Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Church/saint Teaching And Modesty


Recommended Posts

Posted

Dressing simply if you want to avoid marriage might be a good idea, but you'll probably end up attracting people no matter what you wear.  I grew up with guys who would ask me out simply because I didn't wear tight shirts and short skirts, because I looked like a "church girl".  You can't win, no matter what you do.

 
I agree with everything else you've written, but I just want to add something about the part I've put in bold.
 
It is not a sin to feel physically attracted to somebody. Nobody has failed the modesty test if they get asked out on a date.
 
I think sometimes people forget this, and this is why I dislike modesty advice that makes it sound as though female desire doesn't exist (where are all the threads on 'Joseph-like' modesty?) and that male desire is some primitive force that needs to be contained with the aid of Victorian-style crinolines (which I am sure Mary would not be wearing). It's not like this. Desire happens naturally. It's part of who we are. It's also not just about body parts - which should make sense, because sexuality itself is about far more than body parts. I knew one guy who told me that he sometimes found debating with women to be quite hot. The intellectual challenge attracted him and it had nothing to do with what a woman might be wearing. It isn't sinful to feel these attractions and it isn't possible to make them go away anyhow. They just happen. It's how you treat your thoughts that matters - if you fantasise about a person and basically turn them into a lump of meat, that is the sin. You lose focus on who they are and turn them into something quite different, which is not respectful and goes against our understanding of human dignity. But it does take some conscious effort to do this, which is why a lustful person could go on sinning even if the object of his/her passion was wearing a floor-length cardboard box with holes cut out for eyes.
 
MarysLittleFlower, from some of what you've written, I get the impression that you are confusing attraction with lust. You are writing a lot about modesty lately, and I feel that as you come to feel more at home in both faith and sexuality, you won't feel the need to think about this topic quite so much. Take care to avoid becoming preoccupied with any one aspect of your religious observance. It's important to have a balanced faith.
 
Also, bear in mind that not even saints are right on everything all of the time. ;) St Thomas Aquinas might think that 'unadorned' women are less likely to attract interest, but somehow I don't think the average twenty-first century man translates 'no jewellery' as 'unavailable'.
Posted
Standards of Modesty in Dress
Imprimatur dated Sept. 24, 1956
"A dress cannot be called decent which is cut deeper than two fingers breadth under the pit of the throat; which does not cover the arms at least to the elbows; and scarcely reaches a bit beyond the knees. Furthermore, dresses of transparent materials are improper."
The Cardinal Vicar of Pius XII
 
 
 
Sorry ladies... no beach fun for you!
Posted

Standards of Modesty in Dress
Imprimatur dated Sept. 24, 1956
"A dress cannot be called decent which is cut deeper than two fingers breadth under the pit of the throat; which does not cover the arms at least to the elbows; and scarcely reaches a bit beyond the knees. Furthermore, dresses of transparent materials are improper."
The Cardinal Vicar of Pius XII
 
 
 
Sorry ladies... no beach fun for you!

 


If I Google search 'Cardinal Vicar of Pius XII', I don't even get the man's name. All I get is a quotation on modesty, enthusiastically copied and re-copied by groups with names such as 'The League for Modesty in Dress'. No source is ever given. Googling that search term doesn't produce anything else he said or wrote. From this I can conclude one of two things:

 

1.) The quotation has been misattributed (at best) or fabricated (at worst).

2.) The Cardinal Vicar of Pius XII did nothing else whatsoever in his whole life except speak and write about female modesty - in which I case I don't think he is well-balanced enough as a Catholic to be taken seriously.

 

I think it's more likely to be the first one.

PhuturePriest
Posted

Is there a slim chance this quote is out of context and he might be talking about dress codes for the Vatican? Because that's literally what the dress code is for the Vatican.

Posted (edited)

Not ex cathedra. :|

 

Oh that's right, it needs to be ex cathedra for Catholics to follow it, otherwise it can be disregarded

 

:|

Edited by mortify
AwedbyHisGrace
Posted

Not ex cathedra or anything either, but ...

 

"While we are on the subject of dress and its relevance to the problem of modesty and immodesty it is worth drawing attention to the functional significance of differences in attire. There are certain objective situations in which even total nudity of the body is not immodest, since the proper function of nakedness in this context is not to provoke a reaction to the person as an object for enjoyment, and in just the same way the functions of particular forms of attire may vary. Thus, the body may be partially bared for physical labour, for bathing, or for a medical examination. If then we wish to pass a moral judgement on particular forms of dress we have to start from the particular functions which they serve. When a person uses such a form of dress in accordance with its objective function we cannot claim to see anything immodest in it, even if it involves partial nudity. Whereas the use of such a costume outside its proper context is immodest, and is inevitably felt to be so. For example, there is nothing immodest about the use of a bathing costume at a bathing place, but to wear it in the street or while out for a walk is contrary to the dictates of modesty."
 

( Karol Wojtyla in Love and Responsibility)

:) 

IcePrincessKRS
Posted

Oh that's right, it needs to be ex cathedra for Catholics to follow it, otherwise it can be disregarded

 

:|

 

Just pointing out that it's not a morally binding teaching. I don't have to confess wearing a bathing suit.
 

Guest Allie
Posted (edited)

Standards of Modesty in Dress
Imprimatur dated Sept. 24, 1956
"A dress cannot be called decent which is cut deeper than two fingers breadth under the pit of the throat; which does not cover the arms at least to the elbows; and scarcely reaches a bit beyond the knees. Furthermore, dresses of transparent materials are improper."
The Cardinal Vicar of Pius XII
 
 
 
Sorry ladies... no beach fun for you!

