MIKolbe Posted August 16, 2012 Posted August 16, 2012 [quote name='Nihil Obstat' timestamp='1345063203' post='2468191'] That would just be cruel. [img]http://justinmcroberts.com/blog/wp-content/uploads/2011/04/sumo-kid1.jpg[/img] [/quote] Ahhhh From my slimmer days.....
Studiumecclesiae Posted August 16, 2012 Author Posted August 16, 2012 [quote name='fides' Jack' timestamp='1345051542' post='2468045'] What made you finally decide to go to the dark side? Or is that a bad question to ask...? If this thread was moved from the debate table, maybe I shouldn't ask... [/quote] The dark side isn't the SSPX, but the modern Church which teaches heresies. The ED communities are fine, but they aren't allowed to criticize the Vatican II council in public. The SSPX is allowed. The ED communities have great qualities and are doing well but the SSPX ones are having a really authentic fight against modernism and it's very admirable. I left the ED because I was disatisfied, and they would "let go", when it's problematic, accept things that are unacceptable because the Church says it's fine. But the Church is only trying to get adapted to the modern world, when it should be the world adapting to it. This is why I joined the SSPX. Cause I can't accept the Vatican II council, the new catechism of John Paul II, the new Canon Law that lets girls serve mass, ecumenism, interreligious dialogue, collegiality, the new mass and other things. [b]Thanks for all your replies. I'm glad I'm not the only one here.[/b]
dymphnamaria Posted August 16, 2012 Posted August 16, 2012 [quote name='Studiumecclesiae' timestamp='1345101426' post='2468545'] The dark side isn't the SSPX, but the modern Church which teaches heresies. The ED communities are fine, but they aren't allowed to criticize the Vatican II council in public. The SSPX is allowed. The ED communities have great qualities and are doing well but the SSPX ones are having a really authentic fight against modernism and it's very admirable. I left the ED because I was disatisfied, and they would "let go", when it's problematic, accept things that are unacceptable because the Church says it's fine. But the Church is only trying to get adapted to the modern world, when it should be the world adapting to it. This is why I joined the SSPX. Cause I can't accept the Vatican II council, the new catechism of John Paul II, the new Canon Law that lets girls serve mass, ecumenism, interreligious dialogue, collegiality, the new mass and other things. [b]Thanks for all your replies. I'm glad I'm not the only one here.[/b] [/quote]
Nihil Obstat Posted August 16, 2012 Posted August 16, 2012 I am sympathetic towards your thought process, Studiumecclesiae. By that I mean that I share many of your concerns, and (I hope) much of your zeal and desire to right what has gone wrong.
dUSt Posted August 16, 2012 Posted August 16, 2012 I too share your concerns. I disagree with your method to bring about change. I believe it is easier to talk and influence from within a loving embrace, rather than yelling from outside that embrace.
Brother Adam Posted August 16, 2012 Posted August 16, 2012 If the Catholic Church has ever taught heresy in its official capacity to teach faith and morals, I am leaving. None of us actually, has any reason to remain Catholic if the gates of hell have prevailed against the Church. There is also no reason to fight for the Catholic Church if she has been overrun by Satan. That type of weakness and ineffectiveness means God is not with her.
Nihil Obstat Posted August 16, 2012 Posted August 16, 2012 (edited) [quote name='Brother Adam' timestamp='1345138525' post='2468643'] If the Catholic Church has ever taught heresy in its official capacity to teach faith and morals, I am leaving. None of us actually, has any reason to remain Catholic if the gates of hell have prevailed against the Church. There is also no reason to fight for the Catholic Church if she has been overrun by Satan. That type of weakness and ineffectiveness means God is not with her. [/quote] Notwithstanding, of course, that hypothetically men in the Church, even many, even most, including sometimes bishops and even popes, might teach or believe heresy at some arbitrary point in time. I know you know that, but someone reading the thread might not. Edited August 16, 2012 by Nihil Obstat
franciscanheart Posted August 16, 2012 Posted August 16, 2012 [quote name='sixpence' timestamp='1345139450' post='2468649'] what does ED stand for? [/quote] Ecclesia Dei
Vincent Vega Posted August 16, 2012 Posted August 16, 2012 [quote name='sixpence' timestamp='1345139450' post='2468649'] what does ED stand for? [/quote] It means if you experience a liturgy lasting more than four hours, seek help immediately and call a Doctor of the Church.
Studiumecclesiae Posted August 16, 2012 Author Posted August 16, 2012 [quote name='Nihil Obstat' timestamp='1345138875' post='2468644'] Notwithstanding, of course, that hypothetically men in the Church, even many, even most, including sometimes bishops and even popes, might teach or believe heresy at some arbitrary point in time. I know you know that, but someone reading the thread might not.[/quote] Well let's not mix the Catholic Church with the Official Church which is modernist and teaches heresies. Of course the Church will re-consider Vatican II and acknowledge the heresy. Now the Old Mass is allowed but it used to be forbidden, remember? Now it's allowed thanks to whom??? Well if the SSPX hadn't tried to defend it at first, there would be nothing else but the new mass, which is unacceptable. [b]I can see I am no longer allowed MPs, are you afraid that I might try to convert some members?[/b] I don't see why people keep being suspicious about the SSPX. I'm only trying to rely on the Popes's teachings: Piux IX, Piux XI, Leo XIII, etc. It is NOT heretical.
