Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Gay: Born That Way?


  

69 members have voted

You do not have permission to vote in this poll, or see the poll results. Please sign in or register to vote in this poll.

Recommended Posts

franciscanheart
Posted

I'm curious what the general phatmass understanding or belief is in regards to homosexual Homo sapiens. Pick as many answers as fit. I know they won't all be perfectly worded, so choose the best answers for your beliefs or understanding.

No one will be able to see your poll answers, so please be honest.

Posted

I'll make my contribution as short as possible

 

There's certainly some scientific literature that links homosexuality to genetics and pre-natal environment (more so, afaik, for men than women) that is fairly compelling. I think my main issue comes in terms of identity. What makes a certain set of inclinations/thoughts/desires compel someone to demarcate him/herself as gay/straight/etc and why? I think that stuff is almost purely cultural. Even amongst ancient cultures where everybody was banging everyone else there was no one identifying with a sexual orientation. It was a foreign concept cross-historically, and even cross-culturally it seems like a modern, Western phenomenon (although I'm not 100% and that's probably shifting now), but my point is that "genes a, b, and c/ later birth order is linked to homosexuality" is not simply predicated on the data but also of the society that classifies people as gay/straight/bi whatever.

 

 

Also it seems that women are different in that their sexual identity is more fluid/flexible whereas males tend to be more rigidly defined. My anecdotal experience corroborates this, fwiw.

 

 

In b4 the flame war yay

Nihil Obstat
Posted

I am entirely 'agnostic' on the issue, but honestly I do not think it matters either way in a moral sense.

Posted

There is also a young field of study in epigenetics that is able to show how environmental factors and upbringing can have a very physical and direct effect on gene transcription. its super interesting!

Chestertonian
Posted

I am entirely 'agnostic' on the issue, but honestly I do not think it matters either way in a moral sense.

 

Same here. No idea. I sometimes wonder, though, if some folks call themselves homosexual and really aren't because being gay is trendy and they want the attention.

Posted

Same here. No idea. I sometimes wonder, though, if some folks call themselves homosexual and really aren't because being gay is trendy and they want the attention.

 

That's probably an incredibly small percentage of people who id as gay. So small it's probably not even worth talking about.

Posted

 I would tend to agree with Nihil and Chestertonian. But I think I can put a few words on it---the "gay lifestyle" is behavior that is freely chosen no matter what the circumstances are behind the same-sex inclination.

Posted (edited)

My opinion is that behaviourally speaking people are not "born" as anything. Nature vs nurture (which ultimately is what the argument boils down to to) is a false dichotomy and really needs to be abandoned. 

I also feel I should add that I reject the idea that gay people "choose" their attractions. 

Edited by EmilyAnn
Winchester
Posted

I think it quite varies, and have no opinion whether one way is more common, or the other.

 

 

"Freely chosen" is what people who don't have a particular attraction to this or that activity say.

Chestertonian
Posted

That's probably an incredibly small percentage of people who id as gay. So small it's probably not even worth talking about.

 

Probably so. Even when I was vying for attention in high school, that's definitely not something I would've considered.
 

Posted

Probably so. Even when I was vying for attention in high school, that's definitely not something I would've considered.
 

I actually had a conversation on that subject with some friends a while ago and several noted that (at least in this country) in their experience sometimes teenage girls among certain sub-cultures claimed to be bisexual and when they got older and left the sub-culture, shed the bisexuality as well. But such numbers are very small. 

HisChildForever
Posted

I voted - "I'm leaning toward yes, they are born that way."

HisChildForever
Posted

My opinion is that behaviourally speaking people are not "born" as anything. Nature vs nurture (which ultimately is what the argument boils down to to) is a false dichotomy and really needs to be abandoned. 

I also feel I should add that I reject the idea that gay people "choose" their attractions. 

 

I agree that nature and nurture both contribute to behavior.

franciscanheart
Posted

I am entirely 'agnostic' on the issue, but honestly I do not think it matters either way in a moral sense.

