Tinkerlina Posted February 4, 2009 Posted February 4, 2009 [quote name='rkwright' post='1771957' date='Feb 4 2009, 01:49 PM']The death of one or 1,000,000 is still an affront on the dignity of the person. Even if Williamson believed the holocaust was only 300,000, the sin is still extremely grievous. One can still denounce the sin while disagreeing on the numbers. Or at least I thought so...[/quote] Going out of one's way to make statements that seem to downplay the Holocaust is an issue, imo, especially as the numbers are well documented. He could've made a mistake in the numbers, but why would he go out of his way to publically say "Hey, it wasn't as many people as we thought!" -Katie
Winchester Posted February 4, 2009 Posted February 4, 2009 [quote name='Tinkerlina' post='1771954' date='Feb 4 2009, 12:47 PM']The issue of belief in/about the Holocaust is, in a sense, required-as Christians we are called upon to denounce sin, including mass genocide, and minimizing a well documented large scale historical event that resulted in the deaths of millions of people would be contrary to Christian morality. -Katie[/quote] No, it is not. Belief in historical events is not required for salvation, which does not come through exercise of the intellect. We are not Gnostics. Believing the numbers or the nature have been exagerrated has no bearing on the disposition of your immortal soul. Hey, I get very worked up by those who think the WTC collapses were controlled demolition. The people who think that are idiots. As are Holocaust deniers. They are idiots. I firmly believe idiots are permitted into Heaven. My guess is that the Bish is not a denier, but a person who believes the numbers have been exagerrated. This probably disguises some other character flaw, as those who worry about the veracity of the claims tend to be anti-Semites. But I don't know that. What I do know is you can believe that the Holocaust, moon landing and Richard Simmons are all fake, but still love God and accept the Depositum Fidei, which does not include beyond a few religious events, much of history at all.
cmotherofpirl Posted February 4, 2009 Posted February 4, 2009 Honestly the Vatican is probably more interest on Bishop Williamson's views on theology and the Church than his views on history. That is probably why they didn't look into so much. I mean are we going to start screening our bishops for possibly offensive beliefs? [color="#4169E1"]Don't you think it would have been helpful for the Vatican press office to know before the controversy broke with reponses already prepared? [/color] What's more urgent is to deal with the direct matters of faith. Afterward, we can deal with the press and the lesser matters. The issue of most concern is Hell. [color="#4169E1"]How is it suddenly urgent, this has been going on for how many years? Planning ahead would certainly not have hurt anyone AND saved lots and lots of croutons. WHY is common sense suddenly a bad thing?[/color]
Aloysius Posted February 4, 2009 Posted February 4, 2009 (to winchester) and, of course, Bishop Williamson also believes 9/11 was a controlled demolition. go figure sometimes holocaust minimilizing isn't so much an indicator of anti-semitism as it's an indicator that one is predisposed to believe in conspiracies and distrust official accounts of things (which makes one sesceptible to things which can seem like very compelling arguments when they're given a chance; not right, but very convincing... many of those 9/11 conspiracy sites are very convincing which is why there has to be so many volumes of things to de-bunk them and still all it does to the average person who's personally not an expert is confuse them) cmom, what would you have had the pope do? refuse to life the excommunications on the basis of something he wasn't excommunicated for (holocaust denial)? that would be a canonically incorrect decision; a decision which subjected Christian charity and the Christian religion to vanity, worldliness, and the influence of the bullies with mob-mentality. perhaps you are right that a more in depth statement could have been helpful from the start, but not a statement which said +Williamson has to believe in the holocaust to be a Catholic in good standing or to be a Catholic bishop.
kenrockthefirst Posted February 4, 2009 Author Posted February 4, 2009 [quote name='Seven77' post='1771898' date='Feb 4 2009, 12:36 PM']Who said the Holocaust is an article of faith? It's a historical event--pretty foolish to deny it. What if he says that the Church was founded by Christ? He's lost credibility. The Vatican is right to demand a recant. The Church shouldn't get to be discredited for an absurd and erroneous "personally intellectually honest" opinion of a bishop.[/quote] This is the crux of the matter, IMHO. Whether Williamson believes in the Holocaust or wants to minimize the number killed is neither here nor there, from the perspective of whether his excommunication should have been lifted. *However,* insofar as his view on the Holocaust casts doubt on his intellectual acumen and judgment, Williams reinstatement as a bishop certainly raises questions as to his fitness to exercise a leadership position within the Church.
the lords sheep Posted February 4, 2009 Posted February 4, 2009 I think it's important to notice that they didn't give him the ultimatum: recant or don't be Catholic. They said that if he desires to be a PRELATE (an ecclesiastic with superior rank), then he must recant. There's the difference: the Church wants him back in the fold, but She can decide, and has every right to do so, whether or not to give him any "power" so to speak based on his personal views.
