Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Gay: Born That Way?


  

69 members have voted

You do not have permission to vote in this poll, or see the poll results. Please sign in or register to vote in this poll.

Recommended Posts

Posted

“Love between two persons, whether of the same sex or of a different sex, is to be treasured and respected… When two persons love, they experience in a limited manner in this world what will be their unending delight when one with God in the next…  To love another, whether of the same sex or of a different sex, is to have entered the area of the richest human experience…” (Cardinal Basil Hume, Note on the Teaching of the Catholic Church Concerning Homosexual People, 1995).

 

 

Posted

Ok I'm confused. I thought most of these "Born gay" people believed that because that's what the liberal media was feeding them ever since they learned what gay meant. . To put it blunt, I really thought they were brainwashed (and I still think it's true for some of them)

Basilisa Marie
Posted (edited)

Ok I'm confused. I thought most of these "Born gay" people believed that because that's what the liberal media was feeding them ever since they learned what gay meant. . To put it blunt, I really thought they were brainwashed (and I still think it's true for some of them)

 

Speaking for myself only, I believe most people who are gay are born that way because many gay people have told me that it seems to them that they were born that way.  Not whatever the media (or anyone else, for that matter) has told me. 

Edited by Basilisa Marie
Posted (edited)

In all my years I have yet to meet someone who has changed their orientation because of the media. I'm not saying they are not out there, it's just that my work has been with people, as I said above, have felt that God has played some sort of a cruel joke on them. Of course I don't believe that for one minute, but the impression that is given so often is that no matter how early "feelings" arose it's my fault and God and his Church is very angry with me.

 

tumblr_m1cukw8SeZ1qczk7do1_500.jpg

Edited by cappie
Tab'le De'Bah-Rye
Posted (edited)

I love my dad and my brothers in christ and other men, but am not homosexual. Anal sex is a crime against the original covenant, "be fruitful and multiply." You can't be fruitful and multiply in that way, nore can you with condoms,histerechtamies,the pill etc. Chastity is the only exception to not stand against the original covenant, the rest is just lust and irresponsible a conterfiet form of eros. Thats my opinion anyway, and yes i to am a work in progress and still a sinner, but i will not say sin is okay.

 

Edited by Tab'le Du'Bah-Rye
Tab'le De'Bah-Rye
Posted

masturbation included in the counterfeit forms of eros.

Tab'le De'Bah-Rye
Posted

i think i voted wrong,i want my balot paper returned before election time,

Tab'le De'Bah-Rye
Posted

I don't know what your getting at fr cappie ? Is it a sin or not ? I heard 5 priests in the gold coast where excommunicated for there stance on homosexuality and abortion about 3 or 4 years ago, i think i met one of them at st mary's gold coast, who caused me to fall and i've been falling since, gave me heretical advice on the matter of lust, and i never even bought up the subject he opened the conversation on it.

Tab'le De'Bah-Rye
Posted

and i beg your pardon everyone who thinks i shouldn't front up to a priest, i front up to you the same, he is my brother and i need a direct answer so i give direct questions.

Posted

I love my dad and my brothers in christ and other men, but am not homosexual. Anal sex is a crime against the original covenant, "be fruitful and multiply." You can't be fruitful and multiply in that way, nore can you with condoms,histerechtamies,the pill etc. Chastity is the only exception to not stand against the original covenant, the rest is just lust and irresponsible a conterfiet form of eros. Thats my opinion anyway, and yes i to am a work in progress and still a sinner, but i will not say sin is okay.

 

I don't think anyone has mentioned Anal sex.

 

There are basically four different things someone might mean when they say “homosexuality,” and they are often confused.

 

1. Orientation. A person’s orientation tells you only who they are emotionally and physically attracted to. Someone may call themselves gay because that is their orientation. I would maintain people don’t choose their orientation. Some people use the word temptations to describe their orientation.

 

2. Lust. A lot of people confuse orientation with lust, but they’re not the same thing at all. Lust is more than just being attracted to someone; it has to do with how you respond to those attractions in your mind. Lust is a sin regardless of whether you’re lusting for women, men, or even your neighbor’s snazzy new car. The same Greek word translated lust in the Bible also means covet.

 

3. Sex. This is really what most people are talking about when they say that “homosexuality is a sin.” They mean that they disapprove of gay sex, but to some, it sounds like you just disapprove of their unchosen orientation.

