Winchester Posted January 23, 2009 Posted January 23, 2009 [quote name='havok579257' post='1758681' date='Jan 22 2009, 04:38 PM']uh, you never asked for numbers. you said, Iraq was worse.[/quote] No. I said: [quote]Really? What are the numbers? I guess dead Kurds aren't as bad. Yeah, sell the celebrity outrage somewhere else. You think the magic bombs won't kill kids if we attack tribal leaders in Africa instead of the middle east? War is ugly no matter how many pretty celebrities back it.[/quote] [quote]supprting the crusades and supporting being pro-life and preserving EVERY single life are two completly different things. I whole heartedly believe the cruch that pro-life is not just about abortion, its about every life and that we should do everything in our power to preserve every life, be it unborn or born and that Iraq was an unjust war.[/quote] Where's the pope quoted saying the Iraq war is unjust? I know he commented on it, but I don't recall an actual condemnation of the war and I'd love to read it in context. Thanks.
VoTeckam Posted January 23, 2009 Posted January 23, 2009 [quote name='Winchester' post='1758825' date='Jan 22 2009, 09:10 PM']No, since all these are approved by the Church, which should have a more developed conscience than you (unless you hold the pope to be above the Church).[/quote] Im afraid I do not follow Winchester. What is it that is approved by the Church?
VoTeckam Posted January 23, 2009 Posted January 23, 2009 [url="http://www.cbsnews.com/stories/2008/04/16/opinion/main4019265.shtml"]http://www.cbsnews.com/stories/2008/04/16/...in4019265.shtml[/url] [b] "There were not sufficient reasons to unleash a war against Iraq. To say nothing of the fact that, given the new weapons that make possible destructions that go beyond the combatant groups, today we should be asking ourselves if it is still licit to admit."[/b] I also recall reading in an interview before he was Pope that he said there is no concept of preemptive war does not appear in the Catechism.
Saint Therese Posted January 23, 2009 Posted January 23, 2009 This is an article from First Things magazine which addresses the intervention in Iraq from just war theory perspective.[url="http://www.firstthings.com/article.php3?id_article=115"]Article[/url]
Winchester Posted January 23, 2009 Posted January 23, 2009 [quote name='VoTeckam' post='1758915' date='Jan 22 2009, 09:47 PM']Im afraid I do not follow Winchester. What is it that is approved by the Church?[/quote] Both the Crusades and the inquisitional courts.
Winchester Posted January 23, 2009 Posted January 23, 2009 I don't see the second invasion of Iraq as preemptive. Saddam Hussein was an unjust ruler who had a history of slaughtering his own people without regard for non-combatants. He decided to disallow inspections within his country. He could have avoided the war by permitting inspections. Not being a psychotic despot in the first place was also an option. He'd supported terrorism against Israel, had housed Abu Musab al-Zarqawi prior to the invasion. Iraq was not neutral. Yes, other nations have sympathies as well, but total war is not a viable option and Iraq is strategically desirable and was sufficiently weak and hostile to the US. Reality sets in with such decisions, and the reality is that we cannot fight the entire world, which was really only ticked because it hurt their profiteering. They simply weren't clever like our profiteers. Yes, we could have devoted more resources to looking for BL, but all he has to do is enter a country like Pakistan. And the structure of AlQaeda is such that it really wouldn't make that much of a difference. AlQaeda and the Taliban and their ilk are not motivated by our decadence. They started by killing their own for trespasses far less than you could imagine. All your breast beating means nothing to them and no amount of concessions from the Western World will appease them. What we've done has worked--typical international jealousy has hampered this problem because other countries (like France) imagine that if America is diminished that the jihadis will step back. They won't. They'll move to the lesser targets if they manage to beat us. So yes, I disagree with the pope on this one. It's not ends justifying means: deposing evil is a just end. Years of relatively peaceful actions weren't working. Saddam chose that route.
