Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

[quote name='goldenchild17' post='1530123' date='May 16 2008, 01:29 AM']Why can't you? Because the public has told you that he has no shot? Of course he doesn't, if people who support him won't vote for him because they are told it is pointless.[/quote]

he's not American... thats why

JesusIsMySuperHero
Posted

[quote name='Didymus' post='1530264' date='May 16 2008, 10:10 AM']he's not American... thats why[/quote]
Yeah

I spelt Favourite - which is Canadian. If I was American, I would support him, hit the streets immediately, and be intimately involved in his campaign, because Ron Paul is the only person worthy of being President of the United States.

goldenchild17
Posted

[quote name='JesusIsMySuperHero' post='1530741' date='May 16 2008, 05:56 PM']Yeah

I spelt Favourite - which is Canadian. If I was American, I would support him, hit the streets immediately, and be intimately involved in his campaign, because Ron Paul is the only person worthy of being President of the United States.[/quote]

Oh I get it now :D. I thought didy was saying Paul was not an American. Got me confused for minute... Yeah Paul's really good. I'd rather see Keyes win it, but he has less support so I'd have no problem voting for Paul if he got on the ballot in my state.

dairygirl4u2c
Posted

don't you guys get it? ironmonk has posted a link to catholic.com before, which says abortion is the number one issue. therefore, voting third party is a sin.
joke.

actually though, i'd be much more likely to agree taht it's a sin, and would agree, if there's a good chance abortion will change better with mccain and significatly.

and it'd be more wise to vote for a prochoice despite them being that, if other things are going to change and abortion clearly won't.... than to vote third party when not voting their would change things.

goldenchild17
Posted

[quote name='dairygirl4u2c' post='1530858' date='May 16 2008, 07:46 PM']actually though, i'd be much more likely to agree taht it's a sin, and would agree, if there's a good chance abortion will change better with mccain and significatly.

and it'd be more wise to vote for a prochoice despite them being that, if other things are going to change and abortion clearly won't.... than to vote third party when not voting their would change things.[/quote]

I agree that it would probably be a sin to vote 3rd party/indie IF a McCain presidency would result in far less abortions (overall, short-term and/or long-term). This is why I have no problem with someone who wants to vote for McCain if they really believe it will make a positive difference. I just personally don't believe it will make any difference and in the long-term will only hurt it worse. An enemy disguised as an ally is far worse than an enemy in the open, IMO.

but from a Catholic perspective I don't believe your second premise works. Again principle of ends not justifying the means. It's not okay to vote for an evil candidate, even if something good were to come from it.

Posted

[quote name='goldenchild17' post='1530876' date='May 16 2008, 09:12 PM']I agree that it would probably be a sin to vote 3rd party/indie IF a McCain presidency would result in far less abortions (overall, short-term and/or long-term). This is why I have no problem with someone who wants to vote for McCain if they really believe it will make a positive difference. I just personally don't believe it will make any difference and in the long-term will only hurt it worse. An enemy disguised as an ally is far worse than an enemy in the open, IMO.[/quote]

I definitely agree with you on McCain. But what exactly are we using to determine this? At the very least, McCain will put strict constructionists on the S.C. whereas Obama probably would not.

Is this enough though?

Posted

[quote name='goldenchild17' post='1530876' date='May 16 2008, 09:12 PM']I agree that it would probably be a sin to vote 3rd party/indie IF a McCain presidency would result in far less abortions (overall, short-term and/or long-term). This is why I have no problem with someone who wants to vote for McCain if they really believe it will make a positive difference. I just personally don't believe it will make any difference and in the long-term will only hurt it worse. An enemy disguised as an ally is far worse than an enemy in the open, IMO.

but from a Catholic perspective I don't believe your second premise works. Again principle of ends not justifying the means. It's not okay to vote for an evil candidate, even if something good were to come from it.[/quote]


I agree.

Furthermore: How are they going to measure how many aborotions are performed? And is any abortion clinic going to really tell honestly how many were performed? Are the going to count first trimester abortions? Are they going to count Morning After Pill abortions?