 

4. Relationship. When gay people talk about wanting to get married, I think it’s not sex they’re after in the main, but rather, a relationship. Just as straight people (hopefully) don’t get married for the sex, gay people don’t either.

 

Would someone assume two gay people are having sex if you see them holding hands? (Would you assume a straight couple is having sex if you see them holding hands?)

Posted

I don't know what your getting at fr cappie ? Is it a sin or not ? I heard 5 priests in the gold coast where excommunicated for there stance on homosexuality and abortion about 3 or 4 years ago, i think i met one of them at st mary's gold coast, who caused me to fall and i've been falling since, gave me heretical advice on the matter of lust, and i never even bought up the subject he opened the conversation on it.

 

Homosexual desires,are not in themselves sinful. People are subject to a wide variety of sinful desires over which they have little direct control, but these do not become sinful until a person acts upon them, either by acting out the desire or by encouraging the desire and deliberately engaging in fantasies about acting it out. People tempted by homosexual desires, like people tempted by improper heterosexual desires, are not sinning until they act upon those desires in some manner.

 

As to your other remarks. I lived in the Archdiocese of Brisbane for 22 years and the only priest to be deprived of his priesthood was Fr Peter Kennedy the Administrator of St Mary's South Brisbane

on Saturday 21st February 2009. This was done because he was guilty of changing rituals including Baptism and Eucharist and allowing women to preach.

 

 

.

Posted

 

“Love between two persons, whether of the same sex or of a different sex, is to be treasured and respected… When two persons love, they experience in a limited manner in this world what will be their unending delight when one with God in the next…  To love another, whether of the same sex or of a different sex, is to have entered the area of the richest human experience…” (Cardinal Basil Hume, Note on the Teaching of the Catholic Church Concerning Homosexual People, 1995).

 

 

I can see how this can be misinterpreted (intentional no doubt) to serve the gay agenda. You know the love=love=love yada yada yada

GregorMendel
Posted

I love my dad and my brothers in christ and other men, but am not homosexual. Anal sex is a crime against the original covenant, "be fruitful and multiply." You can't be fruitful and multiply in that way, nore can you with condoms,histerechtamies,the pill etc. Chastity is the only exception to not stand against the original covenant, the rest is just lust and irresponsible a conterfiet form of eros. Thats my opinion anyway, and yes i to am a work in progress and still a sinner, but i will not say sin is okay.

 

 

Excuse me, but "Hysterectomies" absolutely should not be considered on a list of what I assume you believe are forms of reproductive prophylactics. A hysterectomy is the surgical removal of the uterus and is not at all indicated as a prophylactic procedure, but rather as a surgical treatment for reproductive cancers, among other conditions.

Posted

So, I don't think gay people have a choice in the matter. They don't choose to be attracted to the same sex. However, I don't think they are born that way either. I think it is something that happens when puberty hits. I also don't believe that just because they are attracted to the same sex that make it impossible to be chaste. No matter who you are attracted to it is possible to lead a virtuous life. Now, I believe that being Gay is a cross that will, if carried out with patience and virtue, will earn them much merit in heaven. It can't be easy. I only think society is making it harder by making it sociably acceptable to have a same-sex partner. That temptation must be very hard. I think we shouldn't judge gay people. It is a cross in their life.

Posted

While there's likely some sort of biological component which predisposes some individuals more than others (as with any other human behavioral tendency), I don't think anyone is truly born gay.  I don't think any infant came out the womb with sexual desires for the same sex (or any sexual desires at all for that matter).  Nor do I believe sexual "orientation" to be utterly set in stone from the beginning.  Identical twins (which share both the same genes and womb environment) don't always grow up to have the same sexual "orientation."

Like many other traits, it's probably a complex interaction of nature and nurture factors, and I think homosexual tendencies can (and sometimes are) overcome.

 

That said, I'm really not sure what the point of this thread is.  Whether the cause of homosexuality is biological or not has absolutely no bearing on the immorality of homosexual activity, the disordered nature of homosexual desires, nor the wrongness of "gay marriage" and "civil unions."

 

Ultimately such desires and tendencies are the result of original sin - like all disordered tendencies, which we all have in some area to some degree.  And we should all work to overcome our disordered tendencies (whatever they may be), rather than try to make them the root of our identity, and be slaves to them.

 

Using biological hypotheses to excuse sinful behavior is symptomatic of the widespread "if it feels good, do it mentality" that people must follow their every sexual urge.

