ironmonk Posted May 15, 2008 Posted May 15, 2008 Is is a sin to vote for someone who has no chance of winning this election? Let's look at the facts... Fact: The president will be either McCain or a dem. Fact: Catholics have a political responsibility to vote. Fact: All wrong doing is sin. Fact: It would be irresponsible to vote for someone who has no chance to win. Fact: McCain is Pro-Life, Pro-God, Pro-Family Fact: Obama and Clinton (and any other dem w/a chance) is completely (at least 90%) against every Catholic moral teaching. A vote for anyone beside McCain for president would be irresponsible... a no vote would be irresponsible. I say yes, it would be a sin to vote for someone with no chance of winning the presidential election, given the facts. A non-McCain vote would benefit Obama/Clinton/(maybe Gore).... a non-McCain vote would not benefit anyone else, even the one someone was voting for. God Bless, ironmonk
kujo Posted May 15, 2008 Posted May 15, 2008 This has been debated endlessly [url="http://www.phatmass.com/phorum/index.php?showtopic=77341"]in this thread[/url].
Alycin Posted May 15, 2008 Posted May 15, 2008 [quote]Let's look at the facts... Fact: The president will be either McCain or a dem. Fact: Catholics have a political responsibility to vote. Fact: All wrong doing is sin. [size=4]Opinion[/size]: It would be irresponsible to vote for someone who has no chance to win. Fact: McCain is Pro-Life, Pro-God, Pro-Family Fact: Obama and Clinton (and any other dem w/a chance) is completely (at least 90%) against every Catholic moral teaching.[/quote]
goldenchild17 Posted May 15, 2008 Posted May 15, 2008 [quote name='ironmonk' post='1528920' date='May 14 2008, 08:14 PM']Is is a sin to vote for someone who has no chance of winning this election? Let's look at the facts... Fact: The president will be either McCain or a dem. Fact: Catholics have a political responsibility to vote. Fact: All wrong doing is sin. Fact: It would be irresponsible to vote for someone who has no chance to win. Fact: McCain is Pro-Life, Pro-God, Pro-Family Fact: Obama and Clinton (and any other dem w/a chance) is completely (at least 90%) against every Catholic moral teaching. A vote for anyone beside McCain for president would be irresponsible... a no vote would be irresponsible. I say yes, it would be a sin to vote for someone with no chance of winning the presidential election, given the facts. A non-McCain vote would benefit Obama/Clinton/(maybe Gore).... a non-McCain vote would not benefit anyone else, even the one someone was voting for. God Bless, ironmonk[/quote] This has been beaten to death. I think there will always be people on both sides of this argument but honestly I can't see how. If the ends truly do not justify the means, and as a result it is immoral to vote for a bad candidate even if a good end were to occur then the reverse MUST also be true: i.e. it is NOT immoral to vote for a good candidate even if a bad candidate will happen to win as a result.
Aloysius Posted May 15, 2008 Posted May 15, 2008 ... the ends neither justify nor condemn the means. you can call it stupid and impractical, but you can't call it immoral according to Catholic morality.
kujo Posted May 15, 2008 Posted May 15, 2008 [quote name='Aloysius' post='1529219' date='May 15 2008, 05:24 AM'] ... the ends neither justify nor condemn the means. you can call it stupid and impractical, but you can't call it immoral according to Catholic morality.[/quote] Yup!
Didymus Posted May 15, 2008 Posted May 15, 2008 we would basically be saying that it is a sin for a Catholic not to vote for John McCain... way to go.
picchick Posted May 15, 2008 Posted May 15, 2008 [quote name='Didymus' post='1529352' date='May 15 2008, 10:43 AM']way to go.[/quote] ....um.....I don't like your phraseology.....you could have been a tad bit about your statement.
picchick Posted May 15, 2008 Posted May 15, 2008 (edited) ...sorry...nicer...a tad bit nicer. You can't fight fire with fire....you only get a bigger blaze. Edited May 15, 2008 by picchick
Didymus Posted May 15, 2008 Posted May 15, 2008 with terms such as Obama bin Lyin being thrown around constantly, I don't know how much less blunt I can be sometimes. If we're going to be doing this, than why don't we just have all of the priests preach from the pulpit that all of the parishioners must vote for John McCain?
