Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

If the clinic is changing nothing but it's name, what is there to be happy about? It will still refer women to get abortions the same way it did before, how does changing nothing but the name decrease abortion referrals?

 

I’m afraid you’re right, it is like calling abortion, pro-choice or woman's healthcare. 

 

Bottom line is whatever it is there called, them places are in the business of prematurely ending human life.

Basilisa Marie
Posted

Well, okay, clearly I was mistaken. 

 

This is a "let's bash Planned Parenthood to make ourselves feed good" thread.

 

I thought it was a thread discussing the name change. 

 

My bad. 

KnightofChrist
Posted

Well, okay, clearly I was mistaken. 

 

This is a "let's bash Planned Parenthood to make ourselves feed good" thread.

 

I thought it was a thread discussing the name change. 

 

My bad. 

 

Yeah that's it... or maybe it's a let's talk down to people who don't get all happy happy joy joy over a empty and hollow name change that doesn't mean jack.

Posted

I'm still happy that a facility is not starting to offer abortions. Yes they still refer abortions, but at least I can be happy that they aren't upgrading from referals to performing them.

Basilisa Marie
Posted

If the clinic is changing nothing but it's name, what is there to be happy about? It will still refer women to get abortions the same way it did before, how does changing nothing but the name decrease abortion referrals?

 

It's disaffiliating with the company.  It decided that it would rather break from the group than offer abortion services themselves.  It's a small victory, and should be recognized. It means that some members of Planned Parenthood decided that providing other services are more important to them than providing abortions, while the parent company believes providing abortions is paramount. 

 

Not everything has to be a giant flashy win in the culture wars.  An army has to stop advancing before it can be pushed back. 



I'm still happy that a facility is not starting to offer abortions. Yes they still refer abortions, but at least I can be happy that they aren't upgrading from referals to performing them.

 

Slappo gets it. 

Posted

Well, okay, clearly I was mistaken.

This is a "let's bash Planned Parenthood to make ourselves feed good" thread.

I thought it was a thread discussing the name change.

My bad.


I don't feel good about this charade. Planned parenthood is evil
Posted

*off topic*

the C.S. Lewis quote in your siggy feels a little bit gnostic yo

Posted

*off topic*
the C.S. Lewis quote in your siggy feels a little bit gnostic yo

Yo
KnightofChrist
Posted

It's disaffiliating with the company. It decided that it would rather break from the group than offer abortion services themselves. It's a small victory, and should be recognized. It means that some members of Planned Parenthood decided that providing other services are more important to them than providing abortions, while the parent company believes providing abortions is paramount.

Not everything has to be a giant flashy win in the culture wars. An army has to stop advancing before it can be pushed back.



The good I can see is overshadowed by unchanged evil, because it's not a victory, it is at best a stalemate, nothing won, nothing changed but the name. It's good, in a empty sense, they didn't start murdering babies on site, but they'll still arrange for babies to be murdered elsewhere. Their active role in the culture of death continues unabated and unchanged.
Basilisa Marie
Posted

*off topic*

the C.S. Lewis quote in your siggy feels a little bit gnostic yo

 

That's because it is.  :) 

Posted

I don't feel good about this charade. Planned parenthood is evil

 

Apparently they didn't feel so good about Planned Parenthood either, since they've elected to cease being affiliated with them.

 

It's too bad so many here seem to think that conversion of the heart is an event, rather than a process.

Posted

*off topic*

the C.S. Lewis quote in your siggy feels a little bit gnostic yo

 

 

That's because it is.   :)

 

It has been bugging me for several weeks now as well, after I re-read some Patristic theology and the Thomistic understanding of the human being.

 

Thomas Aquinas was pretty specific that the human person is not merely the body, and not merely the soul, but the unity of both. The soul seems to be sufficient for maintaining identity after death until the eschaton, but it is not sufficient for the entire human being.

Posted

Apparently they didn't feel so good about Planned Parenthood either, since they've elected to cease being affiliated with them.

It's too bad so many here seem to think that conversion of the heart is an event, rather than a process.

It's not a conversion of the heart it's just good PR
Posted

It's not a conversion of the heart it's just good PR

 

Must be nice to be able to know that. :)

Posted

blessed are they that have not seen, and have believed.

KnightofChrist
Posted

What conversion of heart? A conversion of heart requires internal repentance and change not just external change. There can be no conversion of heart without repentance and change both inwardly and outwardly. Based upon the comments of Family Planning representatives this external change seems to be motivated by economic realities and profitably, not actual repentance or conversion.

Posted

Must be nice to be able to know that. :)

KnightofChrist
Posted (edited)

No conversion of heart.

 

"We will be changing our name in early 2013 to Family Planning of South Central New York. Our mission statement, addresses and services will remain the same.

We remain totally committed to women's reproductive choice. We will continue to provide high quality, affordable health care and lifesaving cancer screenings, offer the full range of FDA-approved contraception, reduce unintended pregnancy, provide pregnancy testing and options counseling, diagnose and treat sexually transmitted diseases, provide medically accurate, age-appropriate sexuality education, promote family communication, and advocate for reproductive freedom."

 

Source: http://www.plannedparenthood.org/ppscny/coming-soon-new-name-same-great-services-40630.htm

 

They also sell the "morning after" abortion pill on site in all their locations, for as low as $15, they make murder cheap. http://www.plannedparenthood.org/ppscny/family-planning-benefit-program-29750.htm

Edited by KnightofChrist
Posted

Nice how the article skips over the increased rates of STDs and PID and subsequent infertility which can result.

 

Glad I wasn't the only one thinking that...reading it reminded me of whenever someone reports about "hot spot" policing and makes it out to be the best thing since sliced bread.  Reported crime rates go down, but usually every non-white group finds themselves at odds with the police over the tactics used and refuse to call them for anything short of a murder (and many times not even then).

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...