PhuturePriest Posted August 22, 2012 Posted August 22, 2012 I have always been one that liked preaching in a bold and fearless manner. Why do you think I have a picture of Michael Voris to the left of me? But I do believe in God's love and his compassion. Inviting a Muslim to your local Church isn't such a bad thing. How else do you expect us to convert people? What lies within a Catholic Church is the centrality of all Catholic teaching: the true presence of Jesus Christ in the Eucharist. How is a non-believer to convert without even seeing the Eucharist and the Mass before his own eyes? The Eucharist is such a truly wonderful thing that no other Church has. Why would be disallow non-believers who are interested in seeing Him? I believe Jesus said something like "Let the children come to me." when the disciples wouldn't let them come near him. We can come to Jesus like a little child even when we are adults. This was the centrality of Saint Therese of Lisieux's spirituality. If one wishes to come to Jesus like a little child and we deny him, we have disobeyed Christ himself.
Maximilianus Posted August 22, 2012 Posted August 22, 2012 um, am I the only one that sees studiem's 'friend' comment to mean that God is not just another homie, albeit through a flawed manner?
To Jesus Through Mary Posted August 22, 2012 Posted August 22, 2012 [quote name='Maximilianus' timestamp='1345623454' post='2471876'] um, am I the only one that sees studiem's 'friend' comment to mean that God is not just another homie, albeit through a flawed manner? [/quote] Nope I am with you. Jesus did call us friend, but in the Protestant world they took it to a whole knew level. That mentality has not-so-slowly found it's way into the Church. It became Jesus "My Buddy" type of mentality. In the process the loss of the fear of God. Yes, amazingly enough, He is calling us to the intimacy of friendship and moving us out of just servitude (which if you look at the passage as a whole that is what he is referring to) but we still must have a fear of God.
beatitude Posted August 22, 2012 Posted August 22, 2012 When St Teresa of Avila's wagon axle broke and pitched her into the road, she shook her fist to the heavens and said to God, "If this is how you treat your friends, no wonder you have so few of them!" I don't think anybody could accuse her of not having proper fear of the Lord, but an indignant exclamation in the colloquial Spanish of her day is very different from the beautiful formal prayers of our tradition. Yet they belong in the same prayer book. This informality is not Protestant - it's human. Sometimes when I have been in pain, or very frightened, or angry, I have poured out my jumbled thoughts pell-mell to God, without giving much thought to the language I used. Kneeling in my room during my designated prayer times, I use my breviary and the rosary. Formal prayer and lectio divina helped me to learn to really trust God. This trust sometimes expresses itself in more informal and spontaneous cries/grumbles/thank-yous as I go about my day.
Papist Posted August 22, 2012 Posted August 22, 2012 [quote name='Slappo' timestamp='1345605343' post='2471733'] Not sure what that has to do with my post? Just because they haven't admitted fault certainly doesn't mean they don't have a bucket load. [/quote] Your post's message is that the Church was in error against the SSPX and Lefebrve, and has admitted it. And nothing of the wrongs of the SSPX, which is the biggest problem I have with these conversations. People that support SSPX believe SSPX have done/doing no wrong and for reconciliation with the Church to happen is for the Church to 100% change to the ways of SSPX. In a thread a while back, someone posted that he could see Lefebrve being canonized someday.
KnightofChrist Posted August 22, 2012 Posted August 22, 2012 (edited) Dp Edited August 22, 2012 by KnightofChrist
KnightofChrist Posted August 22, 2012 Posted August 22, 2012 [quote name='Papist' timestamp='1345633849' post='2471903'] Your post's message is that the Church was in error against the SSPX and Lefebrve, and has admitted it. And nothing of the wrongs of the SSPX, which is the biggest problem I have with these conversations. People that support SSPX believe SSPX have done/doing no wrong and for reconciliation with the Church to happen is for the Church to 100% change to the ways of SSPX. In a thread a while back, someone posted that he could see Lefebrve being canonized someday. [/quote] That was not the message of Slappo's post nor is it the message of Nihil's posts. The message is the Church's relationship with the SSPX has already developed for the better compared to 1988. And that this positive development will continue in the future in ways that we do not yet understand or have the ability to see now.
KnightofChrist Posted August 22, 2012 Posted August 22, 2012 [quote name='beatitude' timestamp='1345632859' post='2471899'] When St Teresa of Avila's wagon axle broke and pitched her into the road, she shook her fist to the heavens and said to God, "If this is how you treat your friends, no wonder you have so few of them!" I don't think anybody could accuse her of not having proper fear of the Lord, but an indignant exclamation in the colloquial Spanish of her day is very different from the beautiful formal prayers of our tradition. Yet they belong in the same prayer book. This informality is not Protestant - it's human. Sometimes when I have been in pain, or very frightened, or angry, I have poured out my jumbled thoughts pell-mell to God, without giving much thought to the language I used. Kneeling in my room during my designated prayer times, I use my breviary and the rosary. Formal prayer and lectio divina helped me to learn to really trust God. This trust sometimes expresses itself in more informal and spontaneous cries/grumbles/thank-yous as I go about my day. [/quote] Indeed.
