Winchester Posted January 22, 2009 Posted January 22, 2009 (edited) [quote name='havok579257' post='1758610' date='Jan 22 2009, 02:54 PM']In your rant, you did just that. Asking me how many kids would die if we invaded [i]Iraq[/i], implying I was for it.[/quote] I'm dizzy. You have got to be kidding me. [quote]I don't recall saying you did condone the attacks in [i]Darfur[/i].[/quote]Darfur: not in Iraq. Seriously, slow down. [quote]Really? What are the numbers? I guess dead Kurds aren't as bad. Yeah, sell the celebrity outrage somewhere else. You think the magic bombs won't kill kids if we attack tribal leaders in Africa instead of the middle east? War is ugly no matter how many pretty celebrities back it.[/quote]You said Saddam was not as bad; I merely put your statement in another light. I also mentioned collateral damage, though perhaps could have mentioned dead troops. But nothing in my post implies you support these actions--I merely reworded your inane statement that Saddam "had nothing" on Darfur. I don't think there are many tribal leaders in Africa that are also in Iraq, given they aren't very good at bi-location. You jumped the gun on goign after me because you misunderstood what I said. Your scre-up, your problem. Jog on. Edited January 22, 2009 by Winchester
kujo Posted January 22, 2009 Posted January 22, 2009 [quote name='havok579257' post='1757804' date='Jan 21 2009, 04:03 PM']i never said it was out of the realm of possibility, but when you are sent war, an unjust war, a war the majority of American's are against, how does that make your death mean anything?[/quote] The US soldiers who have given their lives in Iraq have done so to trying to bring democracy, peace and freedom of self-governance to the citizens of Iraq. Whether or not that is a "just" cause is up for debate, I suppose. But the actions of the individual soldier are not [i]unjust[/i], for they are protecting themselves, their fellow soldiers, their countrymen and those whom they are fighting for. That, in and of itself, means that their death "means" something, regardless of whether the American public agrees with the war. [quote]so since Saddam was evil, why stop at him. Why not invade China and Cuba, Darfur and so on and so on. Are you advocating America go to war with every evil dictator? So should we not be invading other countries? When does it stop. Better yet, is it a just war if another country invaded America and started killing people because they believed we as American's were mass murders because we allow abortion? What makes Obama different in respect to Saddam in the terms of people killed under their rule. So then should another country find it just to invade us because of America's views on abortion? Would that be just to invade America and killl many innocent men, women and children?[/quote] Well, for starters, I am in favor of some sort of intervention in Darfur. I'm not sure what should be done as far as sending troops over there because I fear that the forces driving the genocide are more complex than those that can be solved by soldiers--for instance, how are soliders going to deal with the reintegrating the massive refugee population? Still, a deployment of troops to restore order in the area by stopping the killings would be preferable to the current policy. But more to the point of our discussion, from a realist perspective, there is nothing to be gained--in terms of economics, politics, or national security-- from invading China or Cuba. However, "evil" dictators like Kim Jong Ill, Mahmoud Ahmadinejad (I don't buy him as being elected democratically, thus why I included him in this list), and Saddam, who have proven, through both their actions and words, that they would attack the US or its allies, should be dealt with. You could even include Hugo Chavez to that list due to his control of a large portion of oil (though, I'm not sure that he possesses the ability to really harm us...yet). I am not a neo-con crusader-for-democracy, but I recognize that, from the perspective of realism, it is undoubtedly true that neutralizing a previous and future threat is a just cause for any country to endeavor. Finally, I am not one to draw linkages between our Presidents and nefarious folk like Hitler, Saddam or Bin Laden based on their support for abortion. But I will say this...if Obama, or any other leader, made it clear that they were going to kill an entire population of [i]one country[/i], it would be just for that country to repel such an action. [quote]Also is ridding the world of Saddam worth the innocent children killed by Bush? How many innocent children is an acceptable number. Yes insurgents killed many innocents, but does that excuse Bush and the military from killing innocents? HOw many innocents did we end up killing as colatteral damage?[/quote] When did Bush kill anyone? You seem to be adopting the tired-tactic of blaming him for every single thing in the world. Sending troops to an area is a Constitutional and legal action for any President to take. And those troops, once they are in said area, are responsible for killing targets. I have already demonstrated that the insurgents in Iraq have used the tactic of surrounding themselves with civilians in order to deter the Coalition forces from striking back. Hamas does the same thing. I will ask you again: what would you have the soldiers do? Let the insurgents pick them apart and not strike back? It's a horrible decision to have to make, and all other options should be sincerely-deployed before making it. But sometimes it's gotta be made. [quote]I would have us find another way to deal with Saddam. There are and were better ways. War is an absolute last resort. Can you sit there and say we had absolutly NO alternative to this war. Also Bush turned the focus of the war from terrorists to Saddam. Something the American people are not for.[/quote] What do you call the 10 years of [i]non war[/i]between the Gulf War and this war? What about the sanctions, mandates, fly overs, requests for inspections, all of which did absolutely [b]nothing[/b] to change the behavior of this man? I would argue that this war was necessary. There was no other diplomatic means to be used. He had made it clear that he rejected the authority of the UN and other international bodies. He didn't care about sanctions, refused to let UN inspectors come in, didn't care about us striking certain targets. At what point does the "last resort" become the [i]only[/i] resort? [quote]Saddam was in no way worse that the travesty in Darfur.[/quote] I encourage you to read this report, filed by Human Rights Watch in the '90s called [url="http://www.hrw.org/legacy/reports/1993/iraqanfal/#Table%20of"]"Genocide in Iraq."[/url] It's about Saddam's policy of "Arabizing" the Kurdish region of Iraq through through ethnic cleansing (i.e.- genocide). Maybe it will convince you that what's happening in Darfur and what happened in Iraq are not all that different.
