Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Sspx Members Welcome?


Recommended Posts

Studiumecclesiae
Posted

[quote name='beatitude' timestamp='1345547355' post='2471186']
I would, for the sake of their souls, my soul, and the love of Christ. There's absolutely nothing wrong with having meetings with Muslims, and there is certainly nothing wrong with inviting non-Catholics in your church. We don't have a separatist beliefs in Catholicism, and we're not Mormons, with rules about who can enter our holy places. And I would have thought that inviting people into the presence of the Eucharist is good evangelism rather than otherwise.
[/quote]

I can't believe you can be saying such serious thing!
So to you it is acceptable these Assisi Meetings, and putting the two religions as EQUAL?
Look what Inter-religious dialogue leads us to:
[img]http://www.laportelatine.org/vatican/compromissions/coran_arras001.jpg[/img]

[img]http://www.laportelatine.org/vatican/compromissions/coran_arras01.jpg[/img]

[img]http://www.laportelatine.org/vatican/compromissions/coran_arras02.jpg[/img]
A muslim preaching like a priest!!!

Or worse... What is on the Blessed altar? Nothing but...
[img]http://www.laportelatine.org/vatican/compromissions/coran_arras03.jpg[/img]
The Holy Kuran!!!


I agree that the Church is missionary! But what people don't seem to acknowledge is that it already was SO missionary before Vatican II, and Mgr Lefebvre was a Missionary Father. And we got a great decline in missionary communities because of Vatican II and esp. this tendency to say "all religions are right, we adore the same God, etc etc." People lose faith because of this great heresy.
[img]http://www.laportelatine.org/mediatheque/sermonsecrits/TissierVillepreux101009/delegueApostolique.jpg[/img]

[quote name='beatitude' timestamp='1345547355' post='2471186']
I went to a SSPX chapel once, when I was fifteen. I didn't realise that it was SSPX. I didn't even know what the SSPX was. I had just been confirmed and was keen to discover my faith in its fullness, and I looked for a traditional Latin Mass, never having experienced that before. When I saw in the phone book that there was a local church offering it, I went along.

I left before the Mass even began because the atmosphere in there was so cold and hostile. I have never been made to feel so unwelcome at any Mass in my life. I was the only girl not to have a mantilla (I didn't even know what mantillas were, and I certainly didn't know where you could buy them) and because of this the women sitting in the pew behind me started to whisper and giggle. I could hear the catty things they were saying. Apparently whispering and gossiping in church is acceptable; being without a headcovering isn't. There was something nasty in the air, and the whole experience was saddening and disturbing. When I found out that they were SSPX a few years later, it all clicked into place.[/quote]
Well I'm sorry but no church is perfect as we're all sinners. I've been to several SSPX chapels, and it's not necessary like that. You can't judge on a first impression. Of course it isn't allowed to gossip in a chapel!

No one is worshipping tradition. We are worshipping GOD, the Almighty. He is not our friend, we won't call Him "you" but "Thou", we won't show up bareheaded or with short sleeves, out of RESPECT. Boys won't show up wearing shorts, of course! Such lack of respect, and in particular, you wouldn't do it in front of the head of the state, would you? Same for God. Why should we have to meet the Holy Father (face to face) with a mantilla on when it's not obliged before the Almighty? It doesn't make sense.
Modernism does not make sense. You'd say "Our Father who art in heaven" but "Hail Mary... the Lord is with you", it's not logical.
So who is worshipping who? Don't say the traddies worship tradition, when they thrive to please God as well as Virgin Mary.

[quote name='the171' timestamp='1345549083' post='2471195']
We are a missionary church. Weren't the first bishops converts? And the greatest saints converts?? Why are you so afraid to dialogue with Muslims and other faiths? That is the only way they will know what we believe!! :)
[/quote]
Well dialogue is different from letting people walk all over us.

