Tinkerlina Posted January 23, 2009 Posted January 23, 2009 [quote name='missionseeker' post='1758519' date='Jan 22 2009, 01:07 PM'][url="http://news.yahoo.com/s/ap/20090122/ap_on_go_pr_wh/obama_suspected_terrorists"]http://news.yahoo.com/s/ap/20090122/ap_on_...cted_terrorists[/url][/quote] I'm extremely pleased to hear this. -Katie
Winchester Posted January 23, 2009 Posted January 23, 2009 [quote name='fidei defensor' post='1758591' date='Jan 22 2009, 01:57 PM']The difference between your thinking and the thinking of our country is that the U.S. doesn't throw out it's values just because these people are "different." They'll get what they deserve, in the end, regardless of how or where they're detained. We might as well practice what we preach. If you spend some time researching, you'll actually find out that mutual respect, a tactic used by interrogators, has been the most effective means thus far in getting information.[/quote] So we're giving them to American jury trials? The same people who don't want to ruin child molestor's lives? Seriously? The same people who award millions to people who burn their laps with hot coffee? Why not just give them a nuclear device as a door prize on the way out.
Jesus_lol Posted January 23, 2009 Posted January 23, 2009 winchester, you now have the best avatar ever. i am really happy to hear about this. i am glad to see he hasn't wasted anytime following through on promises, good to see. if you cant hold them on US soil, and give them a fair trial, what right do you have to hold them at all? some of the people that have been held there are astounding. a 15year old boy, with a seriously messed up family, who killed an american soldier during a firefight has been there 3 years now i think? hello?! its a kid! he killed someone in combat, like a soldier not a terrorist! yeesh. anyways keeping them locked up that long with no charges only makes them and their friends and family hate the USA more. quickest way to make a terrorist. i know that if i was plucked off the streets and locked up in a horrible place for years without charges, i would be itching to bomb the people responsible.
cmotherofpirl Posted January 23, 2009 Posted January 23, 2009 Rep Murtha of Pa has offered to house them in our state - it was pointed out today this would be a fair swap if Gitmo would keep him instead.
Winchester Posted January 23, 2009 Posted January 23, 2009 [quote name='Jesus_lol' post='1758851' date='Jan 22 2009, 08:38 PM']. a 15year old boy, with a seriously messed up family, who killed an american soldier during a firefight has been there 3 years now i think? hello?! its a kid! he killed someone in combat, like a soldier not a terrorist! yeesh.[/quote] 15 year olds from there are not like our 15 year olds. POWs are not charged and not usually released prior to the end of the conflict. While they are not exactly POWs, they are not the same as regular prisoners. They are enemy combatants more than simple criminals. Access to Cuba is easier to control. Access into the US will be easier. They might provide an attractive target for terrorists. I don't think we should have any idea what happens to them. It should be completely secret what befalls those who assist islamofascism. They aren't ordinary criminals. This is not an ordinary situation.
CatholicCid Posted January 23, 2009 Posted January 23, 2009 [quote name='kujo' post='1758691' date='Jan 22 2009, 05:45 PM'][b]EXACTLY![/b] I think category 3 is bogus anyway until someone demonstrates to me that a subject under this category has yielded actionable intelligence. And, in the event that there is 1, I'll still say it's not enough to trample over our convictions.[/quote] And what then shall we do to the #1's?
Fidei Defensor Posted January 23, 2009 Posted January 23, 2009 [quote name='Winchester' post='1758830' date='Jan 22 2009, 07:19 PM']So we're giving them to American jury trials? The same people who don't want to ruin child molestor's lives? Seriously? The same people who award millions to people who burn their laps with hot coffee? Why not just give them a nuclear device as a door prize on the way out.[/quote] [quote name='Winchester' post='1758884' date='Jan 22 2009, 08:09 PM']15 year olds from there are not like our 15 year olds. POWs are not charged and not usually released prior to the end of the conflict. While they are not exactly POWs, they are not the same as regular prisoners. They are enemy combatants more than simple criminals. Access to Cuba is easier to control. Access into the US will be easier. They might provide an attractive target for terrorists. I don't think we should have any idea what happens to them. It should be completely secret what befalls those who assist islamofascism. They aren't ordinary criminals. This is not an ordinary situation.[/quote] This nation is governed by rule of law. Just because your emotions run high and you feel angry about what these people did (or could do) doesn't mean you get to throw the law out the window and do as you please. That's exactly why the prison is being closed and exactly why it was the right thing to do.
