hyperdulia again Posted October 12, 2007 Author Posted October 12, 2007 [quote name='friendofJPII' post='1401416' date='Oct 12 2007, 06:03 PM']No one is twittling with an objective. It's a matter of language usage, approach, and how that changes according to the culture of the time.[/quote] Be not conformed! The Pope is well within his rights to refrain from the use of the word heretic, but I see no reason to believe that I am out of the bounds of my rights to use the historic usage of Christ's Church.
hyperdulia again Posted October 12, 2007 Author Posted October 12, 2007 [quote name='hot stuff' post='1401419' date='Oct 12 2007, 06:04 PM']Who's characterization do you resent[/quote] Well then let's go with the phorum guidelines shall we? QUOTE Personal Attacks A post or comment that has nothing to do with the topic, but is specifically meant to upset or criticize another person or group of people. This includes, but is not limited to, calling people "heretics" (used in a derogatory manner), "democrooks", etc. I think the title of this thread goes against the guidelines pretty clearly. Honestly I'm not sure why it hasn't been deleted yet
Jaime Posted October 12, 2007 Posted October 12, 2007 [quote name='hyperdulia again' post='1401423' date='Oct 12 2007, 06:06 PM']Well then let's go with the phorum guidelines shall we? QUOTE Personal Attacks A post or comment that has nothing to do with the topic, but is specifically meant to upset or criticize another person or group of people. This includes, but is not limited to, calling people "heretics" (used in a derogatory manner), "democrooks", etc. I think the title of this thread goes against the guidelines pretty clearly. Honestly I'm not sure why it hasn't been deleted yet[/quote] Oh ok, you resent my characterization... Probably because my characterization is accurate. This thread does break the guidelines. A Oh and you have a poor understanding of heretic.
Noel's angel Posted October 12, 2007 Posted October 12, 2007 Can I make a point? A number of Protestants have shown their presence, yet there seems to be no recognition or intent to talk with them.
hyperdulia again Posted October 12, 2007 Author Posted October 12, 2007 (edited) No you know nothing of my motives. Presumption is a sin that proceeds from a lack of charity. You know nothing of my motives. Nothing. At all. I could write a very long book about formal and material heresy or actually any other subject connected to the Church a person could think of. So I won't be joining you in an intellectaul peeing contest. I'm done with this thread. Delete. Move. I don't care. Love in Christ and Mary. Edited October 12, 2007 by hyperdulia again
Jaime Posted October 12, 2007 Posted October 12, 2007 [quote name='hyperdulia again' post='1401428' date='Oct 12 2007, 06:12 PM']No you know nothing of my motives. Presumption is a sin that proceeds from a lack of charity. You know nothing of my motives. Nothing. At all. I could write a very long book about formal and material heresy or actually any other subject connected to the Church a person could think of. So I won't be joining you in an intellectaul peeing contest. I'm done with this thread. Delete. Move. I don't care. Love in Christ and Mary.[/quote] ROFL Any subject? Wow I'm in awe.. Oh and I make it a rule not to get into an intellectual peeing contest with someone who can't spell intellectual. (What a drama queen)
Noel's angel Posted October 12, 2007 Posted October 12, 2007 (edited) Misdirected post...sorry! Edited October 12, 2007 by Noel's angel
hyperdulia again Posted October 12, 2007 Author Posted October 12, 2007 Noel I haven't made a response to you so if your first line (in post 87) is directed at me I'm afraid it's misdirected.
friendofJPII Posted October 12, 2007 Posted October 12, 2007 [quote name='hyperdulia again' post='1401432' date='Oct 12 2007, 05:19 PM']Noel I haven't made a response to you so if your first line (in post 87) is directed at me I'm afraid it's misdirected.[/quote] This thread is getting mean-spirited, from all ends. It should be deleted.
Noel's angel Posted October 12, 2007 Posted October 12, 2007 Sorry, I thought it was because I said it seemed like you had no real intention to actually talk with Protestants on the board. I'll let you and hot stuff battle it out.
