Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted


Not with that smiley. :dead2:

 

Would this be more appropriate? :bananarap:

Posted

Hey where is the ex-mormon, former agnostic, former spiritual but not religious, generic Christian considering Catholicism option??!! I'm being discriminated against! :evil: Just kidding, this is the closest I could come up with that fits me though, I apparently defy classification.

Fidei Defensor
Posted

meep

Posted

Watch it. I was mourning the loss of family. :|

 


prayers for the one who passed and your family.

Anastasia13
Posted (edited)

Hey where is the ex-mormon, former agnostic, former spiritual but not religious, generic Christian considering Catholicism option??!! I'm being discriminated against!

 


Watch it hun, I'm closer to Catholicism than you are, and you are a St. Hasa Perm.

 

  :evil: Just kidding, this is the closest I could come up with that fits me though, I apparently defy classification.

Welcome to the club. Wine, tea, and waters are to the left. The cookies and pastries to the left but closer to the main stage. Guest speakers start in 15 minutes. Please obtain a name tag at the registration table and have a seat.

Edited by Light and Truth
Anastasia13
Posted

Dust, if you have an "Other" it would cover and shut people up from complaining about unlikely or obscure minority religions. It's also a good catchall if you have rare a B'hai, Sikh, pagan, new age mishmash... etc. show up.

Posted (edited)


Watch it hun, I'm closer to Catholicism than you are, and you are a St. Hasa Perm.

The Armenian Apostolic Church is Catholic. In fact, both Eastern Orthodox and Oriental Orthodox, like Latin Catholics and Eastern Catholics, are members of Catholic Churches, for as the ancient Fathers taught . . . the one Holy Catholic and Apostolic Church exists wherever Christ is present in the Holy Eucharist, 

Edited by Apotheoun
Anastasia13
Posted

The Armenian Apostolic Church is Catholic. In fact, both Eastern Orthodox and Oriental Orthodox, like Latin Catholics and Eastern Catholics, are members of Catholic Churches, for as the ancient Fathers taught . . . the one Holy Catholic and Apostolic Church exists wherever Christ is present in the Holy Eucharist, 

 

Meh. Not everyone fully ascribes to everything word that Pope JPII said.
 

Posted

Meh. Not everyone fully ascribes to everything word that Pope JPII said.
 

I will stick with the ecclesiology of the Church Fathers.

Nihil Obstat
Posted

Also jedi and Satanism.

Posted

I have a vague memory of some satanist troll a while back

Posted (edited)

Also jedi and Satanism.

Both Jedi and Satanism fit in the category "Spiritual, not Religious."

Edited by Apotheoun
Nihil Obstat
Posted

I have a vague memory of some satanist troll a while back


Varg.
Anastasia13
Posted

I will stick with the ecclesiology of the Church Fathers.

 


Yes, but the fact that JPII referred to the the two lungs of the church at some point as inclusive of the Orthodox churches and thus in keeping with the traditional views of the Church Fathers reaffirms the orthodoxy of the Catholic Church while affirming the catholicity of the Orthodox Churches. If he truly disagreed with the ecclesiology of the Church Fathers, then JPII would not have been Catholic much less Pope, now would he?

Anastasia13
Posted (edited)

Would this be more appropriate? :bananarap:

 


No. Considering the already existing level of fundamental alignment of our faith and the creepiness of dancing bananas, would that be better? NO!

Edited by Light and Truth
Posted (edited)


Yes, but the fact that JPII referred to the the two lungs of the church at some point as inclusive of the Orthodox churches and thus in keeping with the traditional views of the Church Fathers reaffirms the orthodoxy of the Catholic Church while affirming the catholicity of the Orthodox Churches. If he truly disagreed with the ecclesiology of the Church Fathers, then JPII would not have been Catholic much less Pope, now would he?

Actually the Eucharistic ecclesiology of the Church Fathers was only reasserted in the Roman Church after the close of the Second Vatican Council (see the CDF document Communionis Notio). Prior to Vatican II there were popes who did not accept the Patristic teaching on the nature of the Church. The fact that they did not accept - and in a few cases were no doubt ignorant of the ancient teaching - does not mean that they were not Catholic, it just means that they were uninformed about the doctrine of the Fathers. There is nothing unique in saying that, because popes are not perfect, and some have been good theologians and others not so good.

Edited by Apotheoun
Posted


No. Considering the already existing level of fundamental alignment of our faith and the creepiness of dancing bananas, would that be better? NO!

 

Awwww. :(

Anastasia13
Posted

Actually the Eucharistic ecclesiology of the Church Fathers was only reasserted in the Roman Church after the close of the Second Vatican Council (see the CDF document Communionis Notio). Prior to Vatican II there were popes who did not accept the Patristic teaching on the nature of the Church. The fact that they did not accept - and in a few cases were no doubt ignorant of the ancient teaching - does not mean that they were not Catholic, it just means that they were uninformed about the doctrine of the Fathers. There is nothing unique in saying that, because popes are not perfect, and some have been good theologians and others not so good.

 


This is true, and in fact those Greek who left at some point where considered not saved (some time in the 1500's commentary I believe on the Rome/EO schism) out of seeming to reject the Church and the faith that goes with it. It is the duty of a church to care for the souls of it's members-you cannot love if you only love the body/for the present. Had they not done that, it would have been contrary to the purpose of the church and thus not of God and not Catholic. In recognizing that, learning more about each other and the Fathers as God reveals His work in time, the acknowledgement of that is what I am calling Catholic. It is when one has that knowledge and still rejects it that one is less Catholic. If the Church rejects the faith, then it is no longer the Church-just look at what has happened in Protestantism. That is why I applaud not only Vatican II but also PJII for the recognition and continuation of that faith.

Anastasia13
Posted

Awwww. :(

 


I could really go for a banana muffin right now...

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...