Winchester Posted January 22, 2009 Posted January 22, 2009 (edited) So I take it you havok and votekam both support all the Church preached Crusades and the various inquisitions and their actions, excluding here the Spanish inquisition due to the state control involved. Edited January 22, 2009 by Winchester
kujo Posted January 22, 2009 Posted January 22, 2009 [quote name='Winchester' post='1758666' date='Jan 22 2009, 05:30 PM']So I take it you two both support all the Church preached Crusades and the various inquisitions and their actions, excluding here the Spanish inquisition due to the state control involved.[/quote] I have no opinion on it because I have almost NO knowledge of it.
Winchester Posted January 22, 2009 Posted January 22, 2009 [quote name='kujo' post='1758669' date='Jan 22 2009, 04:32 PM']I have no opinion on it because I have almost NO knowledge of it.[/quote] Not you, sorry. Will edit.
kujo Posted January 22, 2009 Posted January 22, 2009 [quote name='Winchester' post='1758671' date='Jan 22 2009, 05:33 PM']Not you, sorry. Will edit.[/quote] K.
havok579257 Posted January 22, 2009 Posted January 22, 2009 [quote name='Winchester' post='1758652' date='Jan 22 2009, 04:17 PM']The idiom you used means Darfur is worse than Iraq. I asked for numbers. You're offering nothing concrete because you have nothing concrete. You made the assertion but can't back it up.[/quote] uh, you never asked for numbers. you said, Iraq was worse. I shall get those numbers and return later.
havok579257 Posted January 22, 2009 Posted January 22, 2009 [quote name='Winchester' post='1758666' date='Jan 22 2009, 04:30 PM']So I take it you havok and votekam both support all the Church preached Crusades and the various inquisitions and their actions, excluding here the Spanish inquisition due to the state control involved.[/quote] supprting the crusades and supporting being pro-life and preserving EVERY single life are two completly different things. I whole heartedly believe the cruch that pro-life is not just about abortion, its about every life and that we should do everything in our power to preserve every life, be it unborn or born and that Iraq was an unjust war.
VoTeckam Posted January 22, 2009 Posted January 22, 2009 (edited) [quote name='Winchester' post='1758666' date='Jan 22 2009, 05:30 PM']So I take it you havok and votekam both support all the Church preached Crusades and the various inquisitions and their actions, excluding here the Spanish inquisition due to the state control involved.[/quote] That is quite a strange conclusion. I am just asking what it is that you are placing higher than the opinion of the Holy Father if it is not nationalism. Is your knowledge that is greater than his? Your conscience is better formed? Your wisdom is greater? Edited January 22, 2009 by VoTeckam
kujo Posted January 22, 2009 Posted January 22, 2009 I'm starting to feel jealous. I worked so hard on my response and no one is responding to it.
