Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

...

This is bad for the Church is dozens of ways. When people get over the shock, they will start to realize how bad.

I think you are right.  Past papal resignations haven't gone well.

PhuturePriest
Posted (edited)

Obviously, when my mother woke me up this morning to inform me of his resignation I was in shock and had a hard time processing it. But what has been harder to process is good Catholics turning on the Pope. He has been one of the greatest Popes we could have asked for. The Holy Spirit blessed us with this choice. He is old and sick and can no longer do his job adequately. Who is to say this is not the work of the Holy Spirit? Pope Benedict XVI has been my only experience with Popes (Pope John Paul II died when I was very young and didn't pay much attention to it). I remember watching when Pope Benedict XVI was chosen on the news, and watching him come out for the first time. He has been very dear to my heart, and I will be sad to see him go. It is already a time for weeping. Let us not make it a time of accusations and conspiracy as well. We have been loyal to the Pope this far; let us not abandon him in his greatest time of need.

Edited by FuturePriest387
Posted

Can you imagine St. Peter hanging upside down on the cross saying, "I resign."

Posted

Pope Hasan would never do that. 

HisChildForever
Posted

I honestly believe it must be something with his health, and he's doing what is best for the Church.  Rather than be an invalid Pope, he obviously wants a healthier, stronger successor to maintain sound leadership of the Church...

 

I agree. We don't know the details of his health, for one thing. Also, in these times, the Holy Father has to be very active and very much in the public eye. A very ill Pope wouldn't, or rather couldn't, perform such duties.

Posted

Pope Hasan would never do that. 

If elected you would need to choose a new name.

FutureCarmeliteClaire
Posted

Um, wow. This thread is just... wow. I'm going to exit before I say something I'll regret later.

Hasan, thank you for bringing some necessary humor to my morning.

Posted

I'm male, confirmed, and single.  

 

 

I will issues a call to all righteous Catholic men to take up arms and form an army to retake the Holy Land.  I'll also move to retake the Hagia Sophia by force.  

 

 

HASAN 2013!

 

I don't think 'single' is one of the requirements.
 

FutureSister2009
Posted

At first I did think it was a joke. But I heard it from reliable sources so I had to believe it. So many memories. The only Pope I ever really knew besides the wonderful JPII. The first Pope I ever witnessed get elected, the first Pope I ever saw in person, the first Pope I ever read books by and the first Pope I ever knew to resign apparently 

Posted

I'm not attacking or turning on the Pope. I'm saying his quitting is a bad idea and will hurt the Church. I hope I'm wrong. You can disagree with something your parents or kids do without hating them.

Posted

Obviously, when my mother woke me up this morning to inform me of his resignation I was in shock and had a hard time processing it. But what has been harder to process is good Catholics turning on the Pope. He has been one of the greatest Popes we could have asked for. The Holy Spirit blessed us with this choice. He is old and sick and can no longer do his job adequately. Who is to say this is not the work of the Holy Spirit? Pope Benedict XVI has been my only experience with Popes (Pope John Paul II died when I was very young and didn't pay much attention to it). I remember watching when Pope Benedict XVI was chosen on the news, and watching him come out for the first time. He has been very dear to my heart, and I will be sad to see him go. It is already a time for weeping. Let us not make it a time of accusations and conspiracy as well. We have been loyal to the Pope this far; let us not abandon him in his greatest time of need.

 


Why must I have run out of props?  Why?  This is an amazing post FP.  (And reminds me of my own feelings when JP2 died and I was a non-Catholic.)

 

Also, new from Catholic memes and germane to this thread given we've had some Petrus Romanus posts already:

426164_160618590754558_507148148_n.jpg

HisChildForever
Posted

I'm not attacking or turning on the Pope. I'm saying his quitting is a bad idea and will hurt the Church. I hope I'm wrong. You can disagree with something your parents or kids do without hating them.

 

Perhaps him staying will hurt the Church. We'll never know.

Posted

I'm stunned by the news and like many, anticipating the anti-Catholic reactions in the news and social media. Nevertheless, I have tremendous respect and admiration for the way our Holy Father has led the Church since JPII and I trust that he made this decision after a lot of prayer and discernment. If in fact the Holy Spirit led him to this decision, who are we to disagree with it? I'll keep him, the church, and the future pope in my prayers.

Posted

I'm not attacking or turning on the Pope. I'm saying his quitting is a bad idea and will hurt the Church. I hope I'm wrong. You can disagree with something your parents or kids do without hating them.

Well said.

Posted

Perhaps him staying will hurt the Church. We'll never know.


I guess part of my feeling has to do with having watched John Paul's mortification. As someone who lives each day with pain and disability, I was given strength by watching his strength.
Posted

 "Pope John Paul II remained in office so that he might show us how to suffer and how to die. Pope Benedict XVI is leaving the Papal Office so that he might show us how to live in humble honesty."

Posted

I'm known for having strong opinions. I love Vatican II, dislike the Latin mass and chant. I think the SSPX should be kicked to the curb once and for all, so obviously I have disagreed with some of the stuff Benedict did. That doesn't make me a bad Catholic. Still, I didn't want him to die or quit.

I'm a concrete thinker, and realize what this will mean. It will give fodder to our enemies. Even if no behind the scenes reason comes out, the Catholic haters will say this is to hush up something he did. They will feast on it for years.

Doing it so Cardinals might not be home for Easter is bizarre, or designed to force them to make a quick decision. Both things are bad.

This is bad for the Church is dozens of ways. When people get over the shock, they will start to realize how bad.

 

This is why I am so sad: he did many of the best things ever.

I think that what he did caused him so many enemies within the Church itself he probably wanted to give a strong signal to all.

People can think what they want, people who hates the church will always hate, whatever it happens.

I think this has a much bigger impact on the faithful rather than on non-faithful.

Pope has always spoken about the evil that is inside the church. I fear his resignation has somethng to do with it.

Pope Paul VI too wanted to resign anyway, but he died before he could do it.

PhuturePriest
Posted

 "Pope John Paul II remained in office so that he might show us how to suffer and how to die. Pope Benedict XVI is leaving the Papal Office so that he might show us how to live in humble honesty."

 

Bazinga.

FutureSister2009
Posted

I have a feeling Benny must know something we don't. It must be between him and God right now.

HisChildForever
Posted

I guess part of my feeling has to do with having watched John Paul's mortification. As someone who lives each day with pain and disability, I was given strength by watching his strength.

 

I wonder if, like someone else mentioned, he's been diagnosed with Alzheimer's. From what I understand, JPII was mentally fit, it was his body that was broken down. Could you imagine if B16 or any pope became sick with Alzheimer's - and the illness became advanced to the point where he didn't recognize his bedroom, staff, position, etc.? I wonder how that would be handled.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...