Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Snowflake3981
Posted

[post="0"]http://www.foxnews.com/story/0,2933,464024,00.html[/post]

Excerpt:

"SAN FRANCISCO — Some same-sex marriage supporters are urging people to "call in gay" Wednesday to show how much the country relies on gays and lesbians, but others question whether it's wise to encourage skipping work given the nation's economic distress.

Organizers of "Day Without a Gay" — scheduled to coincide with International Human Rights Day and modeled after similar work stoppages by Latino immigrants — also are encouraging people to perform volunteer work and refrain from spending money.

Sean Hetherington, a West Hollywood comedian and personal trainer, dreamed up the idea with his boyfriend, Aaron Hartzler, after reading online that a few angry gay-rights activists were calling for a daylong strike to protest California voters' passage last month of Proposition 8, which reversed this year's state Supreme Court decision allowing gay marriage.

The couple thought it would be more effective and less divisive if people were asked to perform community service instead of staying home with their wallets shut. Dozens of nonprofit agencies, from the National Women's Law Center in Washington to a Methodist church in Fresno collecting food for the homeless, have posted opportunities for volunteers on the couple's Web site.

"We are all for a boycott if that is what brings about a sense of community for people," said Hetherington, 30, who plans to spend Wednesday volunteering at an inner-city school. "You can take away from the economy and give back in other ways."

Hetherington said he's been getting 100 e-mails an hour from people looking for volunteer opportunities, and that his "Day Without a Gay" Web site has gotten 100,000 hits since mid-November.

Despite Hartzler and Hetherington's attempt to fashion a positive approach, some organizers of the street demonstrations that drew massive crowds in many cities last month have been reluctant to embrace the concept, saying that it could be at best impractical and at worst counterproductive to "call in gay."

"It's extra-challenging for people to think about taking off work as a form of protest, given that we are talking about people who may not be out (as gay) at work, and given the current economic situation and job market," said Jules Graves, 38, coordinator of the Colorado qwerty Straight Alliance. "There is really not any assurance employers would appreciate it for what it is."

Graves' group nonetheless is arranging for interested participants to volunteer at the local African Community Center in Denver. The agency said it could find projects to keep 20 people busy, but so far only 10 have pledged to show up, said Graves.

Scott Craig, a fifth-grade teacher at Independence Charter School in Philadelphia, had no problem requesting and being granted the day off. So many of the school's 60 teachers were eager to show support for gay rights they had to make sure enough stayed behind to staff classrooms.

About 25 teachers plan to take Wednesday off and to have their work covered by substitutes while they discuss ways to introduce gay issues to their students and volunteer at the local branch of the American Civil Liberties Union, Craig said. A letter telling parents why so many teachers would be out went home Monday.

"We want to get the conversation going in the community that gay is not bad," Craig said. "For kids to hear that in a positive light can be life-changing."

Join The Impact, the online community that launched protests last month over the passage of gay marriage bans in California, Florida and Arizona, has urged people to withdraw $80 from their bank accounts Wednesday to demonstrate gays' spending power, and to devote the time they might otherwise spend watching TV or surfing the Internet to volunteer work.

Witeck-Combs Communications, a public relations firm in Washington that specializes in the gay and lesbian market, published a study this year that estimated that gay and lesbian consumers spend $700 billion annually.

Bob Witeck, the firm's chief executive officer, said it would be difficult to measure the success of Wednesday's strike since gay employees occupy so many fields. And rather than suspending all consumer spending for the day, gay rights supporters would have a bigger impact if they devoted their dollars to gay-friendly businesses year-round, Witeck said.

"Our community leaders who are running book stores, newspapers, flower shops, coffee houses, bars and many, many other things are hurting right now, so paying attention to their needs during this hard time is an effective form of activism," he said.

Hetherington said he has been careful to design A Day Without a Gay — he came up with the name after the film "A Day Without a Mexican" and liked it because it rhymed — so no one feels excluded or threatened.

He has specifically urged high school students not to walk out of their classes and assured college students they won't be disloyal to the cause if they go ahead and take their final exams. He also has listed opportunities — ranging from writing letters to members of Congress about federal gay rights legislation to spreading the word about Wednesday on social networking sites — for gay marriage backers who cannot miss work."


---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------


There is so much I find appaling in this article, especially this (bolding added by me):
"About 25 teachers plan to take Wednesday off and to have their work covered by substitutes [b]while they discuss ways to introduce gay issues to their students[/b] and volunteer at the local branch of the American Civil Liberties Union, Craig said. A letter telling parents why so many teachers would be out went home Monday."

