Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

[quote name='Apotheoun' post='1728143' date='Dec 15 2008, 04:01 AM']That is a cope out, because you are making a positive claim, i.e., that homosexual activity is moral.[/quote]

I never claimed it was moral.


[quote]Ah, I bow before your superior argument. Oh wait, you haven't presented an argument, but then you never really do present one.[/quote]

Fine, let's look at your insightfull argument.

"My position is rational, because I look at a thing in order to discover its purpose or meaning; while your position is irrational, in that it is not founded upon an investigation of the matter at hand, but is based purely upon a subjective assumption."


Your position is rational because you "look at a thing in order to discover its purpose or meaning" which of course presupposes a teological biology, the very thing you have yet to demonstrate. Such a presupposition is particularly unwarrented as modern biology is distinctly non-teological. You then somehow claim that by position is "irrational" because "it is not founded upon an investigation of the matter at hadn". What matter at hand? Homosexuality? I know what it is, I have not investigated biology for some hidden teology because I have been presented no evidence for it and it is strictly antithetical with modern biology. There is no "subjective assumption" on my part, I have simply asked you to prove your claim that homosexuality is immoral.

Posted (edited)

[quote name='Hassan' post='1728146' date='Dec 15 2008, 01:08 AM']Your position is rational because you "look at a thing in order to discover its purpose or meaning" which of course presupposes a teological biology, the very thing you have yet to demonstrate. Such a presupposition is particularly unwarrented as modern biology is distinctly non-teological. You then somehow claim that by position is "irrational" because "it is not founded upon an investigation of the matter at hadn". What matter at hand? Homosexuality? I know what it is, I have not investigated biology for some hidden teology because I have been presented no evidence for it and it is strictly antithetical with modern biology. There is no "subjective assumption" on my part, I have simply asked you to prove your claim that homosexuality is immoral.[/quote]
Evidently in your universe there is no meaning to anything. But of course that ultimately entails a denial that man can ever discover the end or purpose of any thing, which simply involves positing an irrational view of the world. That you do not like to have your position called irrational is not my problem; it is your problem.

That said, certainly you admit that the rectum has a natural biological function, so what is that function?

Edited by Apotheoun
Posted

[quote name='Hassan' post='1728146' date='Dec 15 2008, 01:08 AM']Your position is rational because you "look at a thing in order to discover its purpose or meaning" which of course presupposes a teological biology, the very thing you have yet to demonstrate.[/quote]
I hold that the universe has meaning, and that man as a rational animal can discover that meaning; while you hold that there is no meaning in the universe, and that position involves embracing irrationality.

Posted

[quote name='Apotheoun' post='1728148' date='Dec 15 2008, 04:13 AM']Evidently in your universe there is no meaning to anything.[/quote]

that's a very general statement.

[quote]But of course that ultimately involves a denial that man can ever discover the end or purpose of a thing, which simply involves positing an irrational view of the world.[/quote]

No, it is a non-teological view of the world.

[quote]That you do not like to have your position called irrational is not my problem, it is your problem.[/quote]

lol.

My position is non-teological not irrational. You need to learn to distinguish the two.


[quote]That said, certainly you admit that the rectum has a natural biological function, so what is that function?[/quote]


Sure it has a biological function. That does not mean that function is normative or has some pre-ordained "end" and any action contrary to it is immoral.

Posted

Even from a linguistic viewpoint your position is irrational, because logos (reason) indicates that there is a purpose to things, and since you deny that there is a logos to things, you are embracing irrationality.

Posted

[quote name='Hassan' post='1728150' date='Dec 15 2008, 01:18 AM']Sure it has a biological function. That does not mean that function is normative or has some pre-ordained "end" and any action contrary to it is immoral.[/quote]
I will accept your position the moment that you stop using your rectum for its biological purpose, but then you will of course be full of sh-t.

:)

Posted

[quote name='Apotheoun' post='1728149' date='Dec 15 2008, 04:17 AM']I hold that the universe has meaning[/quote]

Sure, you assume it. Outside of a teological presupposition your sexual ethics cannot be demonstrated and you have no right to impose your metaphysical assumptions on others.

[quote]and that man as a rational animal can discover that meaning; while you hold that there is no meaning in the universe, and that position involves embracing irrationality.[/quote]

No. I say I have seen no evidence for a teological Universe. You need to show exactly how a non-teological universe means embracing irrationality.

Posted

[quote name='Apotheoun' post='1728153' date='Dec 15 2008, 04:21 AM']I will accept your position the moment that you stop using your rectum for its biological purpose, but then you will of course be full of sh-t.

:)[/quote]

Lol.

It's 3:23, I have to get to bed. But that totally made my day: )

I hope we will continue this tomorrow?

Have a nice night.