VoTeckam Posted January 22, 2009 Posted January 22, 2009 [quote name='kujo' post='1758699' date='Jan 22 2009, 05:50 PM']I'm starting to feel jealous. I worked so hard on my response and no one is responding to it. [/quote] Haha it was a great response Kujo... I understand that the US invasion had an admirable intent. Of course Iraqi's deserve to live free of the oppression of Saddam. What the Holy father argues is that End's ethics never works. A sloppy war is no way to acheive that freedom. A sloppy war is exactly what we are in.
kujo Posted January 22, 2009 Posted January 22, 2009 [quote name='VoTeckam' post='1758701' date='Jan 22 2009, 05:55 PM']Haha it was a great response Kujo... I understand that the US invasion had an admirable intent. Of course Iraqi's deserve to live free of the oppression of Saddam. What the Holy father argues is that End's ethics never works. A sloppy war is no way to acheive that freedom. A sloppy war is exactly what we are in.[/quote] I am by no means an apologist of Bush. I think his execution of this war was symbolic of his whole presidency--arrogant, misinformed, greedy and narrow minded. Perhaps this war wouldn't have been such a sloppy blunder under a more capable leader.
VoTeckam Posted January 22, 2009 Posted January 22, 2009 [quote name='kujo' post='1758703' date='Jan 22 2009, 05:58 PM']I am by no means an apologist of Bush. I think his execution of this war was symbolic of his whole presidency--arrogant, misinformed, greedy and narrow minded. Perhaps this war wouldn't have been such a sloppy blunder under a more capable leader.[/quote] No disagreements here.
havok579257 Posted January 22, 2009 Posted January 22, 2009 [quote name='kujo' post='1758662' date='Jan 22 2009, 04:27 PM']The US soldiers who have given their lives in Iraq have done so to trying to bring democracy, peace and freedom of self-governance to the citizens of Iraq. Whether or not that is a "just" cause is up for debate, I suppose. But the actions of the individual soldier are not [i]unjust[/i], for they are protecting themselves, their fellow soldiers, their countrymen and those whom they are fighting for. That, in and of itself, means that their death "means" something, regardless of whether the American public agrees with the war. Well, for starters, I am in favor of some sort of intervention in Darfur. I'm not sure what should be done as far as sending troops over there because I fear that the forces driving the genocide are more complex than those that can be solved by soldiers--for instance, how are soliders going to deal with the reintegrating the massive refugee population? Still, a deployment of troops to restore order in the area by stopping the killings would be preferable to the current policy. But more to the point of our discussion, from a realist perspective, there is nothing to be gained--in terms of economics, politics, or national security-- from invading China or Cuba. However, "evil" dictators like Kim Jong Ill, Mahmoud Ahmadinejad (I don't buy him as being elected democratically, thus why I included him in this list), and Saddam, who have proven, through both their actions and words, that they would attack the US or its allies, should be dealt with. You could even include Hugo Chavez to that list due to his control of a large portion of oil (though, I'm not sure that he possesses the ability to really harm us...yet). I am not a neo-con crusader-for-democracy, but I recognize that, from the perspective of realism, it is undoubtedly true that neutralizing a previous and future threat is a just cause for any country to endeavor. Finally, I am not one to draw linkages between our Presidents and nefarious folk like Hitler, Saddam or Bin Laden based on their support for abortion. But I will say this...if Obama, or any other leader, made it clear that they were going to kill an entire population of [i]one country[/i], it would be just for that country to repel such an action. When did Bush kill anyone? You seem to be adopting the tired-tactic of blaming him for every single thing in the world. Sending troops to an area is a Constitutional and legal action for any President to take. And those troops, once they are in said area, are responsible for killing targets. I have already demonstrated that the insurgents in Iraq have used the tactic of surrounding themselves with civilians in order to deter the Coalition forces from striking back. Hamas does the same thing. I will ask you again: what would you have the soldiers do? Let the insurgents pick them apart and not strike back? It's a horrible decision to have to make, and all other options should be sincerely-deployed before making it. But sometimes it's gotta be made. What do you call the 10 years of [i]non war[/i]between the Gulf War and this war? What about the sanctions, mandates, fly overs, requests for inspections, all of which did absolutely [b]nothing[/b] to change the behavior of this man? I would argue that this war was necessary. There was no other diplomatic means to be used. He had made it clear that he rejected the authority of the UN and other international bodies. He didn't care about sanctions, refused to let UN inspectors come in, didn't care about us striking certain targets. At what point does the "last resort" become the [i]only[/i] resort? I encourage you to read this report, filed by Human Rights Watch in the '90s called [url="http://www.hrw.org/legacy/reports/1993/iraqanfal/#Table%20of"]"Genocide in Iraq."