I didn't ask for opinions on morality. And if by agnostic you mean you don't know, I wonder which way you might lean when you ponder.
 

There is also a young field of study in epigenetics that is able to show how environmental factors and upbringing can have a very physical and direct effect on gene transcription. its super interesting!

I studied epigenetics this semester as part of my curriculum. Read some fascinating papers, had it incorporated to my understanding of basic human biology, etc. I don't know that I'd go so far as to say that epigenetics is defining in sexuality, but I do know it's fascinating and has already begun to explain at least some percentage of problems with cancer, metabolic disorders, and other physical problems of similar nature.
 

Same here. No idea. I sometimes wonder, though, if some folks call themselves homosexual and really aren't because being gay is trendy and they want the attention.

I was wondering who might mention this first. For the record, if I were doing a more detailed study on this, I would lump you in the "I'm leaning toward no" group.
 

I would tend to agree with Nihil and Chestertonian. But I think I can put a few words on it---the "gay lifestyle" is behavior that is freely chosen no matter what the circumstances are behind the same-sex inclination.

Again, not looking at lifestyle, morality, etc. Just asking if you think people are born with the homosexual inclination.
Posted (edited)

I picked both "Yes" and "Sometimes." 

 

There were a lot of people in high school and college that fooled around or dated people of the same sex because it was an 'in' thing at the time. In those cases it was obviously chosen and most of them live as straight now. (But I suppose we could say those people were more bicurious than actually dealing with an attraction.)

 

Generally speaking I think most gay/bi people come to realize they're gay/bi at some point in their life. It's an awareness of something that was already there more than a choice. 

 

 

Edited by MissyP89
Winchester
Posted

You expected too much of them. Lower the bar.

Chestertonian
Posted

I was wondering who might mention this first. For the record, if I were doing a more detailed study on this, I would lump you in the "I'm leaning toward no" group.
 
 

 

You'd be wrong.

Spem in alium
Posted

Thinking about this issue also makes me think about or recall stories I sometimes hear of men and women who have been in a heterosexual marriage for a number of years before realising they are in fact gay and subsequently often leaving their partner.

 

Are people in these instances "born gay" and have just repressed it or not recognised it until that moment? Does society make them gay?

 

I am not entirely sure, but I do agree with Missy - I think rather than actively choosing a sexuality with which to identify, most people come to realise or come to an awareness of their sexuality in time. Thus, I'm inclined to answer "Sometimes".

 

 

Nihil Obstat
Posted

I didn't ask for opinions on morality. And if by agnostic you mean you don't know, I wonder which way you might lean when you ponder.


I lean towards making no conclusions one way or the other. I mentioned morality to establish why not knowing does not bother me.
Posted (edited)

 
I studied epigenetics this semester as part of my curriculum. Read some fascinating papers, had it incorporated to my understanding of basic human biology, etc. I don't know that I'd go so far as to say that epigenetics is defining in sexuality, but I do know it's fascinating and has already begun to explain at least some percentage of problems with cancer, metabolic disorders, and other physical problems of similar nature.
 

I dont think ANYONE would say that epigenetics DIRECTLY effects sexuality because the body is way more freaking complex than that haha!

And I dont believe that my post was implying such a thing, if it was my bad.  :spike:

I was merely pointing out that it is a new and interesting field of genetics that may explain social behavior. The whole idea in the nature vs nurture debate that nurture could actually have genetic implications is very interesting.

 

Epigenetics isnt something that is localized to a specific biological system in the body, it can happen anywhere and effect any gene. Methylation, Acetylation, or other various types of modifications dealing with histones and chromosomal density, can change the amount/rate at which a particular gene is transcribed.

It has been noted in mice to cause social changes in the offspring of those who were raised with either an attentive mother or inattentive mother rendering them more withdrawn than those raised by an attentive mother. 

 

But like I said, this IS a new field as Im sure you know so this is just the early stages of understanding. I dont think it is known for certain when/why these modifications happen in the genome but they do know that it DOES happen.

 

I think its wicked cool!  :woot:

Edited by CrossCuT

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...