Why do schools and teachers take it upon themselves to teach controversial things to children? Why not just stick to math, reading, history, etc. Christians, especially Catholics need to be very involved in what is going on in there classrooms to ensure your religious and moral beliefs are upheld, and its sad that you have to worry about public schools teaching these types of things to your children. This is just one of the many reasons why I would not want my children to go to public school, and why I think so highly of homeschooling. (I do not have any children, BTW, just my $0.02).

What do you think of how this "calling in gay" movement will affect the acceptance of gays? Do you think this effort will harm or hurt them? Do you think it will be successful? This is the first I've heard of this and this is supposed to take place tomorrow.

The guy I work with very closely in my dept. is gay and I'm going to ask him if I should expect him to call in tomorrow... :detective:

Posted

When I was a kid, the union did this thing where they traded their pay checks in for all silver dollars, and paid for everything for the month with those as a visible reminder to people of how much money union workers put into the economy. My mom practically got a hernia carrying them to the grocery store. So I know those kind of protests can work, but the idea is to show contributions, and not going to work doesn't contribute to anything. I guess in their place, I'd be afraid that I'd just give my boss an excuse to fire me.

Posted

well, it seems like they are still trying to work out a way to make it happen, without the repercussions. i did like that they specifically asked students not to skip out on their studies, whereas other unions around here have done the opposite(the kids and i liked having a day off, but still should have been involved.)

having the gay issues in the school? not a problem for me, its not like teaching people not to be racist ever made people black, and i doubt teaching tolerance of gay people will do anything of the sort. if it stops kids from jeering and calling each other "gay"(a stupid insult anyways) that would be just great.

homeschoolmom
Posted

[quote name='CatherineM' post='1723288' date='Dec 9 2008, 01:00 PM']When I was a kid, the union did this thing where they traded their pay checks in for all silver dollars, and paid for everything for the month with those as a visible reminder to people of how much money union workers put into the economy. My mom practically got a hernia carrying them to the grocery store. So I know those kind of protests can work, but the idea is to show contributions, and not going to work doesn't contribute to anything. I guess in their place, I'd be afraid that I'd just give my boss an excuse to fire me.[/quote]
That's actually a pretty interesting thing to do. Those Eisenhauer dollars are not light, either... Yikes.

Posted

I don't know that it is a great idea, but who knows. I'm gay and I have to go to school tomorrow (finals! eek!), but I think just dropping out of the world might make someone take notice. The organizers are encouraging us to volunteer tomorrow and saying that those of us who work for GLBT organizations should go to work. Quite a few people I know are taking the day off to work for all sorts of groups here in LA.

The really really crazy thing is that in my home state and 29 others if I called in gay, literally said, "I'm gay," at all, they could legally fire me. That's just wrong. Fine, people don't want me to get married, whatever. I'd like to but it's another discussion. This kind of protest has been shining a bit of light on how unfair it is that in 30 states people can get fired for who they love. It's also been shining a light on the fact that we, the gays, do count and should count legally.

Just my opinion on the thing. I'll be test taking and studying all day so whatever.

eagle_eye222001
Posted

This idea of calling in because of gay is as ridiculous as the [b]Don't buy gas day.[/b]

This is a feel good protest that have as much effect as the [b]Don't buy gas day.[/b] (ZERO)

Actually I lied. There will be an effect. Angry bosses.

What is ironic is that the idea of a protest is to stop something and hold up something while making a statement. Since the teachers have already notified the school several days before the event, does that not take away the real idea of a protest? I mean, the school has substitutes waiting. That kind of takes away the shock, halt, stop and protest. It's like a union telling a factory that in a week they will go on strike so they better get someone to cover for them. :rolleyes:

Again, this is a BS FEEL GOOD protest that will have no effect except rile off some bosses.

If anything this will hurt the gay movement as I see them ticking more people off than winning over.


----------------
Now playing: [url="http://www.foxytunes.com/artist/john+lennon/track/happy+xmas+(war+is+over)"]John Lennon - Happy Xmas (War Is Over)[/url]
via [url="http://www.foxytunes.com/signatunes/"]FoxyTunes[/url]

Posted

[quote name='track2004' post='1723524' date='Dec 9 2008, 06:34 PM']The really really crazy thing is that in my home state and 29 others if I called in gay, literally said, "I'm gay," at all, they could legally fire me.[/quote]
You mean if you called in to protest the non-expansion of marriage, you could be fired?

Good.