cmotherofpirl Posted February 4, 2009 Posted February 4, 2009 [quote name='Aloysius' post='1771966' date='Feb 4 2009, 01:58 PM']cmom, what would you have had the pope do? refuse to life the excommunications on the basis of something he wasn't excommunicated for (holocaust denial)? that would be a canonically incorrect decision; a decision which subjected Christian charity and the Christian religion to vanity, worldliness, and the influence of the bullies with mob-mentality. perhaps you are right that a more in depth statement could have been helpful from the start, but not a statement which said +Williamson has to believe in the holocaust to be a Catholic in good standing or to be a Catholic bishop.[/quote] THis a is not about the validity of what the Holy Father did, but HOW it was done. I expect the pope himself to do nothing, thats why he has a staff I do expect his staff to plan and think ahead of the possible ramifications of a public statement BEFORE its released and have all the talking points AND responses ready. Someone could have just googled the Bishops, and looked for any problems. They also could have used the time-honored practice of leaking hints to the press, guage the reaction and be READY for the firestorm. The lack of preperation and the scramble could have been avoided by simply following the Boy Scout motto: BE PREPARED!
rkwright Posted February 4, 2009 Posted February 4, 2009 [quote name='cmotherofpirl' post='1772001' date='Feb 4 2009, 01:54 PM']THis a is not about the validity of what the Holy Father did, but HOW it was done. I expect the pope himself to do nothing, thats why he has a staff I do expect his staff to plan and think ahead of the possible ramifications of a public statement BEFORE its released and have all the talking points AND responses ready. Someone could have just googled the Bishops, and looked for any problems. They also could have used the time-honored practice of leaking hints to the press, guage the reaction and be READY for the firestorm. The lack of preperation and the scramble could have been avoided by simply following the Boy Scout motto: BE PREPARED![/quote] Well sure. I agree with you on this. Hindsight is 20/20.
eagle_eye222001 Posted February 4, 2009 Posted February 4, 2009 [quote name='Didacus' post='1771895' date='Feb 4 2009, 11:31 AM']I once reviewed some of the logic and explanations by some of the holocaust 'deniers' and found some of their argumetns to be compelling. It is clear to me that the holocaust did indeed happen, however, several exagerations have come from this historical fact.[/quote] Like what? If you do respond, you may want to respond on another thread so we don't kill this one. ---------------- Now playing: [url="http://www.foxytunes.com/artist/flipsyde/track/happy+birthday"]Flipsyde - Happy Birthday[/url] via [url="http://www.foxytunes.com/signatunes/"]FoxyTunes[/url]
Aloysius Posted February 4, 2009 Posted February 4, 2009 This is the report that +Williamson sited in his interview: [url="http://www.ihr.org/jhr/v12/v12p391_Luftl.html"]http://www.ihr.org/jhr/v12/v12p391_Luftl.html[/url] nota bene: I do not endorse the conclusions of that report, and since I have no specific expertice in the matter I simply do not believe the report because I don't want to believe it and because there is so much evidence that there were gas chambers (ie in the trial records it is admitted)... but historical admissions of gas chambers don't directly debunk that report, and I have not seen any engineering-based refutation of the report which is something I would be very interested in (but the kai-bash on all discussion of the matter as a question at all keeps any real direct refutation from coming out; why prove someone wrong ad argumentum when you can just through them in jail or refuse them the episcopy, right?). I pretty much plug my ears and close my eyes to this report on the basis of other historical evidence which is not directly related to the arguments made in it.
ironmonk Posted February 4, 2009 Posted February 4, 2009 [quote name='Aloysius' post='1771877' date='Feb 4 2009, 12:06 PM']great, so now the Holocaust is an artical of faith???[/quote] The Pope is not saying that... what he is saying that as a Bishop ("episcopal function") his personal view of the holocaust cannot be taught and that this man must make it clear. This would fall under obedience, not faith. God Bless, ironmonk
Aloysius Posted February 4, 2009 Posted February 4, 2009 One is never obligated by obedience to sin. If Bishop Williamson, on the basis of obedience, were to say he believes 6 million Jews died in the holocaust, it would be a lie. You cannot obligate under obedience such a lie, such an historical fact with no requirement to believe it on faith must be free to be discussed and debated, free to allow for any wildly wrong opinion. it wouldn't matter if the whole world would be converted by +Williamson's lie, it would be an evil act and it would be absolutely wrong of him to say he believed in the 6 million number if he did not really believe in it.
