Lil Red Posted August 17, 2012 Posted August 17, 2012 [quote name='Nihil Obstat' timestamp='1345222544' post='2469216'] It used to be that links to SSPX sources such as sspx.org and DICI were edited. Is that still the case? What about links to Youtube videos that feature SSPX speakers? The interview that CNS did with Fellay was excellent, and there are some videos of Bishop Williamson that would illustrate the point I made above. [/quote] links or videos that are anti-Vatican II or anti-Popes are still disallowed. if the videos or links themselves don't talk about being anti-Vatican II/Popes but lead/point to other links/videos that are, then i would have a hard time approving them. CNS isn't itself anti-Vatican II/Popes so that would be fine.
Nihil Obstat Posted August 17, 2012 Posted August 17, 2012 [quote name='Lil Red' timestamp='1345222931' post='2469221'] links or videos that are anti-Vatican II or anti-Popes are still disallowed. if the videos or links themselves don't talk about being anti-Vatican II/Popes but lead/point to other links/videos that are, then i would have a hard time approving them. CNS isn't itself anti-Vatican II/Popes so that would be fine. [/quote] I won't post the link with Williamson then, though it's a good talk and a very good starting point for discussion. Here's the first part of Fellay's interview with CNS: [media]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DdnJigNzTuY[/media]
Slappo Posted August 17, 2012 Posted August 17, 2012 [quote name='Papist' timestamp='1345203162' post='2469086'] [u][b]AGAIN[/b][/u], I was not addressing the SSPX, but your flawed logic to apply or not apply the phishy tag. Using your logic, Nancy Pelosi would not receive the phishy tag. [/quote] I looked back at my OP quoting why ppl get phisy tags. What I was saying is not only do SSPX consider themselves to be Catholic, but they truly and actually are Catholic. Doesn't mean there aren't circumstances that warrant them getting phisy though. I realize this line is a different than what I was saying earlier in the thread. My viewpoints changed . Ppl made some good points, so I recant. It is good to know that SSPX doesn't automatically = phishy though .
fides' Jack Posted August 17, 2012 Posted August 17, 2012 Maybe not, but it should mean (and maybe does), "Hey dUSt, this guy's SSPX. We should probably keep an eye on his posts in case we need to give him a fishy tag."
Studiumecclesiae Posted August 20, 2012 Author Posted August 20, 2012 [quote name='Nihil Obstat' timestamp='1345223560' post='2469228'] I won't post the link with Williamson then, though it's a good talk and a very good starting point for discussion. Here's the first part of Fellay's interview with CNS: [media]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DdnJigNzTuY[/media] [/quote] Thanks for this beautiful video. I feel quite close to Bishop Fellay and pray for reconciliation. I don't see why people keep arguing about this case. the SSPX is neither schismatic nor heretical. Indeed, they only keep the old catechism, the old code of canon law, etc. The issue is NOT the magisterium but only just some texts and ideas of the Vatican II council. And I don't see why I should get a Fishy tag when other modernist members would profess any kinds of heresies and not get any tag at all. What I mean by that is that the SSPX is often and mostly MORE catholic than other modernist priests who just do everything BUT what the Church wants them to do. So is it being obedient??? doing whatever we want? (I'm pointing the modernists)
Lil Red Posted August 20, 2012 Posted August 20, 2012 (edited) [quote name='Studiumecclesiae' timestamp='1345474681' post='2470600']And I don't see why I should get a Fishy tag when other modernist members would profess any kinds of heresies and not get any tag at all. [/quote] sorry, but you're wrong. just because you haven't seen them, doesn't mean they don't exist. edit: i just checked through the "pham" tab up top. there are 70 members tagged phishy (including yourself). these people run the gamut of what they don't agree with the Church about. Edited August 20, 2012 by Lil Red
Vincent Vega Posted August 20, 2012 Posted August 20, 2012 [quote name='Studiumecclesiae' timestamp='1345474681' post='2470600'] And I don't see why I should get a Fishy tag when other modernist members would profess any kinds of heresies and not get any tag at all. What I mean by that is that the SSPX is often and mostly MORE catholic than other modernist priests who just do everything BUT what the Church wants them to do. So is it being obedient??? doing whatever we want? (I'm pointing the modernists) [/quote] Something about a log in one's own eye?
PhuturePriest Posted August 20, 2012 Posted August 20, 2012 [quote name='franciscanheart' timestamp='1345150783' post='2468788'] So what Red is saying is this: No. Nothing else. That's it. [/quote] I also thought they could not go on chat?