Jaime Posted October 12, 2007 Posted October 12, 2007 [quote name='friendofJPII' post='1401434' date='Oct 12 2007, 06:22 PM']This thread is getting mean-spirited, from all ends. It should be deleted.[/quote] It started mean spirited
hyperdulia again Posted October 12, 2007 Author Posted October 12, 2007 hot stuff, repectfully, you know nothing of my motives (a definite requirement of being able to say what "spirit" this thread was started in). To claim to be aware of things interior to me is simply impossible. This is my last post on this thread. God Bless
Jaime Posted October 12, 2007 Posted October 12, 2007 [quote name='hyperdulia again' post='1400923' date='Oct 11 2007, 07:18 PM']I (He Raph, not she ) prefer the word used for most of the last five centuries: heretic. I do however recognize how problematic it is in forging Christian unity.[/quote] [quote name='hyperdulia again' post='1401082' date='Oct 12 2007, 12:07 AM']is protestantism a heresy? do protestants believe the protestant heresy? Heretic does not mean Hellish demon. It means misguided Christian. Protestants (not to mention most Catholics) are heretics. FULL STOP.[/quote] [quote name='hyperdulia again' post='1401407' date='Oct 12 2007, 05:54 PM']The Pope has many powers. Twittling with objective reality is not one of them. Protestants are heretics.[/quote] Well let's see.. heretic heretic heretic etc. No elaboration just.. well I think I've made my point If you're asking for protestants, then be specific. Throwing out words that you admit yourself are "problematic" seems to make it pretty clear that you're just being provocative. And in doing so, going against phorum guidelines and well pointless. And this is my 12th to last post on this thread
cmotherofpirl Posted October 12, 2007 Posted October 12, 2007 The term heresy connotes, etymologically, both a choice and the thing chosen, the meaning being, however, narrowed to the selection of religious or political doctrines, adhesion to parties in Church or State. Josephus applies the name (airesis) to the three religious sects prevalent in Judea since the Machabean period: the Sadducees, the Pharisees, the Essenes (Bel. Jud., II, viii, 1; Ant., XIII, v, 9). St. Paul is described to the Roman governor Felix as the leader of the heresy (aireseos) of the Nazarenes (Acts 24:5); the Jews in Rome say to the same Apostle: "Concerning this sect [airesoeos], we know that it is everywhere contradicted" (Acts 28:22). St. Justin (Dial., xviii, 108) uses airesis in the same sense. St. Peter (II, ii, 1) applies the term to Christian sects: "There shall be among you lying teachers who shall bring in sects of perdition [aireseis apoleias]". In later Greek, philosophers' schools, as well as religious sects, are "heresies". St. Thomas (II-II:11:1) defines heresy: "a species of infidelity in men who, having professed the faith of Christ, corrupt its dogmas". "The right Christian faith consists in giving one's voluntary assent to Christ in all that truly belongs to His teaching. There are, therefore, two ways of deviating from Christianity: the one by refusing to believe in Christ Himself, which is the way of infidelity, common to Pagans and Jews; the other by restricting belief to certain points of Christ's doctrine selected and fashioned at pleasure, which is the way of heretics. The subject-matter of both faith and heresy is, therefore, the deposit of the faith, that is, the sum total of truths revealed in Scripture and Tradition as proposed to our belief by the Church. The believer accepts the whole deposit as proposed by the Church; the heretic accepts only such parts of it as commend themselves to his own approval. The heretical tenets may be ignorance of the true creed, erroneous judgment, imperfect apprehension and comprehension of dogmas: in none of these does the will play an appreciable part, wherefore one of the necessary conditions of sinfulness--free choice--is wanting and such heresy is merely objective, or material. On the other hand the will may freely incline the intellect to adhere to tenets declared false by the Divine teaching authority of the Church. The impelling motives are many: intellectual pride or exaggerated reliance on one's own insight; the illusions of religious zeal; the allurements of political or ecclesiastical power; the ties of material interests and personal status; and perhaps others more dishonourable. Heresy thus willed is imputable to the subject and carries with it a varying degree of guilt; it is called formal, because to the material error it adds the informative element of "freely willed". Pertinacity, that is, obstinate adhesion to a particular tenet is required to make heresy formal. For as long as one remains willing to submit to the Church's decision he remains a Catholic Christian at heart and his wrong beliefs are only transient errors and fleeting opinions. Considering that the human intellect can assent only to truth, real or apparent, studied pertinacity -- as distinct from wanton opposition -- supposes a firm subjective conviction which may be sufficient to inform the conscience and create "good faith". Such firm convictions result either from circumstances over which the heretic has no control or from intellectual delinquencies in themselves more or less voluntary and imputable. A man born and nurtured in heretical surroundings may live and die without ever having a doubt as to the truth of his creed. On the other hand a born Catholic may allow himself to drift into whirls of anti-Catholic thought from which no doctrinal authority can rescue him, and where his mind becomes incrusted with convictions, or considerations sufficiently powerful to overlay his Catholic conscience. It is not for man, but for Him who searcheth the mind and heart, to sit in judgment on the guilt which attaches to an heretical conscience. II. DISTINCTIONS Heresy differs from apostasy. The apostate a fide abandons wholly the faith of Christ either by embracing Judaism, Islamism, Paganism, or simply by falling into naturalism and complete neglect of religion; the heretic always retains faith in Christ. Heresy also differs from schism. Schismatics, says St. Thomas, in the strict sense, are they who of their own will and intention separate themselves from the unity of the Church. The unity of the Church consists in the connection of its members with each other and of all the members with the head. Now this head is Christ whose representative in the Church is the supreme pontiff. And therefore the name of schismatics is given to those who will not submit to the supreme pontiff nor communicate with the members of the Church subject to him. Since the definition of Papal Infallibility, schism usually implies the heresy of denying this dogma. Heresy is opposed to faith; schism to charity; so that, although all heretics are schismatics because loss of faith involves separation from the Church, not all schismatics are necessarily heretics, since a man may, from anger, pride, ambition, or the like, sever himself from the communion of the Church and yet believe all the Church proposes for our belief (II-II, Q. xxix, a. 1). Such a one, however, would be more properly called rebellious than heretical. III. DEGREES OF HERESY Both matter and form of heresy admit of degrees which find expression in the following technical formula of theology and canon law. Pertinacious adhesion to a doctrine contradictory to a point of faith clearly defined by the Church is heresy pure and simple, heresy in the first degree. But if the doctrine in question has not been expressly "defined" or is not clearly proposed as an article of faith in the ordinary, authorized teaching of the Church, an opinion opposed to it is styled sententia haeresi proxima, that is, an opinion approaching heresy. Next, a doctrinal proposition, without directly contradicting a received dogma, may yet involve logical consequences at variance with revealed truth. Such a proposition is not heretical, it is a propositio theologice erronea, that is, erroneous in theology. Further, the opposition to an article of faith may not be strictly demonstrable, but only reach a certain degree of probability. In that case the doctrine is termed sententia de haeresi suspecta, haeresim sapiens; that is, an opinion suspected, or savouring, of heresy (see THEOLOGICAL CENSURES).
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now