socalscout Posted February 4, 2009 Posted February 4, 2009 (edited) [quote name='Aloysius' post='1771877' date='Feb 4 2009, 10:06 AM']great, so now the Holocaust is an artical of faith??? maybe we should make sure every bishop gives a statement on their positions on every historical event and whether or not any of their positions offend some people should determine whether or not they can be bishops. eh... this bothers me a lot. imagine if the Church suddenly asked you to change your unpopular historical belief about the Spanish Inquisition and admit the larger numbers of people who were supposedly killed rather than the smaller numbers you believe were killed based upon your reading of the historical account. what if +Williamson doesn't recant? Will he be re-excommunicated? ON WHAT GROUNDS? Remember folks, this is the Catholic Church, not the international historians club. You can be a member of the Church and believe there were no such thing as dinosaurs if you want. your historical beliefs are only regulated by the Church to say certain things about the historicity of the Old and New Testaments and the infallibility of the Church. okay, anyway, apart from my rant, I will say I would support Williamson being made to act [i]ut sacerdos[/i] in the re-integrated society if he does not recant based solely on the fact that he is incapable of ministering to the people of Europe without being potentially arrested... meaning that though he has the valid sacramental episcopal orders, he would limit himself only to acting as a priest. see, here's the thing about +Williamson, he's too personally intellectually honest to ever recant something that he really believes like this simply on the basis that his beliefs offend people; he would have to be convinced by an historical argument not by a bullying move that says "change your historical opinion or else"[/quote] I could not agree with you more! Yes, using Obedience I can totally see the Vatican gagging him and telling him to shut up but excommunication?!! Edited February 4, 2009 by socalscout
Winchester Posted February 4, 2009 Posted February 4, 2009 [quote name='Aloysius' post='1771966' date='Feb 4 2009, 12:58 PM']sometimes holocaust minimilizing isn't so much an indicator of anti-semitism as it's an indicator that one is predisposed to believe in conspiracies and distrust official accounts of things[/quote] I agree wit dat.
Roamin'Catholic Posted February 4, 2009 Posted February 4, 2009 God help you if you believe only 5,999,999 Jews died in the Holocaust.
Deeds Posted February 4, 2009 Posted February 4, 2009 Bishop Williamson never met a conspiracy theory he didn't like. While he's free to subscribe to as many as he chooses, he has (unintentionally) spoilt the partial reconciliation of the SSPX with the Church. Now, I think much of the media reaction to it has been completely hysterical - it's as if he said he was in favour of killing Jews - but the Vatican has to quell it somehow. It's terrible PR. (On Father Z's blog, there's an article by a Rabbi who also thinks the fuss is ridiculous.) I doubt he will recant his views, so if the SSPX fully joins the Church I'm guessing it's au revoir to his Bishop status (or perhaps he'll set up his own breakaway group?). I'm not sure how attached to him the other bishops are, although Bishop Fellay was pretty swift and decisive with his condemnation of the whole affair, so hopefully he won't be a barrier to a full reconciliation.
Aloysius Posted February 4, 2009 Posted February 4, 2009 yes, he may be made to operate ut sacerdotes, ie as a priest. his ordination as a bishop is irrevocable and he will enter into eternity (one way or the other) as a bishop. I think he's too smart to go off on his own over this. The only thing that would make +Williamson break away to make his own sub-schism in my opinion is if there is something in the regularization process that he doesn't like; either a doctrine that the SSPX agrees to espouse which he feels betrays tradition or a juridical structure which he feels sets the SSPX up to eventually become irrelevent and absorbed into modernism. He would not be dumb enough to lead a schism on the basis of rejecting the holocaust; but he also will not lie about what he believes about the holocaust and that may cost him his status as one of the bishops of the society.
Chiquitunga Posted February 4, 2009 Posted February 4, 2009 (edited) [quote name='Aloysius' post='1772188' date='Feb 4 2009, 05:27 PM']yes, he may be made to operate ut sacerdotes, ie as a priest. his ordination as a bishop is irrevocable and he will enter into eternity (one way or the other) as a bishop.[/quote] That sounds reasonable. This is a side topic (sorry) but what then would he say of someone like Edith Stein/St. Teresa Benedicta? She died in a gas chamber. Or maybe he wouldn't recognize her as a saint as she was canonized by JP2. I thought I heard that some in the SSPX don't recognize modern saints .. not that I'm anti-sspx ... I want their full communion and regularization, and I think this topic is irrelevant to that, but it was good the Holy Father is asking him to recant this if he wants to serve as a bishop in the Catholic Church (although on another side note, there are many other bishops in the Church that have some off views on different topics, not making judgments on anyone in particular) Edited February 4, 2009 by Margaret Clare
Aloysius Posted February 4, 2009 Posted February 4, 2009 +Williamson thinks people died in concentration camps, but not in gas chambers, so any individual one can point to who died in a concentration camp he would probably consider to have died a different way. if you watched his interview about it, he really isn't that unreasonable about it. HCF, do you think Williamson should say something he doesn't believe in on the basis of obedience? I disagree with the Holy Father's move here (or, more accurately, his Secretary of State, though I am sure they are of accord on the matter) because this is exactly the type of PR move which should be foreign to the dealings of the Church because it is contrary to Christian freedom and truth. This is the type of thing demanded of celebreties when they run afoul of this or that minority group; it should NOT be the type of thing demanded of successors of the Apostles; at least, not in this way.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now