sixpence Posted August 16, 2012 Posted August 16, 2012 [quote name='USAirwaysIHS' timestamp='1345140232' post='2468653'] It means if you experience a liturgy lasting more than four hours, seek help immediately and call a Doctor of the Church. [/quote]
Vincent Vega Posted August 16, 2012 Posted August 16, 2012 [quote name='Studiumecclesiae' timestamp='1345140504' post='2468656'] I'm only trying to rely on some of the Popes's teachings: Piux IX, Piux XI, Leo XIII, etc. It is NOT heretical. [/quote] fxt
Slappo Posted August 16, 2012 Posted August 16, 2012 Neither is Benedict XVI's teachings though... which the SSPX recognize as being a valid pope. Interpreted correctly, VII doesn't teach heresy. Interpreted in some modernistic "Spirit of Vatican II I can do whatever I want" sure..., but that's not what Vatican II said. Who allowed for the EF form to be said? I'm pretty sure it wasn't the SSPX but Benedict XVI. Although SSPX might have encouraged that, the motu proprio was not specifically promulgated for the SSPX. There are others, [b]many others[/b], in the Church who desire the EF. Just look at Bp. Morlino from Madison, WI and his push for authentic Catholicism. He urges his seminarians to learn the EF, and celebrates in the EF. The doctrines and dogma's of the Church are not heretical. The current trends for "ecumenism" and interreligious dialogue are not doctrinal and binding for faithful Catholics to adhere to. I believe there needs to be interreligious dialogue. We communicate with other relgions... for instance the Anglicans, and bring them into the Catholic Church. That is the primary purpose of interreligious dialogue and is what all true ecumenism leads to, conversion. This is a valid Catholic perspective that many non SSPX'ers hold. I think you're a little too harsh on the Catholic Church. It also is not necessary to battle modernsim in the SSPX fashion. I battle modernism in my every day conversation with other Catholics.
Basilisa Marie Posted August 16, 2012 Posted August 16, 2012 (edited) [quote name='Studiumecclesiae' timestamp='1345140504' post='2468656'] Well let's not mix the Catholic Church with the Official Church which is modernist and teaches heresies. Of course the Church will re-consider Vatican II and acknowledge the heresy. Now the Old Mass is allowed but it used to be forbidden, remember? Now it's allowed thanks to whom??? Well if the SSPX hadn't tried to defend it at first, there would be nothing else but the new mass, which is unacceptable. [b]I can see I am no longer allowed MPs, are you afraid that I might try to convert some members?[/b] I don't see why people keep being suspicious about the SSPX. I'm only trying to rely on the Popes's teachings: Piux IX, Piux XI, Leo XIII, etc. It is NOT heretical. [/quote] No, you got a "phisy" tag. That just means that you're someone who posts things that aren't in line with Rome, but you still consider yourself Catholic. It's so people don't get confused and think that Rome agrees with everything that you're posting. Different tags have different abilities. Like, Phisy people don't have access to PMs, and people with a Church Militant tag have more "props" they can give. Edit: Some smart person please correct me if I'm wrong. Edited August 16, 2012 by Basilisa Marie
Slappo Posted August 16, 2012 Posted August 16, 2012 (edited) [quote name='Basilisa Marie' timestamp='1345141335' post='2468667'] No, you got a "phisy" tag. That just means that you're someone who posts things that aren't in line with Rome, but you still consider yourself Catholic. It's so people don't get confused and think that Rome agrees with everything that you're posting. [/quote] i disagree with SSPX getting phishy tags, because they [b]are [/b]Catholics, not just people who think they are Catholics. The real difference between the SSPX and the Magisterium is that the Magisterium holds that what the SSPX believes are [b]valid viewpoints within Catholicism[/b], and the SSPX holds that what they believe are [b]doctrinal viewpoints and required for all Catholics to believe[/b]. Oh, and on an unrelated note: Pope Benedict is the Pope of Christian Unity. God grant him many years . Edited August 16, 2012 by Slappo
MIKolbe Posted August 16, 2012 Posted August 16, 2012 [quote name='Studiumecclesiae' timestamp='1345140504' post='2468656'] Well let's not mix the Catholic Church with the Official Church which is modernist and teaches heresies. [/quote] I was always under the impression there was one Church. It is precisely this mindset which can be the end result of being your own magisterium.
Lil Red Posted August 16, 2012 Posted August 16, 2012 [quote name='Slappo' timestamp='1345141466' post='2468670'] i disagree with SSPX getting phishy tags, because they [b]are [/b]Catholics, not just people who think they are Catholics. The real difference between the SSPX and the Magisterium is that the Magisterium holds that what the SSPX believes are [b]valid viewpoints within Catholicism[/b], and the SSPX holds that what they believe are [b]doctrinal viewpoints and required for all Catholics to believe[/b]. Oh, and on an unrelated note: Pope Benedict is the Pope of Christian Unity. God grant him many years . [/quote] take it up with the boss.
EmilyAnn Posted August 16, 2012 Posted August 16, 2012 [quote name='Slappo' timestamp='1345141466' post='2468670'] i disagree with SSPX getting phishy tags, because they [b]are [/b]Catholics, not just people who think they are Catholics. The real difference between the SSPX and the Magisterium is that the Magisterium holds that what the SSPX believes are [b]valid viewpoints within Catholicism[/b], and the SSPX holds that what they believe are [b]doctrinal viewpoints and required for all Catholics to believe[/b]. [/quote] I thought Phishy tags were for Catholics who weren't fully in line with the Church. I'd say the SSPX definitely fill that qualification.
sixpence Posted August 16, 2012 Posted August 16, 2012 [quote name='Studiumecclesiae' timestamp='1345140504' post='2468656'] I'm only trying to rely on [s]the Popes's[/s] Popes' teachings: Piux IX, Piux XI, Leo XIII, etc. It is NOT heretical. [/quote] [quote name='USAirwaysIHS' timestamp='1345140997' post='2468661'] [b]almost [/b]fxt [/quote] fixed
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now