Aloysius Posted May 20, 2008 Posted May 20, 2008 Do you disagree with the idea of double effect, then? People can know what the double effect will be and not again, feel free to argue against it in the way you just have, ie that we ought to do it because it's the best way to defend life. it's very compelling and might eventually convince me, but don't argue against the principal of double effect and don't tell me it's a sin to choose to vote for a better candidate even if it's not possible. It is not. You might be right about it being better to choose McCain, but it's not a sin to vote for a good third party candidate even though you know that the unintended double effect will be that a democrat will benefit. We allow surgeries in which we know that the unintended double effect is the definitive death of a baby. An unintended double effect of a democrat winning is just as acceptable so long as the act itself is a good act.
Justin86 Posted May 20, 2008 Posted May 20, 2008 [quote name='Aloysius' post='1534387' date='May 20 2008, 02:27 PM']Do you disagree with the idea of double effect, then? People can know what the double effect will be and not again, feel free to argue against it in the way you just have, ie that we ought to do it because it's the best way to defend life. it's very compelling and might eventually convince me, but don't argue against the principal of double effect and don't tell me it's a sin to choose to vote for a better candidate even if it's not possible. It is not. You might be right about it being better to choose McCain, but it's not a sin to vote for a good third party candidate even though you know that the unintended double effect will be that a democrat will benefit. We allow surgeries in which we know that the unintended double effect is the definitive death of a baby. An unintended double effect of a democrat winning is just as acceptable so long as the act itself is a good act.[/quote] I see your point here so I won't be coming at it from that angle. One of the reasons you said before that you wanted to vote third party is to send a message to the Republican party that you want a more staunch pro-life candidate. Well, first of all I think McCain is pretty much pro-life as we're gonna get at the moment. I don't know if he would sign that bill in Congress that you were talking about that would in effect outlaw abortion, but he does support overturning Roe v. Wade, and has committed to appointing Justices in the line of Scalia and Roberts. I also don't see much hope in the success of the Republican party getting your message. In order for such a thing to happen, like it or not, it pretty much has to be reported as such by the media and the pundits. If Hillary or Obama wins I think the media is more likely to report it as the American people wanting a liberal, pro-choice agenda rather than Republicans demanding stauncher pro-life candidates.
Aloysius Posted May 20, 2008 Posted May 20, 2008 the GOP leadership will receive the message if their candidate failed to receive the support of the republican base. I have explained my belief and distrust of McCain before: I trust Santorum when he says McCain has always tried to avoid votes on pro-life issues coming to a vote and I see him as someone who will always go for the path of least resistance and combined with Santorum's assessment, to me that means he'll not put on justices who are definitively going to fail the democrats' abortion litmus test... he's Mr. BiPartisan no matter how much he's pandering to the conservative base right now. of course, this is only one of my legitimate reasons for withholding my support for McCain.
goldenchild17 Posted May 20, 2008 Posted May 20, 2008 [quote name='Aloysius' post='1533773' date='May 19 2008, 03:01 PM']it says refusing to vote can be a sin if that causes an unworthy candidate to succeed, because refusing to vote is a sinful act in and of itself and it says it can be mortal if it causes an unworthy candidate to succeed. voting third party is not a sinful act, it is a good act; if there is an unintended evil effect to your good act, you are not sinning.[/quote] That's the likely understanding of it probably, but I'm just not sure yet. With the principle of ends not justifying the means if you vote for a good candidate which results in a bad candidate winning, its still justifiable. If you choose not to vote, can the argument be made (or not) that the voter cannot support either major candidate and that is why he is not voting? Same result, still not an immoral end (or is it immoral not to vote?) but a bad outcome...
goldenchild17 Posted May 20, 2008 Posted May 20, 2008 oh well, I'm not really sure I want to explore this aspect of it at this time. It's too confusing for me right now and especially when I don't see how it's possibly relevant. I could never consider McCain to be a decisively better option than Obama, so its not really relevant to this election, IMO. I do fully agree with you so far though, putting this particular issue aside for now.
