track2004 Posted December 10, 2008 Posted December 10, 2008 I wish I was as cool as Doc. Seriously. I should quit law school, move to the desert, practice my gun slinging and go for it. You can join. I'll be the black hat to your white.
mommas_boy Posted December 10, 2008 Posted December 10, 2008 [quote name='Snowflake3981' post='1723277' date='Dec 9 2008, 12:50 PM'][b]Why do schools and teachers take it upon themselves to teach controversial things to children? Why not just stick to math, reading, history, etc.[/b] Christians, especially Catholics need to be very involved in what is going on in there classrooms to ensure your religious and moral beliefs are upheld, and its sad that you have to worry about public schools teaching these types of things to your children. This is just one of the many reasons why I would not want my children to go to public school, and why I think so highly of homeschooling. (I do not have any children, BTW, just my $0.02).[/quote] First off, I will say that I am against gay marriage. But, to answer your (seemingly rhetorical) question, it is important that controversial topics are discussed in schools, because where else will a student learn to discuss them in a charitable manner? Where else will a student learn to break through hype in a controversy in order to discover real truth? Where else will a student learn to be indignant with real injustice (proposition 8 is not an injustice, btw)? The only problem comes in who it is that gets to determine what topics are legitimate controversial topics, and what needs to be swept under the rug. While I don't think that we should be normalizing homosexual behavior and culture any more than what it already is, I think that there is some merit to discussing it in school as a means to teach tolerance for people (but not for their actions).
Jesus_lol Posted December 10, 2008 Posted December 10, 2008 [quote name='Winchester' post='1723595' date='Dec 9 2008, 05:34 PM']Yes, you can get married. Nothing is preventing you from getting married. You are permitted, like everyone else, to marry a member of the opposite sex of legal age. You have the exact same rights as me, and everyone lost the legal right to marry members of the same sex. You're not being singled out, nor is your social group.[/quote] speaking of good analogies, i particularily like the one in the second panel of this comic [img]http://i146.photobucket.com/albums/r267/diablo_man/equality.jpg[/img] btw, i didnt post this to call you a moron winchester!
missionseeker Posted December 10, 2008 Posted December 10, 2008 (edited) [quote name='track2004' post='1723632' date='Dec 9 2008, 09:24 PM']It'd be like lefties made to live in world where they were forced to be righty's[/quote] Can openers. Edited December 10, 2008 by missionseeker
homeschoolmom Posted December 10, 2008 Posted December 10, 2008 I was going to reply, but Winnie said pretty much what I was going to say and better than I would have said it.
Winchester Posted December 10, 2008 Posted December 10, 2008 [quote name='track2004' post='1723669' date='Dec 9 2008, 09:25 PM']I wish I was as cool as Doc. Seriously. I should quit law school, move to the desert, practice my gun slinging and go for it. You can join. I'll be the black hat to your white.[/quote] Always wanted to be a gunslinger.
Snowflake3981 Posted December 10, 2008 Author Posted December 10, 2008 [quote name='mommas_boy' post='1723875' date='Dec 10 2008, 01:03 AM']First off, I will say that I am against gay marriage. But, to answer your (seemingly rhetorical) question, it is important that controversial topics are discussed in schools, because where else will a student learn to discuss them in a charitable manner? Where else will a student learn to break through hype in a controversy in order to discover real truth? Where else will a student learn to be indignant with real injustice (proposition 8 is not an injustice, btw)? The only problem comes in who it is that gets to determine what topics are legitimate controversial topics, and what needs to be swept under the rug. While I don't think that we should be normalizing homosexual behavior and culture any more than what it already is, I think that there is some merit to discussing it in school as a means to teach tolerance for people (but not for their actions).[/quote] I agree that controversial topics should be discussed and debated in schools, obviously with limits. For example, I don't think homosexuality should be discussed in preschool or elementary school, but I am open to its discussion in a junior high or high school debate class or social issues class. Reading the books to preschoolers about kids having 2 mommies, I think that crosses the line. You make a great point that the proper topics need to be determined. I don't know who should determine that, I would assume that school administrators would be the ones to make that decision since curriculums are reviewed.