 

 

 

 

 

Anyway, I think  we should conclude with a word of prayer on the topic from the Reverend Horton Heat:

 

[media]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=R0DtzzkGY1Y[/media]

franciscanheart
Posted (edited)

While there's likely some sort of biological component which predisposes some individuals more than others (as with any other human behavioral tendency), I don't think anyone is truly born gay. I don't think any infant came out the womb with sexual desires for the same sex (or any sexual desires at all for that matter). Nor do I believe sexual "orientation" to be utterly set in stone from the beginning. Identical twins (which share both the same genes and womb environment) don't always grow up to have the same sexual "orientation."
Like many other traits, it's probably a complex interaction of nature and nurture factors, and I think homosexual tendencies can (and sometimes are) overcome.

That said, I'm really not sure what the point of this thread is. Whether the cause of homosexuality is biological or not has absolutely no bearing on the immorality of homosexual activity, the disordered nature of homosexual desires, nor the wrongness of "gay marriage" and "civil unions."

Ultimately such desires and tendencies are the result of original sin - like all disordered tendencies, which we all have in some area to some degree. And we should all work to overcome our disordered tendencies (whatever they may be), rather than try to make them the root of our identity, and be slaves to them.

Using biological hypotheses to excuse sinful behavior is symptomatic of the widespread "if it feels good, do it mentality" that people must follow their every sexual urge.

Anyway, I think we should conclude with a word of prayer on the topic from the Reverend Horton Heat

I'm the original poster and I am positive I made no suggestion that we use biological hypotheses to excuse anything.

I think it's pretty telling that so many have experienced such immature, knee-jerk reactions to a very simple question. That's all it was: a question.

Instead of just answering the question, we ended up with everyone's opinion on everything related to homosexuality and sideways accusations of somehow supporting the "homosexual agenda".

I've never once said that gay sex was moral. I've never once suggested "gay marriage" should be legal. All I did was ask a question about people's understanding of homosexuality.

Do I think many here are ignorant? Yes. Do I strongly disagree with most of the theories presented? Yes. But that doesn't mean I'm preaching something immoral or that I'm somehow supporting the "gay agenda". Edited by franciscanheart
CatholicsAreKewl
Posted (edited)
Ultimately such desires and tendencies are the result of original sin - like all disordered tendencies, which we all have in some area to some degree.  And we should all work to overcome our disordered tendencies (whatever they may be), rather than try to make them the root of our identity, and be slaves to them.

I love conversing with you, even if we tend to disagree a bunch (I still owe you a reply, I'll get to that soon). I think we should be careful about how we address this issue. No one really knows what to classify gayness as exactly, but the way it is phrased in the above statements makes it appear as if attraction is something we can manipulate willfully. I understand that you are a realist, but it might be unnecesary to emphasize the connection between original sin and gayness. Acting on suicidal ideations is also sinful but I wouldn't tell someone that their depression was caused by the fall of man.
 

Edited by CatholicsAreKewl
Tab'le De'Bah-Rye
Posted

Excuse me, but "Hysterectomies" absolutely should not be considered on a list of what I assume you believe are forms of reproductive prophylactics. A hysterectomy is the surgical removal of the uterus and is not at all indicated as a prophylactic procedure, but rather as a surgical treatment for reproductive cancers, among other conditions.

 

 

Hysterectomie obviously is the wrong word. I'm talking about when the tubes of a women are tied and when men have a vesectami, i think that is the word and i wouldn't have a clue how to spell it. 

Tab'le De'Bah-Rye
Posted

Also Jesus sets lust aside from the other 7 deadly sins and pretty much says if you think lustfully of a married women you have already committed the sin in your heart. Is this just in the case of thinking of a married women which he mentions, or does it have a broader implication on what is and what isn't lust. Personally i hope to one day be free from all sin including thoughts and feelings associated with the action of sin. Usually sin starts in the heart or is conceived in the mind before it becomes an action, you can feel it or think it before it happens. Why not cut the whole damn tree down and cast it into the ocean, and not just dilly dally around it singing pop goes the weasel.

Tab'le De'Bah-Rye
Posted (edited)

LUV YAHS. :wave: xoxo

 

Onward christian souls.

JESUS is LORD.

 

JC " If you had but a mustard seed of face you would say to this mulberry tree be uprooted and planted in the sea."

 

Like i take this verse as attacking sin at it's roots, not just picking the fruit off the tree of death each time fruit appears. Why not attack the very roots. And maybe i'm wrong but aren't the roots of sin seeded in the heart and mind.

Edited by Tab'le Du'Bah-Rye

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...