Posted (edited)

[quote name='Studiumecclesiae' timestamp='1345558795' post='2471220']
No one is worshipping tradition. We are worshipping GOD, the Almighty. [b]He is not our friend, we won't call Him "you" but "Thou", [/b]we won't show up bareheaded or with short sleeves, out of RESPECT. Boys won't show up wearing shorts, of course! Such lack of respect, and in particular, you wouldn't do it in front of the head of the state, would you? Same for God. Why should we have to meet the Holy Father (face to face) with a mantilla on when it's not obliged before the Almighty? It doesn't make sense.
Modernism does not make sense. You'd say "Our Father who art in heaven" but "Hail Mary... the Lord is with you", it's not logical.
So who is worshipping who? Don't say the traddies worship tradition, when they thrive to please God as well as Virgin Mary.

[/quote]

Ok, just addressing this point. The word [i]thou[/i], the singular form, was actually used as a familiar pronoun (in some inst[font=arial,helvetica,sans-serif]ances, as a derogative form) and does not automatically show respect.
[url="http://www.etymonline.com/index.php?term=thou&allowed_in_frame=0"]http://www.etymonlin...owed_in_frame=0[/url] .

For what it's worth, I do say "hallowed be thy name... and "blessed art thou among women." It's how the prayers were taught to me. But saying "thou" vs. "you" really isn't an argument for showing respect to the Lord.

[color=#000000][size=4]And...why, yes, the Lord is our friend. That's not all He is, by any means, but it's not disrespectful to say that He is. In fact, Jesus said it.[/size][/color]

[color=#000000][size=4]"I will not now call you servants: for the servant knoweth not what his lord doth. But I have called you friends: because all things whatsoever I have heard of my Father, I have made known to you." (John 15:15)[/size][/color]
[size=2][color=#000000].. using Douay-Rheims because it seems to be preferred.[/color][/size][/font]

Edited by Lisa
Posted

P.S. I really admire your desire to give the proper reverence to God. It's something we can all work at, to be sure. I am really enjoying what you have to say (it makes me look things up and consider how I do things), and I hope you stay around!

franciscanheart
Posted

[quote name='Studiumecclesiae' timestamp='1345558795' post='2471220']
Well I'm sorry but no church is perfect as we're all sinners. I've been to several SSPX chapels, and it's not necessary like that. You can't judge on a first impression. Of course it isn't allowed to gossip in a chapel!
[/quote]
How is it disallowed? Are people flogged for gossiping in a sanctuary?



[quote name='Studiumecclesiae' timestamp='1345558795' post='2471220']
No one is worshipping tradition. We are worshipping GOD, the Almighty. He is not our friend, we won't call Him "you" but "Thou", we won't show up bareheaded or with short sleeves, out of RESPECT. Boys won't show up wearing shorts, of course! Such lack of respect, and in particular, you wouldn't do it in front of the head of the state, would you? Same for God. Why should we have to meet the Holy Father (face to face) with a mantilla on when it's not obliged before the Almighty? It doesn't make sense.
[/quote]
You know, I don't think many people would disagree with your logic on how to dress or even how to address God [b][i]IF[/i][/b] you would be more loving about it. Instead you come off as arrogant and judgmental. What hearts were ever won through anger and disgust?

Please, I beg you: do not come back at me and tell me that we should all be so angry about the state of the Church. I hear you and I understand the idea of righteous anger. I do not believe it is appropriate in this case.

I think, in general, the good people who identify with the SSPX really do themselves and the organization a great disservice by their arrogance. On those matters which we agree, I often do not care even to acknowledge because of the sour disposition.

Regarding "you" vs "thou" -- I've honestly no idea why this is such a huge issue, or why saying "you" or "your" in regards to God is disrespectful or profane. If you care to explain, I'd be happy to hear your logic.



