havok579257 Posted January 21, 2009 Posted January 21, 2009 [quote name='VoTeckam' post='1757692' date='Jan 21 2009, 12:46 PM']How is it that we can rank the importance of one life issue over another? Surely a God who used parables of a lost sheep, lost coin and prodigal son wouldn't conden this...[/quote] Thank you
CatholicCid Posted January 21, 2009 Posted January 21, 2009 [quote name='VoTeckam' post='1757692' date='Jan 21 2009, 01:46 PM']How is it that we can rank the importance of one life issue over another? Surely a God who used parables of a lost sheep, lost coin and prodigal son wouldn't conden this...[/quote] I don't think giving one preeminence would count as ranking. Instead, it's saying that in today's context, this seems to be a larger issue. As Bishop Vann and Farrell said in there letter, there is no other intrinsic evil in America today that outweighs that of abortion. Why? Because the sheer lose of human life daily is that great.
havok579257 Posted January 21, 2009 Posted January 21, 2009 [quote name='CatholicCid' post='1757716' date='Jan 21 2009, 01:07 PM']I don't think giving one preeminence would count as ranking. Instead, it's saying that in today's context, this seems to be a larger issue. As Bishop Vann and Farrell said in there letter, there is no other intrinsic evil in America today that outweighs that of abortion. Why? Because the sheer lose of human life daily is that great.[/quote] but does being anti-abortion give someone the right to kill others and everything be ok as long as they are anti-abortion. Last I checked, anti-abortion and pro-life are not mutually exclusive. They can be one and the same.
Winchester Posted January 21, 2009 Posted January 21, 2009 Good thing there was a parenthetical note in the title, or I wouldn't have gotten the subtle pun.
kujo Posted January 21, 2009 Posted January 21, 2009 [quote name='havok579257' post='1757706' date='Jan 21 2009, 01:57 PM']so now joining the armed forced means death? joining the armed forces means serving ones country. Bush sent men and women to die in a war that was not needed. The pope even said this was an unjust war. We don't need to act like this war was of just importance, on the level of WWII or something. No, this was wrong to get into. Bush lied about the reasons we got into the war. Iraq had nothing to do with Bin Laden or WMD's. Bush sent men and women to die for unjust reasons. Also war should be the basolute last option. Can you honestly tell me, that when it came to Iraq, you felt we were in a situation where a. this war was a just war b. we had NO other alternative to solve the problem but to go to war killing not only many american soliders but how many innocent Iraq's did Bush sentance to death by starting this war. Should we even begin to talk about the innocent men, women and CHILDREN who died in Iraq due to Bush declaring war on Iraq. What about those children. How are they not as important as unborn children? Again, if the pope condemns the war, I don't see how any Catholic can think it was a just war and Bush was right in sending us to war over there. And again the Pope says pro-life means all life. By the popes definition of pro-life, Bush is anything but.[/quote] Volunteering for the armed forces comes with a tacit acknowledgment that, if deployed, you may die. So you can't say that Bush imposed that on them. If they signed up, they knew the risks. It doesn't make their death any less tragic, but it doesn't mean that it is something that is so far out of the realm of possibility. And of course there were other options when dealing with Saddam and his habitual violations of legitimate UN sanctions. We could've continued to use empty diplomacy and meaningless sanctions on a dictator who obviously isn't accountable to his countrymen. We could've issued "strong condemnations" and other fancy diplomatic terms in hopes that this murderer would somehow change his policies. But those options would have yielded the same results as the previous decade---bumpkins. As much as it pains me to say it, I disagree with both B16 and JP2 about the justness of this war. This was a murderous dictator, a man who killed hundreds of thousands of his own countrymen during his reign of terror. And, while there was no link between him and al-Qaeda, there is one fact which is indisputably true-- if given the means and the opportunity, he would've attacked this country and/or our allies in Europe and Asia. In my view, ridding the world of this tyrant is worth the sacrifice our men and women in uniform have made. It is a horrible truth that people die in war. And you're right...there are many Iraqis who have paid the ultimate price for this war. But let me ask you this: how many of those innocent Iraqis that you mourn for were killed as a result of insurgents and terrorists forcing the Coalition forces to strike targets by setting up basecamp in and around schools, hospitals, daycare facilities and innocent villages? What would you have us do? I understand your views but I feel they are just woefully misinformed. Pax, dude.
