Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Sspx Members Welcome?


Recommended Posts

Nihil Obstat
Posted (edited)

[quote name='Papist' timestamp='1345577649' post='2471371']
Bingo!
[/quote]
Exactly.
And IMO his actions could perhaps be re-evaluated in future generations, once we've gained some necessary perspective. As I said, it's a very complex situation, both because of internal and external factors, and I don't think any of the simple answers do it justice.

Edited by Nihil Obstat
franciscanheart
Posted

[quote name='Nihil Obstat' timestamp='1345577859' post='2471373']
Exactly.
And IMO his actions could perhaps be re-evaluated in future generations, once we've gained some necessary perspective. As I said, it's a very complex situation, both because of internal and external factors, and I don't think any of the simple answers do it justice.
[/quote]
So then what you're saying is that you think separation by time will show that the Vatican was wrong about their dealings with the SSPX until now?

Nihil Obstat
Posted

[quote name='franciscanheart' timestamp='1345582573' post='2471410']
So then what you're saying is that you think separation by time will show that the Vatican was wrong about their dealings with the SSPX until now?
[/quote]

Not necessarily. Did you read my previous post?

franciscanheart
Posted

[quote name='Nihil Obstat' timestamp='1345582834' post='2471415']
Not necessarily. Did you read my previous post?
[/quote]
I did.

Your answer is vague.

Nihil Obstat
Posted

[quote name='franciscanheart' timestamp='1345583023' post='2471420']
I did.

Your answer is vague.
[/quote]

I would say cautious, rather than vague. As I have said in two separate comments in this thread, in my opinion this whole 'situation' is extremely complex, and simple answers really do not do any party justice. The whole thing is very sensitive, and deserves careful, reasonable thought and great understanding.

GeorgiiMichael
Posted

Did you hear about that one incident where a bunch of guys were wearing DRESSES at Mass?! Such disrespect.

Source: http://dft.ba/-3oTf

franciscanheart
Posted

[quote name='Nihil Obstat' timestamp='1345583195' post='2471422']
I would say cautious, rather than vague. As I have said in two separate comments in this thread, in my opinion this whole 'situation' is extremely complex, and simple answers really do not do any party justice. The whole thing is very sensitive, and deserves careful, reasonable thought and great understanding.
[/quote]
You toe the phishy line so hard it's not even funny.

Nihil Obstat
Posted

[quote name='franciscanheart' timestamp='1345584246' post='2471443']
You toe the phishy line so hard it's not even funny.
[/quote]

I disagree, and I am somewhat hurt by your suggestion.

Posted (edited)

[quote name='Nihil Obstat' timestamp='1345583195' post='2471422']I would say cautious, rather than vague. As I have said in two separate comments in this thread, in my opinion this whole 'situation' is extremely complex, and simple answers really do not do any party justice. [b]The whole thing is very sensitive, and deserves careful, reasonable thought and great understanding.[/b][/quote]


which is why i look forward to Aloysius' posts on this subject.

Edited by Lil Red
Nihil Obstat
Posted

[quote name='Lil Red' timestamp='1345584466' post='2471452']
i look forward to Aloysius' posts on this subject.
[/quote]

I very much enjoy Aloysius' posts on SSPX-related subjects, though I disagree with him somewhat on his distributist views.

Posted

[quote name='Nihil Obstat' timestamp='1345584531' post='2471455']
I very much enjoy Aloysius' posts on SSPX-related subjects, though I disagree with him somewhat on his distributist views.
[/quote]
Are you saying that Aloysius is in Amway?

Nihil Obstat
Posted

[quote name='dUSt' timestamp='1345584693' post='2471460']
Are you saying that Aloysius is in Amway?
[/quote]
I do not understand the question.

Posted

[quote name='Nihil Obstat' timestamp='1345586083' post='2471481']
I do not understand the question.
[/quote]

I guess dUSt and I must be too old ... I understood it!

Posted (edited)

[quote name='USAirwaysIHS' timestamp='1345565401' post='2471270']
If you know virtually any other European language, you know that they have two forms of you - the so called "t" - "v" distinction. In French, it's tu/vous, in German it's du/Sie, in Spanish it's tu/usted, in Russian it's ty/vy, in Latin, it was tu/vobis.
[/quote]

Almost ... did you know that there are 5 forms of you in spanish if you include the plural forms?
(Argentinian spanish, and other similar dialects)
tu, vos, usted, vosotros, ustedes.
tu and vos are used interchangeably, sort of.
In Argentina -- vos is used exclusively between close friends. They rarely use tu.
And vos is not to be confused with vosotros. That's different. That's 2nd person plural familiar form (i.e. referring to talking to a group of friends that are in front of you -- "you all"). And the way the vos form is formed is not exactly the way that the vosotros form is formed "vosostros escuchais vs. vos escucha, accents missing -- and I may be completely off with the vos form!)

Modern english usually uses "you" 90% of the time for all forms of "you", i.e. familiar, non-familiar, plural, singular.

Artistically speaking, when I translated a religious song from spanish to english it made sense to use thee -- rhythmically, melodically, and meaning-wise. Otherwise (in normal speech) I would have never done so.

Ok -- carry on :)

Edited by cmariadiaz
Posted

[quote name='franciscanheart' timestamp='1345584246' post='2471443']
You toe the phishy line so hard it's not even funny.
[/quote]

Time and time again in Church history we have seen church heirarchy wrong on non dogmatic non doctrinal matters. Gallileo anyone? It most certainly does not mean they are always wrong or usually wrong, but to discount the possibility is a little silly. It certainly isn't speaking against the Vatican to say that in the future it may be determined that they were mistaken in some regard on a matter that is not infallible.