[/url] It's about Saddam's policy of "Arabizing" the Kurdish region of Iraq through through ethnic cleansing (i.e.- genocide). Maybe it will convince you that what's happening in Darfur and what happened in Iraq are not all that different.[/quote] I guess i mis-spoke, i never intended to sye each soilder was unjust. I was trying to get the point across that the purpose of the war was unjust and Bush was the leader of this war. He is the commander in chief. So although these men and women gave their lives willingly, its always up to commanders of these troops what happens to their soilders. I never ment to infer anything about the individual soilders, just the man who lead us into battle. Since to me, they are 2 seperate things. The problem with your second point is that there will ALWAYS be people who wish or if they could would, kill us all. Should we always invade every country that wishes us dead? Just because something is constituational and legal does not make it morally right. ABortion is constitutionally and leggally right to do, but in no way is it morally right. It was not morally right for Bush to invade Iraq. Going after terrorists would be different. WHich is what the man presented right after 9/11. Although he casually switched our focuus from the men who killed thousands of American's to a man who woulf WANT to kill thousands of Americans. Also he lied about the war. The entire WMD thing was a lie to try and justify our switching targets in the supposed war on terror. And again I ask, what if another country said out slaughtering of unborn babies was an atrocity and they decided to invade America to put and end to abortion. Would they be morally right by invading us? Obama has made such a declaration by saying he wants to make abortions not only as legal as possible but fund it in other countries. These are deaths, just as much as Saddam was killing people. So in a few years when the abortion rate increases, is another country morally right to invade us and install their beliefs upon us? Once in Iraq, I have no problem with soilders doing what must be done. I never have. The problem I have is why they are there in the first place. Yes I understand once there, there is certain things that they must do to survive. Although they should not have been there in the first place. So once again, I don't blame them for being there, I blame the man who sent them there. The UN and its santions are a joke and have been for years. America could have gotten her allies together and put more pressure on Iraq. Other countries were calling for us to put more pressure on them. More pressure which is obviously far and above the joke un sanctions. To me, WWII is a perfect example of a war that had no other recourse but for us to go to war with Germany. I do not think Iraq was on that scale where there was no other otion but to go to war. I never said what's happening in Iraq and Darfur are different. In fact, I have saying just the opposite. That they are very similar and that because of their similarities along with the similarities with China and Cuba, should we also be invading them since we are invading Iraq? What makes Iraq so much worse than the other situations that its ok to invade iraq but none of the other places? If they are similar in nature and this entire war was a just one because it was to put an end to an evil dictator in Saddam, then by that logic should we not invade China next? Then Cuba and the Darfur and so on and so on? What makes Iraq a just country to invade but none of the others? Hopefully you can follow this since I don't know how to do part of a post and respond to it in the way you did. With each part of your post seperated.
VoTeckam Posted January 22, 2009 Posted January 22, 2009 [quote name='havok579257' post='1758716' date='Jan 22 2009, 06:12 PM']The entire WMD thing was a lie to try and justify our switching targets in the supposed war on terror.[/quote] I stopped reading here. Even the Un was under the impression that Saddam was in possession of WMD. It was not until the UN saw an opportunity to ridicule Bush (and America as a whole) that the world pretended to forget that Saddam HAD WMDs and had no records of discarding them... Not finding them does not mean we can draw the conclusion that they weren't there.
havok579257 Posted January 22, 2009 Posted January 22, 2009 [quote name='VoTeckam' post='1758722' date='Jan 22 2009, 05:18 PM']I stopped reading here. Even the Un was under the impression that Saddam was in possession of WMD. It was not until the UN saw an opportunity to ridicule Bush (and America as a whole) that the world pretended to forget that Saddam HAD WMDs and had no records of discarding them... Not finding them does not mean we can draw the conclusion that they weren't there.[/quote] Still Bush did lie about it and tried to cover up the info even when it came to his attnetion that they were wrong.
VoTeckam Posted January 22, 2009 Posted January 22, 2009 [quote name='havok579257' post='1758724' date='Jan 22 2009, 06:21 PM']Still Bush did lie about it and tried to cover up the info even when it came to his attnetion that they were wrong.[/quote] No, Bush admitted that bad intel told them that there still WMDs in Iraq at the time of the initial invasion. Again, this is not to say that there were not WMDs in the country before the invasion. If your parents tell you not to have candy in your room, you hide it or throw it out the window when you hear them coming up the stairs. That is what Saddam did.
