Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Vatican Demands Holocaust Denier Recant


Recommended Posts

Posted

[quote name='Tinkerlina' post='1772392' date='Feb 4 2009, 07:10 PM']I don't know that they are forbidding him from believing his insidious nonsense (I mean, you can't force someone to change their mind if they believe it), but I think they are making him recant a[i] public statement[/i] that has became a major scandal. -Katie[/quote]
The Vatican has no authority to require that of him.

HisChildForever
Posted

[quote name='Apotheoun' post='1772390' date='Feb 4 2009, 09:08 PM']The Church condemns acts of genocide, but she cannot excommunicate a person for being wrong about an historical event. Nor can she require a person to "recant" a position taken on a historical event. Ultimately the Vatican is confusing theology, where the Magisterium has the power to require a man to recant a given theological proposition, with history, where the Magisterium has no special competence.[/quote]

How on earth can you say that the Vatican is confusing theology??

Posted

[quote name='Apotheoun' post='1772393' date='Feb 4 2009, 10:11 PM']This whole thing is motivated by political correctness. The next thing you know people will be saying that Pope Benedict XVI should resign because he was a member of the Hitler Youth.[/quote]

Exactly

Posted

[quote name='Tinkerlina' post='1772378' date='Feb 4 2009, 10:01 PM']Even when representing the Church to millions of people in a public arena?[/quote]
it would also be a sin for him to contradict Church teaching.

what you are missing in your analogies is that the holocaust IS NOT CHURCH TEACHING. It's not even close to Church teaching, it could never be Church teaching any more than 2 + 2 = 4 could be Church teaching.

Norseman, the deceit is in saying "I believe..."... if you believe the sky is brown, but you say "I believe the sky is blue", then you have committed a lie by decieving the person you speak to about what you believe. and even without those words, the phrase "i believe" is pretty much implied in every statement of fact you ever make, you would be decieving if you said "the sky is blue" if you truly in your heart believed it was brown, because you are deceiving someone as to what it is that you hold to be true.

Posted

I wish the Vatican would be this active in reprimanding the bishops who have taken positions in opposition to the moral teaching of the Church.

Posted

[quote name='Apotheoun' post='1772393' date='Feb 4 2009, 10:11 PM']This whole thing is motivated by political correctness. The next thing you know people will be saying that Pope Benedict XVI should resign because he was a member of the Hitler Youth.[/quote]

Political Correctness is necessary sometimes. And people made a fuss about the Hitler Youth thing when Benedict became Pope-although once an explanation was given, I understood, but honestly when I heard "New Pope was a member of Hitler Youth" I was taken aback myself. -Katie

Posted

[quote name='Apotheoun' post='1772400' date='Feb 4 2009, 10:13 PM']I wish the Vatican would be this active in reprimanding the bishops who have taken positions in opposition to the moral teaching of the Church.[/quote]

I feel the same way.

Posted

[quote name='Aloysius' post='1772399' date='Feb 4 2009, 10:13 PM']it would also be a sin for him to contradict Church teaching.

what you are missing in your analogies is that the holocaust IS NOT CHURCH TEACHING. It's not even close to Church teaching, it could never be Church teaching any more than 2 + 2 = 4 could be Church teaching.

Norseman, the deceit is in saying "I believe..."... if you believe the sky is brown, but you say "I believe the sky is blue", then you have committed a lie by decieving the person you speak to about what you believe. and even without those words, the phrase "i believe" is pretty much implied in every statement of fact you ever make, you would be decieving if you said "the sky is blue" if you truly in your heart believed it was brown, because you are deceiving someone as to what it is that you hold to be true.[/quote]

I concede that it is not Church teaching-however, the Church does have the authority to prevent a bishop (who is almost back in full communion) from making public comments that cause scandal. Like I said, I don't think they necessarily need him to go to bed at night telling himself something he doesn't believe, but want him to take back the grossly imprudent statements that he made that have been proving hurtful to the Church.-Katie

Posted

[quote name='Norseman82' post='1772388' date='Feb 4 2009, 07:06 PM']That's one of the most absurd things I've ever read.

Besides, CCC 2464 states that "A lie consists in speaking a falsehood with the intention of deceiving", and since stating that the sky is blue is not a falsehood, the first condition for it being a lie is not present.[/quote]
The color of the sky is a matter of perception, not truth. My brother suffers from color blindness, and the sky is rather gray to him.