Snowflake3981 Posted December 10, 2008 Author Posted December 10, 2008 [quote name='missionseeker' post='1723932' date='Dec 10 2008, 04:09 AM']Can openers.[/quote] Remember that episode of the Simpsons where Flanders opened that store just for left handed people? The Leftorium? That was pretty cool.
desertwoman Posted December 10, 2008 Posted December 10, 2008 [quote name='Jesus_lol' post='1723883' date='Dec 10 2008, 02:29 AM']speaking of good analogies, i particularily like the one in the second panel of this comic [img]http://i146.photobucket.com/albums/r267/diablo_man/equality.jpg[/img] btw, i didnt post this to call you a moron winchester![/quote] Hmmm. never saw it like that.
Didacus Posted December 10, 2008 Posted December 10, 2008 Won't this just give homosexuals the reputation of being lazy and calling into work sick for no reason at all?
Guest Optimus Prime Posted December 10, 2008 Posted December 10, 2008 I think, like any special interest group seeking attention this will enable them just that. I see the same things in my work place daily from various special interests groups. Call in this. March for that. Solidarity days. It certainly gets hairy when the issues regard morality. Playing off of a thread above, I think its necessary that this issue and other social justice pieces are discussed in schools. Of course there is a time and place for everything but children, old and young, should be taught to think for themselves. [We need to trust that we have done our part in helping form our children's consciences]. Hopefully those effort will enable our youth to learn to love others unconditionally. Lord knows we could use a lot more love, espcially in this country.
Winchester Posted December 10, 2008 Posted December 10, 2008 The cartoon is cute. It equates homosexuality first with personal identity (apparently unchangeable and inherent), with religion, which is clearly not due to genetics or any inborn character and with size, which may or may not be changeable by personal action. It does not defeat the argument. The argument stands. It does not prove that homosexual unions are a viable choice, merely that marrying a member of the opposite sex may not be part of an individual's identity. It doesn't prove that not changing the definition of marriage is unjust. Taking the argument in the cartoon to its logical conclusion (that freedom is harmed by not permitting people to be themselves), we must permit all actions people identify as being inherent to their person. I don't think I need to list all the various behaviors that are against the law in spite of many people's compulsion, desire or need to perform them. The logical conclusion of the argument is anarchy, no matter how cute the analogy may be. We may logically permit choice in religions (up to a point. Satanists do not have complete freedom of religion--shall we grant it?) without problem. We may logically permit people to have different sized pants. However, if we define marriage by one's love as the criteria (which the law does not), then we open up to incest, polygamy and pedopilia. This is not to say the law will be logical, but things have a way of following logical conclusions. Witness the direction of the family as we became more openly permissive of sexual license. It is not that we now sin; it is that we are now not ashamed of sin.
MissyP89 Posted December 10, 2008 Posted December 10, 2008 When is call out straight day? I am so in on that!
mommas_boy Posted December 10, 2008 Posted December 10, 2008 [quote name='Jesus_lol' post='1723883' date='Dec 10 2008, 01:29 AM']speaking of good analogies, i particularily like the one in the second panel of this comic [img]http://i146.photobucket.com/albums/r267/diablo_man/equality.jpg[/img] btw, i didnt post this to call you a moron winchester![/quote] Erm ... is that cartoon drawing a caricature of conservatives or liberals?
eagle_eye222001 Posted December 12, 2008 Posted December 12, 2008 [quote name='Snowflake3981' post='1724132' date='Dec 10 2008, 01:37 PM']Remember that episode of the Simpsons where Flanders opened that store just for left handed people? The Leftorium? That was pretty cool.[/quote] I have that episode.
jeffpugh Posted December 13, 2008 Posted December 13, 2008 [quote name='missionseeker' post='1723932' date='Dec 10 2008, 04:09 AM']Can openers.[/quote] [quote name='Snowflake3981' post='1724132' date='Dec 10 2008, 01:37 PM']Remember that episode of the Simpsons where Flanders opened that store just for left handed people? The Leftorium? That was pretty cool.[/quote] I must look that episode up.