Papist Posted August 20, 2012 Posted August 20, 2012 (edited) [quote name='Studiumecclesiae' timestamp='1345474681' post='2470600'] Thanks for this beautiful video. I feel quite close to Bishop Fellay and pray for reconciliation. I don't see why people keep arguing about this case. the SSPX is neither schismatic nor heretical. Indeed, they only keep the old catechism, the old code of canon law, etc. The issue is NOT the magisterium but only just some texts and ideas of the Vatican II council. And I don't see why I should get a Fishy tag when other modernist members would profess any kinds of heresies and not get any tag at all. What I mean by that is that the SSPX is often and mostly MORE catholic than other modernist priests who just do everything BUT what the Church wants them to do. So is it being obedient??? doing whatever we want? (I'm pointing the modernists) [/quote] Obedience is traditional. Edited August 20, 2012 by Papist
the171 Posted August 21, 2012 Posted August 21, 2012 (edited) [quote name='the171' timestamp='1345524048' post='2471092'] So how about the Eucharist? That's pretty razzle dazzle! [/quote] *insert dramatic falling to my knees and throwing my hands in the air* YOU'RE TEARING US ALL APARRRRRT!!!! Edited August 21, 2012 by the171
Nihil Obstat Posted August 21, 2012 Posted August 21, 2012 [quote name='the171' timestamp='1345524048' post='2471092'] *insert dramatic falling to my knees and throwing my hands in the air* YOU'RE TEARING US ALL APARRRRRT!!!! [/quote] [img]http://media-cache-ec5.pinterest.com/upload/64035625921899383_ngY7uuPU_f.jpg[/img]
Studiumecclesiae Posted August 21, 2012 Author Posted August 21, 2012 [quote name='Papist' timestamp='1345485051' post='2470656'] Obedience is traditional. [/quote] So basically if your bishop encouraged you to have meetings with the muslims, to invite them in your church, etc. Would you do it? For "inter-religious dialogue" sake? I think there are two kinds of obedience: blind, or intelligent. The SSPX ordained the bishops in order to survive. Bishop Lefebvre was feeling he was going to die. And Rome had accepted that he'd get one bishop, but they would keep delaying the permission. The SSPX perfectly knew their technique was for the SSPX to lose their only Bishop. And they didn't!! Thanks to what? The consecrations!
Nihil Obstat Posted August 21, 2012 Posted August 21, 2012 (edited) [left]No matter what one's views are on the morality of the Econe consecrations and whatnot, we still might also agree that Archbishop Lefebvre especially, and the rest of the SSPX were treated rather badly by a lot of people within the Church. In my opinion there were failures on both sides. To set the stage for this, recall that Archbishop Lefebvre was the Superior General of the Holy Ghost Fathers. The Holy Ghost Fathers, following the Council, held a general chapter and essentially made it clear to Archbishop Lefebvre that his leadership was no longer welcome.[/left] [left] [b][extract][/b][/left] [left][b][size=3][b]A Homeless Bishop:[/b] The Archbishop left the motherhouse, one simple bag in hand. A French seminarian saw him and asked "Where are you going like that, Excellency?" "I don't know..." "Can I be of assistance?" "Thank you, that's all right." He found refuge firstly on November 1 at the Institute of the Holy Ghost on Via Machiavelli. A little later, he found a small room at the Villa Lituania on Via Casalmonferrato. It was maintained by the sisters who were attached to the Lithuanian seminary. He bought himself a desk, a wardrobe, and some shelving, and he had just enough to pay his rent with the ninety thousand lira he received monthly from the Sacred Congregation for the Propagation of the Faith for his work as a consulter and as president of the commission responsible for catechisms in Africa. It was a role he kept until 1972.[/size][/b][/left] [b][/extract][/b] I think it's very sad. He offered his entire life up to that point in service to the Holy Ghost Fathers. He was among the best missionaries they had in French West Africa. He was probably their most effective bishop, and did a huge amount of good in the area. And this is how he was thanked, at the end of it all. It's a shame. How might things have been different? There are a few moments in his life where I wonder that. That's definitely one of them. How much more could he have done for the Church? That's something we'll never know. Edited August 21, 2012 by Nihil Obstat