There are reasons to call in to work, and protesting that everyone has the same rights as everyone else is not one of them. It's abuse of leave time and it should be punished, possibly with termination.

dominicansoul
Posted

i don't think there will be a big difference if all gays called in "gay" in texas...

...maybe just a slight percentage of businesses would be affected...

with the only exception being that it may shut down the whole city of Austin...

Posted

[quote name='Winchester' post='1723547' date='Dec 9 2008, 08:48 PM']You mean if you called in to protest the non-expansion of marriage, you could be fired?

Good.

There are reasons to call in to work, and protesting that everyone has the same rights as everyone else is not one of them. It's abuse of leave time and it should be punished, possibly with termination.[/quote]

Actually here, in CA, Prop 8 TOOK my right to marry away. When I moved here in July I COULD get married, now I can NOT. Everywhere else you can argue that, but not here, not to me.

Sexual Orientation is not a protected class in most states, so back where I come from my bosses, landlords, etc could discriminate against me for it. Any day of the year, for any reason, they could fire me (or kick me out of my appt) for being gay. People should be fired for being bad at their job, not because of who they go home to.

Besides if homosexuality is something that needs to be fixed or maybe even "cured" then couldn't we call in gay everyday, wouldn't it be like calling in with the flu?

Posted

[quote name='eagle_eye222001' post='1723537' date='Dec 9 2008, 08:42 PM']Again, this is a BS FEEL GOOD protest that will have no effect except rile off some bosses.

----------------
Now playing: [url="http://www.foxytunes.com/artist/john+lennon/track/happy+xmas+(war+is+over)"]John Lennon - Happy Xmas (War Is Over)[/url]
via [url="http://www.foxytunes.com/signatunes/"]FoxyTunes[/url][/quote]

Would you rather us do something else, something more drastic. Pacifist protests are cute, and sometimes they work, but I'm all for [i]fighting[/i] for my rights. I think a drastic move would be good for us, but none of the protest options ever quite work; they all "rile" off someone, and maybe that's the point.

We all plan on staying home for a day: bosses are "riled" up; we march once a year to remember Stonewall: right wing extremists are "riled" up; we fight for HIV/AIDS awareness: it gets labeled a 'gay disease'; we protest because the state allowed people to take our rights away: people complain, say it was a 'popular vote' and we should be quiet.

The POINT of protests is to RILE people. Things need to change and that doesn't happen without a fight. This protest might not work because it isn't as confrontational as it should be, as it could be. We're trying to stand up for ourselves without offending American 'sensabilities.' Let the bosses be upset because God knows we are.

Posted

Track - I can highly recommend the Courage group to you. I'll bet LA has a local meeting, but if not go to their web site. We are all given crosses, and the one you have received is one of the heaviest, but you can still live a full life in the church.

Posted

[quote name='track2004' post='1723566' date='Dec 9 2008, 07:01 PM']Actually here, in CA, Prop 8 TOOK my right to marry away. When I moved here in July I COULD get married, now I can NOT. Everywhere else you can argue that, but not here, not to me.

Sexual Orientation is not a protected class in most states, so back where I come from my bosses, landlords, etc could discriminate against me for it. Any day of the year, for any reason, they could fire me (or kick me out of my appt) for being gay. People should be fired for being bad at their job, not because of who they go home to.

Besides if homosexuality is something that needs to be fixed or maybe even "cured" then couldn't we call in gay everyday, wouldn't it be like calling in with the flu?[/quote]
Yes, you can get married. Nothing is preventing you from getting married. You are permitted, like everyone else, to marry a member of the opposite sex of legal age. You have the exact same rights as me, and everyone lost the legal right to marry members of the same sex. You're not being singled out, nor is your social group.

You can't legally be fired for being gay any more than someone can be fired for being Catholic. You can be fired for any number of heterosexual acts (asking someone out once is enough to get nailed) as well as homosexual.

Posted

CatherineM: I appreciate it, but I'm not interested. At all.

Winchester: I could get married to some boy, but the vows I took wouldn't be true. I'd have some legally sanctioned union and get all the benefits and responsibilities, sure. But if I can do that with any man, why can't I do that with a girl? If I get married to a guy it won't be the holy, child-producing, etcetc you'd want, it'd be a legal contract. Why can't I have the loving family I want? Why can you be happily married but I cannot?