havok579257 Posted January 21, 2009 Posted January 21, 2009 [quote name='kujo' post='1757772' date='Jan 21 2009, 02:25 PM']Volunteering for the armed forces comes with a tacit acknowledgment that, if deployed, you may die. So you can't say that Bush imposed that on them. If they signed up, they knew the risks. It doesn't make their death any less tragic, but it doesn't mean that it is something that is so far out of the realm of possibility. And of course there were other options when dealing with Saddam and his habitual violations of legitimate UN sanctions. We could've continued to use empty diplomacy and meaningless sanctions on a dictator who obviously isn't accountable to his countrymen. We could've issued "strong condemnations" and other fancy diplomatic terms in hopes that this murderer would somehow change his policies. But those options would have yielded the same results as the previous decade---bumpkins. As much as it pains me to say it, I disagree with both B16 and JP2 about the justness of this war. This was a murderous dictator, a man who killed hundreds of thousands of his own countrymen during his reign of terror. And, while there was no link between him and al-Qaeda, there is one fact which is indisputably true-- if given the means and the opportunity, he would've attacked this country and/or our allies in Europe and Asia. In my view, ridding the world of this tyrant is worth the sacrifice our men and women in uniform have made. It is a horrible truth that people die in war. And you're right...there are many Iraqis who have paid the ultimate price for this war. But let me ask you this: how many of those innocent Iraqis that you mourn for were killed as a result of insurgents and terrorists forcing the Coalition forces to strike targets by setting up basecamp in and around schools, hospitals, daycare facilities and innocent villages? What would you have us do? I understand your views but I feel they are just woefully misinformed. Pax, dude.[/quote] i never said it was out of the realm of possibility, but when you are sent war, an unjust war, a war the majority of American's are against, how does that make your death mean anything? so since Saddam was evil, why stop at him. Why not invade China and Cuba, Darfur and so on and so on. Are you advocating America go to war with every evil dictator? So should we not be invading other countries? When does it stop. Better yet, is it a just war if another country invaded America and started killing people because they believed we as American's were mass murders because we allow abortion? What makes Obama different in respect to Saddam in the terms of people killed under their rule. So then should another country find it just to invade us because of America's views on abortion? Would that be just to invade America and killl many innocent men, women and children? Also is ridding the world of Saddam worth the innocent children killed by Bush? How many innocent children is an acceptable number. Yes insurgents killed many innocents, but does that excuse Bush and the military from killing innocents? HOw many innocents did we end up killing as colatteral damage? I would have us find another way to deal with Saddam. There are and were better ways. War is an absolute last resort. Can you sit there and say we had absolutly NO alternative to this war. Also Bush turned the focus of the war from terrorists to Saddam. Something the American people are not for. And again I ask what about China, Cuba and Darfur? Should we invade them because of the evils comitted there? Saddam was in no way worse that the travesty in Darfur.
VoTeckam Posted January 21, 2009 Posted January 21, 2009 [quote name='kujo' post='1757772' date='Jan 21 2009, 03:25 PM']I understand your views but I feel they are just woefully misinformed. Pax, dude.[/quote] The Holy Father agrees with him... I thought that pulled a lot of weight here.
Winchester Posted January 21, 2009 Posted January 21, 2009 [quote name='havok579257' post='1757804' date='Jan 21 2009, 03:03 PM']And again I ask what about China, Cuba and Darfur? Should we invade them because of the evils comitted there? Saddam was in no way worse that the travesty in Darfur.[/quote]Really? What are the numbers? I guess dead Kurds aren't as bad. Yeah, sell the celebrity outrage somewhere else. You think the magic bombs won't kill kids if we attack tribal leaders in Africa instead of the middle east? War is ugly no matter how many pretty celebrities back it.
Winchester Posted January 21, 2009 Posted January 21, 2009 (edited) That said, I think it's terrible, but it's going on in many African nations. The solution is to aid the rebel forces and train the right people. And bomb the Dutch. Edited January 21, 2009 by Winchester
Winchester Posted January 21, 2009 Posted January 21, 2009 [quote name='VoTeckam' post='1757831' date='Jan 21 2009, 03:50 PM']The Holy Father agrees with him... I thought that pulled a lot of weight here.[/quote] He might also like the 80's Corvettes, but it ain't an article of faith. The main disapproval was from an international community making money from skirting the sanctions--France's disapproval was motivated purely by money.
havok579257 Posted January 21, 2009 Posted January 21, 2009 [quote name='Winchester' post='1757875' date='Jan 21 2009, 05:14 PM']Really? What are the numbers? I guess dead Kurds aren't as bad. Yeah, sell the celebrity outrage somewhere else. You think the magic bombs won't kill kids if we attack tribal leaders in Africa instead of the middle east? War is ugly no matter how many pretty celebrities back it.[/quote] Obviously you did not read my post and instead chose to jump in and make comments off of ideas in your own head. Next time, I advise readings the postS before making nonsense rambelings. I never once condoned attacks in Darfur. The post I replied to was directed at a poster claiming that going to war in Iraq was absolutly necessary because it was necessary to stop the evils in Iraq. I simply asked the poster what about the other evils around the world? Should we invade them also? If not, what makes one ok but not the other. As has been my posts this entire thread, I do not condon what we did in Iraq and think it was a travisty. But go ahead and continue to thump your chest from your high horse. Although next time, it would be nice if you read all the posts that were posted about the topic before jumping in and making no sense at all.