[quote name='Studiumecclesiae' timestamp='1345558795' post='2471220']
Modernism does not make sense. You'd say "Our Father who art in heaven" but "Hail Mary... the Lord is with you", it's not logical. So who is worshipping who? Don't say the traddies worship tradition, when they thrive to please God as well as Virgin Mary.
[/quote]
First: ... who is worshiping whom? (Sorry. It was driving me nuts.)

Second: I still do not understand your hangup on language. I also don't know where you got the impression that all of us pray so awfully. (I think it's pretty tacky for you to judge someone's prayers, but I won't go there right now.) I happen to pray the prayers with "thou" and "thy" and "thine". But you wouldn't know that because you've never prayed with me, don't know me. Here's my sarcastic thanks for passing judgment about me because I am a regular attendee of one of those terribly disrespectful and profane OF Masses.



[quote name='Studiumecclesiae' timestamp='1345558795' post='2471220']
Well dialogue is different from letting people walk all over us.
[/quote]
I do not believe anyone suggested we let people walk all over us. You are quite the extremist, though this comes as no shock.



[quote name='beatitude' timestamp='1345547355' post='2471186']
You say that there is blind obedience and intelligent obedience. There is also a difference between loving tradition, and worshipping tradition - turning it into an idol and giving your veneration to that instead of to God.
[/quote]
YES. Absolutely. So well said.



[quote name='beatitude' timestamp='1345547355' post='2471186']
The FSSP priests are able to foster tradition and offer beautiful reverent Latin liturgies without any need for disobedience. ... But the difference is that they aren't presenting themselves as an exclusive little coterie, distinct from the rest of the church, and often worryingly critical towards the popes who followed Vatican 2.
[/quote]
This, too. Thanks, b, for such a wonderful post!

Posted

[quote name='Studiumecclesiae' timestamp='1345533488' post='2471154']
So basically if your bishop encouraged you to have meetings with the muslims, to invite them in your church, etc. Would you do it? For "inter-religious dialogue" sake?
I think there are two kinds of obedience: blind, or intelligent.
[/quote]

Sure I would. I'd not encourage them to partake in Holy Communion, but I would have no problem in hoping that they would see the Truth of the Church by attending the celebration of Mass. This summer I had the honor of attending a friend's nuptial Mass and helped a Muslim friend, who had also been invited, to understand what was going on; she had never been inside a church before. No, I'd not care to see an Imam preaching from the altar, but I'd see no harm in a constructive dialogue in the parish hall or parish library.

If I had never attended Mass, nor Eucharistic Adoration, I would never have converted to the Catholic faith.

[quote name='Studiumecclesiae' timestamp='1345558795' post='2471220']
He is not our friend, we won't call Him "you" but "Thou", we won't show up bareheaded or with short sleeves, out of RESPECT. Boys won't show up wearing shorts, of course! Such lack of respect, and in particular, you wouldn't do it in front of the head of the state, would you? Same for God. Why should we have to meet the Holy Father (face to face) with a mantilla on when it's not obliged before the Almighty? It doesn't make sense.
[/quote]

I think, as FranciscanHeart said, you'd find a lot of us agree with you on how to dress reverently for the holy sacrifice of the Mass, but you're rushing to judgment. I was in Philadelphia recently with a friend. The night before I went into the city, I went out with the man I was staying with and one of his female friends.

Much to my surprise, over dinner, the SSPX came up, in particular this very issue of how to dress. His female friend had signed up for a pilgrimage ten mile hike and had no clue what the SSPX was, she just saw the ad and was like "Oh nature, worshiping God, and bringing my Rosary. That sounds like a beautiful experience." She was eventually allowed to go on the hike with the group, though reminded more than once that her hoodie and jeans were definitely against the dress code.

Now, I know this girl, and I know that if she had known there would be a "dress code" she would have still gone and followed it. However, she didn't know, it was a nature hike pilgrimage after all. Some people though, are unable to afford "Sunday Best" clothing, and I would be upset to see anyone cast out of a chapel for failing to embrace a standard that has been set by men and not by God.