kujo Posted January 22, 2009 Posted January 22, 2009 [quote name='havok579257' post='1758716' date='Jan 22 2009, 06:12 PM']I guess i mis-spoke, i never intended to sye each soilder was unjust. I was trying to get the point across that the purpose of the war was unjust and Bush was the leader of this war. He is the commander in chief. So although these men and women gave their lives willingly, its always up to commanders of these troops what happens to their soilders. I never ment to infer anything about the individual soilders, just the man who lead us into battle. Since to me, they are 2 seperate things.[/quote] Okay cool. Glad we understand each other here. You feel this war was unjust but I don't. I don't think this is something we will agree on, so let's just move on. [quote]The problem with your second point is that there will ALWAYS be people who wish or if they could would, kill us all. Should we always invade every country that wishes us dead?[/quote] When a Head of State demonstrates that he/she would attack this country, I say that we should be ready to defend ourselves. For our government not to respond to such a potential threat would be to violate a very basic principle of its existence: to provide for the safety of its citizens. This segues into a discussion on the ethics of preemptive wars which is a whole other issue. [quote]Just because something is constituational and legal does not make it morally right. ABortion is constitutionally and leggally right to do, but in no way is it morally right.[/quote] Point well taken. [quote]It was not morally right for Bush to invade Iraq. Going after terrorists would be different. WHich is what the man presented right after 9/11. Although he casually switched our focuus from the men who killed thousands of American's to a man who woulf WANT to kill thousands of Americans. Also he lied about the war. The entire WMD thing was a lie to try and justify our switching targets in the supposed war on terror.[/quote] I think that what VoTeck says is true. Everyone was under the impression that Iraq had WMDs. That is a fact. Yet, just because we didn't find the stockpiles of WMDs we thought we would (remember...we DID find WMD) doesn't mean that Saddam didn't have them. For all we know, Saddam possessed both the [i]means and the desire[/i] to attack us. He just didn't have the opportunity. The man responsible for 9/11 has eluded capture. That is an unforgivable truth. But there are more "terrorists" than those who are members of al-Qaeda. [quote]And again I ask, what if another country said out slaughtering of unborn babies was an atrocity and they decided to invade America to put and end to abortion. Would they be morally right by invading us? Obama has made such a declaration by saying he wants to make abortions not only as legal as possible but fund it in other countries. These are deaths, just as much as Saddam was killing people. So in a few years when the abortion rate increases, is another country morally right to invade us and install their beliefs upon us?[/quote] I've never really thought about this, to be honest with you. I don't know how I feel about it. But I know that it has nothing to do with the topic at hand. [quote]The UN and its santions are a joke and have been for years. America could have gotten her allies together and put more pressure on Iraq. Other countries were calling for us to put more pressure on them. More pressure which is obviously far and above the joke un sanctions. To me, WWII is a perfect example of a war that had no other recourse but for us to go to war with Germany. I do not think Iraq was on that scale where there was no other otion but to go to war.[/quote] I would assert that there is a fine line between calls for "more pressure" and appeasement. The Munich Syndrome has infected our foreign policy for 60 years, forging false-analogies to be drawn about isolated incidents and causing fallacious, flawed decisions to be made (e.g.- the Vietnam War. Read anything stuff by Robert McNamara or Graham Allison or Irving Janis regarding this subject.) Suffice to say, I don't think that a war must be comparable to or as exemplary as WWII in order to be justified. [quote]I never said what's happening in Iraq and Darfur are different. In fact, I have saying just the opposite. That they are very similar and that because of their similarities along with the similarities with China and Cuba, should we also be invading them since we are invading Iraq? What makes Iraq so much worse than the other situations that its ok to invade iraq but none of the other places? If they are similar in nature and this entire war was a just one because it was to put an end to an evil dictator in Saddam, then by that logic should we not invade China next? Then Cuba and the Darfur and so on and so on? What makes Iraq a just country to invade but none of the others?[/quote] Again, I think there's something to be said about national security. Whether or not you agree with it, Saddam had the potential to pose a greater threat [i]in terms of national security[/i] than Cuba or China or members of the Sudan. The genocidal activities of Saddam were just examples of [i]why[/i] he should be take out, not the sole justification for it. [quote]Hopefully you can follow this since I don't know how to do part of a post and respond to it in the way you did. With each part of your post seperated.[/quote] It's easy dude. Just put a "[" and a "]" in front of the word "quote" to start a separation and then do "[/" and "quote]."
Winchester Posted January 23, 2009 Posted January 23, 2009 [quote name='VoTeckam' post='1758693' date='Jan 22 2009, 04:46 PM']That is quite a strange conclusion. I am just asking what it is that you are placing higher than the opinion of the Holy Father if it is not nationalism. Is your knowledge that is greater than his? Your conscience is better formed? Your wisdom is greater?[/quote] No, since all these are approved by the Church, which should have a more developed conscience than you (unless you hold the pope to be above the Church).
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now