Also, discrimination based on sexual orientation is still legal and prevalent. True, most jobs are ones where you can get fired at will for any reason, but the government has stepped in and protected classes of people: women, ethnic minorities, the elderly, etc. They have done this because it was a problem, because in a job where everyone could be fired for any reason, those people were getting fired more often and for silly reasons. I don't know if it's a big problem (live in CA now, where we are protected, and worked for large gay-friendly companies in IN) but I know it's a problem.

This is my life, my family, my future, and I'll fight for it to be the best it can be. This is a deeply personal issue for me. It is about who I love, who I go home to at night, and the rights we (don't) have.

Posted

Again, it is about the rights no one has.

There's nothing in the law about happiness or love. It's about a legal recognition, and your rights are the same as anyone else.

No, discrimination based upon sexuality is not. You have yet to cite a law protecting it. Your orientation is not comparable so sex or race or physical disability. It is a mental predilection, whether or not it's an illness. Your behaviors are your choice. Perhaps not a free choice, I agree. I don't carry the burden of wanting something with all my person of which society does not approve. But that doesn't change reality.

Posted

[url="http://www.nolo.com/article.cfm/objectId/E76BEBE6-E194-46C1-983629F17557E86D/catID/DE34C24C-9CBE-42EF-917012F2F6758F92/111/259/283/ART/"]http://www.nolo.com/article.cfm/objectId/E...11/259/283/ART/[/url]

[quote]Sexual Orientation Discrimination in the Workplace

A growing number of states prohibit discrimination against gay and lesbian employees.

Traditionally, gay and lesbian employees have found little in the law to protect them from discrimination and harassment in the workplace. Times are changing, however, and a growing number of employers are finding themselves responsible for providing a workplace that's free of harassment and discrimination based on sexual orientation.
Antidiscrimination Laws

Federal laws. While there is no federal law that prohibits this type of discrimination in private employment, an executive order specifically outlaws discrimination based on sexual orientation in the federal government.

If you are a private employer and you operate your business in a state, county, or city with a law or ordinance prohibiting sexual orientation discrimination, you must follow that law despite the fact that there is no federal law in place.

State laws. Seventeen states and the District of Columbia have laws that currently prohibit sexual orientation discrimination in private employment: California, Connecticut, Hawaii, Illinois, Maine, Maryland, Massachusetts, Minnesota, Nevada, New Hampshire, New Jersey, New Mexico, New York, Rhode Island, Vermont, Washington, and Wisconsin. Some of these states also specifically prohibit discrimination based on gender identity. (In addition, six states have laws prohibiting sexual orientation discrimination in public workplaces only: Colorado, Delaware, Indiana, Michigan, Montana, and Pennsylvania.)

Local laws. Locally, more than 180 cities and counties nationwide prohibit sexual orientation discrimination in at least some workplaces -- from Albany, New York to Ypsilanti, Michigan.

To find out whether your state, county, or city has a law prohibiting discrimination on the basis of sexual orientation, contact your state labor department or your state fair employment office. You can also visit the Lambda Legal Defense and Education Fund website at www.lambdalegal.org, where you will find a state-by-state list of antidiscrimination laws, including city and county ordinances.[/quote]

Your argument about my rights being the same as everyone else's fails on a very fundamental level. So I can marry a boy and you (presumably because of that dashing picture) can marry a lady, true. If we're in an argument about what marriage means, not the legal contract, but the actual union of two people, then I don't get the rights you do. I don't get to pick the person I want to have the contract either. It'd be like lefties made to live in world where they were forced to be righty's else they were admonished. People are different, things happen. In real life you get to do things and enjoy life in a way I can't, either because of who I am or because of the laws.

Oddly, this has turned into me wanting to have a family and a loving spouse, and you telling me it's not right. I find that funny because usually it's the other way around. I have all the legal right you do, but I cannot marry the person I want to, I can't raise the family I want to, I can't grow old with the person I want to AND be protected like you and your family will be. I could get married to a boy OR I could just live with a girl and adopt or have kids. BUT either way I won't be enjoying the same benefits and responsibilities you have with your (theoretical, at least) spouse. I want those.

I think this falls under the "pursuit of happiness" part of that "life, liberty, & the pursuit of happiness" business.

Posted

[quote name='track2004' post='1723632' date='Dec 9 2008, 08:24 PM']Your argument about my rights being the same as everyone else's fails on a very fundamental level. So I can marry a boy and you (presumably because of that dashing picture) can marry a lady, true. If we're in an argument about what marriage means, not the legal contract, but the actual union of two people, then I don't get the rights you do. I don't get to pick the person I want to have the contract either. It'd be like lefties made to live in world where they were forced to be righty's else they were admonished. People are different, things happen. In real life you get to do things and enjoy life in a way I can't, either because of who I am or because of the laws.