As for the Jesus as friend comment:[quote]
Douay-Rheims Translation, John 15:11-20

These things I have spoken to you, that my joy may be in you, and your joy may be filled. This is my commandment, that you love one another, as I have loved you. Greater love than this no man hath, that a man lay down his life for his friends. [u]You are my friends, if you do the things that I command you[/u]. I will not now call you servants: for the servant knoweth not what his lord doth. But I have called you friends: because all things whatsoever I have heard of my Father, I have made known to you.

You have not chosen me: but I have chosen you; and have appointed you, that you should go, and should bring forth fruit; and your fruit should remain: that whatsoever you shall ask of the Father in my name, he may give it you. These things I command you, that you love one another. If the world hate you, know ye, that it hath hated me before you. If you had been of the world, the world would love its own: but because you are not of the world, but I have chosen you out of the world, therefore the world hateth you. Remember my word that I said to you: The servant is not greater than his master. If they have persecuted me, they will also persecute you: if they have kept my word, they will keep yours also.
[/quote]

Or a more modern quotation, from Pope Benedict XVI:
[quote]
“Are we not perhaps all afraid in some way? If we let Christ enter fully into our lives, if we open ourselves totally to him, are we not afraid that He might take something away from us? Are we not perhaps afraid to give up something significant, something unique, something that makes life so beautiful? Do we not then risk ending up diminished and deprived of our freedom? . . . No! If we let Christ into our lives, we lose nothing, nothing, absolutely nothing of what makes life free, beautiful and great. No! Only in this friendship are the doors of life opened wide. Only in this friendship is the great potential of human existence truly revealed. Only in this friendship do we experience beauty and liberation. And so, today, with great strength and great conviction, on the basis of long personal experience of life, I say to you, dear young people: Do not be afraid of Christ! He takes nothing away, and he gives you everything. When we give ourselves to him, we receive a hundredfold in return. Yes, open, open wide the doors to Christ – and you will find true life. Amen.”
[/quote]

We are not called to cower in fear of God, nor His Son, nor the Holy Spirit. We are to work out our salvation with fear and trembling according to Saint Paul, but this doesn't preclude us from engaging in a very personal relationship with our God and King. If it did, we would dare not to call Him, "Our Father, Who Art in Heaven". :)

LittleWaySoul
Posted

Small aside: This thread is so fascinating to me! I had no idea about anything like the SSPX before. I love learning these things :) I think everyone has made wonderful points and intelligent arguments thus far. Please, however, as franciscanheart said, remain loving and civil. It will do no one any good to have nastiness shouted at one another. Keep up the interesting conversation! Peace :nun1:

Vincent Vega
Posted

[quote name='Studiumecclesiae' timestamp='1345558795' post='2471220']
No one is worshipping tradition. We are worshipping GOD, the Almighty. He is not our friend, we won't call Him "you" but "Thou"
[/quote]
Oh, my poor, sweet, silly, dear girl. Allow me to explain...

If you know virtually any other European language, you know that they have two forms of you - the so called "t" - "v" distinction. In French, it's tu/vous, in German it's du/Sie, in Spanish it's tu/usted, in Russian it's ty/vy, in Latin, it was tu/vobis.

Now, for those of you who know Latin, we're going to disregard it for this exercise, because as you well know, 1st and 2nd person pronouns are not used very commonly in Latin (or in modern Spanish). As our language and its more closely related languages differ from it in that respect, we will part with Latin at this juncture.

All of the t words and all of the v words in the all of the languages listed above are cognate. So, when all of the Angles were sitting around - after the Normans had invited themselves to the party - deciding what wild and crazy stuff they were going to put into their language (okay, so that's not actually how languages develop, pipe down), they absorbed this t-v distinction, in the forms of thou and you (or, at least the words that would become thou and you). There are two factors in the 16th century mind when deciding which pronoun is appropriate: number and familiarity. If you were addressing two or more people, it was easy: use you. However, if you were addressing only one person, you had to decide how formal the situation was. If you were speaking to someone above your position, you had better use you. If you were speaking to a friend, a lover, or anyone else with whom you shared some level of an intimate relationship, you could use thou.