I don't trust them as far as I can thow them. And I can't throw them. They are too heavy to even pick up.

Posted

[quote name='goldenchild17' post='1530876' date='May 16 2008, 10:12 PM']I agree that it would probably be a sin to vote 3rd party/indie IF a McCain presidency would result in far less abortions (overall, short-term and/or long-term). This is why I have no problem with someone who wants to vote for McCain if they really believe it will make a positive difference. I just personally don't believe it will make any difference and in the long-term will only hurt it worse. An enemy disguised as an ally is far worse than an enemy in the open, IMO.

but from a Catholic perspective I don't believe your second premise works. Again principle of ends not justifying the means. It's not okay to vote for an evil candidate, even if something good were to come from it.[/quote]
:cyclops: I disagree. all the reasons it is OK to vote for a third party candidate are still applicable even if McCain would result in a significant lessening of abortions. if this were the case, it might be even more impractical and maybe stupid, but so long as the person you vote for is a good candidate according to Catholic teaching, and you did not intend for a pro-choice candidate to win as a result of your vote, you have acted morally.

this would be a stronger argument in favor of the pragmatic political strategy of supporting McCain, but it would be only that and no one could be accused of sin for merely supporting someone who seemed a better candidate who was also pro-life.

Posted

[quote name='picchick' post='1531475' date='May 17 2008, 01:24 PM']Are they going to count Morning After Pill abortions?[/quote]

Wouldn't that be impossible?

The morning after pill is a "just in case" thing, there isn't really a way to tell if it aborted or prevented a pregnancy or not. Someone who took the morning after pill who doesn't get pregnant may not have ended up pregnant anyway.

:think:

cmotherofpirl
Posted

[quote name='Aloysius' post='1529219' date='May 15 2008, 05:24 AM']:yes: ... the ends neither justify nor condemn the means.

you can call it stupid and impractical, but you can't call it immoral according to Catholic morality.[/quote]
We are to wise as serpents and innocent as doves, I don't recall stupid being listed as a virtue.

Posted

[quote name='Alycin' post='1532073' date='May 18 2008, 12:14 AM']Wouldn't that be impossible?

The morning after pill is a "just in case" thing, there isn't really a way to tell if it aborted or prevented a pregnancy or not. Someone who took the morning after pill who doesn't get pregnant may not have ended up pregnant anyway.

:think:[/quote]

Exactly my point. There is no way to count it. Yet it is abortion nonetheless if the woman was pregnant, right? There is no way to count it yet we KNOW that it does cause abortion.

Posted

[quote name='picchick' post='1532494' date='May 18 2008, 05:24 PM']Exactly my point. There is no way to count it. Yet it is abortion nonetheless if the woman was pregnant, right? There is no way to count it yet we KNOW that it does cause abortion.[/quote]


yeah. i think a lot of people are led to believe that it's somehow less evil, akin to how they feel about birth control. i always wonder how many people on any given day have popped the morning after pill with as little feeling as if it were a tic-tac. :sadder:

Norseman82
Posted

[quote name='cmotherofpirl' post='1532084' date='May 18 2008, 12:27 AM']I don't recall stupid being listed as a virtue.[/quote]

but it is a gift of God that must not be misused........

Seriously, though, there is a significant enough difference on the life issues between McCain and Hillabama, and until those differences evaporate (like if McCain chose a pro-abortion running mate like Lieberman or backtracks in teh debaltes this fall), then we should not be playing "the whole loaf or none" games, since those who insist on the whole loaf often end up with none. (The exception being if you live in such an overwhelming blue state that McCain would get creamed anyway, but there may be risks involved there).