VoTeckam Posted January 22, 2009 Posted January 22, 2009 [quote name='Winchester' post='1757882' date='Jan 21 2009, 06:20 PM']He might also like the 80's Corvettes, but it ain't an article of faith. The main disapproval was from an international community making money from skirting the sanctions--France's disapproval was motivated purely by money.[/quote] Surely the Holy father is wiser, more informed and has a more fully deveoloped conscience that anyone here at Phatmass. It would be a shame to place nationalism over the guidance of the Holy Father (be it a mere opinion or not).
Winchester Posted January 22, 2009 Posted January 22, 2009 (edited) [quote name='havok579257' post='1757889' date='Jan 21 2009, 05:28 PM']Obviously you did not read my post and instead chose to jump in and make comments off of ideas in your own head. Next time, I advise readings the postS before making nonsense rambelings. I never once condoned attacks in Darfur.[/quote] I don't recall saying you did condone the attacks in Darfur. Take your own advice. Edited January 22, 2009 by Winchester
Winchester Posted January 22, 2009 Posted January 22, 2009 [quote name='VoTeckam' post='1758450' date='Jan 22 2009, 09:07 AM']Surely the Holy father is wiser, more informed and has a more fully deveoloped conscience that anyone here at Phatmass. It would be a shame to place nationalism over the guidance of the Holy Father (be it a mere opinion or not).[/quote] You're assuming it's motivated by nationalism to support the war in Iraq. Big assumption.
Winchester Posted January 22, 2009 Posted January 22, 2009 [quote name='havok579257' post='1757014' date='Jan 20 2009, 09:05 PM']Saddam had NOTHING on the violence in Darfur.[/quote][url="http://www.historycommons.org/events-images/a562_kurds_gassed_halabja_2050081722-18673.jpg"]Picture of Kurdish victims of Saddam's gas attacks.[/url] [quote]Saddam's torture victims can at last rebuild their lives. Inigo Gilmore reports from Baghdad Over the past 19 years, Jasim Muter has rarely shown his horribly scarred face in public, fearful of mockery and abuse. Last week, he did something he never imagined he would do: he spoke openly about his traumatic past, sharing his disturbing experiences with 30 other men who were brutally mutilated by Saddam's henchmen. In a smoke-filled fourth-floor office in downtown Baghdad, Mr Muter found a seat between two men missing parts of their ears. Tentatively, slowly peeling away the layers of pain and anguish, he began to tell the story of how he was horribly burned, and its effect on his life. While Saddam was in power, everyone knew that victims of mutilation had fallen foul of the regime and shunned them as a result, fearing for their own safety. After suffering years of rejection, just a few days ago Mr Muter heard from a friend about a new self-help group for victims such as him, set up by a compassionate woman whom the men in the room refer to as "our mother". Mona al-Adhami's father and husband were both executed by Saddam for refusing to do military service. Mrs al-Adhami now wants to help these men because international NGOs are not operating in the country because of security threats. Gently, she encouraged Jasim to unburden himself. His story came out painfully, his mouth twisted and disfigured by scar tissue. In 1985, when Mr Muter was a frontline soldier during the Iran-Iraq war, his unit refused to carry out what would have effectively been a suicide mission. Their commanding officer's response was to fire phosphorous shells straight into their position. Five men around him were flayed alive by the exploding shells, while Mr Muter's body was engulfed in a ball of flame as he tried to escape. Severely burned, when he regained consciousness from a month-long coma he could barely walk or talk. Mr Muter needed four operations to help him heal, but had just one. Iraqi officials refused to sanction further surgery, to make an example of him. He still cannot shut his eyes properly. While his physical scars may never heal, Mr Muter hopes that the victims' group will help his mental recovery. "All these years I have been hiding away, living my life as an outcast, with boys and girls pointing at me wherever I go," he said. "Saddam wanted to destroy us, and I wished that they had killed me back then. I need a lot of help and that is why I came here." Reaching into his jacket, Mr Muter produces a black-and-white photograph taken just a few months before the incident. The handsome man with a moustache bears almost no resemblance to the disfigured man in the room. He lost his job as a history teacher because, he said, "the children were too frightened of me". Since then Mr Muter, a father of six, has had no regular work. More than 200 men, many of whom were tortured by Saddam's officials after "taking his name in vain" - making jokes about the dictator - or refusing to serve in the army, have signed up to the group set up by Mrs al-Adhami last month and funded entirely by donations. The men see her