Oddly, this has turned into me wanting to have a family and a loving spouse, and you telling me it's not right. I find that funny because usually it's the other way around. I have all the legal right you do, but I cannot marry the person I want to, I can't raise the family I want to, I can't grow old with the person I want to AND be protected like you and your family will be. I could get married to a boy OR I could just live with a girl and adopt or have kids. BUT either way I won't be enjoying the same benefits and responsibilities you have with your (theoretical, at least) spouse. I want those.

I think this falls under the "pursuit of happiness" part of that "life, liberty, & the pursuit of happiness" business.[/quote]
No, it does not fail. There is no legal right to marry the person you want to marry. There is no legal right enforcing happiness or anything beyond legal recognition and the benefits thereof. Unless you're dating women, you can't make the claim you just made. There are people out there who never find the perfect marriage partner--even ones who are trying--there's no law guaranteeing they will.

This is the right: To marry a member of the opposite sex of legal age. That's the right. No more, no less. Any mental impediment to your enjoyment is your problem. Not society's, not the state's. We don't make allowances for polygamists, pedophiles or those who fall in love with their siblings, either. Because it's not about love. That isn't a requirement or an assurance.


Good analogy with the handedness. It is like that. But I don't attach any moral significance to handedness, so it's going to fail on me. But good analogy.

Listen. We're not going to agree, and the arguments I use are going to hurt you. I don't have the same issue you have. I think it's an issue, and you don't. It's a disorder, whatever its cause. Like any other predilection to any other sin. Like any mental problem. Treatable or not. That's how I see it, and I don't see any way I could avoid hurting you by saying it, but you have decided to step into my territory so there it is. Eventually, your side will win this battle--that's where society is going. You might not live to see it, but you probably will unless you're in your sixties. You will never have the happiness possible in my marriage. I know lots of gay couples, and they're not the same. I'm sorry. I mean it, and it's not pity. You don't want my pity. You might want my anger. You might want justification to hate people who oppose the expansion of the definition of marriage. You might want some kind of warm feeling from combat, I don't know. But you didn't come here to make nice--I [i]know [/i]that. Here's your fight, if you want it. When I have time, of course.

Another thing. You don't want what I have. You want the same results from a different action. It's like wanting to taste steak when you eat fish. You're not eating steak, though. Like wanting to put out a fire by throwing gasoline on it. Ain't gonna happen. Sorry. Not pity, just fact.

You're not going the same way, so you don't get to the same place.

I had a partner a few years ago that was a lesbian. She's my friend. I love her. I remember how she told me she wished she liked men--how easy it would be, and it just broke my heart. The world is a cruel place, and no law will change that for you. It might make it easier to pretend. Hell, you might fool yourself. But the world will still be cruel. Will still be fallen.

I'm sorry.

Posted

[quote name='track2004' post='1723632' date='Dec 9 2008, 08:24 PM']I think this falls under the "pursuit of happiness" part of that "life, liberty, & the pursuit of happiness" business.[/quote]
You don't want to use that argument.

Posted

I'm cool with you disagreeing with me, Winchester, that's fine. I appreciate your post, and I am oddly proud of myself that you liked the handedness part*.

I am dating women (theoretically, at least) and Prop 8 hurt. It took something away from me, the hope that one day I could marry the girl of my dreams. I understand that you and other people here aren't going to agree with that, but I want you to understand it hurt. We can debate for days about whether my 'lifestyle' is wrong or immoral and if the state should even be the judge of that, but in the end life would be easier if I liked boys.

Most days all I want is for everyone to see that all these gay rights issues they're voting on aren't for some imaginary group of people far away. It's for people you work for, and with, and people you love; real people. Maybe tomorrow will show people that because while I can't convince you I'll be able to convince other people. You'll fight me every step of the way, but you're a good guy, we just disagree.



*(I'm not going to make it an issue but handedness used to have a moral qualifier on it to hence "sinister" meaning lefty.)

Posted

Hey, I missed the Doc reference, darn it. Passed it right over.

Doc's better looking and smoother, but I do okay.

Posted

For what it's worth, I don't think of you as imaginary or far away. Certainly because of personal experience. I don't like the God hates... tactics, and I don't support that element of the opposition. Unfortunately, the fight is carried in part by the lowest common denominator, so we'll have to endure them--you more than I, of course.

I should have scrolled you profile. Assumptions make an ass out of you and umption.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...