beatitude Posted August 21, 2012 Posted August 21, 2012 [quote name='Studiumecclesiae' timestamp='1345533488' post='2471154'] So basically if your bishop encouraged you to have meetings with the muslims, to invite them in your church, etc. Would you do it? For "inter-religious dialogue" sake?[/quote] I would, for the sake of their souls, my soul, and the love of Christ. There's absolutely nothing wrong with having meetings with Muslims, and there is certainly nothing wrong with inviting non-Catholics in your church. We don't have a separatist beliefs in Catholicism, and we're not Mormons, with rules about who can enter our holy places. And I would have thought that inviting people into the presence of the Eucharist is good evangelism rather than otherwise. I went to a SSPX chapel once, when I was fifteen. I didn't realise that it was SSPX. I didn't even know what the SSPX was. I had just been confirmed and was keen to discover my faith in its fullness, and I looked for a traditional Latin Mass, never having experienced that before. When I saw in the phone book that there was a local church offering it, I went along. I left before the Mass even began because the atmosphere in there was so cold and hostile. I have never been made to feel so unwelcome at any Mass in my life. I was the only girl not to have a mantilla (I didn't even know what mantillas were, and I certainly didn't know where you could buy them) and because of this the women sitting in the pew behind me started to whisper and giggle. I could hear the catty things they were saying. Apparently whispering and gossiping in church is acceptable; being without a headcovering isn't. There was something nasty in the air, and the whole experience was saddening and disturbing. When I found out that they were SSPX a few years later, it all clicked into place. You say that there is blind obedience and intelligent obedience. There is also a difference between loving tradition, and worshipping tradition - turning it into an idol and giving your veneration to that instead of to God. I'm not saying that all SSPX attendees do this, but the risk is there. The FSSP priests are able to foster tradition and offer beautiful reverent Latin liturgies without any need for disobedience. The Oratorians at my current parish do it too. But the difference is that they aren't presenting themselves as an exclusive little coterie, distinct from the rest of the church, and often worryingly critical towards the popes who followed Vatican 2.
Vincent Vega Posted August 21, 2012 Posted August 21, 2012 [quote name='Studiumecclesiae' timestamp='1345533488' post='2471154'] So basically if your bishop encouraged you to have meetings with the muslims, to invite them in your church, etc. Would you do it? For "inter-religious dialogue" sake? [/quote] "Then Jesus got up in front of the crowd and said 'Therefore, brethren, do not talk with any sinner or non-believer, as each of you is perfect and everyone who has not already heard my message is pretty much flooped'." The Gospel according to St. Spix. (Thanks be to God.)
Papist Posted August 21, 2012 Posted August 21, 2012 [quote name='Studiumecclesiae' timestamp='1345533488' post='2471154'] So basically if your bishop encouraged you to have meetings with the muslims, to invite them in your church, etc. Would you do it? For "inter-religious dialogue" sake? I think there are two kinds of obedience: blind, or intelligent. The SSPX ordained the bishops in order to survive. Bishop Lefebvre was feeling he was going to die. And Rome had accepted that he'd get one bishop, but they would keep delaying the permission. The SSPX perfectly knew their technique was for the SSPX to lose their only Bishop. And they didn't!! Thanks to what? The consecrations! [/quote] Let me guess. Your obedience is intelligent. Re your question. I would try to fulfill the Church's primary mission the best I could. Do you know what the Church's primary mission is? I would also invite SSPXers for a dialogue. [spoiler]http://www.vatican.va/holy_father/john_paul_ii/encyclicals/documents/hf_jp-ii_enc_07121990_redemptoris-missio_en.html[/spoiler]
the171 Posted August 21, 2012 Posted August 21, 2012 We are a missionary church. Weren't the first bishops converts? And the greatest saints converts?? Why are you so afraid to dialogue with Muslims and other faiths? That is the only way they will know what we believe!!
MIKolbe Posted August 21, 2012 Posted August 21, 2012 [quote name='Studiumecclesiae' timestamp='1345533488' post='2471154'] The SSPX ordained the bishops in order to survive. [/quote] Obey the Church unless I need to survive. Got it!!!
Lisa Posted August 21, 2012 Posted August 21, 2012 Happy feast day of St. Pius X to everyone in this thread [url="http://www.catholic.org/saints/saint.php?saint_id=313"]http://www.catholic.org/saints/saint.php?saint_id=313[/url] I think there's a lot in his life that we can learn from. His views on relativism are so important for our world today, and he promoted daily communion!
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now