. Protestants (not to mention most Catholics) are heretics. FULL STOP.
XIX Posted October 12, 2007 Posted October 12, 2007 [quote name='Nadezhda' post='1401072' date='Oct 12 2007, 12:52 AM']There are still some of us non-Catholics here. The degree of militancy varies wildly. I'm here because I'm curious and still learning. Some are here to proselytize.[/quote] I dunno how I forgot you.
friendofJPII Posted October 12, 2007 Posted October 12, 2007 (edited) [i]There are Protestants I know who have been taught the truth of the Catholic faith several times, and after many conversations with me (and a bunch of other Catholics) they still hold onto their false ideas. I'd consider them to be culpable for the sin of heresy.[/i][/i] Only God can judge such things, not us. We don't know what is going on in their head/heart/soul. It depends.... if they really and know and believe that the CC is the one true Church and willing choose to reject it, then yes they are guilty. If they really believe their faith is okay, and they are loving God with their full heart, I believe God will have mercy on them Nevertheless, calling them a heretic is uncharitable and will acomplish nothing. Same thing with calling someone who lives a life of sin a "pagan." I think "poor sinner" the term Our Lady has used in several apparitions is more appropriate. Of course, there are people who practice witchcraft, in which case, "pagan" is appropriate. Edited October 12, 2007 by friendofJPII
friendofJPII Posted October 12, 2007 Posted October 12, 2007 [quote name='Andreas E.' post='1401074' date='Oct 11 2007, 10:53 PM']I put "Christian" for religion as I am not a Catholic, but I do not belong to any particular protestant denomination either. I do not identify myself with any protestant church.[/quote] I'm glad you're here!
Anastasia13 Posted October 12, 2007 Posted October 12, 2007 (edited) [quote name='missionseeker' post='1400989' date='Oct 11 2007, 08:00 PM']Like Raph said, most modern Protestants would probably fall under the ctegory of Material heretic. Not formal.[/quote] Most Protestants are baptised but are not baptised Catholic. We never believe in papal infallibility to begin with. Do I mean nothing to you people? Do I not matter? Am I invisible? Or was this for very mean spirited Protestants? Do you only count really doctrinally argumentitive Protestants? Your token Prot. L&T P.S. Yes, I admit that I do come and go a bit. Edited October 12, 2007 by Light and Truth
PapaHilarious Posted October 12, 2007 Posted October 12, 2007 [quote name='Light and Truth' post='1401126' date='Oct 12 2007, 12:15 AM']Most Protestants are baptised but are not baptised Catholic. We never believe in papal infallibility to begin with. Do I mean nothing to you people? Do I not matter? Am I invisible? Or was this for very mean spirited Protestants? Do you only count really doctrinally argumentitive Protestants? Your token Prot. L&T P.S. Yes, I admit that I do come and go a bit.[/quote] I can see this post, so I guess you're not invisible. In response to your comment about baptism, though, it should be pointed out that the Church recognizes all Trinitarian (in the Christian sense, not in any pseudo-cultist definition) baptisms as valid. Therefore, there is a distinct connection in the body of Christ that all baptized Christians share. How that related to papal infallibility, I dunno. Maybe I missed something. [Not sure what the point of such a thread is or how it really promotes a healthy dialogue, btw.]
Anastasia13 Posted October 12, 2007 Posted October 12, 2007 [quote name='PapaHilarious' post='1401127' date='Oct 12 2007, 12:29 AM']I can see this post, so I guess you're not invisible. In response to your comment about baptism, though, it should be pointed out that the Church recognizes all Trinitarian (in the Christian sense, not in any pseudo-cultist definition) baptisms as valid. Therefore, there is a distinct connection in the body of Christ that all baptized Christians share. How that related to papal infallibility, I dunno. Maybe I missed something. [Not sure what the point of such a thread is or how it really promotes a healthy dialogue, btw.][/quote] I meant that as an example of how we have never really fully bought into all of what you believe to begin with. Many of us have only been members of distinctly non-Catholic ecclesiastical groups.
Justin86 Posted October 12, 2007 Posted October 12, 2007 I think the world should only be divided into two groups: Catholic and non-Catholic. Non-Catholics should be killed. The world would be alot simpler.
friendofJPII Posted October 12, 2007 Posted October 12, 2007 (edited) We have to remember also that language usage changes over time. For example, we wouldn't say that our happy friend was "gay" anymore, even if the formal definition still fits. Neither do we use the term "illegitimate children.." rather we say children born into single parent families or something else that describes the situation without compromising the dignity of the child. Since Vatican II, the CC has used the term "separated brethren" to describe our Protestant brothers and sisters. Considering that the term "heretic" sounds so harsh, and considering that most Protestants today would be taken aback, we should not use it. If we are going to call anyone a "heretic" we should start with the dissenting Clergy within our own Church. Edited October 12, 2007 by friendofJPII
Noel's angel Posted October 12, 2007 Posted October 12, 2007 [quote name='Justin86' post='1401132' date='Oct 12 2007, 09:16 AM']I think the world should only be divided into two groups: Catholic and non-Catholic. Non-Catholics should be killed. The world would be alot simpler.[/quote] And that's clearly the Catholic attitude... I'd rather live with a thousand Protestants than one person with your attitude.
Noel's angel Posted October 12, 2007 Posted October 12, 2007 (edited) double post... Edited October 12, 2007 by Noel's angel
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now