Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Vatican Demands Holocaust Denier Recant


Recommended Posts

HisChildForever
Posted

[quote name='Aloysius' post='1772234' date='Feb 4 2009, 06:11 PM']HCF, do you think Williamson should say something he doesn't believe in on the basis of obedience?[/quote]

First, there is no logical reason as to why he denies the historical evidence.

Second, absolutely. Why? Well I feel the Church has no legal say in the business of homosexual civil unions, but I am obediant to the Church. I also strongly dislike the thought of subordination in marriage because I am independent, stubborn, and hard-headed, but I am obediant to the Church and will perform that role within marriage (if I ever get married).

Any Catholic who disobeys Catholic teaching (the one being discussed now Papal authority) has no right to call themselves Catholic.

Posted

[quote name='HisChildForever' post='1772251' date='Feb 4 2009, 04:35 PM']Any Catholic who disobeys Catholic teaching (the one being discussed now Papal authority) has no right to call themselves Catholic.[/quote]


As Al already said though, papal authority does not stretch as far as commanding someone to lie.

If a priest, under holy obedience, is told by his bishop to kill himself, that priest is under moral obligation to REFUSE his bishop. The same would go for a bishop telling his priest to lie in a court of law (or really any lie).

Although the belief that williamson might have is untrue, to deny that he believes it would be a lie. If I truly believe the sky is brown, but I tell someone I believe it is blue... I become a liar.

HisChildForever
Posted

[quote name='Slappo' post='1772282' date='Feb 4 2009, 07:23 PM']If a priest, under holy obedience, is told by his bishop to kill himself, that priest is under moral obligation to REFUSE his bishop. The same would go for a bishop telling his priest to lie in a court of law (or really any lie).[/quote]

These are [b]extreme[/b] examples.

[quote]Although the belief that williamson might have is untrue, to deny that he believes it would be a lie. If I truly believe the sky is brown, but I tell someone I believe it is blue... I become a liar.[/quote]

I would really like to know why Williamson denies historical evidence. Technically, he already is a liar for saying that the evidence is wrong, yes?

Posted

as was discussed before, there are plenty of seemingly compelling reasons to question the historical evidence, not the least of which is the engineer's report cited by +Williamson in the interview, linked by me earlier in the thread (especially the exact 6 million number is a little questionable only because it seems to have sprung from nowhere, please correct me if I'm wrong, i think it likely to be a very accurate ballpark estimate but I've never heard of concrete studies that showed the 6 million number) and a complete lack of intellectually honest de-bunkings of those compelling reasons (i believe they could very well be de-bunked, but it's simply not done, instead outrage is called for and the mob mentality simply villifies whoever brings any questions).

one is never bound in obedience to lie about anything. if one is in the Church, one is bound to give assent of their will to the ordinary teachings of the Church and the instructions of the magisterium, so long as it would not cause one to sin. If it would cause you to sin, you are morally obligated NOT to obey. if the pope commanded you to murder, you must disobey. if the pope commanded you to lie (or else, demanded you say something about what you believe which is not what you believe), you must disobey.

assent to the mind of the Church on the matter of homosexual marriage is an entirely different matter; you assent to the mind of the Church on the basis of your membership in the Church and the humility to say your opinion might not hold as much weight as the Church's sometimes. but you never say "my opinion is x" unless your opinion truly is x. you cannot lie, it's one of the Ten Commandments and the Church has never had any pretense about being above the commandments of God.

Posted

[quote name='Winchester' post='1771960' date='Feb 4 2009, 01:53 PM']No, it is not. Belief in historical events is not required for salvation, which does not come through exercise of the intellect. We are not Gnostics. Believing the numbers or the nature have been exagerrated has no bearing on the disposition of your immortal soul.

Hey, I get very worked up by those who think the WTC collapses were controlled demolition. The people who think that are idiots. As are Holocaust deniers. They are idiots. I firmly believe idiots are permitted into Heaven. My guess is that the Bish is not a denier, but a person who believes the numbers have been exagerrated. This probably disguises some other character flaw, as those who worry about the veracity of the claims tend to be anti-Semites. But I don't know that. What I do know is you can believe that the Holocaust, moon landing and Richard Simmons are all fake, but still love God and accept the Depositum Fidei, which does not include beyond a few religious events, much of history at all.[/quote]

I do get your point, I'm just thinking of the Holocaust as more than a historical event in the sense that landing on the moon was a historical event. I'm not saying these people are going to hell, but I think denying/minimizing something atrocious like the Holocaust is failing in one's moral duty to speak out against crime. I know it isn't required in a theological sense, I just think in a moral sense the argument could be made. -Katie

Posted

Jewish groups are understandably offended, but what do they know about excommunications? You don't impose excommunications simply because someone holds on to a ridiculous view, nor is lifting an excommunication an endorsement of that view. The Vatican has too many hands in it's pockets telling it what to do, it needs to stand up for what it knows to be right.

