arfink Posted May 15, 2013 Posted May 15, 2013 (edited) I think it's possible to be born with a homosexual inclination. Original sin and all that. Of course forming it later is possible too. There are stories about that. Edited May 15, 2013 by arfink
Tony Posted May 15, 2013 Posted May 15, 2013 What if my reasoning if someone can be born gay or not is BECAUSE of Morality? If God didn't want anyone to be gay, he wouldn't let them be born that way.
PhuturePriest Posted May 15, 2013 Posted May 15, 2013 One of my friends is gay. He wishes he wasn't, and he would change it in a heartbeat if he could. But he can't. Therefore, he never chose to be that way. Are some people born that way? I do not know. I think it has to do with your upbringing, but that's what I've concluded from the little I've learned about it.
IcePrincessKRS Posted May 15, 2013 Posted May 15, 2013 I think that sometimes people can be born gay, and other times it's developed from other factors in their environment. I don't think many people would actively choose to be gay. In fact, I think many, if given the chance, would choose not to be. (I'm not talking about choosing to act in a certain manner, but just the very basic inclination of attraction.)
arfink Posted May 15, 2013 Posted May 15, 2013 Many people would also choose not to be attracted to porn. Or chose not to be attracted to alcohol. Or a gazillion other things. I think it's simplistic to say we are born with particular desires, because it implies there is nothing we can do about them.
Era Might Posted May 15, 2013 Posted May 15, 2013 (edited) What if my reasoning if someone can be born gay or not is BECAUSE of Morality? If God didn't want anyone to be gay, he wouldn't let them be born that way. I don't think that follows logically. There are all kinds of natural conditions that still need subsequent meaning attached (cultural, social, moral, etc). Economics is one example. The idea of "scarcity" is the basis of economics, but it would not follow that because things are scarce, that necessitates utilitarianism, capitalism, communism, etc. These are all different ways of attaching meaning to a natural phenomenon. Edited May 15, 2013 by Era Might
CatholicsAreKewl Posted May 15, 2013 Posted May 15, 2013 Same here. No idea. I sometimes wonder, though, if some folks call themselves homosexual and really aren't because being gay is trendy and they want the attention. I totally do this. It's counter-culture and pretty cool. I tell people Jeff's my bf, even though we're both straight.
CatholicsAreKewl Posted May 15, 2013 Posted May 15, 2013 (edited) I am entirely 'agnostic' on the issue, but honestly I do not think it matters either way in a moral sense. So wait... does that mean you believe the answer to this question is unknown and possibly unknowable? You can be agnostic and still hold a position. There are agnostic theists (I don't take agnostic atheists who refer to themselves exclusively as "agnostic" seriously). Edited May 15, 2013 by CatholicsAreKewl
Nihil Obstat Posted May 15, 2013 Posted May 15, 2013 (edited) So wait... does that mean you believe the answer to this question is unknown and possibly unknowable? You can be agnostic and still hold a position. There are agnostic theists (I don't take agnostic atheists who refer to themselves exclusively as "agnostic" seriously). Unknown certainly. Unknowable... Probably not. If I accept it as possible that there does exist a genetic reason, then that reason is probably not unknowable. How about we say currently unknowable, but perhaps not always so? Edited May 15, 2013 by Nihil Obstat
IcePrincessKRS Posted May 15, 2013 Posted May 15, 2013 (edited) Many people would also choose not to be attracted to porn. Or chose not to be attracted to alcohol. Or a gazillion other things. I think it's simplistic to say we are born with particular desires, because it implies there is nothing we can do about them. My comment about it being possible to be born that way stems from a show I watched several years ago that documented a group of adults in some random rural area that had a high number of homosexual people. I can't recall where it was, or the name of the show. What I do remember was that they did a number of tests on the group of adults they were following and they discovered that a number of the gay women had, for lack of a better term, and anomaly or birth defect in their brains that caused a certain area of the brain that differs slightly, between men and women, in size and shape (can't remember which part) that made the physical make up of their brains to basically be a "male brain" rather than mirror what a woman's brain typically looks like. Maybe they don't want to be that way but they can't help it because their brain is literally wired differently. That doesn't mean that I think that all gay people have some sort of birth defect that makes them gay. Far from it. I don't know why or how it happens to people. I believe that homosexuality can come from any number of factors and is not limited to or exclusive of being born that way. Edited May 15, 2013 by IcePrincessKRS