Posted

[quote name='Hassan' post='1728154' date='Dec 15 2008, 01:22 AM']Sure, you assume it. Outside of a teological presupposition your sexual ethics cannot be demonstrated and you have no right to impose your metaphysical assumptions on others.[/quote]
And you keep assuming that there is no "end" to things. Why should I accept your irrational assumption?

Posted

I don't know if it will matter to either of you, but generally the courts will consider moral not on biology or rhetoric, but on legality. This isn't always the case, but because gay sex isn't illegal I doubt they'd say it was immoral.

"Pursuit of happiness" is defined as moral pursuits, but the court couldn't say something that wasn't illegal was immoral. If it was so morally blameworthy they'd make it a crime. They just made it (in the last 50 years) [b]not[/b] a crime.

You're arguing about the sex, the marriage is a better debate to have this about, but I bet it would still fall on my side.

dominicansoul
Posted

[quote name='track2004' post='1727882' date='Dec 14 2008, 06:17 PM']The argument about the governments involvement in marriage is something I'd probably agree with you about. But free association stops when you go to work. Do your job and keep your mouth shut about what everyone else does in their off hours if you disagree with it. Co-workers are not your friends; they're your colleagues.

The fact that Dominican and St T thought it was funny that people were so scared to be thought of as gay is upsetting.

(I's a lawyer too, or I will be in a few years. I hate being a 1L.)[/quote]
get over it, i'm not prejudiced against anybody! I'm the nicest person you could ever meet, and I treat anybody, gay, straight, dyslexic, disabled, straight, healthy, cancerous, bald, hairy, white, black, yellow, brown, liberal, democrat, republican, stupid, genius, witty, dull, Catholic, protestant, atheist, earth-worshipping, geniuses, angels, goats and sheep ALL ALIKE.

the fact that my sick co-workers were afraid to call in doesn't make me one bit prejudiced.

YOU jumped to conclusions and made a judgement against me. Everybody does it, so quit making out like your a victim in this world, 'cos you do it, too. You just did it to me...

chillax

Posted

Your post didn't send off that message, and if "everybody does it" at least own up to your own prejudices. Also please don't let goats and sheep use your compy, it doesn't work out well.

I wasn't making myself a victim. I just told you what I've seen and what's happened to me and mine. I'm sorry if I have a chip on my shoulder.

My post was, at least I think, a fairly rational and well explained reaction to why I thought your post was offensive. Respond to what I said, don't just tell me to "chillax." I's law student during finals week, I barely understand that word.

Posted

Since the Church has been under fire since well lets say the reformation. Catholics make up %25 of America and 1/6th of the world, why don't we as Catholics "call in Catholic" the next time the Gays, atheists, Muslims, protestants, or lets say any other one of our haters(ya I said haters). You know why because we are taught to turn the other cheek.

Posted

[quote name='Apotheoun' post='1728156' date='Dec 15 2008, 04:25 AM']And you keep assuming that there is no "end" to things. Why should I accept your irrational assumption?[/quote]


Because it is no assumption. A survey of modern biology shows no teological facet evident through the tools of modern scientific methodology. If you want to present a philosophical argument for some hidden teology that's fine, but at the moment there is no evidence for it. I am not aware of any major, respected biologist, even the great Christian biologists I know of(there certianly are a number of them) admit that for the puspore of science there is no evidence of teology.

Posted

Aren't you assuming that the scientific method is the only valid standard against which to measure these sorts of things?

Posted

[quote name='Arpy' post='1729284' date='Dec 16 2008, 01:24 AM']Aren't you assuming that the scientific method is the only valid standard against which to measure these sorts of things?[/quote]

Sure. I'm happy to move from raw scienticif naturalism, but it must be done so rationally, it can't just be an assumption.

Posted

Hassan, you still haven't answered the question :mellow: I see a lot of skirting the answer(s) you have as an option.

dominicansoul
Posted

[quote name='track2004' post='1728740' date='Dec 15 2008, 06:14 PM']Your post didn't send off that message, and if "everybody does it" at least own up to your own prejudices. Also please don't let goats and sheep use your compy, it doesn't work out well.

I wasn't making myself a victim. I just told you what I've seen and what's happened to me and mine. I'm sorry if I have a chip on my shoulder.

My post was, at least I think, a fairly rational and well explained reaction to why I thought your post was offensive. Respond to what I said, don't just tell me to "chillax." I's law student during finals week, I barely understand that word.[/quote]

[mod]Personal attack. --Era Might[/mod]

Posted

[quote name='dominicansoul' post='1729526' date='Dec 16 2008, 09:55 AM'][mod]Personal attack. --Era Might[/mod][/quote]

I just have to say ZING!

Posted

[quote name='Sacred Music Man' post='1729433' date='Dec 16 2008, 02:41 AM']Hassan, you still haven't answered the question :mellow: I see a lot of skirting the answer(s) you have as an option.[/quote]

I'm sorry, whcih question do you mean?

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...