[b]WHAT!? [/b]Yes, that's right. Thou was the informal form of the word. Why do you suppose the Bard wrote "Shall I compare thee to a Summer's day?" It would have been pretty bizarre for him to have written "Shall I compare you to a summer's day?" since it would be a little off to refer to your romantic item in such a formal way (or, of course, if he was a player (or a Mormon), maybe you would have been more proper...but that's tangential).

So, if it makes you feel better to refer to God as thou, feel free. I'm not against it, in fact, I like more flowery language in the liturgy. It's almost like Latin insofar as it's like a special language set aside for a higher purpose. But don't go around saying that God's not our friend so we should use "thou"...it's like advising everyone in the room that henceforth, you're going to bathe with your clothes on so that your skin doesn't get so wet.

Or you might run into somebody who knows what they're talking about and get shut down. ;)

franciscanheart
Posted

[quote name='USAirwaysIHS' timestamp='1345565401' post='2471270']
Oh, my poor, sweet, silly, dear girl. Allow me to explain...

If you know virtually any other European language, you know that they have two forms of you - the so called "t" - "v" distinction. In French, it's tu/vous, in German it's du/Sie, in Spanish it's tu/usted, in Russian it's ty/vy, in Latin, it was tu/vobis.

Now, for those of you who know Latin, we're going to disregard it for this exercise, because as you well know, 1st and 2nd person pronouns are not used very commonly in Latin (or in modern Spanish). As our language and its more closely related languages differ from it in that respect, we will part with Latin at this juncture.

All of the t words and all of the v words in the all of the languages listed above are cognate. So, when all of the Angles were sitting around - after the Normans had invited themselves to the party - deciding what wild and crazy stuff they were going to put into their language (okay, so that's not actually how languages develop, pipe down), they absorbed this t-v distinction, in the forms of thou and you (or, at least the words that would become thou and you). There are two factors in the 16th century mind when deciding which pronoun is appropriate: number and familiarity. If you were addressing two or more people, it was easy: use you. However, if you were addressing only one person, you had to decide how formal the situation was. If you were speaking to someone above your position, you had better use you. If you were speaking to a friend, a lover, or anyone else with whom you shared some level of an intimate relationship, you could use thou.

[b]WHAT!? [/b]Yes, that's right. Thou was the informal form of the word. Why do you suppose the Bard wrote "Shall I compare thee to a Summer's day?" It would have been pretty bizarre for him to have written "Shall I compare you to a summer's day?" since it would be a little off to refer to your romantic item in such a formal way (or, of course, if he was a player (or a Mormon), maybe you would have been more proper...but that's tangential).

So, if it makes you feel better to refer to God as thou, feel free. I'm not against it, in fact, I like more flowery language in the liturgy. It's almost like Latin insofar as it's like a special language set aside for a higher purpose. But don't go around saying that God's not our friend so we should use "thou"...it's like advising everyone in the room that henceforth, you're going to bathe with your clothes on so that your skin doesn't get so wet.

Or you might run into somebody who knows what they're talking about and get shut down. ;)
[/quote]
I would prop this post with my full daily allotment if I could. Thanks for sharing your knowledge, USAIHS. :like:

Nihil Obstat
Posted

[quote name='Studiumecclesiae' timestamp='1345558795' post='2471220']
I agree that the Church is missionary! But what people don't seem to acknowledge is that it already was SO missionary before Vatican II, and Mgr Lefebvre was a Missionary Father. And we got a great decline in missionary communities because of Vatican II and esp. this tendency to say "all religions are right, we adore the same God, etc etc." People lose faith because of this great heresy.
[img]http://www.laportelatine.org/mediatheque/sermonsecrits/TissierVillepreux101009/delegueApostolique.jpg[/img]


[/quote]

I've always liked this picture, and admired the younger Archbishop Lefebvre's epic beard.
He was a great missionary. He really got it. Apparently if you go to Dakar and Gabon there's stuff named after him all over the place because of how influential and popular he was.

