Galloglasses Posted July 28, 2008 Posted July 28, 2008 [quote name='Era Might' post='1610819' date='Jul 28 2008, 05:01 PM']In the United States, I don't think "ethnicity" and "race" are necessarily equivalent words. For example, someone might refer to "ethnic" parishes, which can be Polish, Italian, Irish, etc. However, when someone uses the word "race," they usually mean skin color and general physical attributes, and not necessarily culture. In the common American usage of the word "race," I would say that everyone is grouped into a short list of races: white, black, Hispanic, Asian, and perhaps Native American. It's not an exact definition of where you come from or what you look like, just a general categorization. If you are Asian, you may be from Japan, China, Korea, Vietnam, etc. But you will be categorized into the general Asian "race" because you have the general characteristics of an Asian person. If you are white, you will be categorized as white, even though white people can be from different continents (North America, Europe, Australia). "Ethnicity" refers more to culture than to general physical characteristics. Irish and Italian would be seen as different ethnicities, but not necessarily different races.[/quote] I already touched upon racial groups in my first post in this thread, i'm aware of it. And In American that is true, but as I stated before there are racial differences within these racial Groups, so ethnicity can be considered interchangeable with the word Race. So, argueably, an Irish and an Italian Parish can be considered racially as well as culturally different. Its just that Ethnicity is a safer word to use.
Era Might Posted July 28, 2008 Posted July 28, 2008 [quote name='Galloglasses' post='1610878' date='Jul 28 2008, 05:26 PM']I already touched upon racial groups in my first post in this thread, i'm aware of it. And In American that is true, but as I stated before there are racial differences within these racial Groups, so ethnicity can be considered interchangeable with the word Race. So, argueably, an Irish and an Italian Parish can be considered racially as well as culturally different. Its just that Ethnicity is a safer word to use.[/quote] I was addressing the two words specifically in common American usage. I don't think "ethnicity" is just another way to say "race." They have different meanings. Race refers to general physical characteristics, while ethnicity refers more to culture. Irish and Italian may or may not be racially different, but in America they will both be seen as the same race: white. However, they are seen as different ethnicities. This is reflected in the old ethnic parishes in the United States. There are Polish parishes, Italian parishes, German parishes, etc. But there are no "white" parishes, because "white" is not seen as an ethnicity, but rather as a race. Interestingly, some American communities (mostly Protestant) did (and do) identify as "black churches." I think that is because black Americans were historically seen by race, not by ethnicity, so race has become a major part of their American identity. A white American (particularly immigrants) would more likely identify by ethnicity, not by race. In the past, there was some discrimination against white immigrants by white Americans, not because the immigrants were white, but because of their foreign ethnicity. I'm not arguing whether or not the common American usage of the words "race" and "ethnicity" are accurate. I'm just pointing out that the two words do not necessarily mean the same thing in America.
Era Might Posted July 28, 2008 Posted July 28, 2008 [quote name='cmotherofpirl' post='1610847' date='Jul 28 2008, 05:14 PM']So are you saying race is a color and ethnicity is a culture?[/quote] In the common usage of those two words, then I think that is an accurate distinction. Although I would say that race is not just used to refer to skin color, but rather to general physical characteristics, which can include skin color. A black American and a person from Latin America with dark skin might have similar skin colors, but I think most people would recognize one as black and the other as Hispanic. I think we have to distinguish between the common usage of the word "race," and its technical or scientific meaning. The common usage does not try to be too technical, it is just a general categorization based on general physical characteristics.
VeniteAdoremus Posted July 29, 2008 Posted July 29, 2008 If I'm filling out a Dutch questionnaire/form and ethnicity comes up, it's always done like "Where were you born?" (The Netherlands/Western Europe/Other) "Where was your mother born?" (same options) "Where was your father born?" (same options) Often the options are a bit more diverse (up to a complete list of countries), this is the bare minimum. But still, you can be born somewhere else, and your parents too, but assimilate so thoroughly that you'd be considered Dutch anyway. Most people have trouble identifying my foster dad as Swiss, and he beat me at the Dutch Dictionary game (okay, it was eight years ago, but I can't let it go just yet) - yet he only moved here after college and still almost exclusively speaks Swiss German with his wife. I don't think it means so much. And according to PP I'm a minority in this country (100% ethnic Dutch tracing back to 1652), so I'm allowed to say that, aren't I?
dUSt Posted August 1, 2008 Posted August 1, 2008 Race is a social construct. Therefore, our race is determined predominantly by our skin color and physical features, since that is how society would judge a person on a superficial level. Secondary factors, which would not be immediately disposed to society, would be culture and behavior.
cmotherofpirl Posted August 1, 2008 Author Posted August 1, 2008 [quote name='dUSt' post='1615210' date='Aug 1 2008, 03:43 PM']Race is a social construct. Therefore, our race is determined predominantly by our skin color and physical features, since that is how society would judge a person on a superficial level. Secondary factors, which would not be immediately disposed to society, would be culture and behavior.[/quote] Thank you. So what "race" is a biracial baby, since most are neither "black" or "white" or whatever other mix [asian, indian, native american]? The culture of their parents?
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now