Papist Posted August 22, 2012 Posted August 22, 2012 [quote name='KnightofChrist' timestamp='1345639477' post='2471917'] That was not the message of Slappo's post nor is it the message of Nihil's posts. The message is the Church's relationship with the SSPX has already developed for the better compared to 1988. And that this positive development will continue in the future in ways that we do not yet understand or have the ability to see now. [/quote] I beg to differ. The tone is the defense of the SSPX while elaborating on the problematic actions by the Church. It is extremely rare that I hear from SSPX supporters the problematic actions by the Lefebrve and/or the SSPX, and what actions are the SSPX taking to reconcile. It is always the Church needs to do this and the Church needs to stop doing that for the SSPX to come back in fullness. I am not a SSPX supporter, nor am I a SSPX hater. I would love for them to come back into the fullness of the Church. But until [u]BOTH [/u]sides are honest and open with humility, that is not likely to happen.
KnightofChrist Posted August 22, 2012 Posted August 22, 2012 I've known Nihil and Slappo for sometime now and I've seen them express both positive and negative views about the SSPX. I've never seen them actually say the type of things that you say their tone says.
Papist Posted August 22, 2012 Posted August 22, 2012 [quote name='KnightofChrist' timestamp='1345642338' post='2471928'] I've known Nihil and Slappo for sometime now and I've seen them express both positive and negative views about the SSPX. I've never seen them actually say the type of things that you say their tone says. [/quote] SSPX supporters not= Nihil and Slappo. If that is what you understood, you are mistaken and/or I failed to articulate it. My experiences re this topic are not limited to the posts of Nihil and Slappo nor this forum.
KnightofChrist Posted August 22, 2012 Posted August 22, 2012 (edited) I was speaking about post 145 that is a response to Slappo. I don't believe the tone you see is what he is actually saying. A similar tone has been applied to Nihil earlier in the thread and it is also not what he is actually saying. Edited August 22, 2012 by KnightofChrist
cmotherofpirl Posted August 22, 2012 Posted August 22, 2012 [quote name='Slappo' timestamp='1345590379' post='2471530'] Time and time again in Church history we have seen church heirarchy wrong on non dogmatic non doctrinal matters. Gallileo anyone? It most certainly does not mean they are always wrong or usually wrong, but to discount the possibility is a little silly. It certainly isn't speaking against the Vatican to say that in the future it may be determined that they were mistaken in some regard on a matter that is not infallible. I personally don't ever foresee the Church coming out and saying the SSPX was totally in the right on everything, but she's already come out and admitted fault with a few things associated with the SSPX (Summorum Pontificum re-instating a form of the mass that should never have been removed, lifting of the excommunications without the bishops recanting anything). [/quote]Actually the Church was not wrong on Gallileo.... the Church was perfectly happy if he would teach his stuff as a THEORY but he refused, even though he had no proof at that point.
dells_of_bittersweet Posted August 22, 2012 Posted August 22, 2012 Galileo got in trouble for obedience, not his science. SSPX got in trouble for obedience, not for their love of tradition.
Papist Posted August 22, 2012 Posted August 22, 2012 [quote name='KnightofChrist' timestamp='1345644142' post='2471938'] I was speaking about post 145 that is a response to Slappo. I don't believe the tone you see is what he is actually saying. A similar tone has been applied to Nihil earlier in the thread and it is also not what he is actually saying. [/quote] Nutshell for you, I see defending SSPX. tone = SSPX in the right I do not see defending the Church. tone = Church in the wrong Obvious, you and I are wearing two different pair of glasses.
PhuturePriest Posted August 22, 2012 Posted August 22, 2012 [quote name='Maximilianus' timestamp='1345623454' post='2471876'] um, am I the only one that sees studiem's 'friend' comment to mean that God is not just another homie, albeit through a flawed manner? [/quote] When did we ever not care about technicalities on Phatmass?
franciscanheart Posted August 22, 2012 Posted August 22, 2012 [quote name='KnightofChrist' timestamp='1345644142' post='2471938'] I was speaking about post 145 that is a response to Slappo. I don't believe the tone you see is what he is actually saying. A similar tone has been applied to Nihil earlier in the thread and it is also not what he is actually saying. [/quote] When people don't say what they mean, it's really difficult to [i]know [/i]what they mean. Adults don't beat around the bush; they say what they mean and, generally speaking, mean what they say.
KnightofChrist Posted August 22, 2012 Posted August 22, 2012 [quote name='Papist' timestamp='1345647655' post='2471961'] Nutshell for you, I see defending SSPX. tone = SSPX in the right I do not see defending the Church. tone = Church in the wrong Obvious, you and I are wearing two different pair of glasses. [/quote] Tone too often equals what someone thinks was said not what was actually stated. If they actually believed those things they as grown men would be men enough to state those things without need of tone interpretation.
KnightofChrist Posted August 22, 2012 Posted August 22, 2012 (edited) [quote name='franciscanheart' timestamp='1345649295' post='2471970'] When people don't say what they mean, it's really difficult to [i]know [/i]what they mean. Adults don't beat around the bush; they say what they mean and, generally speaking, mean what they say. [/quote] I believe these two grown men have stated as clearly as they can their views on a complex problem and hopes of positive things that may happen in the future. I believe you have misunderstood them. Unless you can read minds and hearts you really have no idea if they really meant to say something that they did not actually state. Edited August 22, 2012 by KnightofChrist
IcePrincessKRS Posted August 22, 2012 Posted August 22, 2012 And there's nothing wrong with pointing out that what they said might come across differently than they intended.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now