Posted

Re: The whole "If Williamson recants his statements he is lying about what he believes"-what if someone disagrees with the Church on another issue? If he had gone on Swedish TV and said that abortion isn't as big of a deal because less babies than we think are killed each year, I think a lot of people here would feel differently. -Katie

Posted

[quote name='Tinkerlina' post='1772365' date='Feb 4 2009, 09:48 PM']Re: The whole "If Williamson recants his statements he is lying about what he believes"-what if someone disagrees with the Church on another issue? If he had gone on Swedish TV and said that abortion isn't as big of a deal because less babies than we think are killed each year, I think a lot of people here would feel differently. -Katie[/quote]
such a person must either convert to the truth of the Church, or in the process of converting humble themselves and simply not speak about the issue out of trust that their opinion must be wrong and the Church's must be right, or else leave the Church out of honesty. however, this is completely non-comparable to an historical event which is not connected to our faith or morals. +Williamson is bound by faith and morals to say "it would be atrocious and horribly immoral to round up 6 million Jews and send them to gas chambers to kill them".. he is not, however, bound to say that that's what Adolf Hitler did; at least he's not bound by faith or morals to do so.

and actually, if he believed that less babies are killed each year than the statistics allow, he would not be doing anything immoral. one should point the statistics out to him and argue the point; but not as a point of faith or morals but a mere point of regular old fact. which is what should happen with any holocaust minimalizer, you should point to facts to prove them wrong not cry foul, woe is me, and ask that they be sent to jail!

it would be a sin for one who believed abortion to be morally permissable to say "I do not believe abortion is morally permissable". it is always sinful to lie.

please not, +Williamson is NOT disagreeing with the Church on any issue, because the Church has no scope to say anything on historical issues. the Church will never make a statement that Neil Armstrong went to the moon and she never will, so everyone who thinks it was a soundstage is safe to remain in the Church as long as they want. the level of atrocity in the historical record you disagree with does not matter. you could not think the Rwanda genocide occurred, and it wouldn't be a moral issue unless you said it should have occurred or that if it had occurred it would have been justified.

Posted

[quote name='Aloysius' post='1771877' date='Feb 4 2009, 09:06 AM']great, so now the Holocaust is an article of faith???[/quote]
I am concerned.

Posted

[quote name='Aloysius' post='1772371' date='Feb 4 2009, 09:54 PM']such a person must either convert to the truth of the Church, or in the process of converting humble themselves and simply not speak about the issue out of trust that their opinion must be wrong and the Church's must be right, or else leave the Church out of honesty. however, this is completely non-comparable to an historical event which is not connected to our faith or morals.[/quote]

I get you, but I don't see that the Holocaust (or any genocide) is not in some way connected to faith and morals. I think a well formed conscience would be compelled to uphold the facts and not blatantly make a genocide out to be less than it was. I do realize that he could be honestly confused about this, but I think the Church is right in telling him to can it.

[quote name='Aloysius' post='1772371' date='Feb 4 2009, 09:54 PM']and actually, if he believed that less babies are killed each year than the statistics allow, he would not be doing anything immoral. one should point the statistics out to him and argue the point; but not as a point of faith or morals but a mere point of regular old fact. which is what should happen with any holocaust minimalizer, you should point to facts to prove them wrong not cry foul, woe is me, and ask that they be sent to jail![/quote]

Who said anything about sending him to jail?

[quote name='Aloysius' post='1772371' date='Feb 4 2009, 09:54 PM']t would be a sin for one who believed abortion to be morally permissable to say "I do not believe abortion is morally permissable". it is always sinful to lie.[/quote]
Even when representing the Church to millions of people in a public arena?

Posted

[quote name='Aloysius' post='1772371' date='Feb 4 2009, 08:54 PM']please not, +Williamson is NOT disagreeing with the Church on any issue, because the Church has no scope to say anything on historical issues.[/quote]

"With regard to those truths connected to revelation by historical necessity and which are to be held definitively, but are not able to be declared as divinely revealed, the following examples can be given: the legitimacy of the election of the Supreme Pontiff or of the celebration of an ecumenical council, the canonizations of saints (dogmatic facts), the declaration of Pope Leo XIII in the Apostolic Letter Apostolicae Curae on the invalidity of Anglican ordinations." (The Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, [i]Doctrinal Commentary on the Concluding Formula of the Professio Fidei[/i], 29 June 1998)

Posted (edited)

[quote name='Slappo' post='1772282' date='Feb 4 2009, 05:23 PM']As Al already said though, papal authority does not stretch as far as commanding someone to lie.[/quote]
Nor does papal authority touch on matters of geometry or algebra, subjects about which the pope could be an utter idiot. Moreover, the pope does not have the competence to decree that the American perspective on the Japanese attack on Pearl Harbor must be accepted by all Catholics. To give just a few examples.

Catholics must not accept uncritically the view of the holocaust which focuses upon the six million Jews who were killed by Hitler's war machine, while ignoring the other 12 million people who died in the Nazi concentration camps.