Posted

[quote name='cmotherofpirl' post='1532084' date='May 18 2008, 01:27 AM']We are to wise as serpents and innocent as doves, I don't recall stupid being listed as a virtue.[/quote]
I don't consider it stupid, I said people are free to call it stupid. Myself, I don't think supporting lost causes even though they are futile is stupid at all.

goldenchild17
Posted (edited)

[quote name='Aloysius' post='1531525' date='May 17 2008, 01:00 PM']:cyclops: I disagree. all the reasons it is OK to vote for a third party candidate are still applicable even if McCain would result in a significant lessening of abortions. if this were the case, it might be even more impractical and maybe stupid, but so long as the person you vote for is a good candidate according to Catholic teaching, and you did not intend for a pro-choice candidate to win as a result of your vote, you have acted morally.

this would be a stronger argument in favor of the pragmatic political strategy of supporting McCain, but it would be only that and no one could be accused of sin for merely supporting someone who seemed a better candidate who was also pro-life.[/quote]

I don't necessarily have a problem with that, but just personally I'm a little uncomfortable with it due to some of the manuals from the 50's (don't know where it's addressed elsewhere pre-vat):

[quote]205. – 3. Election of good representatives.

[b]Voting is a civic duty which would seem to bind at least under venial sin whenever a good candidate has an unworthy opponent. It might even be a mortal sin if one’s refusal to vote would result in the election of an unworthy candidate.[/b]

One may vote for an unworthy candidate only when this is necessary to prevent a still less worthy candidate from obtaining office; but in such a case one should explain the reason for his action if this is possible. In an exceptional case one may vote for some unworthy candidate; viz., if he can thereby avert some unusually great personal disadvantage." (Jone - Moral Theology[/quote]

I think if it could be demonstrated that McCain was for sure a far less evil then I give some credibility to the idea that as a Catholic we may have to vote for him. Not saying I'm right, and most definitely not saying this actually applies to him (because I don't find him of significant difference from Obama).

Bush might be a good example of a borderline call. I don't think he was great by any means in terms of abortion, and his policies in regards to a lot of other things made in less than ideal in my opinion. But when compared to Kerry, I think it was demonstrable that Bush was far better, and in actuality (while not perfect) he did a lot of good pro-life things. Voting for him (which is now not in agreement with my preferred political practice) doesn't really help the idea of improving the Republican Party and bringing it back to conservatism. But I do believe he was sufficiently better than Kerry that it may have been somewhat obligatory to vote for him. I think with McCain it is a totally different story, but the principle (were it applicable in this race) may be the same.

Edited by goldenchild17
Posted

a protest vote for someone with no chance of winning is a half a vote, I believe in making sure my vote counts..I can't stand McCain and would never vote for a democrat like Clinton or Obama, but I'll probably end up voting for McCain..

Posted

[quote name='slywakka250' post='1533491' date='May 19 2008, 01:20 PM']a protest vote for someone with no chance of winning is a half a vote, I believe in making sure my vote counts..I can't stand McCain and would never vote for a democrat like Clinton or Obama, but I'll probably end up voting for McCain..[/quote]

What does "making my vote count" mean? Is it an economic thing? Is it a philosophical issue?

Your vote is your choice. Plain and simple.

Posted

it says refusing to vote can be a sin if that causes an unworthy candidate to succeed, because refusing to vote is a sinful act in and of itself and it says it can be mortal if it causes an unworthy candidate to succeed. voting third party is not a sinful act, it is a good act; if there is an unintended evil effect to your good act, you are not sinning.

cmotherofpirl
Posted

[quote name='Aloysius' post='1533773' date='May 19 2008, 05:01 PM']it says refusing to vote can be a sin if that causes an unworthy candidate to succeed, because refusing to vote is a sinful act in and of itself and it says it can be mortal if it causes an unworthy candidate to succeed. voting third party is not a sinful act, it is a good act; if there is an unintended evil effect to your good act, you are not sinning.[/quote]
But you see you can't claim it unintended can you, since you know that the election of Obama/Clinton will result in the death of more and more babies, and by throwing your vote away you are complicit in evil. You can throw all the excuses out you want, but when the fate of babies and the elderly and disabled hang in the balance, it becomes somewhat more than an quixotic academic exercise!!!

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...