as an inspirational figure, helping them to find jobs and trying to arrange plastic surgery. She conducts her own counselling classes for the men, advising them on relationships and marriage. "They realised that they could open up and cry, which is a release for them," said Mrs al-Adhami. "We are trying to bring these men together as one family because they have suffered so much. We need to restore their dignity and give them hope." Many of the men were mutilated in the mid-1990s, when lopping off ears was a common torture. Mrs al-Adhami has seen medical records showing that in Baghdad alone at least 15 men who were put under anaesthetic while their ears were being sliced off also had a kidney "stolen" at the same time. She knows of several men whose tongues were cut out. Saleh Shnawa, a 36-year-old man with sad eyes, joined the group two weeks ago. He confided how his wife left him after his ear was cut off: he had not been able to meet another woman since. Sitting next to him, Hashem Saif, 40, had grown his hair long to conceal the evidence of his mutilated ears. "They bound my hands, blindfolded me and cut off both my ears," he said. "I don't know why I am different from most of the others." News of the group is travelling by word of mouth. Even so, dozens of victims from southern towns far from Baghdad have managed to contact Mrs al-Adhami. Next week, after being "inundated" by men pleading to attend, she will open another branch in Amara, 250 miles south of Baghdad. Mrs al-Adhami, a mother of three, has so little money that her children are cared for in an orphanage five days a week. She survives on $50 (£27) a month, some of which she spends on the group. Her sacrifice appears to be paying off, however. Remarkably, Mr Saif sounds upbeat about the future. "After this happened I never tried to talk to a woman, I was so ashamed," he said. "My life has been very difficult. "Now, I just want our 'mother' to help me get a job so I can at last have a life, so I can have a future."[/quote] Yeah, nothing. No big deal. He was a pussycat. Sell that to someone else--maybe you can repoup the loss of buying that we shouldn't have attacked Iraq.
VoTeckam Posted January 22, 2009 Posted January 22, 2009 [quote name='Winchester' post='1758571' date='Jan 22 2009, 02:37 PM']You're assuming it's motivated by nationalism to support the war in Iraq. Big assumption.[/quote] What isyour support based on?
havok579257 Posted January 22, 2009 Posted January 22, 2009 [quote name='Winchester' post='1758587' date='Jan 22 2009, 01:52 PM'][url="http://www.historycommons.org/events-images/a562_kurds_gassed_halabja_2050081722-18673.jpg"]Picture of Kurdish victims of Saddam's gas attacks.[/url] Yeah, nothing. No big deal. He was a pussycat. Sell that to someone else--maybe you can repoup the loss of buying that we shouldn't have attacked Iraq.[/quote] i never said Saddma was not evil or what he did was atrocious. But compared to how many rapes happen in a day in Darfur, how many children are forced to become mercanaries, how many people lose limbs, how many people starve to death, how many people are killed, Saddam although evil, does not compare to the evils in Darfur. And again the question was if your going to invade a country because of atrocities happening, how can you justify invading Iraq but not Darfur or communist China, or Cuba. Again, I ask YOU, what makes Iraq ok, but none of the other ok.
havok579257 Posted January 22, 2009 Posted January 22, 2009 [quote name='Winchester' post='1758571' date='Jan 22 2009, 01:37 PM']You're assuming it's motivated by nationalism to support the war in Iraq. Big assumption.[/quote] Well its not motivated by scripture, the Pope or Catholisism, so what is it motivated tby then?
havok579257 Posted January 22, 2009 Posted January 22, 2009 [quote name='Winchester' post='1758567' date='Jan 22 2009, 01:33 PM']I don't recall saying you did condone the attacks in Darfur. Take your own advice.[/quote] In your rant, you did just that. Asking me how many kids would die if we invaded Iraq, implying I was for it.
Winchester Posted January 22, 2009 Posted January 22, 2009 [quote name='havok579257' post='1758608' date='Jan 22 2009, 02:51 PM']i never said Saddma was not evil or what he did was atrocious. But compared to how many rapes happen in a day in Darfur, how many children are forced to become mercanaries, how many people lose limbs, how many people starve to death, how many people are killed, Saddam although evil, does not compare to the evils in Darfur. And again the question was if your going to invade a country because of atrocities happening, how can you justify invading Iraq but not Darfur or communist China, or Cuba. Again, I ask YOU, what makes Iraq ok, but none of the other ok.[/quote] The idiom you used means Darfur is worse than Iraq. I asked for numbers. You're offering nothing concrete because you have nothing concrete. You made the assertion but can't back it up.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now