Edited by Apotheoun
Posted (edited)

[quote name='Resurrexi' post='1772381' date='Feb 4 2009, 07:02 PM']"With regard to those truths connected to revelation by historical necessity and which are to be held definitively, but are not able to be declared as divinely revealed, the following examples can be given: the legitimacy of the election of the Supreme Pontiff or of the celebration of an ecumenical council, the canonizations of saints (dogmatic facts), the declaration of Pope Leo XIII in the Apostolic Letter Apostolicae Curae on the invalidity of Anglican ordinations." (The Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, [i]Doctrinal Commentary on the Concluding Formula of the Professio Fidei[/i], 29 June 1998)[/quote]
The holocaust, or any other Nazi activity for that matter, is not connected to the dogmas of the Catholic faith by either logical or historical necessity. The Magisterium has no authoritative role in the presentation of the history of World War II.

Edited by Apotheoun
Posted (edited)

[quote name='Slappo' post='1772282' date='Feb 4 2009, 07:23 PM']Although the belief that williamson might have is untrue, to deny that he believes it would be a lie. If I truly believe the sky is brown, but I tell someone I believe it is blue... I become a liar.[/quote]

That's one of the most absurd things I've ever read.

Besides, CCC 2464 states that "A lie consists in speaking a falsehood with the intention of deceiving", and since stating that the sky is blue is not a falsehood, the first condition for it being a lie is not present.

Edited by Norseman82
Posted

[quote name='Tinkerlina' post='1772378' date='Feb 4 2009, 07:01 PM']I get you, but I don't see that the Holocaust (or any genocide) is not in some way connected to faith and morals. I think a well formed conscience would be compelled to uphold the facts and not blatantly make a genocide out to be less than it was. I do realize that he could be honestly confused about this, but I think the Church is right in telling him to can it.[/quote]
The Church condemns acts of genocide, but she cannot excommunicate a person for being wrong about an historical event. Nor can she require a person to "recant" a position taken on a historical event. Ultimately the Vatican is confusing theology, where the Magisterium has the power to require a man to recant a given theological proposition, with history, where the Magisterium has no special competence.

Posted

[quote name='Resurrexi' post='1772381' date='Feb 4 2009, 10:02 PM']"With regard to those truths connected to revelation by historical necessity and which are to be held definitively, but are not able to be declared as divinely revealed, the following examples can be given: the legitimacy of the election of the Supreme Pontiff or of the celebration of an ecumenical council, the canonizations of saints (dogmatic facts), the declaration of Pope Leo XIII in the Apostolic Letter Apostolicae Curae on the invalidity of Anglican ordinations." (The Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, [i]Doctrinal Commentary on the Concluding Formula of the Professio Fidei[/i], 29 June 1998)[/quote]
yes, with those types of notable exceptions as those are matters of faith, they are connected to revelation by historical necessity. the holocaust is not a matter of faith and is not connected to revelation by historical necessity, nor can the Church ever make it such.

who wants to send him to jail? the Germans (read: Nazi thought-crime police)

Posted

[quote name='Apotheoun' post='1772390' date='Feb 4 2009, 10:08 PM']The Church condemns acts of genocide, but she cannot excommunicate a person for being wrong about an historical event. Nor can she require a person to "recant" a position taken on a historical event. Ultimately the Vatican is confusing theology, where the Magisterium has the power to require a man to recant a given theological proposition, with history, where the Magisterium has no special competence.[/quote]

I don't know that they are forbidding him from believing his insidious nonsense (I mean, you can't force someone to change their mind if they believe it), but I think they are making him recant a[i] public statement[/i] that has became a major scandal. -Katie

Posted

This whole thing is motivated by political correctness. The next thing you know people will be saying that Pope Benedict XVI should resign because he was a member of the Hitler Youth.

Posted

[quote name='Aloysius' post='1772391' date='Feb 4 2009, 10:08 PM']yes, with those types of notable exceptions as those are matters of faith, they are connected to revelation by historical necessity. the holocaust is not a matter of faith and is not connected to revelation by historical necessity, nor can the Church ever make it such.

who wants to send him to jail? the Germans (read: Nazi thought-crime police)[/quote]

Ok, he shouldn't go to jail and no one can force him to change his mind but if he is working toward coming into full communion with the Church, I do think the Church is within its rights to make him recant public statements that he's made on a public level, statements that have caused a major scandal. -Katie

Posted (edited)

[quote name='Apotheoun' post='1772387' date='Feb 4 2009, 09:05 PM']The holocaust, or any other Nazi activity for that matter, is not connected to the dogmas of the Catholic faith by either logical or historical necessity. The Magisterium has no authoritative role in the presentation of the history of World War II.[/quote]

The fact that Pius XII was Pope and that Maximilian Kolbe and that Teresa Benedicta of the Cross are Saints is connected to the deposit of faith by historical necessity, however.

Edited by Resurrexi

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...