Saint Therese Posted January 23, 2009 Posted January 23, 2009 And what rule of law is being violated by the detention center in Gitmo?
kujo Posted January 23, 2009 Posted January 23, 2009 [quote name='CatholicCid' post='1758924' date='Jan 22 2009, 10:56 PM']And what then shall we do to the #1's?[/quote] Prosecute them to the fullest extent of the law, either here or in their countries of origin.
philothea Posted January 23, 2009 Posted January 23, 2009 [quote name='Saint Therese' post='1758945' date='Jan 22 2009, 10:34 PM']And what rule of law is being violated by the detention center in Gitmo?[/quote] The Geneva Conventions. Do some research for yourself.
Saint Therese Posted January 23, 2009 Posted January 23, 2009 The conventions only protects combatants in uniform. Also, all combatants according to the Geneva Conventions are members of military of governments, which terrorists are not. Perhaps YOU should do some research.
Saint Therese Posted January 23, 2009 Posted January 23, 2009 In WW2 non uniformed combatants were executed.
Winchester Posted January 23, 2009 Posted January 23, 2009 [quote name='fidei defensor' post='1758935' date='Jan 22 2009, 10:22 PM']This nation is governed by rule of law. Just because your emotions run high and you feel angry about what these people did (or could do) doesn't mean you get to throw the law out the window and do as you please. That's exactly why the prison is being closed and exactly why it was the right thing to do.[/quote] Mine is practicality. They are soldiers more than criminals and they are not citizens. You've created a straw man--I've not advocated anarchy. I have made the point that these are neither citizens nor mere criminals. Thus they should not be treated the same as other criminals.
philothea Posted January 23, 2009 Posted January 23, 2009 (edited) [quote name='Saint Therese' post='1758970' date='Jan 22 2009, 11:04 PM']The conventions only protects combatants in uniform. Also, all combatants according to the Geneva Conventions are members of military of governments, which terrorists are not. Perhaps YOU should do some research.[/quote] The Geneva Conventions are primarily concerned with non-combatants and prisoners of war, but address many international issues and humanitarian concerns. In any case, the International Committee of the Red Cross is in charge of determining Convention violations, which they've have said have been going on in Guantanamo Bay. [url="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Guantanamo_Bay_detention_camp"]http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Guantanamo_Bay_detention_camp[/url] [quote]The International Committee of the Red Cross has stated that, "Every person in enemy hands must have some status under international law: he is either a prisoner of war and, as such, covered by the Third Convention, a civilian covered by the Fourth Convention, [or] a member of the medical personnel of the armed forces who is covered by the First Convention. There is no intermediate status; nobody in enemy hands can fall outside the law." Thus, if the detainees are not classified as prisoners of war, this would still grant them the rights of the Fourth Geneva Convention as opposed to the more common Third Geneva Convention which deals exclusively with prisoners of war.[/quote] (edit for typos) Edited January 23, 2009 by philothea
CatholicCid Posted January 23, 2009 Posted January 23, 2009 [quote name='kujo' post='1758952' date='Jan 22 2009, 11:42 PM']Prosecute them to the fullest extent of the law, either here or in their countries of origin.[/quote] #1 was the one's that we were not likely to try and were not welcome in their home country.
Saint Therese Posted January 23, 2009 Posted January 23, 2009 I didn't realize that we were bound to follow guidelines of the Red Cross, as opposed to following American law.
philothea Posted January 23, 2009 Posted January 23, 2009 [quote name='Saint Therese' post='1759033' date='Jan 23 2009, 12:35 AM']I didn't realize that we were bound to follow guidelines of the Red Cross, as opposed to following American law.[/quote] The Red Cross looks for violations because they're the only ones allowed in to places. That's like saying people have to follow the "guidelines of the FBI" instead of federal law. They're investigators in this instance, not lawmakers. The United States of America is one of the leading signatories of the Geneva Accords. The treatment and detention of people by the USA in Guantanamo Bay has been in consistent, flagrant violation of the treaties we agreed to. You asked what rule of law was being violated; I answered.
CatherineM Posted January 23, 2009 Posted January 23, 2009 [quote name='Saint Therese' post='1759033' date='Jan 22 2009, 11:35 PM']I didn't realize that we were bound to follow guidelines of the Red Cross, as opposed to following American law.[/quote] Depends on how you want the US to be viewed by the rest of the folks we share the planet with. We can be the big bully who uses a disproportionate amount of resources, and tells everyone else how to act without doing so ourselves. Or, we can be viewed as just, compassionate, and practicing what we preach. I awoke to the sound of my father screaming in his sleep, what little he got, several times a week growing up. His screams were reliving violations of the Geneva Convention committed against him. Why would any American, let alone any Catholic, want to be approving of activities that we long ago decided weren't and shouldn't be a part of our civilized behavior. Yes, I know that some of these men were involved in atrocities against our people. We don't need to become them. We're supposed to be better than that.
Saint Therese Posted January 23, 2009 Posted January 23, 2009 Frankly I don't care how the U.S is viewed abroad. Why should I care about the opinions of people who can't even run their own countries?
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now