I personally don't ever foresee the Church coming out and saying the SSPX was totally in the right on everything, but she's already come out and admitted fault with a few things associated with the SSPX (Summorum Pontificum re-instating a form of the mass that should never have been removed, lifting of the excommunications without the bishops recanting anything).

Posted

[quote name='Slappo' timestamp='1345590379' post='2471530']

Time and time again in Church history we have seen church heirarchy wrong on non dogmatic non doctrinal matters. Gallileo anyone? It most certainly does not mean they are always wrong or usually wrong, but to discount the possibility is a little silly. It certainly isn't speaking against the Vatican to say that in the future it may be determined that they were mistaken in some regard on a matter that is not infallible.

I personally don't ever foresee the Church coming out and saying the SSPX was totally in the right on everything, but she's already come out and admitted fault with a few things associated with the SSPX (Summorum Pontificum re-instating a form of the mass that should never have been removed, lifting of the excommunications without the bishops recanting anything).
[/quote]
And what fault has the SSPX admitted?

Posted

[quote name='Papist' timestamp='1345593943' post='2471574']
And what fault has the SSPX admitted?
[/quote]

Not sure what that has to do with my post? Just because they haven't admitted fault certainly doesn't mean they don't have a bucket load.

Posted

[quote name='USAirwaysIHS' timestamp='1345565401' post='2471270']
If you know virtually any other European language, you know that they have two forms of you - the so called "t" - "v" distinction. In French, it's tu/vous, in German it's du/Sie, in Spanish it's tu/usted, in Russian it's ty/vy, in Latin, it was tu/vobis.
[/quote]

Tu / [i]vos[/i], with regard to Latin, actually. It's worth pointing out, though, that neither the classical Latin of Cicero and Vergil, nor the late antique Latin of Jerome and Augustine, nor really even the medieval Latin of Aquinas contained a T-V distinction comparable to that used in the Romance languages. The main example of the T-V distinction, one only used in very late Latin (and even then infrequently), was in addressing figures who would have used the "royal we," such as the pope.

Also, I'm fairly certain that the use of "thou" to translate the second person singular in texts such as the Lord's Prayer was not so much about using the familiar form and as it was about preserving the distinction between second person singular and second person plural in the original. This is also why the translators of the King James Version used "thou" so frequently, despite the fact that by the early 17th century it already sounded rather archaic.

Posted (edited)

[quote name='Studiumecclesiae' timestamp='1345558795' post='2471220']
He is not our friend,
[/quote]

This is only true if you are not in the state of grace.

According to the Catholic understanding of justification, those in the state of grace are, in fact, friends of God, as mentioned twice in the Council of Trent.

Edited by Amory
PhuturePriest
Posted (edited)

[quote name='Studiumecclesiae' timestamp='1345558795' post='2471220']
I can't believe you can be saying such serious thing!
So to you it is acceptable these Assisi Meetings, and putting the two religions as EQUAL?
Look what Inter-religious dialogue leads us to:
[img]http://www.laportelatine.org/vatican/compromissions/coran_arras001.jpg[/img]

[img]http://www.laportelatine.org/vatican/compromissions/coran_arras01.jpg[/img]

[img]http://www.laportelatine.org/vatican/compromissions/coran_arras02.jpg[/img]
A muslim preaching like a priest!!!

Or worse... What is on the Blessed altar? Nothing but...
[img]http://www.laportelatine.org/vatican/compromissions/coran_arras03.jpg[/img]
The Holy Kuran!!!


I agree that the Church is missionary! But what people don't seem to acknowledge is that it already was SO missionary before Vatican II, and Mgr Lefebvre was a Missionary Father. And we got a great decline in missionary communities because of Vatican II and esp. this tendency to say "all religions are right, we adore the same God, etc etc." People lose faith because of this great heresy.
[img]http://www.laportelatine.org/mediatheque/sermonsecrits/TissierVillepreux101009/delegueApostolique.jpg[/img]


Well I'm sorry but no church is perfect as we're all sinners. I've been to several SSPX chapels, and it's not necessary like that. You can't judge on a first impression. Of course it isn't allowed to gossip in a chapel!

No one is worshipping tradition. We are worshipping GOD, the Almighty. He is not our friend, we won't call Him "you" but "Thou", we won't show up bareheaded or with short sleeves, out of RESPECT. Boys won't show up wearing shorts, of course! Such lack of respect, and in particular, you wouldn't do it in front of the head of the state, would you? Same for God. Why should we have to meet the Holy Father (face to face) with a mantilla on when it's not obliged before the Almighty? It doesn't make sense.
Modernism does not make sense. You'd say "Our Father who art in heaven" but "Hail Mary... the Lord is with you", it's not logical.
So who is worshipping who? Don't say the traddies worship tradition, when they thrive to please God as well as Virgin Mary.


Well dialogue is different from letting people walk all over us.
[/quote]

Where in the Bible does it state God isn't to be your friend?

And by the way, I say "The Lord is with thee", because I like traditional things. In fact, I hate it when people say "The Lord is with you" when they do the Hail Mary, but that's simply because I was raised with "thee". Like Airways I enjoy flowery language in prayers. I have prayer books and in these prayer books I have favorite prayers, and I noticed almost all of them have this sort of language in them. But that doesn't mean if I preferred "you" I would be a great sinner. This is the 21st century. We don't speak old English. And do you know how I know that? Because if someone spoke in old English we wouldn't know a flooping thing they were saying, because it sounds like a complete foreign language to us. Languages progress and change throughout the centuries. You can't get bent out of shape for languages to take their natural course.

Edited by FuturePriest387

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...