Posted

Your photos of Muslims preaching in church (if that is what the man was doing) and a Qu'ran placed on the altar are irrelevant to what you said originally. In your initial post you objected to 'meeting with Muslims' and 'inviting them in church', and having a meeting with Muslims or inviting them to church does not automatically involve either of those things. Why would it? You have created a strawman there. In response, I could pull out plenty of examples of traditionalism gone wrong - when it has led people to be disobedient, disrespectful, or flat-out cruel to one another - but I won't, because those things do not make traditionalism wrong in and of itself.

[quote]No one is worshipping tradition. We are worshipping GOD, the Almighty. He is not our friend, we won't call Him "you" but "Thou"[/quote]

He is very much our friend. In His own words: "No longer do I call you servants, for the servant does not know what his master is doing; but [b]I have called you friends[/b], for all that I have heard from my Father I have made known to you."

As others have already pointed out, 'thee' and 'thou' were actually used in informal speech. It is only their age that now makes them seem very formal. I happen to use the thee and thou pronouns (most churches I've ever been in do) but it's not particularly relevant anyway, as these prayers are translated prayers. If we were going to be such linguistic purists, we would all learn biblical Hebrew and NT Greek and Aramaic in order to pray exactly as the first Christians did and use the exact words of scripture. But we don't.

I appreciate beautiful prayers, but I also know that all spoken language is human - spirit and truth are the biblical hallmarks of pure worship, and to see that, God looks not at our language, but at our hearts. If only holiness was as easy as just using the right language (Church Latin) and saying the right words. Getting fixated on things like 'thou' and 'thee' is an example of the worship of tradition that I was talking about.

I gave my personal experience of the judgmentalism I faced from grown adults in a SSPX chapel, as a teenage girl who was trying to understand her heritage. I didn't say that all SSPX attendees were like that, just that I can see how dissent fosters such judgmental behaviour. Six years later, in a very modernist parish, I received an unpleasant welcome again - this time for being too traditional. Both times the unkindness was the product of disobedience. SSPX attendees might be outraged at being compared with the publicans in the modernist church, and those parishioners would have been horrified to think that they were like the tax collectors in the SSPX, but really they were no different. It was their way or the high way. Again, I am not saying that attending a disobedient church will automatically make you like this, just that it can lead in that direction - because you're being encouraged to see yourself as right (whether as a bold prophetic revolutionary, or a proud restorer of tradition) and others as wrong. The tone and substance of your own posts hasn't done anything to put me at ease on this.

Posted

Studiumecclesiae,

I love your zeal. Truely! The Church needs such zeal from both Her ordained and laity. However, I beleive it is somewhat misguided zeal. There is so much beauty and splendor in the Catholic Church to embrace and participate in. I rather embrace and participate in Her beauty and splendor, than to be an investigative reporter looking for deficiencies of its members and clergy. However, if I do experience abuse, heresy, etc., I will not turn a blind eye to it. I will take prudent corrective measures through proper channels.
God bless you.

Posted

[quote name='Papist' timestamp='1345572685' post='2471326']
Studiumecclesiae,

I love your zeal. Truely! The Church needs such zeal from both Her ordained and laity. However, I beleive it is somewhat misguided zeal. There is so much beauty and splendor in the Catholic Church to embrace and participate in. I rather embrace and participate in Her beauty and splendor, than to be an investigative reporter looking for deficiencies of its members and clergy. However, if I do experience abuse, heresy, etc., I will not turn a blind eye to it. I will take prudent corrective measures [b]through proper channels.[/b]
God bless you.
[/quote]

I think that's the key point - through proper channels. Many of us share some of the concerns held by members of the SSPX. But there are licit ways to tackle these problems - many great saints saw problems in their own times but they reformed [i]from within[/i].