 

Just curious, were there standards of modesty for men in 1956?
 

Edited by Allie
CatholicCid
Posted

Standards of Modesty in Dress
Imprimatur dated Sept. 24, 1956
"A dress cannot be called decent which is cut deeper than two fingers breadth under the pit of the throat; which does not cover the arms at least to the elbows; and scarcely reaches a bit beyond the knees. Furthermore, dresses of transparent materials are improper."
The Cardinal Vicar of Pius XII
 
 
 
Sorry ladies... no beach fun for you!

Why would they wear a dress to the beach?

homeschoolmom
Posted

Standards of Modesty in Dress
Imprimatur dated Sept. 24, 1956
"A dress cannot be called decent which is cut deeper than two fingers breadth under the pit of the throat; which does not cover the arms at least to the elbows; and scarcely reaches a bit beyond the knees. Furthermore, dresses of transparent materials are improper."
The Cardinal Vicar of Pius XII
 
 
 
Sorry ladies... no beach fun for you!

I don't swim in a dress. :|

Basilisa Marie
Posted

Standards of Modesty in Dress
Imprimatur dated Sept. 24, 1956
"A dress cannot be called decent which is cut deeper than two fingers breadth under the pit of the throat; which does not cover the arms at least to the elbows; and scarcely reaches a bit beyond the knees. Furthermore, dresses of transparent materials are improper."
The Cardinal Vicar of Pius XII
 
 
 
Sorry ladies... no beach fun for you!

 

You're not being helpful. 

Posted

Just pointing out that it's not a morally binding teaching. I don't have to confess wearing a bathing suit.
 

 

Look, if a woman wants to wear something revealing on the beach, I really don't mind, by all means go do it! All I'm saying is Catholicism does not operate as you describe it. You can't just disregard a directive from the Pope because it's not Ex Cathedra, otherwise we could scrap the entire Second Vatican Council, which some say might not be a bad idea! The general Magisterium has to be obeyed, even if it goes against your personal preference.

 

But that said, I suppose if a man is tempted by the revealing bathing suit of a woman a beach, then she bears no part in his sin? Or has she committed sin as well?

Posted

"One cannot sufficiently deplore the blindness of so many women of every age and condition; made foolish by desire to please, they do not see to what a degree the in decency of their clothing shocks every honest man, and offends God. Most of them would formerly have blushed for those toilettes as for a grave fault against Christian modesty; now it does not suffice for them to exhibit them on the public thoroughfares; they do not fear to cross the threshold of the churches, to assist at the Holy sacrifice of the Mass, and even to bear the seducing food of shameful passions to the Eucharistic Table where one receives the heavenly Author of purity. And We speak not of those exotic and barbarous dances recently imported into fashionable circles, one more shocking than the other; one cannot imagine anything more suitable for banishing all the remains of modesty."

 

Pope Benedict XV

 

http://www.vatican.va/holy_father/benedict_xv/encyclicals/documents/hf_ben-xv_enc_06011921_sacra-propediem_en.html

 

Posted

Just curious, were there standards of modesty for men in 1956?


Ummm of course not! Only shameful sinful women have to worry about what they wear, silly!
PhuturePriest
Posted

"One cannot sufficiently deplore the blindness of so many women of every age and condition; made foolish by desire to please, they do not see to what a degree the in decency of their clothing shocks every honest man, and offends God. Most of them would formerly have blushed for those toilettes as for a grave fault against Christian modesty; now it does not suffice for them to exhibit them on the public thoroughfares; they do not fear to cross the threshold of the churches, to assist at the Holy sacrifice of the Mass, and even to bear the seducing food of shameful passions to the Eucharistic Table where one receives the heavenly Author of purity. And We speak not of those exotic and barbarous dances recently imported into fashionable circles, one more shocking than the other; one cannot imagine anything more suitable for banishing all the remains of modesty."

 

Pope Benedict XV

 

http://www.vatican.va/holy_father/benedict_xv/encyclicals/documents/hf_ben-xv_enc_06011921_sacra-propediem_en.html

 

I agree with all of this. That being said, this was not an infallible statement, it was an opinion that in my opinion is spot-on. None of this implies that bathing suits are evil, however. I'm not one for bikinis and I'll argue that women shouldn't wear them since they are practically panties and a bra. But none of the bathing suits shown on this thread ever resembled a bikini or any of the like.

Posted

I don't swim in a dress. :|

 

And neither do I. Modesty at church or work is different from modesty at the beach. Alot of modesty is situational.
 

Posted

And neither do I. Modesty at church or work is different from modesty at the beach. Alot of modesty is situational.

:o so you're a relative-ist?! :o so shocking!
PhuturePriest
Posted

Ummm of course not! Only shameful sinful women have to worry about what they wear, silly!

 

If I were Pope, I would write an encyclical that denounced hanging pants that exposed your underwear and male speedos.

mysisterisalittlesister
Posted

I don't think I can contribute to this discussion, because I'm 14 and not very knowledgable on the topic of church documents regarding modesty :p

 

buuuut….

 

I don't see anything wrong with the swimsuits that the171 posted. I think they're cool :) Personally though, I like simple sport swimsuits and high necks because I'm always mortally terrified that my swimsuit neckline will fall down (it's happened before, and I don't want it to happen again  :pinch: )

 

carry on! :popcorn:

Posted

I'm just giving some historical perspective, the reality is no one cares about what the Pope or anyone else says for that matter. We're free to do as we please, it's time to celebrate the human body and not veil it up.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...