Hassan Posted December 13, 2008 Posted December 13, 2008 [quote name='Winchester' post='1724738' date='Dec 10 2008, 07:09 PM']The cartoon is cute. It equates homosexuality first with personal identity[/quote] Sexuality is part of an individuals identity, a major part. [quote](apparently unchangeable and inherent), with religion, which is clearly not due to genetics or any inborn character and with size, which may or may not be changeable by personal action.[/quote] I don't know about that. The relation between biology and religious disposition is not fully known. [quote]It does not defeat the argument. The argument stands.[/quote] It refutes the argument that homosexuals have equal rights because. just like everyone else, they ar free to marry an individual of a different gender. Unless you would claim that the Jim Crow laws of the south protecting every individuals right to marry another individual of the same race, or everyone haveing the right to embrace, for example, Islam are instances of full rights then to claim that homosexuals have full rights as they marry an individual of the opposite gender like everyone else is silly. [quote]It does not prove that homosexual unions are a viable choice, merely that marrying a member of the opposite sex may not be part of an individual's identity.[/quote] You need to give a strict, analytical definition of what does constitute a "viable choice" with reguards to marriage in a secular state like the US. [quote]It doesn't prove that not changing the definition of marriage is unjust.[/quote] Mariag has changed, in the Bible it evolves from a legal contract validating procreation that can exist between a man and a number of women to a sacramental union between one man and one woman. [quote]Taking the argument in the cartoon to its logical conclusion (that freedom is harmed by not permitting people to be themselves), we must permit all actions people identify as being inherent to their person.[/quote] That was not the point of the cortoon, the cartoon satarized the claim that "homosexuals have equal rights, they may marry someone of the opposite sex like anyone else" [quote]I don't think I need to list all the various behaviors that are against the law in spite of many people's compulsion, desire or need to perform them. The logical conclusion of the argument is anarchy, no matter how cute the analogy may be.[/quote] Anarchy as opposed to deneying a contingent of the population access to important legal protections based on the arbitrary whims of a larger contingent of the population. [quote]We may logically permit choice in religions (up to a point. Satanists do not have complete freedom of religion--shall we grant it?) without problem. We may logically permit people to have different sized pants.[/quote] Satanists do have equeal treatment and rights. Freedom of religious belief is absolutly protected, that freedom does not give an individual to break the law. Freedom of religious belief does not permit freedom of religious action. You are free to hold your belief that it is not morally wrong to stone a child to death who curses his parents, but your are not allowed to actually carry out that practice (not that Catholicism sanctions such an act). [quote]However, if we define marriage by one's love as the criteria (which the law does not), then we open up to incest, polygamy and pedopilia. This is not to say the law will be logical, but things have a way of following logical conclusions. Witness the direction of the family as we became more openly permissive of sexual license. It is not that we now sin; it is that we are now not ashamed of sin.[/quote] I don't know why you would object to pologamy as it has been allowed by your God in the past, the other two are not apt analogies. Prop 8 denies concenting adults legal protections and sanctions, anti pedofilia laws protecting a child who lacks the cognitive or emotional facalities and maturity to concent to a sexual relationship with an individual. Two men having sex in their bedroom and being able to visit each other in the hospital in no way infringes on your rights, as pedofilia does a child. I do not mean for this to be agressive. I like you and appreciate the wit and thoughtfullness you bring to the board. I do hope we can have a good discussion over this and that was the point of this post.
Arpy Posted December 14, 2008 Posted December 14, 2008 (edited) [quote name='Hassan' post='1726793' date='Dec 12 2008, 05:38 PM']I don't know about that. The relation between biology and religious disposition is not fully known.[/quote] There's not much evidence to suggest any sort of correlation, is there? Sure, there are people who successfully pass their religion on to their offspring, but many people also reject their parents' religion to whatever degree. [quote name='Hassan' post='1726793' date='Dec 12 2008, 05:38 PM']Mariag has changed, in the Bible it evolves from a legal contract validating procreation that can exist between a man and a number of women to a sacramental union between one man and one woman.[/quote] Actually, it's still a legal contract validating procreation. Marriage's sacramentalization is more of an addition than a complete change. Edited December 14, 2008 by Arpy
dominicansoul Posted December 14, 2008 Posted December 14, 2008 the funny thing is, no one called in sick on that day at the office, for fear that rumours might spread about them being gay....! i had to endure sneezing, sniffling, coughing, aching co-workers all day long.... ..thanks, gays!
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now