Posted

[quote name='EmilyAnn' timestamp='1345574918' post='2471349']
I think that's the key point - through proper channels. Many of us share some of the concerns held by members of the SSPX. But there are licit ways to tackle these problems - many great saints saw problems in their own times but they reformed [i]from within[/i].
[/quote]
Precisely. Ranting and raving on forums, blogs, facebook, etc. is unproductive, and at times dangerous, to youth especially.

Nihil Obstat
Posted

Just to make sure the other side isn't ignored:
There have been various people, including saints throughout history, for instance Joan of Arc just because she was the first to come to my mind who, for one reason or another, were not in favour with the Roman hierarchy. For them it took some time, in some cases many years after their death, before their reputation was 'rehabilitated'. It is, in my opinion, possible that some years down the road, probably decades, at such a time that we are more removed from the situation and perhaps can view it more objectively, that the actions of Marcel Lefebvre and the other four since then may be treated with considerably more sympathy by official sources.
Right now, being very much caught up in the situation, it's hard for either side to be truly objective. There is a lot of hurt both in Econe and in Rome. Harsh things have been said, rather extreme criticisms have been made, and at the end of the day a lot of people feel or felt personally attacked by the other 'side'. Therefore I don't believe we can have a truly objective look at this right now, at least such a perspective will be very difficult to uncover.
Perhaps a generation or two later on a pope will look and say "most of Archbishop Lefebvre's criticisms were correct. John Paul II did the best job he could with the information that was available at the time, but historical perspective tells us that Marcel Lefebvre acted justly."
All I'm saying is that such things could happen, and it's very hard for us to say many things with certainty right now. It's a complex situation which we're still living out, and things may very well look different when we come out the other side. For now, I attend Mass every week with the FSSP, and I'm content. But there is much work yet to be done. The liturgical crisis is far from over, and speaking more broadly the Church has many challenges now and in Her future. These are confusing times, and the simplest answer may not always be the best one.

Posted

All of that is for the Church to handle. All I can do is pray and stay out of the way.

Ash Wednesday
Posted

I hope someday this business with the SSPX and the Vatican gets resolved. I know BXVI wants it. And I want it... in part because of the people it would throw into apoplectic fits.

:evil:


And that's all I got to say about that.

Nihil Obstat
Posted

[quote name='Papist' timestamp='1345577170' post='2471365']
All of that is for the Church to handle. All I can do is pray and stay out of the way.
[/quote]

Indeed. I'm glad it's not my responsibility to sort out. It is an enormous burden, I think.

[quote name='Ash Wednesday' timestamp='1345577248' post='2471367']

And that's all I got to say about that.
[/quote]

That is one of the best ways to end any statement.

Posted (edited)

[quote name='Nihil Obstat' timestamp='1345577285' post='2471368']
Indeed. I'm glad it's not my responsibility to sort out. It is an enormous burden, I think.
[/quote]
People trying to find abuses and what-not to justify Lefebvre's actions and the SSPX does not help the matter. Also, it goes the other way too. People trying to find ills of the SSPX oes not help the matter.

Edited by Papist
Nihil Obstat
Posted

[quote name='Papist' timestamp='1345577295' post='2471369']
People trying to find abuses and what-not to justify Lefebvre's actions and the SSPX is does not help the matter.
[/quote]

Well I don't think many on this site will deny that many of his concerns were quite valid. The question is more about his actions than the reasons for them.

Posted

[quote name='Nihil Obstat' timestamp='1345577357' post='2471370']
Well I don't think many on this site will deny that many of his concerns were quite valid. The question is more about [b]his actions[/b] than the reasons for them.
[/quote]
Bingo!

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...