CatholicsAreKewl Posted May 15, 2013 Posted May 15, 2013 (edited) My comment about it being possible to be born that way stems from a show I watched several years ago that documented a group of adults in some random rural area that had a high number of homosexual people. I can't recall where it was, or the name of the show. What I do remember was that they did a number of tests on the group of adults they were following and they discovered that a number of the gay women had, for lack of a better term, and anomaly or birth defect in their brains that caused a certain area of the brain that differs slightly, between men and women, in size and shape (can't remember which part) that made the physical make up of their brains to basically be a "male brain" rather than mirror what a woman's brain typically looks like. Maybe they don't want to be that way but they can't help it because their brain is literally wired differently. That doesn't mean that I think that all gay people have some sort of birth defect that makes them gay. Far from it. I don't know why or how it happens to people. I believe that homosexuality can come from any number of factors and is not limited to or exclusive of being born that way. Interesting post. Thanks for sharing! From my very limited knowledge on this subject, I would say the idea of there being a "gay gene" is losing ground. There is, however, evidence suggesting that the sexual preferences of a child may be decided in the womb. I agree with you that those who are born hetero are also able to develop a liking for the same sex. http://news.sciencemag.org/sciencenow/2012/12/homosexuality-may-start-in-the-w.html Edited May 15, 2013 by CatholicsAreKewl
dUSt Posted May 15, 2013 Posted May 15, 2013 Is sexual preference the same as other preferences? Isn't it just a function of the brain? A gay person is not physically different than a straight person are they? It's just how one's brain works. For example, as a kid, I loved vanilla ice cream and didn't like chocolate. As I get older, I am starting to prefer chocolate. I hated the taste of beer, now I love it. My taste buds did not physically change. My brain did, right? I use to be repulsed by red heads, but now I am beginning to like them. What changed? All this to say, the human brain is utterly complex and open to manipulation--so I don't see how environment can not effect to what extent a person may embrace those tendencies. Although, as far as the poll, I would err to the side of people being born gay, if that's how you want to say it. Just like some people are born with a natural ability to be artistic, or a natural ability to be great thinkers, or are better at sports, etc, etc. I do think everyone's brain is different from conception--in other words, a baby's brain doesn't start out as a completely blank slate.
CatholicsAreKewl Posted May 15, 2013 Posted May 15, 2013 Unknown certainly. Unknowable... Probably not. If I accept it as possible that there does exist a genetic reason, then that reason is probably not unknowable. How about we say currently unknowable, but perhaps not always so? No idea. I usually just pretend I know everything.
Not The Philosopher Posted May 15, 2013 Posted May 15, 2013 Homosexuality is a complicated phenomenon, and exactly how it manifests itself will differ from individual to individual. So I doubt we'll hit upon a single explanation for it. The usual narrative, or at least the one that I'm familiar with through my own experiences is that of gradually becoming aware that your desires just not being in step with what's normal. How that plays out in the whole nature/nurture spectrum is going to differ.
CatholicsAreKewl Posted May 15, 2013 Posted May 15, 2013 (edited) Is sexual preference the same as other preferences? Isn't it just a function of the brain? A gay person is not physically different than a straight person are they? It's just how one's brain works. For example, as a kid, I loved vanilla ice cream and didn't like chocolate. As I get older, I am starting to prefer chocolate. I hated the taste of beer, now I love it. My taste buds did not physically change. My brain did, right? I use to be repulsed by red heads, but now I am beginning to like them. What changed? All this to say, the human brain is utterly complex and open to manipulation--so I don't see how environment can not effect to what extent a person may embrace those tendencies. Although, as far as the poll, I would err to the side of people being born gay, if that's how you want to say it. Just like some people are born with a natural ability to be artistic, or a natural ability to be great thinkers, or are better at sports, etc, etc. I do think everyone's brain is different from conception--in other words, a baby's brain doesn't start out as a completely blank slate. True. That might also explain the existence of forniphilia, acrotomophilia, emetophilia, telephone scatalogia, and other strange paraphilias. Edited May 16, 2013 by dUSt
CatholicsAreKewl Posted May 16, 2013 Posted May 16, 2013 (edited) :pinch: Edited May 16, 2013 by CatholicsAreKewl
IcePrincessKRS Posted May 16, 2013 Posted May 16, 2013 Interesting post. Thanks for sharing! From my very limited knowledge on this subject, I would say the idea of there being a "gay gene" is losing ground. There is, however, evidence suggesting that the sexual preferences of a child may be decided in the womb. I agree with you that those who are born hetero are also able to develop a liking for the same sex. http://news.sciencemag.org/sciencenow/2012/12/homosexuality-may-start-in-the-w.html My knowledge on the subject is very limited as well. The "why/how" of it all has never really been a focus of discussion for me, usually it's the moral "choose to/not to" that comes up. The show wasn't linking their homosexuality to any genetic component. From what I recall there was speculation that the difference in the brain development in those women was caused by chemical exposure from a nearby factory when they were in utero. They couldn't pinpoint exactly the cause, and I'm quite certain it was only some of the women. None of the gay men in the show had a similar anomaly. This was a good 8 years ago, so my memory of exact details is foggy, I only remember the general gist of the show and some of their findings.