kujo Posted January 23, 2009 Posted January 23, 2009 [quote name='Winchester' post='1759017' date='Jan 23 2009, 01:17 AM']I don't see the second invasion of Iraq as preemptive. Saddam Hussein was an unjust ruler who had a history of slaughtering his own people without regard for non-combatants. He decided to disallow inspections within his country. He could have avoided the war by permitting inspections. Not being a psychotic despot in the first place was also an option. He'd supported terrorism against Israel, had housed Abu Musab al-Zarqawi prior to the invasion. Iraq was not neutral. Yes, other nations have sympathies as well, but total war is not a viable option and Iraq is strategically desirable and was sufficiently weak and hostile to the US. Reality sets in with such decisions, and the reality is that we cannot fight the entire world, which was really only ticked because it hurt their profiteering. They simply weren't clever like our profiteers. Yes, we could have devoted more resources to looking for BL, but all he has to do is enter a country like Pakistan. And the structure of AlQaeda is such that it really wouldn't make that much of a difference. AlQaeda and the Taliban and their ilk are not motivated by our decadence. They started by killing their own for trespasses far less than you could imagine. All your breast beating means nothing to them and no amount of concessions from the Western World will appease them. What we've done has worked--typical international jealousy has hampered this problem because other countries (like France) imagine that if America is diminished that the jihadis will step back. They won't. They'll move to the lesser targets if they manage to beat us. So yes, I disagree with the pope on this one. It's not ends justifying means: deposing evil is a just end. Years of relatively peaceful actions weren't working. Saddam chose that route.[/quote]
VoTeckam Posted January 23, 2009 Posted January 23, 2009 [quote name='Winchester' post='1759017' date='Jan 23 2009, 01:17 AM']I don't see the second invasion of Iraq as preemptive. Saddam Hussein was an unjust ruler who had a history of slaughtering his own people without regard for non-combatants. He decided to disallow inspections within his country. He could have avoided the war by permitting inspections. Not being a psychotic despot in the first place was also an option. He'd supported terrorism against Israel, had housed Abu Musab al-Zarqawi prior to the invasion. Iraq was not neutral. Yes, other nations have sympathies as well, but total war is not a viable option and Iraq is strategically desirable and was sufficiently weak and hostile to the US. Reality sets in with such decisions, and the reality is that we cannot fight the entire world, which was really only ticked because it hurt their profiteering. They simply weren't clever like our profiteers. Yes, we could have devoted more resources to looking for BL, but all he has to do is enter a country like Pakistan. And the structure of AlQaeda is such that it really wouldn't make that much of a difference. AlQaeda and the Taliban and their ilk are not motivated by our decadence. They started by killing their own for trespasses far less than you could imagine. All your breast beating means nothing to them and no amount of concessions from the Western World will appease them. What we've done has worked--typical international jealousy has hampered this problem because other countries (like France) imagine that if America is diminished that the jihadis will step back. They won't. They'll move to the lesser targets if they manage to beat us. So yes, I disagree with the pope on this one. It's not ends justifying means: deposing evil is a just end. Years of relatively peaceful actions weren't working. Saddam chose that route.[/quote] The war was certainly preemptive. The alternative would be that the inital strike was retaliatory. From the US perspective it was not (if you are a Kurd or an Iraqi then it would have been). Yes, there were criminal elements in Iraq that attacked US interests in Isreal before the war, but you can not make a decent case that al-Zarqawi spent any time in Iraq prior to the instability that followed the war. In fact, Al-Zarqawi's presence would not have been welcomed by Saddam. While I (and the Church) realize that proportional and even violent response is necessary in today's world plagued with evil. If this war was handled differently then I would likely be on your side of this arguement; in disagreement with the Holy Father. As I said earlier to Kujo, the intent for this war was likely noble. You will find no greater proponent of freedom in democracy in recent history than that of JPII so I thik is the war would not have been so terrible mishandled his opinion and that of his successor would have been much different. As it is now though, we delivered the Iraqis from one evil and abandoned them to another. Where is the justice in that?
Winchester Posted January 24, 2009 Posted January 24, 2009 [quote name='VoTeckam' post='1759195' date='Jan 23 2009, 09:13 AM']The war was certainly preemptive. The alternative would be that the inital strike was retaliatory. From the US perspective it was not (if you are a Kurd or an Iraqi then it would have been). Yes, there were criminal elements in Iraq that attacked US interests in Isreal before the war, but you can not make a decent case that al-Zarqawi spent any time in Iraq prior to the instability that followed the war. In fact, Al-Zarqawi's presence would not have been welcomed by Saddam.[/quote] No, the alternative is that the first strike was dealing with a threat engaged in injustice and in cooperation with our enemy who ahd a proven record of using his weapons in an immoderate manner. Really. Where is Saddam on record as having disapproved of terrorism? [quote]Saddam's interest in, and support for, non-Iraqi non-state actors was spread across a wide variety of revolutionary, liberation, nationalist, and Islamic terrorist organizations. For years, Saddam maintained training camps for foreign "fighters" drawn from these diverse groups. In some cases, particularly for Palestinians, Saddam was also a strong financial supporter. Saddam supported groups that either associated directly with al Qaeda (such as the Egyptian Islamic Jihad, led at one time by bin Laden's deputy, Ayman al-Zawahiri) or that generally shared al Qaeda's stated goals and objectives. 97[/quote] [i]Iraqi Perspectives Project Saddam and Terrorism: Emerging Insights from Captured Iraqi Documents Volume 1 (Redacted)Kevin M. Woods, Project Leader with James Lacey[/i] I might have been careless and put down the wrong name. I will recheck my other sources and correct myself if such is the case, or make a note of the innacuracy of those sources should the error lie with my memory and the source.
VoTeckam Posted January 24, 2009 Posted January 24, 2009 [quote name='Winchester' post='1760092' date='Jan 24 2009, 09:55 AM']Really. Where is Saddam on record as having disapproved of terrorism?[/quote] It is not terrorism that Saddam disapproved of it was a potential threat to his power.
Winchester Posted January 24, 2009 Posted January 24, 2009 [quote name='VoTeckam' post='1760157' date='Jan 24 2009, 11:59 AM']It is not terrorism that Saddam disapproved of it was a potential threat to his power.[/quote] Yes, only AlQaeda was a threat to his power, but he aided other organizations. Bit of a stretch, there for you to make that claim. Who says this was Saddam's motivation for his supposed opposition to Al Qaeda? Terrorist organizations with varying goals have a history of aiding each other (the provos worked more than once with various mideast terrorist organizations) to aid one is to aid all--which is a practical concern.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now