Aloysius Posted May 20, 2008 Posted May 20, 2008 the manual says not voting is in and of itself a sin, and that if an unworthy candidate could win as a result of not voting that increases the gravity of the sin and might make it a mortal sin. it is evil to not vote. you cannot do an evil means even to achieve a good, not voting is an evil.
goldenchild17 Posted May 20, 2008 Posted May 20, 2008 (edited) [quote name='Aloysius' post='1534409' date='May 19 2008, 11:56 PM']the GOP leadership will receive the message if their candidate failed to receive the support of the republican base. I have explained my belief and distrust of McCain before: I trust Santorum when he says McCain has always tried to avoid votes on pro-life issues coming to a vote and I see him as someone who will always go for the path of least resistance and combined with Santorum's assessment, to me that means he'll not put on justices who are definitively going to fail the democrats' abortion litmus test... he's Mr. BiPartisan no matter how much he's pandering to the conservative base right now. of course, this is only one of my legitimate reasons for withholding my support for McCain.[/quote] I do think this will be the case if a sufficient number of truly conservative options show up on the ballot results, i.e. Paul or Keyes or whomever. If they make up a margin big enough (even if its small) to cause McCain to lose then I think they will get the message. I don't think they will get the message if he loses simply because people either decide not to vote, or worse, vote for the Democratic Party in the hopes of some "social programs" resulting in less abortions. If the GOP sees some of these conservative names on the ballot results then they may have to redo their thinking, even if it takes a couple consecutive elections to set the precedent. Edited May 20, 2008 by goldenchild17
goldenchild17 Posted May 20, 2008 Posted May 20, 2008 (edited) [quote name='Aloysius' post='1534414' date='May 20 2008, 12:06 AM']the manual says not voting is in and of itself a sin, and that if an unworthy candidate could win as a result of not voting that increases culpability and might make it a mortal sin. it is evil to not vote. you cannot do an evil means even to achieve a good, not voting is an evil.[/quote] again I'm not trying to argue with you, because I do believe I'm with you on the basic idea. Just trying to flesh out some details. Could you point out where it says it is a sin in and of itself to not vote? "205. – 3. Election of good representatives. Voting is a civic duty which would seem to bind at least under venial sin whenever a good candidate has an unworthy opponent. It might even be a mortal sin if one’s refusal to vote would result in the election of an unworthy candidate. One may vote for an unworthy candidate only when this is necessary to prevent a still less worthy candidate from obtaining office; but in such a case one should explain the reason for his action if this is possible. In an exceptional case one may vote for some unworthy candidate; viz., if he can thereby avert some unusually great personal disadvantage." (Jone - Moral Theology)" It says it would bind under venial sin whenever a good candidate has an unworthy one. and it says that it could even be a mortal sin if refusing to vote would result in the better candidate losing, but I don't see where it says we are bound to vote, period. And I don't see that being the author's case. I'm having a little trouble reconciling my interpretation of the author's intent with the understanding of ends not justifying the means, but I'm not sure how else to interpret the passage given what the text is saying. Edited May 20, 2008 by goldenchild17
goldenchild17 Posted May 20, 2008 Posted May 20, 2008 (edited) EDIT: Maybe the first paragraph is differentiating between a truly good candidate and a bad one and this would make it a sin? i.e. If there was a fully Catholic (or someone in line with Catholic ideals) running vs. someone who was not. Then it would be a venial sin not to vote for the good candidate, and possibly a mortal one should that non-vote help to result in the bad candidate winning? Then paragraph 2 would be more relevant to what I initially was thinking. I.e. it says one MAY vote for a lesser evil candidate if that would result in the worse candidate not obtaining office. Doesn't say one is required to, only in the case of a truly good candidate vs. a truly bad one. Would that work or am I still off? sorry if that sounded confusing, I'm just throwing out ideas that just came to me. peace Edited May 20, 2008 by goldenchild17
Justin86 Posted May 20, 2008 Posted May 20, 2008 [quote name='Aloysius' post='1534409' date='May 20 2008, 02:56 PM']the GOP leadership will receive the message if their candidate failed to receive the support of the republican base.[/quote] You really think the media is going to point that out? How would that agree with their agenda?
Aloysius Posted May 20, 2008 Posted May 20, 2008 The media messes with popular opinion. Trust me, the GOP leadership itself will know if their base didn't support them. Like golden said, it'll be reflected in the percentages that go to third party conservative candidates. Also, exit polls, and basically all sorts of polls (the GOP pretty much already knows that McCain has an uphill battle to win the conservative base and if he cannot accomplish that, they will know) obviously the loss of McCain will be spun by the media as a support for liberal causes. The GOP leadership would obviously know better if its base did not support McCain and that was what really caused the loss.
goldenchild17 Posted May 20, 2008 Posted May 20, 2008 yeah, although they've had a highly unfair amount of influence in elections, all that really matters is what the GOP knows. While it would be good for this information to get out to the public, I don't think it will matter much. If the GOP knows that they lost because McCain was too liberal, then if they want to win again, they will do something to remedy it, despite what the media spins.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now