Posted

Nancy Pelosi, Joe Biden, and Ted Kennedy are "Catholics" in good standing with their bishops, and they are for the murder of the innocent unborn, while Bishop Williamson is wrong about a historical matter. Those in authority within the Church shall be judged by God for not worrying about what is really important.

Posted

[quote name='Tinkerlina' post='1772401' date='Feb 4 2009, 07:13 PM']Political Correctness is necessary sometimes.[/quote]
You'd make an excellent Stalinist.

Posted

[quote name='rkwright' post='1771958' date='Feb 4 2009, 01:50 PM']Another factor that is present is that B16 is German, and its illegal to deny the holocaust in Germany. It probably influenced him a little...[/quote]

You know, in a way I don't blame Germany for having a law like that. Do I agree with it? NO. But I can see where that kind of thinking came about. I've never been to Germany but my cousin worked over there for a project and said that she found a lot of people held a deep sense of shame that they had "failed" to prevent the Holocaust-so maybe this law comes from fear of falling into the same trap of lies. -Katie

Posted

[quote name='Apotheoun' post='1772408' date='Feb 4 2009, 10:18 PM']Nancy Pelosi, Joe Biden, and Ted Kennedy are "Catholics" in good standing with their bishops, and they are for the murder of the innocent unborn, while Bishop Williamson is wrong about a historical matter. Those in authority within the Church shall be judged by God for not worrying about what is really important.[/quote]

But, Pelosi, Biden and Kennedy aren't clergy who publically represent the Church when they speak, however horrible their beliefs are. And I do believe the Vatican has condemend pro-choice politicians on several occasions. -Katie

Posted (edited)

[quote name='Apotheoun' post='1772410' date='Feb 4 2009, 10:19 PM']You'd make an excellent Stalinist.[/quote]

You know it. I bet that's what he was trying to do when he perpetuated the Holodomor.-Katie

Edited by Tinkerlina
Posted (edited)

[quote name='HisChildForever' post='1772397' date='Feb 4 2009, 07:12 PM']How on earth can you say that the Vatican is confusing theology??[/quote]
The Nazi genocide is not a "theological truth." The Vatican may not like that Bishop Williamson doesn't think that that many Jews were killed in the Holocaust, and his position may be historically speaking "idiotic," but Bishop Williamson has not made a theological error in saying what he has said. Now, the Vatican could step in if Bishop Williamson were to say that contraception is moral (something that the former bishop of my diocese did), and it could then reprimand him and require that he recant, because that is a theological matter.

Sadly, the Vatican never made my former bishop confess his error on contraception, but the Anti-Defamation League wasn't pressuring the Vatican on that issue.

Edited by Apotheoun
Posted

[quote name='Apotheoun' post='1772418' date='Feb 4 2009, 10:24 PM']The Nazi genocide is not a "theological truth." The Vatican may not like that Bishop Williamson doesn't think that that many Jews were killed in the Holocaust, and his position may be historically speaking "idiotic," but Bishop Williamson has not made a theological error in saying what he has said. Now, the Vatican could step in if Bishop Williamson were to say that contraception is moral (something that the former bishop of my diocese did), and it could then reprimand him and require that he recant, because that is a theological matter. Sadly, the Vatican never made my former bishop confess his error on contraception, but the Anti-Defamation League wasn't pressuring the Vatican on that issue.[/quote]

Did your bishop go on multinational TV and proclaim his views? -Katie

Posted

[quote name='Tinkerlina' post='1772419' date='Feb 4 2009, 07:28 PM']Did your bishop go on multinational TV and proclaim his views? -Katie[/quote]
He preached it from the pulpit of the cathedral. He was also a big supporter of homosexual "rights" and of allowing for "gay gifts" in the Church.

Posted

[quote name='Tinkerlina' post='1772419' date='Feb 4 2009, 07:28 PM']Did your bishop go on multinational TV and proclaim his views? -Katie[/quote]
Swedish TV isn't multi-national.

Posted

[quote name='Apotheoun' post='1772421' date='Feb 4 2009, 10:29 PM']He preached it from the pulpit of the cathedral. He was also a big supporter of homosexual "rights" and of allowing for "gay gifts" in the Church.[/quote]

That is wrong. My point is not that he is less wrong, but that the Vatican can't possibly account for every bishop all the time but when someone goes on international television, they are probably more likely to be noticed. -Katie

Posted (edited)

[quote name='Apotheoun' post='1772422' date='Feb 4 2009, 10:30 PM']Swedish TV isn't multi-national.[/quote]

Sorry, national TV. -Katie ETA: No, actually I think they do broadcase in other parts of europe.

Edited by Tinkerlina

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...