picchick Posted May 15, 2008 Posted May 15, 2008 [quote name='Didymus' post='1529499' date='May 15 2008, 01:17 PM']with terms such as Obama bin Lyin being thrown around constantly, I don't know how much less blunt I can be sometimes. If we're going to be doing this, than why don't we just have all of the priests preach from the pulpit that all of the parishioners must vote for John McCain?[/quote] You can be blunt yet nice in your bluntness. I am not saying I agree with Iron monk on this topic. AND by calling Obama bin Lyin you (meaning who ever uses the term), in my eyes you are lowing yourselfs to the same level of the candidates who fling insults and try to tear each other down. Mind you, I am not good at politics and terms and whatever but I can mos def see uncharitable behavior and it turns me off to a candidate. If a candidate is going to be uncharitable towards another, how do I know that they are not going to be uncharitable towards me? Meg
Didymus Posted May 15, 2008 Posted May 15, 2008 [quote name='picchick' post='1529507' date='May 15 2008, 01:30 PM']You can be blunt yet nice in your bluntness.[/quote] very well then. I apologize for the three words i said that weren't "nice"
ironmonk Posted May 16, 2008 Author Posted May 16, 2008 Doing something that does not matter is worthless which is irresponsible... this is a fact. Learn logic.
picchick Posted May 16, 2008 Posted May 16, 2008 (edited) [quote]Doing something that does not matter is worthless which is irresponsible[/quote] I never liked logic..... A is B B is C Therefore A is C Dogs are mammals. Mammals are animals. Therefore Dogs are animals. Ok...it works. On a serious note: I don't think it is a sin as long as you are not voting for someone who is promoting death. I know that it will not help promote a candidate that might do more but, if you feel that it is against your conscience to vote for someone not totally prolife then I don't think you should. Edited May 16, 2008 by picchick
JesusIsMySuperHero Posted May 16, 2008 Posted May 16, 2008 (edited) My Favourite Candidate is Ron Paul. That sentence in itself should show why I can't vote for him though! If I could, I would immediately! Edited May 16, 2008 by JesusIsMySuperHero
goldenchild17 Posted May 16, 2008 Posted May 16, 2008 [quote name='ironmonk' post='1529996' date='May 15 2008, 09:25 PM']Doing something that does not matter is worthless which is irresponsible... this is a fact. Learn logic.[/quote] irresponsible? possibly, but many people have reasons for doing so that have specific worthwhile goals in mind. Regardless, even if it is dumb and useless, it is not sinful. There's no way around that unless you deny the ends don't justify the means.
goldenchild17 Posted May 16, 2008 Posted May 16, 2008 [quote name='JesusIsMySuperHero' post='1530060' date='May 15 2008, 10:51 PM']My Favourite Candidate is Ron Paul. That sentence in itself should show why I can't vote for him though! If I could, I would immediately![/quote] Why can't you? Because the public has told you that he has no shot? Of course he doesn't, if people who support him won't vote for him because they are told it is pointless.
Alycin Posted May 16, 2008 Posted May 16, 2008 [quote name='ironmonk' post='1529996' date='May 15 2008, 10:25 PM']Doing something that does not matter is worthless which is irresponsible... this is a fact.[/quote] What matters to one may not matter to another. Worth can be subjective. Anyway, that wasn't what I was challenging. You deviated from your original statement, which was flawed, and therefore a matter of YOUR opinion. One, as the saying goes, a vote is never "worthless" Two, you don't have any way of proving that a certain candidate won't win just because they are third-party. That's what you suppose, and assume, but it isn't an IMPOSSIBILITY just because you say so. It's unlikely, yes. But not impossible.
Aloysius Posted May 16, 2008 Posted May 16, 2008 It was dumb and pointless for Poles to mount horses to meet the Nazi Army and fight. They did it anyway. And I for one think it was a noble endeavor and they met their maker as good and faithful servants who did what was right until the final end. How about the dumb and stupid martyrs of the first century... it seems quite pointless and impractical to go around dying for a cause you want to spread. it would make much more sense to reject Christ officially and live to spread his message in secret. Catholics have a long and colorful history of doing the dumb and pointless thing, of supporting the lost causes against all odds. Not only Catholics, though, but all freedom loving people. The Spartans were dumb and pointless. Remember the Alamo? Dumb and pointless. "But you and all the kind of Christ Are ignorant and brave, And you shall have wars [and elections] you hardly win And souls you hardly save." -The Ballad of the White Horse, G.K. Chesterton
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now