franciscanheart Posted May 16, 2013 Author Posted May 16, 2013 I dont think ANYONE would say that epigenetics DIRECTLY effects sexuality because the body is way more freaking complex than that haha! And I dont believe that my post was implying such a thing, if it was my bad. :spike: I was merely pointing out that it is a new and interesting field of genetics that may explain social behavior. The whole idea in the nature vs nurture debate that nurture could actually have genetic implications is very interesting. Epigenetics isnt something that is localized to a specific biological system in the body, it can happen anywhere and effect any gene. Methylation, Acetylation, or other various types of modifications dealing with histones and chromosomal density, can change the amount/rate at which a particular gene is transcribed. It has been noted in mice to cause social changes in the offspring of those who were raised with either an attentive mother or inattentive mother rendering them more withdrawn than those raised by an attentive mother. But like I said, this IS a new field as Im sure you know so this is just the early stages of understanding. I dont think it is known for certain when/why these modifications happen in the genome but they do know that it DOES happen. I think its wicked cool! :woot: I think my knee-jerk reaction is that we shouldn't pull epigenetics into the discussion for various reasons. I understand methylation, acetylation, etc. I was speaking out of the assumption that a child knows at 9 that he or she is gay. But then one thing we know is that some epigenetic modifications are passed from generation to generation. So maybe it's influencing some parts of the population? Then you have to wonder: what is the factor causing the mutation? IS MONSANTO BEHIND THIS?! Many people would also choose not to be attracted to porn. Or chose not to be attracted to alcohol. Or a gazillion other things. I think it's simplistic to say we are born with particular desires, because it implies there is nothing we can do about them. Again, not addressing what to do with the inclination, just wondering if phatmassers believe gay people are born gay or choose to be. What implication you draw from my belief that gay people are born gay is your own business. I will say though that I think it's unfair to discount science because it makes the argument too easy for those who would approve the homosexual lifestyle.Is sexual preference the same as other preferences? Isn't it just a function of the brain? A gay person is not physically different than a straight person are they? It's just how one's brain works. For example, as a kid, I loved vanilla ice cream and didn't like chocolate. As I get older, I am starting to prefer chocolate. I hated the taste of beer, now I love it. My taste buds did not physically change. My brain did, right? I use to be repulsed by red heads, but now I am beginning to like them. What changed? All this to say, I'm leaning towards maybe people are born with certain tendencies, but the human brain is utterly complex and open to manipulation--so I don't see how environment can not effect to what extent a person may embrace those tendencies. Really excellent points. I am of the belief that most gay people are born with the inclinations or are predisposed to develop them. I do not, however, deny there may be some who claim to be homosexual who actually choose the lifestyle for some non-attraction-related reason(s), perhaps encompassing brain chemistry influenced by life experience and other outside factors.
CrossCuT Posted May 16, 2013 Posted May 16, 2013 I think my knee-jerk reaction is that we shouldn't pull epigenetics into the discussion for various reasons. We shouldnt use knew scientific understandings to further our knowledge on an unclear topic? Does not compute. *robot dance* But in all seriousness, I disagree completely. :pinch: Maybe for this conversation by itself thats fine, but I am 1000% in favor of looking into all modes of evidence to understand our physical world more even if those avenues are new and not entirely understood. Thats why we science. :paco:
franciscanheart Posted May 16, 2013 Author Posted May 16, 2013 We shouldnt use knew scientific understandings to further our knowledge on an unclear topic? Does not compute. *robot dance* But in all seriousness, I disagree completely. :pinch: Maybe for this conversation by itself thats fine, but I am 1000% in favor of looking into all modes of evidence to understand our physical world more even if those avenues are new and not entirely understood. Thats why we science. :paco: *New.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now